Added: 5 years ago
From: ocskaboy
Views: 48,870
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (235)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Wow. He's so young and hot? 2006? I was 13 and had no idea that there was a HP community. Man, I missed out on so much.

  • Ah, he's so young <3

  • 10 people forgot cedric. Or their hands slipped.

  • Now I need chocolate :(

    Awesome song though

  • cedric was a spare before he sparkled

  • edward created 10 youtube acounts

  • Aw, Alex you're so cute and young here. Now you're....older :)

  • Don't Forget Lupin always has/had chocolate :D you know 3 book

  • ok the saddest thing so far in harry potter: #1) dobby dying #2) cedric dying

  • @angelofepicdarkness what bour hedwig and tonks and lupin and fred?

  • @angelofepicdarkness # 1 Fred dying!!!!!

  • @darrencrissisHOT yes fred dying too. fred and cedric have to be my favorite male characters, besides marcus flint. lol

  • no after i watched this i look at my tv and right then is when voldmort killed Cedric now i am sad...

  • I cried when Cedric died... CEDRC FOREVER!!! <3

  • I wish I had chocolate cause I'm sad now. I really miss Cedric. :(

  • @UserxEffingxName

    I don't.

    In my eyes he is a traitor to the Harry Potter series.

    Or maybe it's just the actor i dislike..

  • is he the only one in the band

  • LOve this band :( *sniff*yes we miss you cedric

  • Alex looks a bit like Remus.

  • @bluederby12 yeah :'D makes it even better

  • I didn't get chocolate when I saw you in Salt Lake… Now I'm sad.

  • This was the first wrock song I ever heard. I cried the first time, I cried when I saw you do it live a few years ago, and I cried now. Thank you for bringing wizard rock into my life.

  • SEE 'EM TOMORROWWW. >:D

  • *drools everywhere*

    Hahah :D. It's my life's goal to get a hug from him.

  • Comment removed

  • Alex gives great hugs. You haven't lived until you've had one -- or two, in my case. ;)

    This song really is depressing. I swear on that first line my eyes welled up and I'm a Slytherin. Wrock on!

  • Alex looked so awesome back then... Well, he looks awesome now, of course, but still...

  • i wanted Hermione and Draco to get together (SPOILERS!) because after Ron left i was like yesssssssssss and in the 6th book Draco wasn't going to kill Dumbledore! he lowered his wand its right there read it! they would have been sooo cute but NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!

  • We got chocolate back in 07! :3

  • 'its not quite as rock and roll but pass it around' that made me laugh so much

  • Hahaha! I can't believe that people are this awesome. Chocoholic Remus Lupin would be proud, I think.

    I dressed up as Lupin for Character Day at my school, but I completely ignored the possibilities presented by chocolate.

  • Why DIDN'T you give ME chocolate Alex?

  • The Remus Lupins Is the beast band of Wizard Rock of the World!!

  • Let's give some props for the king of stalling. No other band uses chocolate.

  • Holy fuk!!! They were the first people I added on myspace when I was in 7th grade!!! I'm a junior now!! Lmao that was the year I read and fell in love with hp:'-) rip lupin

  • This is amazing! alex played it with riddletm on friday in edinburgh! I'm so glad he came all the way over to the UK! He's so awesome! I got a pic with him! OMG, it was5 days ago and I'm still buzzing! I'm in a wrock band called The Dark Mark Experience in england, hardly anyone know about us though :-) This song makes me cry! Wrock on! and Alex if you ever read this, please come to the Snowball 2010!!!!!

  • Wrock on! xD

  • Haha "It might have hurt them, i'm not sure." Alex, i love you, you're hilarious.

  • hahaha

    "it mighta put their eye out... i dont know... but it hurt them for sure. so it's not quite as rock and roll, but take one and pass it around."

    :D hahhaha thats FUNNY

  • I love Alex. He is really very nice. And quite funny. YAY REMUS LUPINS!

  • they only make music about hp xD

  • What does Edward have to do with The Remus Lupins or Cedric?

  • cerdic and edward are played by the same actor

  • I know but Twilight seems to be the main subject on this video but it's about Harry Potter not Twilight.

  • Cedrid and Edward are played by he same people yet the Wizard is more graceful then the  Vampire

  • we all love harry more though, everybody knows that, we just enjoy comparing the two franchises, because really, there isnt one, harry potter owns, and i guess you're right, i should hold my twilight tongue

  • harry potter doesnt own. he pwns, bigtime.

  • lolz, sure does, but rowling's lvl 80 for sure

  • i'm glad hat the characters died, i mean i cried and cried and cried, but at the same time, i was more satisfied at the end of harry potter than in the end of breaking dawn. all is fair in love and war. Rowling understands that there cant be freedom and hope and happiness and life without death and tragedy and hopelessness. hell, she even killed harry for a couple of chapters.

  • I think the thing about Rowling is that she isn't afraid to kill her characters off. I mean however many times I read the series (I'm on my 6t run through the seventh book) it will always make me cry wheneer there's a death. Dobby is the worst though because of the manner in which he dies. But the best bit is you can ignore their deaths by going back to an earlier book :)

  • poor Cedric i even have i shirt that says support Cedric Diggory and i cry every time he dies in the movie... D:

  • lol i have a top that says cedric!

    because he's dead

    *tear* ;(

  • this song makes me sad...i wish they had it on itunes i would buy it. Alex if you see this try to get those itunes people put it on itunes.

  • Seriously. The song's about Cedric, not Pattinson or Edward. RIP...

  • hey! this song is goood

    =]

    i liked it

  • I have respect for both writer equally.... There no comparison!

    Remus lupins was my first expierence to wizard rock!!!! I love them!!!

  • We're gonna miss you Cedric....

  • I love both Harry Potter and Twilight!! <3

  • of course meyer cant touch rowling. she didn't create a world within a world like in the HP books. Also, although i respect that other people love the whole bella/edward thing, but i believe that the relationships in HP are more realistic. EX: (SPOILERS) snape/lilly, tonks/lupin, and of course ron/hermione, who's love is the most believable to me.

  • Harry/Ginny? xD

  • @rebecca1918420 Are you kidding? HG/RW Is the MOST unlikely pair in the HP books.

  • @DuchessCullen No way, they're always flirting back and forth and hiding feelings. Just like children and teenagers always do

  • @biblegirl Yes, they were written that way (they had to be paired up according to JK) but really HG's (personal) character is not based on Ron or vice versa. Their characters don't even mesh well. Why on earth would a brilliant brave young woman ever be with and forgive a cowardly simple young man with nothing to recommend him. In fact, he comes from a much less educated background than her and he does nothing to better himself. He doesn't deserve her and she deserved much better!

  • @DuchessCullen -- "cowardly simple young man" Insecure is the word you're looking for, dear. He's not cowardly, never cowardly: he's insecure and impulsive.

    "He doesn't deserve her and she deserved much better!"

    But she CHOSE him. (Do note that SHE initiated the first kiss.) She CHOSE him. Choices. They show who we truly are, far more than our abilities. She could have done better--but she loved Ron, and chose him.

  • @rebecca1918420 I love Twilight and Harry Potter and I can agree with that statement. Meyer created a story that had already been created, there are lots of forbidden romance out there, but JK made a story that was completey authentic, but at the same time used history and knowledge of our world to make the wizarding one.

    I think she is fantastic, for creating a world so spectacular as Harrys. I love Harry Potter and not ashamed to say it has changed my life and the way I think about things.

  • @rebecca1918420 Dont forget Harry/Ginny

  • @TheKittyKat1000 I never really liked Harry/Ginny

    I just think it was so cliche and that it would have been a school romance and then fall apart when they both grew up

    Not to mention they married so young

    It would never have worked

    That is one thing i never liked about the epilogue

    Just stating my opinion ;)

  • @FeltTipPencil Well every one has opinions

  • @rebecca1918420 I think Meyer and Rowling both had different goals with their stories. And, while I'm not a fan of Twilight, I don't see the point in comparing the books because they had different morals and meanings.

  • @rebecca1918420 Tonks/Lupin my arse. I hate that pairing. It seemed like Rowling just threw them together because they were the only ones left.

  • I hate twilight. It's lame.

    Harry Potter forever.

    and the twilight fandom doesn't have half as big a fan base

  • The books are good. The film of twilight is not so good. They ain't got shit on Harry Potter though!

  • robert patinson does not look like how i imagined cedric diggory or edward. i thought that he captured cedric fairly well though, but i've never really been a fan of edward. kinda pissed me off that bella would lead jacob on like that.

  • I think I cried more when he died in the movie, not the book because we saw it happening.

  • @broadwaygal2008 It's so embarrassing but I cried hard when he died in the book and then when the movie came out I was hoping that he wouldn't die (silly, I know) and when he did I started sobbing. Now when I watch the movie or read the book, I just stop before he dies. I DO think Rob was the PERFECT Cedric, I just with he could've actually used what little acting skills he had to make Twilight a better movie. .also, shave, ALOT!!! Wax or something jeeze he's more wolf than Jacob sometimes.

  • *Wish

  • I love this song <3<3

  • i cired in the book and the film when cedric died =(

    my mates made fun out of me for days xp

  • No worries, I still cry. Lol.

    I'm a dork, who cares?

    <3 HARRY POTTER!

  • way better than harry and the potters. yknow, i dont think any1 cared about cedric until the movie came out and he was robert pattinson who is also edward who sucks ass and harry potter kicks twilight ass and jacob kicks edward ass so theres my opinion.

  • you know. i think i just didn't care that much about cedric because he was only in the one book. and i was really young at the time so i didn't completely comprehend. Plus the fact that Voldemort comes back after that is a bit overwhelming. But I agree. I think people suddenly care more because of RPattinson...

  • You know, he was technically in more than the fourth if you count harry's dreams and such. Like, they talk about him all the time. -sigh-

    RIP Cedric.

  • I don't agree, I really loved Cedric before the movie came out. When he died it was the first time i cried in a Harry potter book. I still have trouble reading that passage. IMO Robert Pattinson is totally not what i had expected him to be

  • I actually liked Cedric before the movie came out,

    and I thought robert Pattinson did a fantastic job as him.

    Which is why I'm a fan of his.

    He did better as Cedric than as Edward, but I hate how everyone loves him now BECAUSE he's playing edward. You know?

    HARRY POTTER FOREVER!

  • 4EVA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • FERSURE.

  • haha i love him "why did u give me chocolate alex?" "because this song rocks!" this song made me cry the first time i heard it

  • Saaaame here. xD

  • i think its;

    1 2 3 4 567

    all down but i cant be sure..

  • can someone figure out the strum pattern for this?

  • This song DOES frekaing rock!! lolz he so funny 'take one and pass it around'

  • lol i know right :P

  • i cried my eyes out the first time i heard this song

  • Best Wizard Rock group ever.

  • they're on itunes :) x

  • best news i've heard all day

  • Why did you give us chocolate, Alex? Because this song freakin rocks! haha!

  • i want to start a wizard rock band that rules

  • You totally should start a wrock band!

  • all wizard rock bands rule hon

  • Oh god. He's playing a show in a bookstore about 20 minutes from me and I CANT GO! AGH. It fucking sucks.

  • I know what you mean! They're playing near me this weekend, and I can't go either! GAH!

  • I love this!!

  • Ok I think I can feel all right taking the kids to a Wizard Rock concert after watching a few of these.

  • I love him :D HE HANDS OUT CHOCOLATE omg.

  • Fan fiction doesn't infringe on the copy rights, and they're actually using the characters in the same way that JK Rowling uses them! Also, these bands are verrrry well known, and I'm sure that JK Rowling know about them. She doesn't care though, obviously! She knows that this kind of thing is going to happen with something as famous as HP, and she went ahead and wrote all those books anyways, did she not?

  • well I would assume that she would know about it all, and I'm sure that she doesn't care.

    And I can even understand the part about it not being copyright infringement, however, due to the fact that they are making a profit, they could get into deep shit if Rowling decided the press the issue because they are not paying royalties.

  • Actually very few of them make any profit from this. Most of them donate alll the money they make to the HP Alliance and other charities which aim to get more children into reading.  And JKR does know about the existance of wrock bands - MTV have filmed them and there has been a documentary filmed, so there haven't been any problems.

  • They don't make much money off of this at all and Jo would have decided by now if she's going to bring them to court and it's not as though they're passing it off as their own work! They take credit for writing the songs, but not for coming up with the characters or scenarios, they give Jo full and complete credit for that!

  • Well, some people do make money. Matt from The Whomping Willows actually quit his job because he can now support himself from wrock. But he does a TON for charity.

    And JKR and WB do know about wrock. WB actually originally called Harry and the Potters to complain, but they weren't being crazy about it, and it was eventually settled that the bands couldn't sell any merchandise except CDs online. That's why you can't really find any wrock t-shirts except at live shows.

  • Well, you can find 'em at Zazzle, but they aren't official or anything.

  • why would jk rowling care if they earn some money on it, shes like so rich that doesnt matter for her at all. and i bet she just thinks it fun with such bands from her work..

  • Come to wainwright! (in the summer cuz that storm in buffalo didn't sound like fun and it wasn't fun here either)

  • lol may 13 - my bday! eeee :)

  • could this be more touching? love it

  • I always want to cry during this song!

  • the first concert i ever saw was a remus lupins concert! it was a small concert but still completely ROCKIN'!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • I never would have thought something like this existed. There's like 3 bands dedicated to Harry Potter! Awesome!

  • there is a lot more then 3 bands. there is a whole TON of wizard rock bands. my favs are the remus lupins, the moaning myrtles, and harry and the potters!

  • I hope you realize that there are well over a hundred wizard rock bands. XD haha

  • ...there needs to be a massive gig for this sometime soon-ish...

    t'would be AWESOME. =D

  • Azkatraz 2009 is next summer.

  • Where is it?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!

  • San Francisco! I live in Chicago, but my mom said I can go as long as I don't get a C in chemistry for first semester!

  • really u don't to go that far

  • PLEASE COME TO GERMANY! I would love to see you live!

  • i want...to do him.

    haha no but seriously this is amazing i absolutely love him and the remus lupins! fave wrock band ever!

  • why wasn't anyone singing along?

  • cause it's such a sensitive song.

    and HP fans do not sing.

    we're full of emo.

  • wizrock.hell ye. the remus lupins straight up pwn. one of the few wizrock bands that have actual skill. probs alex - everyone else, buy his albums.:D

  • Alex should come up in North California, we need him and his rock.

  • come to ENGLAND Alex!!!!! you wouldnt believe the number of fans you have over here!!!!

  • "look at how sensitive i am,

    because my voice is so soft..."

  • This is a great song. Alex Carpenter is awesome!

  • Alexm one of my top Wrock bands. His latest alub really rocked. Come to England!!!!

  • I love these guys. Alex wrocks!

  • Yay! I love them.

    Just an idea... Some one should make a wizard rock band and call it the Marauders. Maybe some already has I'm not sure though. But that would be pretty cool.

  • me and my best friend / sister have created a band called the Marauderesses

    but at the moment we aint known yet

    we are in England

  • This is my favorite Wizard Rock band.

  • LOVE THE END!!

  • One of the best wrockbands...

    I just love Remember Cedric!

    Wrock on ;-)

  • lol legends <33

    Wrock On

  • Rofl i love this video alex cracks me up.

  • Very nice, just u cant hear him well

    GO REMUS LUPINS!!!!!!!!!

    Vicci if you read this its Maite

  • do they make money off this?? im not dissin'.. just curious

  • Yeah. The Remus Lupins are on iTunes. I think some of their shows are free, but you can buy their music.

  • I think they do make a little money but the majority of that probably goes to traveling when they tour or go to a conference(s) and then for the merchandise CD's shirts, etc. I think most of their concerts are free though if there at a conference one has to pay for the conference and there might be a small fee for the venues they use, which would go the venue owner or to help pay for them using the venue.

  • Awesome!

  • Quit Hating!

    Just Because He Can Sing And You Can't Don't Give You The Right To Hate.

    Harry Potter Is Freakin' Awesome!

    This Is An Awesome Song!

    So Get Off Of His Fucking Tip!

  • what the fuccccccck. you people suck. POTTER ROCKS AND SO DO THE REMUS LUPINS. fuuuuuuuuu

  • bhaha

    Image having to go to the hospital cause chocolate vicously attacked you

  • i was just with them!! my friend had a party and shes friends with them so YES!

  • I LOVE YOU ALEX!!!!!

  • Rofl. I love Alex, and The Remus Lupins. Total geniusness.

  • He's coming to Toronto!!! So excited. ^___^

  • Alex is so funny, and hot