stupid POME's yeah yeah pay all that money to listen to a bunch of drunk ASS Ozzies howl like tomcats! Dumb POME's put em all on a short boat ride to tasmania.... it's a quiet song! not a sing along. DUH?!?!?!? it's NIN not INXS! idiots!!!!! surprised he didn't walk off stage! must of cranked up his monitor
everyone knows about this track now but imagine driving around in your car the day after this was released & hearing this for the 1st time when only a tiny TINY percentage of the entire planet knew who this guy was because that's what i was lucky enough to experience 1st hand....i can say i'm truly sorry for those who were too young to have been there in 1989 to really REALLY see/hear the entire scope of the picture...experience always trumps assumption
The thing is, when he first started performing as NIN, his fans were people who respected the music. They cheered during breaks between verse and chorus, for example. Nowadays, some of the people who attend his concerts are annoying little EMO or kindergoth who just. don't. get. it. They think THEY'RE cool for listening to his music. Nevermind the genius and talent HE is.
@KellyGreen5555 uuuuuh.. you think so? kinda having a hard time judging her from the few songs that I've heard her sing. Trent is ciritisized a lot for his singing I've noticed. And yet I always find his renditions of songs appropriate and highly enjoyable to listen to.
seriously people, if you're piss drunk and sound like a braying donkey, please stfu so everyone else can enjoy the song. I can't stand it, especially during beautiful, sad songs like this or hurt... it just really ruins the experience imho
Yeah, I feel the same with songs like this and 'Hurt'. Singing along is one thing but talking through quiet parts of a song can be annoying. That's why I don't always go standing to gigs anymore cos a lot of people just talk through a lot of the quieter moments and not listening to the song.
I've been to most gigs that have been worth standing at and done the madness so now I go seated if I know the band will play songs like this so I can appreciate the music
Don't go to a concert if you're going to bitch about people there havin a good time.You think Trent is mad cause his fans know the words and are into the music.U are the people that ruin the shows with your disrespectful comments about the other people there. Get a life. If Trent hated it he wouldn't talk about how its amazing to him that so many fans know his songs and want to sing along. People like U R more disrespectful then anyone in the audience expressing how much they love NIN
What the fuck is wrong with the crowd? They ruined what would have been probably the best performance of this song ever. But instead half of them were talking through it, I can put up with the singing because that shows they're enjoying it but talking? Thats disrespectful and if I was Trent I'd be really pissed off.
This is one of my favorite songs by them... I can't wait to see Reznor in May. I actually GREW UP listening to NIN since I was a baby, so their tour in North America is like a dream come true to me.
I love how Trent can perform sooo passionatly no matter how many times he has had to perform this song, you can still see the passion... OMG What an incredible man!!!
I can't listen to this song unless im like full fledged depressed, it brings back way too many horrible memories. it's beautiful none the less, just alittle powerful
@monikakf Agreed!!!Though when I saw NIN on the 'Fragility 2.0' tour w/'A Perfect Circle on the 'Mer de noms' tour THAT was a moving,exctatic,emotional show that it stuck with me for months after,Course TOOL & NIN have done that consistently for me through the yrs.I was lucky to be able to asst. drum tech on 'the downward spiral' tour & THAT made all the difference for me in landing the gig with 'Mindzeye'-who I HOPE you'll be hearing soon-cd is being mixed now!BTW-check out 'Kaura' @ myspace!
@TheNineinchsnails -THAT craked me up good.If i had 2 punches I could smack someone with it's be 1)Dick Cheny(maybe Glen Beck-hard to call)& I'd love to smack Justin Bieber so hard it'd turn that 'swoop' of a haircut his backwards! Thans NINs-seriously-great jk! I love to wake up with a laugh!But I shouldve added 2 more to most 'passionate' performers-1)Maynard James Keenan is pretty obvious,& 2)Mike Patton-I mean Faith No More are throwing down as heavy NOW as they did on the 'Angel Dust' tour
i can't even begin to talk about how disrespectful that crowd is...
HugoBarrientos89 3 months ago
sing along but dont scream along. jeez o.O
metallichika 3 months ago 2
He is a force to be reckoned with...god I love Trent!!! I named my son after the man!!!!
trentsmama07 3 months ago 3
DONT SHOUT man like trent isn't liking much either i think.
ZoeMushroom 4 months ago 4
God shut the fuck up, what kind of concert is this? Retarded kids sing along? Jesus....
ShammyWoWLoL 5 months ago 4
Comment removed
thorgeist666 6 months ago
i prefer version of flyleaf
thorgeist666 6 months ago
@thorgeist666
lol, joke right?
pls listen to the version recorded in 1989, then we'll talk.
reznor is god, you're just blind.
Deathcorpler 5 months ago
stupid POME's yeah yeah pay all that money to listen to a bunch of drunk ASS Ozzies howl like tomcats! Dumb POME's put em all on a short boat ride to tasmania.... it's a quiet song! not a sing along. DUH?!?!?!? it's NIN not INXS! idiots!!!!! surprised he didn't walk off stage! must of cranked up his monitor
Sid8idAK 6 months ago
everyone knows about this track now but imagine driving around in your car the day after this was released & hearing this for the 1st time when only a tiny TINY percentage of the entire planet knew who this guy was because that's what i was lucky enough to experience 1st hand....i can say i'm truly sorry for those who were too young to have been there in 1989 to really REALLY see/hear the entire scope of the picture...experience always trumps assumption
CarellaRoss 7 months ago
@CarellaRoss WOW. THAT WAS PRETENTIOUS. But, I get your point.
ironman276 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
3:00
"I love you Trent!"
He looks over at her like, "Shut up, whore"
That's probably what he was going to say, too, but he stopped himself.
MrGarky 8 months ago
Comment removed
MrGarky 8 months ago
The thing is, when he first started performing as NIN, his fans were people who respected the music. They cheered during breaks between verse and chorus, for example. Nowadays, some of the people who attend his concerts are annoying little EMO or kindergoth who just. don't. get. it. They think THEY'RE cool for listening to his music. Nevermind the genius and talent HE is.
PhenoxRyzing 9 months ago 5
This has been flagged as spam show
What a jackassy crowd! Stop clapping, shut the fuck up and listen to the music people!
mr5elfde5truct
Yeah so says the guy spells destruct with 5's instead of S's
unlitdarkness6 1 year ago
i fucking love you trent
BUTCH666420 1 year ago
bitch who cant sing kinda ruins it
SuckItLily 1 year ago 3
@SuckItLily You mean Trent's wife? Talk about a bitch who can't sing.
KellyGreen5555 10 months ago
@KellyGreen5555 uuuuuh.. you think so? kinda having a hard time judging her from the few songs that I've heard her sing. Trent is ciritisized a lot for his singing I've noticed. And yet I always find his renditions of songs appropriate and highly enjoyable to listen to.
SuckItLily 10 months ago
seriously people, if you're piss drunk and sound like a braying donkey, please stfu so everyone else can enjoy the song. I can't stand it, especially during beautiful, sad songs like this or hurt... it just really ruins the experience imho
nirewolf0 1 year ago 2
4:17 wow
sodom87 1 year ago
What a jackassy crowd! Stop clapping, shut the fuck up and listen to the music people!
mr5elfde5truct 1 year ago 8
soooo gooood.....
johnleclerc88 1 year ago
awesome
kiesha4188 1 year ago
being in a crowd at a concert like this is a DRUG.. the music is a ride i can only compare to exstasy.. get goosebumps watching this..
oneyetroll 1 year ago
Is that Courtney Love singing in the audience?
mooniethecat 1 year ago 4
This is awesome.
I wish it had the drums, though!
thirty30150hates 1 year ago
I love the inclusion of what I think is a double bass in this - it gives it a really haunting quality
Gumbroid 1 year ago
beautiful...
thirstwill 2 years ago 2
stfu bitch !
fireoceanqc 2 years ago
that high pitched girl really knows how to ruin a great performance. :<
ejjph2 2 years ago 9
how is it possible for some tone deaf bitch to over power the crowd and be heard at 2:17
252477514 2 years ago 4
Ah god. The crowd should at least sing in the fucking right key. Nevertheless this is a fucking great performance of this song.
superfundeathhammer 2 years ago 3
i'm so happy i went to this concert
allnightdwight 2 years ago
Yeah, I feel the same with songs like this and 'Hurt'. Singing along is one thing but talking through quiet parts of a song can be annoying. That's why I don't always go standing to gigs anymore cos a lot of people just talk through a lot of the quieter moments and not listening to the song.
I've been to most gigs that have been worth standing at and done the madness so now I go seated if I know the band will play songs like this so I can appreciate the music
JuiKuen 2 years ago
a fucking incrediable performance in my opinion the best band!!!!!!
ejjph2 2 years ago
One of the greatest (if not the greatest) performances i have ever seen! Nobody shows more true emotion than Trent Reznor!!! Nobody!!!
thescarface1989pt4 2 years ago 4
looks like he was crying at the end there
Joeyal123 2 years ago 2
fuken amazing.... not many artists put everything into their performance, he looks drained.. :(
enzs6 2 years ago 2
well it is a sad song to sing
Joeyal123 2 years ago 2
Don't go to a concert if you're going to bitch about people there havin a good time.You think Trent is mad cause his fans know the words and are into the music.U are the people that ruin the shows with your disrespectful comments about the other people there. Get a life. If Trent hated it he wouldn't talk about how its amazing to him that so many fans know his songs and want to sing along. People like U R more disrespectful then anyone in the audience expressing how much they love NIN
peterson50219 2 years ago
he gained weight
jonandreesa 2 years ago
No man, thats muscle. He's gotten buff
superfundeathhammer 2 years ago 3
some people are bullshit and dont deserve to be at a NIN concert. they should check for those people at the door or something somehow ha
GoldfenixYoshi 2 years ago
What the fuck is wrong with the crowd? They ruined what would have been probably the best performance of this song ever. But instead half of them were talking through it, I can put up with the singing because that shows they're enjoying it but talking? Thats disrespectful and if I was Trent I'd be really pissed off.
createsumchaos 2 years ago 5
I agree.
vikonja121 2 years ago
great song, great recording, great version (without the thudding drums during the chorus)...
but, as always, the out of tunes singers yodelling incessantly really ruins the powerful moment...
i came to hear trent reznor sing, not some screaming, caterwauling drunkard bellowing randomly and singing the wrong lyrics...
cheers to the taper and trent for not being distracted by the 'backup singers'...
dmbgilligan 2 years ago
I agree. I hate people like that. But thanks to the wonders of in-ear monitors Trent doesn't have to hear all that.
JesusRebellion 2 years ago
only like 3 more days for me
xxfulatoxx 2 years ago
i love hurt but this theme is the only one shit in the world that makes me cry
Hackmoune 2 years ago 3
The absolute most powerful song NIN has ever made...keep making the fantastic music you have for years.
rolledunder 2 years ago 4
This is one of my favorite songs by them... I can't wait to see Reznor in May. I actually GREW UP listening to NIN since I was a baby, so their tour in North America is like a dream come true to me.
thornedbishop 2 years ago
I think I'd die of happiness if I saw them and they played this..
UseYourAppetite 2 years ago 3
Damnit. :'(
woohoonin 2 years ago
So god damn beautiful...now if only the audience would shut the fuck up...
demon00dmn 2 years ago 6
I love how Trent can perform sooo passionatly no matter how many times he has had to perform this song, you can still see the passion... OMG What an incredible man!!!
NINtrigued420 2 years ago
I can't listen to this song unless im like full fledged depressed, it brings back way too many horrible memories. it's beautiful none the less, just alittle powerful
skateNappreciate 2 years ago
note to people attending NIN concerts: it's not a competition to try to sing along louder than Trent.
enterspacecapsule 2 years ago 86
not to be sexist... but its obviously the women. they don't know how to control themselves sometimes.
mestupkid185 2 years ago
@enterspacecapsule Especially when they can't sing for shit
MrCr1spy 1 week ago
This is one of the heaviest deepest darkest emotional songs that has ever been written.
CFKMAN 2 years ago 5
Trent Reznor is like modern music's Hamlet. His vulnerability is his strength and it is so sincere.
riotstick67 2 years ago 4
From this camera angle he looks identical to Richard Patrick of Filter
DRIVEBYRACHKO 2 years ago
I haven't heard it done this well in a long time.
twistfinger 2 years ago
I can't think of anyone who puts more honest passion into a performance than Trent Reznor.
Soulcatt 2 years ago 51
@Soulcatt I totally agree with you. TR is the best singer and person I have ever met.
monikakf 1 year ago
@monikakf Agreed!!!Though when I saw NIN on the 'Fragility 2.0' tour w/'A Perfect Circle on the 'Mer de noms' tour THAT was a moving,exctatic,emotional show that it stuck with me for months after,Course TOOL & NIN have done that consistently for me through the yrs.I was lucky to be able to asst. drum tech on 'the downward spiral' tour & THAT made all the difference for me in landing the gig with 'Mindzeye'-who I HOPE you'll be hearing soon-cd is being mixed now!BTW-check out 'Kaura' @ myspace!
TheSoulcraft 1 year ago
@Soulcatt justin bieber? .....lololol jk
TheNineinchsnails 1 year ago
@TheNineinchsnails -THAT craked me up good.If i had 2 punches I could smack someone with it's be 1)Dick Cheny(maybe Glen Beck-hard to call)& I'd love to smack Justin Bieber so hard it'd turn that 'swoop' of a haircut his backwards! Thans NINs-seriously-great jk! I love to wake up with a laugh!But I shouldve added 2 more to most 'passionate' performers-1)Maynard James Keenan is pretty obvious,& 2)Mike Patton-I mean Faith No More are throwing down as heavy NOW as they did on the 'Angel Dust' tour
TheSoulcraft 1 year ago
@Soulcatt Maynard James Keenan, Trent's only equal.
0uterHeaven0 1 year ago 5
@Soulcatt Bieber?
TomFromJersey 1 year ago
oh this is soooooo good!
ashlarr23 2 years ago
god bless you mr reznor
awire007 2 years ago
Top Notch, Great Quality. What camera were you using. 5/5
DesolateMinds 2 years ago
Fantastic footage Ryan!
Kristin1228 2 years ago