American Idol Recap: Top 12 attempt the Rolling Stones with entertaining result!

[jsatt91]

Fire can be one or two syllables. Usually it is pronounced with 2, but Ellen is originally from the south and they tend to forget syllables in their accents :P

[johnphoenix17]

I think that SIOBHAN should be the winner, she can out sing any other contestant this season and i like that shes unique and just different with an amazing voice.

As for the others i like Crystal but shes too predictable i like her but not to win, ill give her top 3. And Aaron is very good too.

Top 3: Siobhan, Crystal, Aaron

Top 6: Lee, Andrew and Didi

Any other contestants will go home next,IMO.

But the winner should be SIOBHAN :)

oh and good recap.

[BlackTwilight16]

I didnt get to watch the show this week :( but I heard clips of Siobhan's proformance which i loveddd. In general I like Lee Dewyze and Tim Urban (Don't hate me for it. Ahaha) even if tonight wasnt there best week. <33

And for the record, fire is one syllable :PP

[cdgonsalves]

Yes, he does have a beautiful falsetto! Go Michael!

ELLEN marry me! (not so much Siobhan) '...but then for people like me .. blondes' L! O! L!

[athousandstrats]

@cdgonsalves Haha, good falsetto, I'll give him that. Not so into any other aspect of him though :P

[dpontarelli007]

Sibhan all the way!!! Her interpretation of the songs she does is spot on, her voice is great, the right amount of drama w/o overdoing it....just perfect. Tired of Crystal already and the thought of 5 or 6 more songs of the same is nauseating. Missing Alex Lambert on the male side.

[angersausten]

my favorites are siobghan and aaron

[skytate20]

i totally agree with you on everything! i think Siobhan and Didi were the best of the night for different reasons. I also love Ellen (I don't miss Paula at all either) i love her "gay joke"!

i also wanted to ask you what would you've sang if you were on the show, but you already said it in the video so good job man!

[Arkansas19852003]

Sex in the Tags..nice..haha

[alex1209]

I have to disagree with you on this vid a bit Joe, Siobhan Magnus is good , The note at the end was very impressive She had a very great personality on stage, great song choice, great vocals, but nothing we havent seen before *cue Kelly Clarkson, Carrie Underwood, Fantasia Barrino Etc.

She is one of my favorites but just because someone uses every note in their range doesnt make them a front runner Ie. Kris Allen

Overall spot on for the other critiques. Great Job.

[athousandstrats]

@alex1209 Haha, you meant to refute but really just kind of backed up my point. You say all that like its a bad thing, yet I seem to recall all of those girls WINNING the show and actually having careers (less so with Fantasia).

I never said using all of ones range makes you a front runner. In fact thats not at all true. But you cant ignore that it helps. Even just a little bit, e.g. Adam Lambert. Didn't win, but was the front runner all season long.

But glad you enjoyed the video :)

[alex1209]

@athousandstrats @athousandstrats LMAo i was trying to make a point about her not being original in the sense of her performance, I just dont think a piercing scream, or dramatic lights is anything special. but then again I like Adam Lambert Hahaha.

Its a matter of taste and Id be stupid to try and give you my tastebuds :D

Do a cover of Jeff Buckleys Lover You Should've Come Over. Because Im a huge fan of him and I think you could pull it off

:D

[Arkansas19852003]

Kris Allen is the man!

[JulianTheGreat01]

lol... "Take that Big Mike!"

[Imkeepinon]

enjoyed your comments. I am a really really love Crystal and hope that she wins but you can never tell with Idol many people voting with differant tastes

[JGarcia658]

Play With Fire is a Stone's classic. Go back and listen to Out of Our Heads.

Otherwise, I am giving you a good review for your review. 5