After listening to the CD version more than hundreds of time and having a little pause to clear my ear, I can confirm that this is totally live. But she did a great job here, really close to CD but inflections and differences in places like before the transition to touch my body and the tone in her high notes are slightly but clearly different.
2007 - Early 2008 > Nodules Starting to worsen once again, making her performances Great to OK.
Late 2008 - Mid 2009 > Her nodules were at its worst, Making her voice very raspy strained and hoarse, and unrested.
Late 2009 - Present > Her Voice is well rested, and her performances are Ok to Unbelievable! ( ex. I Wanna Know what Love is X Factor UK, and Europe performances!) ... Hope she con't to rest her voice and con't to promote good music!
disagree with you, she sounded good at 2005- late 2006 - then she kinda didn't show up in stage or go on TV much in the year 2007 cuz she was busy making E-MC2 then Early 2008 ( signs that her voices is really changing, she had trouble hitting notes) Late 2008 - Mid 2009 her voice was at her worst condition then Late 2009 and Present, her voice is in Good Condition!!
@Sall80 no what is wrong with you? her 2005/2006 album the emancipation of mimi had amazing vocals. and that was the best selling cd of 2005it was number 1 on charts and selling 10 million coppies. and spit out 4 hit singles "its like tha6t# 16, shake it off number 2, we belong together number 1, dont forget about us number 1. and her voice was amazing buddie shes lipping 8% here. 2008 atleaste the album did good and she looked hot because she was skinny1990-2008. her new auto tune music succks
wow shes amazing! god she did that whistle note at the end!!! That proves to all you haters that Mariah Carey is still an amazing singer and can still do whistle notes! If u dont know what that is, then look it up! You go Mariah Carey!!!
The same way you know she's slut. In other words you don't you illiterate son of bitch. You can't even spell right. Look at your dumb ass. Mad cuz you're a street walker LMAO!
one way to prove this is live she almost lose the timing in the end when she went into the whistle register.. but its not bad its just that i picked it up..
She's not lipsyncing. She's Mariah Carey, Dumbass. You don't become number one, and stay that way with weak talent. Don't hate, take your jealousy elsewhere.
Can't believe this is the same woman that released "hero" "love takes time" etc. She has changed so much, can't get over it. I'll always love her songs, but i just can't get over the change in her. I do miss all of those amazing ballads from the early 90's. Oh well.
i see where the fuck u comin from but u don't have to call da girl ugly mariah and beyonce is equally pretty and they just did a song wit each other nad some other artist so...
This song (which is one of the better ones on the album, even though it's the usual light Mimi fare) more than likely won't reach the #19 Ho 100 peak of "Bye Bye." Plus, Mimi finally looks like she's not as interested in Hot 100 peaks as she once was- this marriage may be good for getting rid of that obsession. Mega fans, take note. :)
This song is currently #61 on the hot 100 ... let make it #1... by downloading it on itunes... streaming the video at yahoo or aol ... and requesting the song on radio....... mariah needs our help
I love mariah carey she is hot and this is coming from a 14 year old.. age ant nothing but a number also i hate how people say that she is to revealing to much .. in my opinion to revealing would have a bra and panties she got some pants and a shirt on all yall haters need to stop hating
After listening to the CD version more than hundreds of time and having a little pause to clear my ear, I can confirm that this is totally live. But she did a great job here, really close to CD but inflections and differences in places like before the transition to touch my body and the tone in her high notes are slightly but clearly different.
PairJaNaJa 6 months ago
@PairJaNaJa lol Listen to the other live performance of this, the Touch my Body part sounds... well, identicle.
theovanua 2 weeks ago
i don't like how she only held her fan's hands for about 3 seconds.
the09conradz 6 months ago
wow..look how sexy she used to be!!!! but idc coz mariah u r my biggest inspiration...
Sj2690 10 months ago
*SIGH* i still remember watching this on tv, still amazed with the last note :)
EternalRoller 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
LADY GAGA'S out of this world - and so are her curves as she poses TOPLESS for the first time. - - Naked Lady Gaga. C000M -
Aime3072 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
1990-1993 > MC's Voice was Un deniable! simply THE BEST! Effortless!
1994-1996 > The Fist sign of change was her tone, her voice was much higher, but still her voice was incredible and still effortless!
Late 1996 - 1998 >After Daydream Tour Her nodules worsen making her voice raspy
1999 > Strong voice and new tone
2000 - 2003 > her voice was high and strong, and she whispered a lot in her songs.
2004 - 2006 > At her best, strong and effortless singing!
CONT.....
JCNRBA 1 year ago
2007 - Early 2008 > Nodules Starting to worsen once again, making her performances Great to OK.
Late 2008 - Mid 2009 > Her nodules were at its worst, Making her voice very raspy strained and hoarse, and unrested.
Late 2009 - Present > Her Voice is well rested, and her performances are Ok to Unbelievable! ( ex. I Wanna Know what Love is X Factor UK, and Europe performances!) ... Hope she con't to rest her voice and con't to promote good music!
JCNRBA 1 year ago 3
I think she didn't sound to good between 2005-2008. She sounds much better again now.
Sall80 1 year ago 4
disagree with you, she sounded good at 2005- late 2006 - then she kinda didn't show up in stage or go on TV much in the year 2007 cuz she was busy making E-MC2 then Early 2008 ( signs that her voices is really changing, she had trouble hitting notes) Late 2008 - Mid 2009 her voice was at her worst condition then Late 2009 and Present, her voice is in Good Condition!!
JCNRBA 1 year ago
Comment removed
JCNRBA 1 year ago
@Sall80 no what is wrong with you? her 2005/2006 album the emancipation of mimi had amazing vocals. and that was the best selling cd of 2005it was number 1 on charts and selling 10 million coppies. and spit out 4 hit singles "its like tha6t# 16, shake it off number 2, we belong together number 1, dont forget about us number 1. and her voice was amazing buddie shes lipping 8% here. 2008 atleaste the album did good and she looked hot because she was skinny1990-2008. her new auto tune music succks
JulianDaniEmilyShow 1 year ago
i have seen this when i was 4th year and i loved it so much!!!!
fuglybucket 2 years ago
nice boobs
beenthesun 2 years ago 3
is that ppossible
riverad55 2 years ago
how cute mariah looks :] her last whistle at the end soungs like a beautiful bird :]
Elepho113 2 years ago
I just love Mariah Carey!
LiteraryLibra 2 years ago
luv this song
SARWEEDEN4 2 years ago 2
excellent remix, would love to have heard a recorded version
MimiNirvlarva 2 years ago
I love this performance! Mariahs vocals are so amazing why is it so hard to believe she can sound just as good on the record as she would live?!
She is the BEST REGARDLESS
MimiFanKat 2 years ago
wow shes amazing! god she did that whistle note at the end!!! That proves to all you haters that Mariah Carey is still an amazing singer and can still do whistle notes! If u dont know what that is, then look it up! You go Mariah Carey!!!
ray112244 2 years ago 5
This has been flagged as spam show
freenudeteengirl{.}[c0m]_
Avril Lavigne did CHOP SUEY Im gonna shit, then watch it, then post insulting
JaysonFrye 2 years ago
how the hell does she do that last note
riverad55 2 years ago 15
This comment has received too many negative votes show
she needs to suck a lot of dick first
orangecarrotcake 2 years ago
She has a 5 Octave Range. Part of it God-Given and the other part is a lot of hard work and Vocal training!
Ginuwinejay 2 years ago
all of the haters of mariah carey can go fuck themselves because she is a real talented singer.
dejathequeen 3 years ago 5
This comment has received too many negative votes show
you mean real talented slut
jus lyk miley cyrus
missyhaleybabby 3 years ago
Aww you're mad cuz you're an UNTALENTED slut???
avwhite 3 years ago
look whose talkin
besides i b getin money and you just standin on the street corner lookin lik tha fat heffer that you are
*QUESTION* HOW would u kno if i even was one?
STALKER!!!
missyhaleybabby 3 years ago
The same way you know she's slut. In other words you don't you illiterate son of bitch. You can't even spell right. Look at your dumb ass. Mad cuz you're a street walker LMAO!
avwhite 3 years ago 2
why dont you ask yo momma if im a street walker
she know
who cares if i dont spell right? wat u gonnna do? tell yo nerd friends??
omg she dont know how to spell she must be stupid haha
watever get a life
missyhaleybabby 3 years ago
one way to prove this is live she almost lose the timing in the end when she went into the whistle register.. but its not bad its just that i picked it up..
KevinDukekmd 3 years ago
MC's the best HANDS DOWN
bbdbdj 3 years ago 6
I wish ppl would stop giving mariah such a hard time she ain't lipsynching!
JayJay258 3 years ago 4
Personally, I loved her high-pitched bird call at the very end. :P
jessparks21 3 years ago 7
Comment removed
Abstractionant 3 years ago 4
they didnt cut it out of the studio version, but she added it to live performances..........
MCFan20000 2 years ago
ok people HOW THE HELL CAN SHE LIP SYNCHING IT'S LIVE YOU DUMBASSES
alimenka 3 years ago 3
omg that was soo much fun i went with a friend. Chad Micheal Murray is soo hot!:P
so is Mariah!:p
talfulaij 3 years ago
She's not lipsyncing. She's Mariah Carey, Dumbass. You don't become number one, and stay that way with weak talent. Don't hate, take your jealousy elsewhere.
JiaSene 3 years ago 7
well i saw the what the buck show and well he said she was lip synching :P
so umm yeah ...you gotta be a dumbass not to notice too
betoloco123 3 years ago
I think Micheal Buckley was talking about her Good Morning America show where she got CAUGHT lipsyching I don't think he was talking about this show.
BlyueMOON 3 years ago
I get it! Those whistles are supposed to be her speaking dolphin!
crazy2hazy 3 years ago
what the hell!
alimenka 3 years ago
there's a dolphin in the music video
crazy2hazy 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
She lip singing
BAD!
koasterkid360 3 years ago
No u r bad!!! and she singing live jack ass
aquamarine11500 3 years ago
u stink u can see shes not singing
koasterkid360 3 years ago
she not lip singing , if ur a hater then dont watch mariah carey vids
taillow22 3 years ago 2
how the hell can she be lipsinging it's live you dumbass
alimenka 3 years ago 3
i didnt say shit , the other dude said she was lipsinging dipshit , not me
taillow22 3 years ago
Can't believe this is the same woman that released "hero" "love takes time" etc. She has changed so much, can't get over it. I'll always love her songs, but i just can't get over the change in her. I do miss all of those amazing ballads from the early 90's. Oh well.
daydreams82 3 years ago 3
i see where the fuck u comin from but u don't have to call da girl ugly mariah and beyonce is equally pretty and they just did a song wit each other nad some other artist so...
aquamarine11500 3 years ago
This song (which is one of the better ones on the album, even though it's the usual light Mimi fare) more than likely won't reach the #19 Ho 100 peak of "Bye Bye." Plus, Mimi finally looks like she's not as interested in Hot 100 peaks as she once was- this marriage may be good for getting rid of that obsession. Mega fans, take note. :)
JimmyRAD9 3 years ago 2
This song is currently #61 on the hot 100 ... let make it #1... by downloading it on itunes... streaming the video at yahoo or aol ... and requesting the song on radio....... mariah needs our help
Yowpower 3 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
She got to much clothes on her, cant u see its warm in there? :P
*waiting
Arachnomen 3 years ago
Veryyyyyyyyy Gooooooood !!!
Muito bom mesmo Rapaz o que será que essa mulher guarda nessa garganta p dar um agudo desses !!!
gostei fico apaixonado qnd Mimi canta ao vivo sem medo de ser feliz
portalreis 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Mariah should act, and especially dress her age. She can't sing or dress. Terrible, just terrible.
ssej0628 3 years ago
u r just a plain hater,u r just mad because u r not as beautiful as mariah carey
dejathequeen 3 years ago 14
This comment has received too many negative votes show
so r u thats y u stick uup for her..
missyhaleybabby 3 years ago
ok im a hater big deal
how would you kno how i look?
stalkeer...
missyhaleybabby 3 years ago
I love mariah carey she is hot and this is coming from a 14 year old.. age ant nothing but a number also i hate how people say that she is to revealing to much .. in my opinion to revealing would have a bra and panties she got some pants and a shirt on all yall haters need to stop hating
countolaf11993 3 years ago 5
This comment has received too many negative votes show
dude it may be summer outside but inside they have air conditioning on the inside put some clothes on slut
missyhaleybabby 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
11 yr. old prostitute
missyhaleybabby 3 years ago
haha. what the buck. "oh look here's my boob."
2010soleil 3 years ago 4
ya lol if she didnt wear that short ridiculous outfit it wouldnt have happened
missyhaleybabby 3 years ago
one perfect word to describe your ass,HATER!!.
dejathequeen 3 years ago
THANK YOU
idc ima hater get over it
missyhaleybabby 3 years ago
love her!!!! Mimi you are awesome!
xoxokaila 3 years ago 4
OMG,thats gorgeous and awesome
isseymyake79 3 years ago 2
What a cute performance! As always, Mariah looks very youthful and fresh! Thanks for posting this video! :~)
rksu747 3 years ago
the queen
9martinko 3 years ago 3
THE QUEEN!
feedbackfeedback 3 years ago