Proposing to your girlfriend in public is such the dumbest thing to do and as a man i will never venture to do this in public.This should always be done very privately during an intimate moment with just the two of you and no one else around or involved and in a special place.Again i insist that it should be done privately.You can't take risks like that in public and shocking your girlfriend out of the blue.He should face the consequences,he is stupid.Also he only knew her for some months!!!
women need to be trained. they all need this training. very simple stuff. here goes: when you're in public and some idiot proposes, say YES. reject him later in private, but damn. this guy's gonna go home and hang himself now.
@btr003 He's the one that proposed in public. He should be prepared for rejection. He just embarrassed her on national television so she has no reason to save face for him.
Sorry I did not get back to you Bobby Iam too busy with theJOHN BLEAK show at moment but I did enjoY this video your sincerely JOHN BLEAK Boby don't forget to look at show
wow this wasn't even funny i just felt really bad for the dude..
ok dumb ass girls this is for all of you !!!
If some dude propose to you in a very public place were there is many people watching like in this case, or in the middle of disney or whatever the F the place is . your answer is YES , you say YES . then when you guys are alone say no or whatever the F you wanna say to him.
@ButHeHasDImples I don't get it...my comment is totally accurate, this girl is an actress. As for OJ, I thought he was found guilty and is in jail!!!! So OJ is not innocent.
Tell you what she looked pretty damn hot for a guy like that. I could see if he had a sense of humor or something, but he be lacking some serious skills!
i would hate for a guy to propose to me on tv. that just sucks. i see a proposal as an intimate, beautiful, private thing that does not involve television.
you can tell the giuy's got some mental issues.. "a couple of months"? cmon.. the guy is desperate.. she is just naive of the type of wako she is dating..
Girls in this situation should just say "yes" so the guy doesnt look like a big loser, and then when they're OFF Camera say, actually no... that would be a LOT nicer in the long run
Prolly the closest he's been to a piece of ass and he wanted to lock it down. Duh m bass. Putting her in a corner and pressuring her to make a decision is fail. You better be damn sure she's into u or u r a fool. Sure plenty of peeps have played the fool but u didn't have to do it live in front of so many. Nooob.
It's his own goddamn fault for proposing so early. Good for her, I say, he's a total prick to put her on the spot like that after a FEW MONTHS of dating.
Marriage is something the couple should talk about for a while and know for sure that it is what they wanna do. Not some shithead who has probably had rejection after rejection and want to cling to something good. Ride it out, bro, if it's meant to happen it will, don't rush it.
omg that hella sucks for him because it's public...but then again maybe it was the right answer because they've only dated for a couple of months...he should have waited for at least the one year mark
If it was real: POOR GUY, SILLY GIRL, and mean person who got the vid.
Recomends 4 who want to propose:
1) at least 6 months of been Boyfriend-Girlfriend
2) when you propose DON'T SAY "umm" I know it is hard to make the words come out of your mouth but c'mon say it seriously and looking in the eyes. Just breathe.
3) DON'T DO IT WITH PUBLIC cuz it makes everyone nervous; you, her and the public.
thats freakin sad... look at his face! he was like "um..." :*( but yeah a few months is a short time to think about marriage! i really do hope this was a fake, planned event.
We (men) make women Gods and worship them for sex, and this is our problem, because of this we are wimps and controlled. There is only one God. Once you find the truth you can see and start to control your life, do not be a Adam he failed to control Eve and then saw here naked and has worshiped her as we do the same, there is only one way to brake from this, truth.
Fake. The groom's awkwardness is canned and the host is clearly in on it. It looks like everyone practiced their faces in front of a mirror. Fake fake fake.
The guy is a GEEK. She probably screws the bad boy later after "Poindexter" here drops her off after paying for dinner... He brought it on himself... I feel sorry for him and I would die a thousand deaths if I were him
Why do people propose after a few months? Heck, some couples in my school have been together for more than 1 year and I don't hear any special announcements that say "Will you marry me?"
I blame the guy for pulling the trigger too quickly. Not that he deserves the rejection, nobody does, but he was just in a hurry. He's desperate perhaps?
HAHAHAHAHAAAA! Fucking owned! A few months, are you fucking nuts? You can't learn all there is to know about a relationship in a few months. EPIC FAIL!
He was wrong to propose like that. But how stupid was she...She should gleefully accept, then tell him to shove his cheap and nasty nasally accent later.
This was so pathetic way to propose to a woman. Come on, he put pressure to the woman to accept it. It was like, hey don't embarrass me, ok? we are on tv now, just accept it.
I feel sorry 4 both of them, but mainly the girl coz that would have been really hard on her, way too much pressure, especially after just a few months...
WTF? I mean if you're going to propose to someone, do it on the top of a mountain or on a quiet beach, not on a cheap talkshow surrounded by strangers...and certainly not after a few fucking months. What a pathetic guy.
if you propose after a few months then i doubt it will work out, I mean for all we know its been 2 months. What would you say if after 2 months you were proposed to?
im usually not one of those douchebags that say everything is fake but i think this may be. but if not, the guy is a complete moron for asking after 3 months.
Ouch. If you're going to ask someone to marry you, don't do it in such a publicly visible and embarrassing way unless you're damn sure she's on the same page.
Proposing to your girlfriend in public is such the dumbest thing to do and as a man i will never venture to do this in public.This should always be done very privately during an intimate moment with just the two of you and no one else around or involved and in a special place.Again i insist that it should be done privately.You can't take risks like that in public and shocking your girlfriend out of the blue.He should face the consequences,he is stupid.Also he only knew her for some months!!!
jackfoxman1967 3 weeks ago in playlist rejected proposals
CLAP!!!!! lOL
Lizziewho310 3 weeks ago
Play them off, keyboard cat!
moeezS 3 weeks ago
women need to be trained. they all need this training. very simple stuff. here goes: when you're in public and some idiot proposes, say YES. reject him later in private, but damn. this guy's gonna go home and hang himself now.
btr003 2 months ago in playlist rejected proposals
@btr003 He's the one that proposed in public. He should be prepared for rejection. He just embarrassed her on national television so she has no reason to save face for him.
Quinkans 3 weeks ago
not to sound cliche... but fake! :D
FreedmFightr 2 months ago in playlist rejected proposals
Sorry I did not get back to you Bobby Iam too busy with theJOHN BLEAK show at moment but I did enjoY this video your sincerely JOHN BLEAK Boby don't forget to look at show
JohnBleakSpeaks 2 months ago
Fake.
lastassassin13 3 months ago
wow this wasn't even funny i just felt really bad for the dude..
ok dumb ass girls this is for all of you !!!
If some dude propose to you in a very public place were there is many people watching like in this case, or in the middle of disney or whatever the F the place is . your answer is YES , you say YES . then when you guys are alone say no or whatever the F you wanna say to him.
Don't be a nasty bitch!!
rojocapo610 4 months ago
The bleach blond cunt did not want to get married because she is taking a big black cock in her white snatch. Stupid fucking American cunts.
ViperDriver88 5 months ago in playlist rejected proposals
This has been flagged as spam show
@ViperDriver88 She is a stupid evil bitch. The twat would decline him if he was black. American women are trash.
Lrdvltr 5 months ago
she was nice with her can we talk about this later,,,,
CarolineEmilie4 8 months ago
I dont know about this video
LVnthelife 9 months ago
he didn't get laid that night
imatunisian 9 months ago 2
He's been with her "A FEW MONTHS???" Oh geez, why do people always have to rush everything?
Sparkles10155 11 months ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
yeeahhhhh FAKE FAKE FAKE
MrReznor 1 year ago
AWKWARD! I like how when she says can we talk about this later, a guy in the audience goes, "Woah." lol!
SillyRamaBubbles 1 year ago
it's fake. The acting sucks.....especially by her.
JimboVids 1 year ago
@JimboVids come on it doesn't matter
Lippreader 1 year ago
that reeked of fake to me
FartyFartyPoopyPants 1 year ago 2
haha "we'll be right back... awkward"
megan1147 1 year ago
Well, apparently it wasn't the happiest months of HER life..lol.
homogenic97 1 year ago
Oh come on, MASSIVELY staged.
olabz 1 year ago
This is so staged and fake. If you youtube marriage propsosals gone wrong, you'll see this girl in a couple different uploads with different guys!!!!
pokergalpoker 1 year ago
@pokergalpoker yeah and OJ is innocent..........
ButHeHasDImples 1 year ago
@ButHeHasDImples I don't get it...my comment is totally accurate, this girl is an actress. As for OJ, I thought he was found guilty and is in jail!!!! So OJ is not innocent.
pokergalpoker 2 months ago
@pokergalpoker wait what??? he wasnt found guilty, he was acquitted.
i was being sarcastic in my last comment 1 YEAR AGO lol
ButHeHasDImples 2 months ago
@ButHeHasDImples...SO WAS I !!!
pokergalpoker 2 months ago
At the end, 1:56, the guy says "...clap.."
lithuanian101 1 year ago
A few months? What the crap!? I hate it when people treat marriage like a joke.
People who get engaged after being together only a few months or less than a year are . . . STUPID!
dd1985 1 year ago 3
aww...poor guy............
but still he counted on love for a "few months"
justcharlenprens 1 year ago
It's amazing this guys is even dating a pretty girl, given the fact that he can barely speak.
jeremyraybrown 1 year ago
A few months! A few months!!!!!! The odds are against you my friend...
tjb234567 1 year ago
Shit, I can only guess how this guy felt afterwards, totally devastated and stupid.
LiveReligiously 1 year ago
Lyn is a slut
grapjaz 1 year ago
This guy was heinous in every way. She seems nice though. This one may actually work out at some point if he gets rich enough.
jeremyraybrown 1 year ago
Tell you what she looked pretty damn hot for a guy like that. I could see if he had a sense of humor or something, but he be lacking some serious skills!
THeMaskedBlogCritic 1 year ago
that music is fucking epic
ChippThaRipper 1 year ago
who tell him do this ...its a set up lol lol
VixenLove2u 1 year ago
i would hate for a guy to propose to me on tv. that just sucks. i see a proposal as an intimate, beautiful, private thing that does not involve television.
ender6137 1 year ago 11
you can tell the giuy's got some mental issues.. "a couple of months"? cmon.. the guy is desperate.. she is just naive of the type of wako she is dating..
YouGlued 1 year ago
FAKE
littledippr86 1 year ago
I checked with the producer for this show and he said it was also his hair style too.
TheClaudos 1 year ago
Yep...I double checked this video, and it is definetly the music... I can quietly confirm that it was Michael on the keyboard who is at fault here.
TheClaudos 1 year ago
I'm sure it was the music?
TheClaudos 1 year ago
'Uh...we'll be right back...awkward...'
Y2KillerSPOOBLY 1 year ago
a couple months really chows that hes a waiter
StallionsForYou 1 year ago
Girls in this situation should just say "yes" so the guy doesnt look like a big loser, and then when they're OFF Camera say, actually no... that would be a LOT nicer in the long run
lizdylanboykie 1 year ago 5
@lizdylanboykie that would be a let down
pyxiefrog124 1 year ago
@lizdylanboykie: guys should not put themselves into this kind of situation.
James92802 1 year ago
FAAAKKKKKKEEEEEEEEe
WeAreYoMomma 1 year ago
Prolly the closest he's been to a piece of ass and he wanted to lock it down. Duh m bass. Putting her in a corner and pressuring her to make a decision is fail. You better be damn sure she's into u or u r a fool. Sure plenty of peeps have played the fool but u didn't have to do it live in front of so many. Nooob.
JamJHolmes 1 year ago
You sir, are a fucking moron. that is all.
DaemonicSavior 1 year ago
The way that both him and her looked at the end........F-A-K-E!! Try better next time!
Latterlife 2 years ago
Must be fake. Unless he's a millionaire there is NO WAY that hot blonde is dating him.
policemanaaron 2 years ago
FAKE
GAY
GoodJ0bSquidward 2 years ago
HAHAH!!
tbpth 2 years ago
at the very end "clap"
lain61 2 years ago
LOL. 1:30 "Can we talk about this later" dead silence, then 1 man band keyboard......dink dink di di dink...we'll be right back
JK47Tubing 2 years ago 30
no one gets married after a few months....lol
xXdieXromanticXx 2 years ago
she's too hot 4 him so's u know it's fake
bcsROBBERY 2 years ago
a few months! what?
jeweledbridge75 2 years ago 2
this is so clearly fake
tinkywinkypoo 2 years ago 3
no way.. cant u tell by the silence...
redflare100 2 years ago
a few months??
"hey baby weve been datin for a month now...can u marry me? :-P"
NittoBBS 2 years ago
A FEW MONTHS?????
ciberneche 2 years ago
haha love watching the host at 1.37
skateskatskasks 2 years ago
This. Is. Fake.
Why are people so gullible?!
bbraswe2 2 years ago
funny but sad
wargod435656 2 years ago 2
I can just feel the embarrasment and pain everytime I watch the video......fail!
iceman050890 2 years ago 3
wow he looked so uncomfortable it made me cringe
whoaza 2 years ago 2
Scarred for life ... poor guy, asking the question is hard enough and being on TV made it ever harder!
MisterHougy 2 years ago 2
he did nit have to say in tv
trekkicat 2 years ago
That was so sad and awkward.
shinikita 2 years ago 3
poor guy
Zee32595 2 years ago
I never understand why people cannot just say yes publically, and then, when off the air say no. For God's sake this poor guy is humiliated!
lynncrf 2 years ago
I think this is a set up - they're actors.
alittlebitofperil 2 years ago 2
OH YEA? What's his name? :O
It does look sort of fake...
Unerly 2 years ago
I don't know - but there's something very suspicious about it. It doesn't seem genuine to me.
alittlebitofperil 2 years ago 2
Arrggh painful to watch!
Psychodan204 2 years ago
girl is HOT
and
dude give it a year wtf
sjg2 2 years ago
We can see the exact moment when this poor man's heart breaks in half @ 1:41
nitzwalsh86 2 years ago
She's way too good looking for him. What an odd couple! No wonder she said no!
JanieJane96 2 years ago
Well she should have said yes on camera so she didn't totally kill the guy on national tv... :/
OBSESSIVEfanocity 2 years ago
ok that's awkward
blast1412 2 years ago
FAILLLLLLLLLLL LOLOLOLOL
xXJPXx1000 2 years ago
It's his own goddamn fault for proposing so early. Good for her, I say, he's a total prick to put her on the spot like that after a FEW MONTHS of dating.
Marriage is something the couple should talk about for a while and know for sure that it is what they wanna do. Not some shithead who has probably had rejection after rejection and want to cling to something good. Ride it out, bro, if it's meant to happen it will, don't rush it.
gzussturbo 2 years ago
a few months???
drummerzoneT1995 2 years ago
a couple months DAMMM for all we know it could be 3 or 4 months but she should of said yeah then no while off camera or something
AztecInfantry 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
If you want you can watch The Proposal the movie for free here:
MOVIEM[dot]TV/the-proposal/
movieforfreeeee 2 years ago
No no no no...
NippleBerry 2 years ago
omg that hella sucks for him because it's public...but then again maybe it was the right answer because they've only dated for a couple of months...he should have waited for at least the one year mark
specialcrayon 2 years ago
soooo fake....
giopagoda 2 years ago
i was shocked when he was denied! It makes her look like a snob though.
goodwoodgoodywoody 2 years ago
Well if its fake its still sad. I hope thats not real
GuMdRoPbUbBlEpOp01 2 years ago
did he die? i think after this shame he did.
kampfsou 2 years ago
doesn't matter it was fake; IT WAS HEARTBROKEN.
If it was fake, well good vid and great actors.
If it was real: POOR GUY, SILLY GIRL, and mean person who got the vid.
Recomends 4 who want to propose:
1) at least 6 months of been Boyfriend-Girlfriend
2) when you propose DON'T SAY "umm" I know it is hard to make the words come out of your mouth but c'mon say it seriously and looking in the eyes. Just breathe.
3) DON'T DO IT WITH PUBLIC cuz it makes everyone nervous; you, her and the public.
=)
mixamixamixa83 2 years ago
I'm not sure how to respond to a YouTube comment giving advice on proposing...Fail?
zofspade 2 years ago
thats freakin sad... look at his face! he was like "um..." :*( but yeah a few months is a short time to think about marriage! i really do hope this was a fake, planned event.
Sumeow 2 years ago 2
a few months with her?!?!WTF!!!!
aWTFproduction 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
We (men) make women Gods and worship them for sex, and this is our problem, because of this we are wimps and controlled. There is only one God. Once you find the truth you can see and start to control your life, do not be a Adam he failed to control Eve and then saw here naked and has worshiped her as we do the same, there is only one way to brake from this, truth.
dualaroma 2 years ago
oh my fucking GOD.
shut the fuck up.
:D
DammItsDenys 2 years ago
I think she needed more time.
funktroop3r 2 years ago
doesn't matter if it was fake or not. it was funny.
ValeriesGal 2 years ago
umm hes been with her for a few months?!?
RingoBerri 2 years ago
howu guys noe its fake
dats wut i wanna noe..
Argentina2012 2 years ago
omg, of course its fake. and some of you thought it was real?? lol
gixer121121 2 years ago
hmmm... either very well acted fake or extremely humiliating event preserved forever on the internet.
akarpowicz 2 years ago
FAKE
phorat 2 years ago
she's probably having an affair with another guy!!!!! HAHAHAHA
samnaps1 2 years ago 2
Fake. The groom's awkwardness is canned and the host is clearly in on it. It looks like everyone practiced their faces in front of a mirror. Fake fake fake.
vidlyvid 2 years ago 2
Ok I see loads of problems
1) a couple of months? wtf? REALLY BAD IDEA. Was she his first time or something?
2) You can't say, "I want to ask you to marry me" you have to be DIRECT. "will you marry me?" retard.
3) Ring without a box? he handed it to her like giving her a tissue
4) If you're going to do all the above, do it with CONFIDENCE. He did it like a wounded pig
5) Shave goatee
6) Unless you are SURE, don't go public with proposal, forget national
raichu314 2 years ago 36
5) shave goatee
hahaha!
rainbowgorilla 2 years ago
DUDE. BURN.
jennifizzle14 2 years ago 2
poor guy, should have waited at least a year...
Kaji617 2 years ago 2
Beauty and the monkey!
tehuda 2 years ago 3
Youve gotta be a complete moron to propose after a few months
xbrirzx9494 2 years ago 2
a few months????
DaLovelyOne5 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
who would marry that nerd anyhow...deserves the humliation!!
marissaisahott 2 years ago
maybe if he would've acted more confident she would've said yes...
sming01 2 years ago
this guy was wayyyy too nervice lol
Shokeybutsi 2 years ago
this is probably one of the most painful videos to watch
plasticbarf 2 years ago 3
Why would he propose after a few months...... GG guy.
RofllWaffles 2 years ago
"c..can...can we talk about this later?"
OUCH.
UNOxDExELLOS 2 years ago
poor guy.
gracegrizzle 2 years ago
she was to hot for him...
odxoxbo 2 years ago
fake fake fake. I saw same chic in another "proposal Rejection" on you tube. I think it's part of a class project or osmething.
Dexterity99 2 years ago
dyou have the other video on youtube?
takiswakis 2 years ago
fake
jennifergeorge 2 years ago 2
Regardless of how foolish it was to propose after such a short amount of time.... It's so sad! How embarrassing!
sparklekitti 2 years ago
The guy is a GEEK. She probably screws the bad boy later after "Poindexter" here drops her off after paying for dinner... He brought it on himself... I feel sorry for him and I would die a thousand deaths if I were him
Twifty1 3 years ago
HOLY FUCK she just shat on this mans hear lol its funny how the announcer guys face looked
nitrousboy0311 3 years ago
this is weird...a guy who has no balls showing balls. i tell ya tho, this cant help his confidence issue.
Mikex87 3 years ago
Why do people propose after a few months? Heck, some couples in my school have been together for more than 1 year and I don't hear any special announcements that say "Will you marry me?"
I blame the guy for pulling the trigger too quickly. Not that he deserves the rejection, nobody does, but he was just in a hurry. He's desperate perhaps?
All I have to say is GG! (Good game) (^∀^)
DestroyerXD 3 years ago
'some couples in my school have been together for more than 1 year'
dude, "school"
TheWanderingColossus 3 years ago
Hahahahaha. Yeah "school"...I understand!!! Hahaha...kinda wrong to be marrying each other during High School.
DestroyerXD 3 years ago
That girl was smoking hot, and this guy had to douchebag it up for her on national television. What a pussy.
briefcasemanx 3 years ago
Actually,it's just local.
Pulgo6 3 years ago
Not anymore, lol
stevek83 1 year ago
poor man
dahnish1 3 years ago
oooh awkward......
ballsy101 3 years ago
a few months? how pathetic! a proposal comes after at least 2-3 years!
worldslayer 3 years ago 3
owch charlie!
Idino13 3 years ago
faaaaaaaaaaaake
DASLIBERTINE 3 years ago
yes, we know that your 3 inch cock is fake
Musmeister 3 years ago
Is that really the best your intellect could muster? fucking hell man,thats an embarrassing attempt at humour.
DASLIBERTINE 3 years ago
HAHAHAHAHAAAA! Fucking owned! A few months, are you fucking nuts? You can't learn all there is to know about a relationship in a few months. EPIC FAIL!
jonrmahnke 3 years ago
afew months??! thats it? they need like 2 years or something before a proposal..
ItsJulieee 3 years ago
yeah man.. Dont know if the girl relly wants you dude until you get to know her for a good 2 years or more (even better).
ainjeldahst 3 years ago
LMAO @ the music at the end! Was that calypso music?
nelldadiva 3 years ago 2
He was wrong to propose like that. But how stupid was she...She should gleefully accept, then tell him to shove his cheap and nasty nasally accent later.
xtcongo 3 years ago
This was so pathetic way to propose to a woman. Come on, he put pressure to the woman to accept it. It was like, hey don't embarrass me, ok? we are on tv now, just accept it.
kububeach 3 years ago 2
I feel sorry 4 both of them, but mainly the girl coz that would have been really hard on her, way too much pressure, especially after just a few months...
funxlovinxchick 3 years ago
damnn first of all you never propose to a girl that u been with for a few month! hwo would do that
litomiami 3 years ago
so sadd...poor boy.....
cuterubii 3 years ago
a few months???
cadhamjer 3 years ago
epic fail!
kuracin 3 years ago
wkakakakakakk poor guy.... dont get too rush dude
tempeemendoan 3 years ago
Fail......
llking86 3 years ago
WTF? I mean if you're going to propose to someone, do it on the top of a mountain or on a quiet beach, not on a cheap talkshow surrounded by strangers...and certainly not after a few fucking months. What a pathetic guy.
lonerook860 3 years ago 5
SMD!!
k33pitez 3 years ago
lol at the music that started playing to break the awkward silence :P
gnredbull 3 years ago 3
I think its real man. Its not staged or part of the show. Even the host felt bad. Cmon its real.
santanaincubus 3 years ago
She want to talk to him...and tell him. she "thinks" she can do better than him.
There is an Alpha man just round the corner.
Alpha male will treat her like trash.
The OLD Story!!!
dougcepe 3 years ago
if you propose after a few months then i doubt it will work out, I mean for all we know its been 2 months. What would you say if after 2 months you were proposed to?
FORZION 3 years ago
A couple is 2, a few is 3 or more.
agentbong138 3 years ago
he said "this has been the happiest 8 months of my life" so we do know how many months.
kenken30103 3 years ago
If you are talking about at 1:21 he says "linn umm these have been the happest months of my life..." never says 8
FORZION 3 years ago
i'm sorry. i stand corrected. i could have sworn i heard 8 tho but i turned my volume up real loud and your right.
kenken30103 3 years ago 5
if she does not want to marry she just using you buddy!
dougcepe 3 years ago
Fake.
radcam69 3 years ago
wow she was dating a monk?
k33pitez 3 years ago
idiot, marriage after 3 months.
use your head
dkkmjmj 3 years ago 3
im usually not one of those douchebags that say everything is fake but i think this may be. but if not, the guy is a complete moron for asking after 3 months.
fitzy01 3 years ago
actors
virusinsideus 3 years ago
HAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHHAHA
I felt bad for the guy at the end though :P
iloveumorethanu 3 years ago
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
Freehugsforall125 3 years ago
this is obviously part of the show if u guys cant see.
zDeMoNl 3 years ago
Ouch. If you're going to ask someone to marry you, don't do it in such a publicly visible and embarrassing way unless you're damn sure she's on the same page.
bobnfreely 3 years ago 2
a few months! wtf was he thinking!?
say it like you actually have some balls too!
goes up there like some squirl
retard
tenniskidpsi04 3 years ago
Failure.
wemallards 3 years ago