I think Gruberova has the best coloraturas in this tempo. Moser is more dramatic and Damrau's performance is overally balanced.
I like also Popp (earlier performance is more precise, later one is more dramatic), Dessay (this role doesn't fit to her, but her vocal abilities are really fine). Serra and Kwon are also interesting.
which year is this?
akherousia 4 months ago
Edita sings the best version .
hazelssister 5 months ago
hardest song for a soprano....clarity, speed, accuracy and to sustain the voice. @.@
upaa83 7 months ago
it's the best version I've heard.
david1218a 1 year ago 4
OH MY GOD
Webarton 1 year ago
Esse sotaque não é de alemão.
BrasilianMusician 1 year ago
Gorgeous, but with a little glitch at 1:06 and a slightly imprecise High F at 1:12.
She must also be greatly commended for her ENUNCIATION here, which many others completely overlook.
Rapture1987 1 year ago
God i love her!!!
robdizzle5280 1 year ago
How old is she in this recording? Her voice has an unpleasant "metallic" quality to my ear that might come from age.
saagua1953 1 year ago
@saagua1953 She was 41 here. By operatic vocal age standards she should be in her prime.
CountertenorJ 1 year ago
Well; her technique is flawless, but the tempo is a bit fast. Then again; she is famous for her fast-paced coloratura.
Nahsaghara 1 year ago
Comment removed
HydraDiablos09 1 year ago
nicht so gut wie in 1987.
Vincenzo2010an 1 year ago
Comment removed
Vincenzo2010an 1 year ago
Fantastica.
tenorisimo1975 1 year ago
super!
VINCENZO3002 2 years ago
SUPER
thomastmwc 2 years ago
i dont believe this... Only Edita has sung this incredibly difficult aria in the last 70 years... it is amazing
LohengrinT 2 years ago
i think that it's too fast though....compared to damrau and the others...
christmascarol18 2 years ago
I enjoy the tempo
Hemanthemannequin 2 years ago
to big vibrato for me... :)
But it is so good! :)
dorak8 2 years ago
I think Gruberova has the best coloraturas in this tempo. Moser is more dramatic and Damrau's performance is overally balanced.
I like also Popp (earlier performance is more precise, later one is more dramatic), Dessay (this role doesn't fit to her, but her vocal abilities are really fine). Serra and Kwon are also interesting.
tomasburi 2 years ago
thats true- but Gruberovas performance is much better
hillevifan 3 years ago
She is wonderful. I think one of top 3 in this aria with Sumi Jo and June Anderson
freegman007 3 years ago
i agree, but i'd add joan sutherland.
rterrybell 2 years ago
Sutherland never managed an F! I do admire her, but that was just NOT HER ROLE...
mggirl85 2 years ago
Do you think it's rather weird that she sang an F in "O Zittre Nicht," and yet she couldn't manage it for this aria?
ChrisStockslager 2 years ago
I don get it....she couldn't manage what?? at which time point ?? :) tell me please,I didn't catch it
thomastmwc 2 years ago
this execution is not dramatic, or operatic, mayb, but it's so artistic
like, this doesnt show she's an evil queen here, but this execution itself is kinda perfect
agree :) ??
thomastmwc 2 years ago
CHE AGILITà!!
DiegoMartinazzoli 3 years ago
She does a nice job with this tough aria. Her high notes are just okay for me though.. Diana Damrau is better
bradfordkern 3 years ago
SHE IS THE BEST!! BRAVA!!!!!!!!!
DiegoMartinazzoli 3 years ago
I hope you like this.
THANK YOU FOR COMMENTING!!!!!
leoperarm 3 years ago
@leoperarm I don't like this, i LOVE this !!! :D
YAM466 1 year ago 4