wow.didn't think it'd be possible to build on this song... very nice. a VERY literal interpretation of this song that really breathes new life into it. amazing.
@caaarias For as much as i hate Justin Bieber it's normal Bieber/gaga are first since they're pop... But think it this way, there are also a lot of ppl actually enjoying "good music" like you do so not all is lost! :)
Enchanting, waltz like.. There are not enough words to describe this cover. I literally feel like I'm sitting on the edge of a lake staring at the moon in the distance. With nothing but my thoughts and a drink in my hand, thinking about the one I've laid my heart out too..
we all have a different tune that resonates with us. if you're looking for something you enjoy, and this isn't it, why not just look elsewhere? he's brilliant for some people.
wow everything la blogotheque says is true- go watch some take away shows on their website. it is soft and beautiful. chris garneau did a great cover.
agreed. It so odd to hear someone else doing Elliott but this was really imaginative on the piano, i loved the way his singing style sort of matched the way he was playing. Sort of more skippy and halting than the original.
This is my favorite version of Between the Bars, can't even listen to Metric's version after my addiction to Chris' La Blogotheque version, and even prefer it to Elliott Smith's. Thank you Vincent and Chris!
you have turned such a unique experience into a fragile masterpiece... dude keep it up you have conquered an impossible task. elliot smith would be proud.
Awful. Elliott Smith is the one of the greatest songwriters to ever live, and deserves a far better tribute than this. It's being over-dramatized and faked, warped into something it was never meant to be. Elliott told stories, he didn't self-center his songs like Garneau does here. I was hoping to find a video of a true genius covering Elliott. It's going to take someone brilliant, like Sufjan Stevens or Sam Beam, to really do Elliott justice. Search those two names, please.
I love that people are chatting and drinking away in the background...it is a perfect sound cape. Chris, you are so.....words escape me. Keep fueling that fire...it does shine not only on you but on so many others.
i find this to be the most incredible. i say, if you're big on elliott smith you probably won't enjoy this. you'll swear he's doing this song no justice but
i swear he does. it's pretty; it's genuine. might not be his own words but he can sing them like they are.i get chillssss. blast this quiet song and tell me you dont agree
I'm going off the shifts in their volume... true, everyone could have gotten quieter saying to one another "who is this retard? he's awful... oh good lord, make it stop." So you're right, I took liberties assuming that the audience was mesmerized by this... no, it's not dead silent but what do you expect? I think the set up of this cafe is such that the people could probably ignore him for the duration but I think they are Involved by the end....
My opinion... It's not necessarily better, both Elliott and Chris obviously have very unique voices. It's the emotion that matters, and as far as i can see they both put an enormous amount of emotion into it.
its not like one of those shitty garage recordings where they stop and laugh and try again you know?
Je trouve ça déplacé de dire "à chier". Tu as le droit de préférer un artiste à un autre, mais Mr Garneau a une voix merveilleuse et transmet une émotion différente de celle d'Eliott Smith. Non, ce n'est pas "à chier", c'est différent, point.
Elliott's original version is alot better in my opinion as i don't really find this version moving.Sounds a bit cheesy fake sort of singing.However I'm not saying that its bad but i do think his voice sounds like a girl singing. Just listen to the audio and don't watch the video and u might know what im talkin bout. Reminds me a bit like James Blunt
I agree completely. Also, the simultaneously soft and metalic sound of the piano captures the true essence of the song like no other cover I've heard. The song is a lullaby, except you're trapped in the nightmare, behind the bars. Brilliant.
i don't really like this cover nor this artist, i think he abuses too much of the whispering, there are a couple musics that please in "music for tourists" though, black and blue is one of them
I wanted to say I love the sadness in his voice. He really is singing it like he's alone at his piano, playing it for somebody who will never hear it. I love it.
and I think this, what Mr Garneau created for this little vid is quite magical! I was going through some vids on their website and I saw this and my heart stopped.. his cover fits the scene perfectly..
well because in my opinion chris did in amazing job. that should be everyones im not a terrible person and dont think everyone has to agree with me but when it come to chris i have to be right............ anyway who ever said fuck elliot i say fuck you. elliot is such an amazing singer i hope you get run over by a bus so when you get to where ever you go after you die you can apoligse to elliot because he deserves 100000000000000% respect
I don't think he "ruined" the song or anything, but I really don't care for this cover. Lyrically, anyway. The piano is really nice but I just really don't get the love for his voice. At all.
i love the song but this version sounds a tiny little bit gay no offence
valahogy 1 week ago
DOUX JESUS :3
RA00H 3 weeks ago
Comment removed
AinysDorMent 1 month ago
hipster camera man
you552 3 months ago 7
:,)
JoeBreeVideos 3 months ago
Beautiful. Just, beautiful....
Xustafu 4 months ago
one of the best covers i've listened.
magnificent voice,
il perfecto!
l0stc0ntr0l 4 months ago
I enjoyed Your short Movie
onlinedating1a1 5 months ago
such a soft and fragile voice. Lovely version.
guyjonesmusic 8 months ago
makes me wish elliott smith were alive so he could be in A Take Away Show
Groundbase 9 months ago 10
wow.didn't think it'd be possible to build on this song... very nice. a VERY literal interpretation of this song that really breathes new life into it. amazing.
shanemoore02 10 months ago
not a bad version, though i still prefer the original :)
Groundbase 1 year ago
And justin bieber is Number 1 ????
Chris is millions times better!
caaarias 1 year ago 6
@caaarias For as much as i hate Justin Bieber it's normal Bieber/gaga are first since they're pop... But think it this way, there are also a lot of ppl actually enjoying "good music" like you do so not all is lost! :)
OneManAndHisToaster 2 months ago
He has an interesting tone of voice
ChioSuper94 1 year ago 2
The slight syncopation of the piano against his voice grants this an incredible lightness. I love this so much!
Boros1184 1 year ago 3
hi is simply wonderful
gatoreloko1 1 year ago 11
Absolutely beautiful, his voice reminds me a little of Patrick Watson.
DougHiggs 1 year ago
WHY are the people still talking?
elfderfische 1 year ago
If only we had some Blogotheque-style recordings of Elliott.
dreamerfadesawake 1 year ago 12
this song just shuts the entire bar up. by the end no one dares talk.
danminer49er 1 year ago 9
I'm in love...
laetitiacroft 1 year ago 4
beautiful...
imAstardust2 1 year ago
very nice it touched me....
Ziggurathss 1 year ago
if i had to pick anyone to cover elliott it would be chris garneau, he has the perfect voice and aura to do it justice
Rikoshima 1 year ago
Enchanting, waltz like.. There are not enough words to describe this cover. I literally feel like I'm sitting on the edge of a lake staring at the moon in the distance. With nothing but my thoughts and a drink in my hand, thinking about the one I've laid my heart out too..
I love this..
xXSythenXx 1 year ago
fuck that.
TheBangmyhead 1 year ago
amazing taste he has
dondempezar 1 year ago
I'm a huge Elliott fan... have been for years. I can say I genuinely like this cover.
Galefox 1 year ago 6
oh its so sad it makes me cry - from my dik!
trueplayer31 1 year ago
we all have a different tune that resonates with us. if you're looking for something you enjoy, and this isn't it, why not just look elsewhere? he's brilliant for some people.
that's allowed.
smittyschair 1 year ago 3
breaking news - he isn't regina spektor and maybe her dumb ass sounds like him... maybe
drippingbeauty 1 year ago
wow really great cover i love it thanks for doing this song......ha he sounds like regina spektor in some parts of the song ha
mynameismyname22 2 years ago 7
I know! When i first heard him, i thought he was regina spector!
sasssygirl08 2 years ago
never mind is written at the end !
diego40100 2 years ago
what bar is this, anyone knows?
diego40100 2 years ago
i like it, but i hate his phrasing
mixtapeinfection 2 years ago
wow
Entrusrnamehere 2 years ago 4
the way in which he says "thank you very much" at the end pretty much sums up the kind of person he is.
spatchycakes 2 years ago
@spatchycakes - so... what kind of person is he? (sorry, did't get it)
feneco2 2 years ago
One of the best covers. It's hard for me to like Elliott Smith covers, because he was one of a kind.
LaughterIsEvrything 2 years ago 7
i feel the same way bro, i didnt like this too much man, but its grown on me alot.
creepske 2 years ago
beautifully done sir....as a fan of elliotts its hard to hear other versions but in your case its a pleasure to listen too.5*
spiralisedcat 2 years ago
Wow nicely done
teh8man 2 years ago
Ti amo!
fedeliallalinea 2 years ago
This is an incredible cover. Wow.
alkalineboy64 2 years ago 4
♥
paintingangels 2 years ago 5
I wish Elliott was still alive to see how much his music has influenced other people's lives, and other artist's music
Dakkaeo 2 years ago 5
BUY EL RADIO!
rospiltore 2 years ago 2
he has so much feeling in his voice. Love his songs...
andthxforallthefish 2 years ago 7
wow everything la blogotheque says is true- go watch some take away shows on their website. it is soft and beautiful. chris garneau did a great cover.
beatnikmichelle 2 years ago 6
This has been flagged as spam show
sounds like someone is holding his balls, but good cover. very clean.
loonetik 2 years ago
his voice is incredibly unique. i enjoyed it.
dansaysHELL0 2 years ago 26
i'm too protective of elliott smith to like any covers but this is the best one ive heard. also-this was shot incredibly beautifully, perfect
rosesandkarma 2 years ago 6
agreed. It so odd to hear someone else doing Elliott but this was really imaginative on the piano, i loved the way his singing style sort of matched the way he was playing. Sort of more skippy and halting than the original.
MClavicles 2 years ago 2
Si beau, si poignant, si sincère... aaah...magique!
nomoreallucaneat 2 years ago 3
so sad.
I want this in mp3.
zhulia 2 years ago 3
Such a beautiful and chilling cover song.
Sarah12345 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
too much "spirit" for me-
viki008 2 years ago
wow
impressed
Somethingpower 2 years ago
"It was soft and beautiful."
So true.....
bluhmfeld 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
top five indie bands
1. elliott smith
2. bright eyes
3. mountain goats
4. fleet foxes
5. kevin m. kirker
but elliott smith will always be #1! we miss you and love you elliott! we'll never forget you! rest in peace
astonishing00 2 years ago
what a soul
wildepeaches 2 years ago
best cover i have heard.
WolfToHula 2 years ago 2
Absolutely beautiful and so haunting
riotgrrlsassy 2 years ago 8
This comment has received too many negative votes show
man you sound like a bitch!
Kaneblind 2 years ago
Amazing, very good cover of an excellent song
suufjan11 2 years ago 2
I love the way this cover was done, and just the video itself is magnificently shot.
Twobitgangster 2 years ago 3
where the video go? please post again someone it is fantastic! peace
pecorskuwitz 2 years ago
I love him.
I didn't know he was so cute.
Lucky Guy.
AliceHatt 2 years ago
this is an intoxicating, haunting version of elliott smith's aready incredible song. wow. very nicely done!
:}
mitralikesmusic 2 years ago 45
herrrrrrrro
charosaurus 2 years ago
well well well, what a surprise, hello to you to
hehehe :}
mitralikesmusic 2 years ago
wow...sooo beautiful and moving, i love this
01barnesc 2 years ago
this makes my eyes water . freakin beautiful.
SomethingNewWithYou 2 years ago 7
This is my favorite version of Between the Bars, can't even listen to Metric's version after my addiction to Chris' La Blogotheque version, and even prefer it to Elliott Smith's. Thank you Vincent and Chris!
sygnussvi 2 years ago 2
you have turned such a unique experience into a fragile masterpiece... dude keep it up you have conquered an impossible task. elliot smith would be proud.
izmag1 3 years ago 8
This has been flagged as spam show
Awful. Elliott Smith is the one of the greatest songwriters to ever live, and deserves a far better tribute than this. It's being over-dramatized and faked, warped into something it was never meant to be. Elliott told stories, he didn't self-center his songs like Garneau does here. I was hoping to find a video of a true genius covering Elliott. It's going to take someone brilliant, like Sufjan Stevens or Sam Beam, to really do Elliott justice. Search those two names, please.
TrevorCrown 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
i agree, this dude butchered this song. and totally meant to, for self-promotion at elliotts expense.
somethingclever2007 3 years ago
I love that people are chatting and drinking away in the background...it is a perfect sound cape. Chris, you are so.....words escape me. Keep fueling that fire...it does shine not only on you but on so many others.
sugarhiccup333 3 years ago
i like his cover over metric's...it has a nicer feel
moriningstar 3 years ago
i find this to be the most incredible. i say, if you're big on elliott smith you probably won't enjoy this. you'll swear he's doing this song no justice but
i swear he does. it's pretty; it's genuine. might not be his own words but he can sing them like they are.i get chillssss. blast this quiet song and tell me you dont agree
thisiskevrageous 3 years ago 10
j'adore sa version,celle de Metric est pas mal aussi.artiste magique,chanson magnifique
xtrait2lux 3 years ago
i agree. metric is wonderful
poisonpinklemon 3 years ago
lol i know, but i guess they probably get a lot of interesting musicians in parisian cafe's, maybe they get desensitized..or they just don't care
shutteredmemory 3 years ago
interesting cover but didn't like it much. his voice is a little too ... gay for my liking!
the metric cover blew my mind though.
kasra333 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
awful voice
poor performance
winternightsky37 3 years ago
what are your talking about his voice is amazing... and tht cover was unbelivible!
goyankees4 3 years ago 4
are you deaf?
MovieFreak838 3 years ago 3
there's an emotionless, cold feeling you have to emit to do this song justice. Chris Garneau does precisely that
eitheror6903 3 years ago 3
can't stop listening.
mleen85 3 years ago
amazing,
i wanna have the notes...
iHennigs 3 years ago
The audience becomes mesmerized.
youjones 3 years ago
the don't sound very mesmerized to me! sounds like they're all socializing and sipping their beers in the background!
kasra333 3 years ago 2
I'm going off the shifts in their volume... true, everyone could have gotten quieter saying to one another "who is this retard? he's awful... oh good lord, make it stop." So you're right, I took liberties assuming that the audience was mesmerized by this... no, it's not dead silent but what do you expect? I think the set up of this cafe is such that the people could probably ignore him for the duration but I think they are Involved by the end....
youjones 3 years ago
My opinion... It's not necessarily better, both Elliott and Chris obviously have very unique voices. It's the emotion that matters, and as far as i can see they both put an enormous amount of emotion into it.
its not like one of those shitty garage recordings where they stop and laugh and try again you know?
theyre both outstanding
Emericanization 3 years ago 2
Beautiful Video
Natron4x4 3 years ago
vraiment à chier à côté de la version de Mr Smith.
tentonjohn 3 years ago
Je trouve ça déplacé de dire "à chier". Tu as le droit de préférer un artiste à un autre, mais Mr Garneau a une voix merveilleuse et transmet une émotion différente de celle d'Eliott Smith. Non, ce n'est pas "à chier", c'est différent, point.
NanaEtPipim 3 years ago
Oh Garneau
<3
kattdancer777 3 years ago
it looks like he is going to die
CoffeeForSleep 3 years ago
This cover blows me away.
albeitmanny 3 years ago
Anyone saying THIS is better than Elliott Smiths version is out of their fucking mind.
oyouarehereo 3 years ago
Wow, Um, I must say I could like this version better than any other - yes including Smiths
ItWasTheVoices 3 years ago
decent, i guess. compared to a lot of the other fuckin horrible elliott covers out there.
jackwhiteyum 3 years ago 3
personally i like it, but i think elliot's has more emotion, which is what i like more.
RIP smith, your music has touched my life more than any other.
TMoney89playa 3 years ago 2
I personally like Garneaus version of between the bars than Smiths
meum02 3 years ago
agreed
TwelveOhTwoAM 3 years ago
a little too high-pitched for me, but good job
1234e4321 3 years ago
Elliott's original version is alot better in my opinion as i don't really find this version moving.Sounds a bit cheesy fake sort of singing.However I'm not saying that its bad but i do think his voice sounds like a girl singing. Just listen to the audio and don't watch the video and u might know what im talkin bout. Reminds me a bit like James Blunt
sofman7 3 years ago
you could say the same thing about the origonal. It's just a matter of opinon
willcomment4food 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i think elliot smiths voice is boring...I actually like this version better
kowtpr187 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Anything compared to james blunt automatically means it's shitty.
xraytedvision 3 years ago
Reminiscent of a genius. This is a brilliant cover.
the location: a bar where people that don't speak your same language are oblivious to you and the song that encapsulates you.
Like a scene out of an epic movie.
mzhwhezcy 3 years ago
I agree completely. Also, the simultaneously soft and metalic sound of the piano captures the true essence of the song like no other cover I've heard. The song is a lullaby, except you're trapped in the nightmare, behind the bars. Brilliant.
StartA9 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
whats up this dudes voice?
justinx0r 3 years ago
he has an awesome unique voice. Love it!
kowtpr187 3 years ago 4
quite original. i like it, even though i dont really like high strung singers ... but well its the french accent i guess hehe :)
subterreanhighrise 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
really a shame this guy finds inspiration in elliott while not learning anything from his work to improve his own, mediocre at best
vlibl 3 years ago
fuk off he is great
kowtpr187 3 years ago 2
thank you for this video
Walkr 3 years ago
rdv the first june ;)
heragibou 3 years ago
He truly expresses his emotion in this song,,, His voice makes me shiver,, He leaves me under a spell..
michaelwalsh123 3 years ago 4
he sounds like regina... sometimes..
cacashojas 3 years ago
call me crazy, but i do not like this cover.
johnwillc 3 years ago
yeah me neither
brunobliss 3 years ago
His voice puts me into a trance. I am in awe. Best cover of Between the bars.
Manatee1nsanity 3 years ago 2
mejor que el original! si no le gusta, por favor no mires el video.
BUJUBIJI 3 years ago
i don't really like this cover nor this artist, i think he abuses too much of the whispering, there are a couple musics that please in "music for tourists" though, black and blue is one of them
brunobliss 3 years ago
I wanted to say I love the sadness in his voice. He really is singing it like he's alone at his piano, playing it for somebody who will never hear it. I love it.
Youngdubber 3 years ago 4
I dig the piano. Really good.
Youngdubber 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
GAYYYY
joshveino 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
You have my respect...
DevianceGOTP 3 years ago
its on his album.... go purchase it then :p
r3quiem 3 years ago
I really love this cover. I would buy a properly recorded version easily.
tragg2 3 years ago
Excellant !
trlstaff 3 years ago
hum ...un classique
xtrait2lux 3 years ago 2
Intemporelle ..Magnifique ..
c'est ma chanson preferée
themissdidi 4 years ago 5
I am in london
Italian
I love Elliott Smith
and would like Chris to be my friend, very very much
What an interpretation, quite magnificent
milanlondon 4 years ago 5
:____)
audreycr 4 years ago
I'm a big fan of la blogotheque..
and I think this, what Mr Garneau created for this little vid is quite magical! I was going through some vids on their website and I saw this and my heart stopped.. his cover fits the scene perfectly..
madkitt 4 years ago 4
all the chattering!
stop talking people. listen to him...
pogololuba 4 years ago
well because in my opinion chris did in amazing job. that should be everyones im not a terrible person and dont think everyone has to agree with me but when it come to chris i have to be right............ anyway who ever said fuck elliot i say fuck you. elliot is such an amazing singer i hope you get run over by a bus so when you get to where ever you go after you die you can apoligse to elliot because he deserves 100000000000000% respect
blueidblonde 4 years ago 6
gorgeous-simply incredible
therealshakira 4 years ago 4
i wish i could've been there. chris garneau<3
oumai123 4 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
fuck elliot smith how about that? thanks christ garneau for saving the chord progression from that emo-clownshoe-cumstain tool...
smurfzeppelyn 4 years ago
i hope you die
ThisIsWar257 4 years ago
Seems like a lot of people don't like this cover. I rather enjoy it. This is shot beautifully as well.
MovieFreak838 4 years ago 6
i agree that his voice/melody choices doesn't really fit the song. Still, I like his voice elsewhere
Seppuko 4 years ago
He's an amazing singer, but I don't think this song is really right for him.
Still, he did a good job, could be better though.
cptnchang 4 years ago
I don't think he "ruined" the song or anything, but I really don't care for this cover. Lyrically, anyway. The piano is really nice but I just really don't get the love for his voice. At all.
indiejane 4 years ago
I love how every comment that isn't 100% "omg, lurve" gets major thumbs down. It's just opinions.
MrTsBastardChild 4 years ago
i tried to play this song on my piano
but i cant sing this gentle when i'm singing that high
great job chris g.
BaerMasterr 4 years ago 2
best elliott cover i would say. not to mention chris is just amazing himself as well
erinerinetc 4 years ago 3
god i love this
erinerinetc 4 years ago 2
he calms me :) love it
dancerpsique 4 years ago 2
this guy's voice is nuts
felmotes 4 years ago
chills...perfect cover. enjoying chris but missing elliott
mailmandday 4 years ago 7
Agreeing with so many - as a huge fan of Elliott Smith, I've never found a cover that hasn't disappointed me, but this one definitely didn't.
missxmooney 4 years ago 3
Oh wow. His voice is so gentle and mournful and magnificent. Excellent cover!
FaiSchlechterWolf 4 years ago 2
agreed!
lestyebecomeamonster 4 years ago 3
Vincent Moon is a genius at this stuff.
TheBoss2332 4 years ago 2
i love this video.
& this song.
i love chris garneau.
jasongs89 4 years ago 2
this is my favorite song of all time. and this is such a good cover. the best one i've seen hands down.
hellanervousx 4 years ago 8
kudos...a good job even if it was perhaps a little melodramatic
let the song do that instead...dont force
it
esqueejy 4 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
you dont force it crazy slut butch hoe mother fucker
i love chris
hes my favorite
abcdemilyx3 4 years ago
holy take it easy!
lestyebecomeamonster 4 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
you take it easy cock sucker
poop licker
toe toucher
but lover
mexican hater
rasist
boob
i hates youuuu
abcdemilyx3 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
is he a midget?
killingspree 4 years ago
Love it
TetrisTwoThumbsUp 4 years ago
too much people do covers of this song but this one was actually good
kaskaskia17 4 years ago
this guy's voice sends chills down my spine. this is a beautifully horrific rendition.
beeboydance 4 years ago 6
haha yes..:)
lestyebecomeamonster 4 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
is he trying to sound like Bjork? the piano was great but noone can touch this song
XAVIERCUERVO 4 years ago
Something you don't like in his vocals?
daftmar 4 years ago
oh my.. beautiful.
nimcy85 4 years ago 3
Omg! I love the original song and I really really love this cover!! His voice is amazing, beautiful, it really touches me
GataNegra07 4 years ago
thats some scary shit,but its like he is reading elliotts diary,a bit weird
faghammer 4 years ago 2