WoW! As a long time fan of the franchise, I watch alot of these type of videos. I favorite only a few. This is one of that few. I seriously cannot put into unique words how bloody brilliant your work here is. Everyone that has commented before me has stolen those words, and my comment pales in comparison. Sad, beautiful, brilliant, awesome, perfect - words all used before. Thank you for sharing this with us.
i felt so sorry for the doctor when he had to wipe donna's memory. i think the loss of donna affected him more than the loss of rose because donna actually helped him to get over rose by being such a wonderful, loud and hilarious friend and now that she's gone the doctor is reminded of how he just loses everyone in the end
I honestly have no idea why this *isn't* in my favorites! I thought I'd favorited it months ago, but gosh, watching this again just made me want to crawl into bed and sob [in a good way, don't worry hun:P]
You captured the Doctor's emotions incredibly well and gosh it's just so beautifully made!
Anyways, now this is officially in my favorites, for good! sigh, *dies from the beautifullness of this vid* :))
THIS IS AWESOME! At 3:02 what ep is that from? The Doc's cradling someone's head and crying and others are standing in the background watching? It doesn'ts look like the Doc's Daughter ep. What is it? Thanks for doing this it's great!
Absolutely beautiful work- that was both visually and emotionally stunning. Really original choice of clips too, and it was great to see some series 4. Saved for much rewatching!
That was wonderful. I am a huge fan of this beautiful song. I love the way you edited so well to the strikes of the piano keys mixed with a perfect choice of clips. Heartbreaking. Well done. Favourited. :)
Oh yay, that's 3 great Doctor who videos I've seen to this song now:) I absolutely loved this, very poignant and beautiful- nice use of b/w, and really lovely shots used. 5 stars and favourited!
oh my god! it was so touching. perfect footage for the music, seriously. i'm not a fan of the song, tho, but you know my taste in music aint so big :/ Hehe, anywhos, thanks for the dedication. i'm always here to help, you knnow <3
wow... just wow! this was amazing, honestly! i loved the effects and the clips u used were perfect for the song and just great job all around!! 5 stars and favorited!
1:52 through 2:00 is the saddest part. xD I all most cried.
iSpudnik 11 months ago
how can two people not like this video???
franl155 1 year ago
WoW! As a long time fan of the franchise, I watch alot of these type of videos. I favorite only a few. This is one of that few. I seriously cannot put into unique words how bloody brilliant your work here is. Everyone that has commented before me has stolen those words, and my comment pales in comparison. Sad, beautiful, brilliant, awesome, perfect - words all used before. Thank you for sharing this with us.
scubadogg 2 years ago 4
3:03 is the best part...awesome clips there...This vid made me so sad
Twilight438 2 years ago
Sad is happiness for deep people. Brilliant.
2006hoss2006 2 years ago
this is so beautiful.
i felt so sorry for the doctor when he had to wipe donna's memory. i think the loss of donna affected him more than the loss of rose because donna actually helped him to get over rose by being such a wonderful, loud and hilarious friend and now that she's gone the doctor is reminded of how he just loses everyone in the end
MUSEequalsMUSIC 2 years ago
brilliant!
Runawayer 2 years ago
perfect.
MsWholigan 2 years ago
so sad,he's so lonely
AngelTheLonely 2 years ago 2
3:31 "can you reach me" is the best timing/clip of the vid for me. I really like the thing as a whole, too. Can't get the song out of my head.
sorcha425 2 years ago
absolutely beautiful, i love this song and it works so nicely with your clip
Doddsy8825 2 years ago
omg...*tear*... brilliant
Why couldnt donna stay she was perfect for hime, the 10th doctor has a hard time of it!
I wish just one fo the companions would stay with him:(
dtsfangirl 2 years ago 2
Luv it! Good job!
thedoctorsdonna 3 years ago
Excellent vid. Really moved me
visitjessiechan 3 years ago
I honestly have no idea why this *isn't* in my favorites! I thought I'd favorited it months ago, but gosh, watching this again just made me want to crawl into bed and sob [in a good way, don't worry hun:P]
You captured the Doctor's emotions incredibly well and gosh it's just so beautifully made!
Anyways, now this is officially in my favorites, for good! sigh, *dies from the beautifullness of this vid* :))
HarryDoesntKnow 3 years ago
He sooooo needs some good times I hope gets some soon!!!!
This was so very well done every choice was right for what you wanted to convey you are truly an artist!!!
Kansas/Oz
I hope Our Doctor gets more Oz time soon
Sheliabluerose 3 years ago
aww he is soo lonely :(
davidtennantlovers 3 years ago
loved it
TMontannaScarface 3 years ago
Thank you for everyones brilliant comments, i really appreciate it :)x
RosetylerProductions 3 years ago
no problem
TMontannaScarface 3 years ago
It's so sad and beautiful at the same time.
aliacapone8129ad 2 years ago
Beautiful. :) Great song and clip choices! I love the way you edited to the beat. 5* and *faved*
THEpowerOFme 3 years ago
I'd love to see something done to Mummer's Dance like the Peter Pan video on my site but with Doctor Who
truecalling 3 years ago
THIS IS AWESOME! At 3:02 what ep is that from? The Doc's cradling someone's head and crying and others are standing in the background watching? It doesn'ts look like the Doc's Daughter ep. What is it? Thanks for doing this it's great!
truecalling 3 years ago
truecalling: That was from Last of the Time Lords from Season 3... I won't spoil it for you tho, sounds like you haven't seen it. ^^
katesmeow 3 years ago
Yeah, she's right. Last of the Timelords. That ending SO made me cry.
Elanel 3 years ago
yay. i'm happy now. in a sad happy way.
it;s like what Sally said in Blink about sad things making her happy.
tjchasikin 3 years ago
gimme a FAN
gimme a TAS
gimme a TIC
put it all together and what does that make?
FANTASTIC
i may be in spain.. but i would never miss out on watchin your vids mate.
*favs + 5 stars*
ncis2doctorwho 3 years ago
Aww that was beautiful! Just completely beautiful. Great song choice! 5* and *faved*
THEpowerOFme 3 years ago
Absolutely beautiful work- that was both visually and emotionally stunning. Really original choice of clips too, and it was great to see some series 4. Saved for much rewatching!
piffo 3 years ago 4
Thank you Piffo (:
glad you liked it
and thanks for faving the video also :)
asarathWitch:- :O wow! thanks for the compliment i can't help but blush. Your comment has really brightended up my day.
RosetylerProductions 3 years ago
Another masterpiece. I'm becoming a hufe fan! ^^
AsarathWitch 3 years ago
That was wonderful. I am a huge fan of this beautiful song. I love the way you edited so well to the strikes of the piano keys mixed with a perfect choice of clips. Heartbreaking. Well done. Favourited. :)
seduff 3 years ago
5* just for making me cry (which I didn't really want to do, lol)! That was so touching, so moving...especially 1:53 - 1:58 *wipes away tears*
Brilliant song choice as well =)
KimiMclarenFan 3 years ago
Okay. This actually sent a REALLY big shiver down my spine.
And for some really strange reason i have butterflies.
its just like ... WOW
DTloverforever 3 years ago
How did you get it to sort of flash whilst it was crossing over the other clip. So it's like:
Crossover, then a small flash then the rest of the new clip, (if you understand me :P)
Great video. Can't wait for you heatbeats one aswell!
zcatz 3 years ago
I did through Brightness and Contrast...
and thank you all for the great comments :)
I really appreciate it :D
RosetylerProductions 3 years ago
Oh yay, that's 3 great Doctor who videos I've seen to this song now:) I absolutely loved this, very poignant and beautiful- nice use of b/w, and really lovely shots used. 5 stars and favourited!
gracefulangel47 3 years ago
WOAH! WKD!
Rosetylermad111 3 years ago
thank you (:
RosetylerProductions 3 years ago
mann. i can't get this video to work and everyone says it's awesome. youtube hates me. :( i was really looking forward to this.
goggles226 3 years ago
Beautifully tragic, absolutly wonderful :)
x-Bouffie-x
bouff2006 3 years ago
Soo beautiful.
The Lonely Angel indeed.
Poor thing.
He really is a wonderfully tragic character, and this portrays it brilliantly.
I'm in bloody tears here!
Which means, of course, that I absolutly adore it!!!!
HogwartsHonorRoll 3 years ago
thank you for the compliment :) HHR, sorry about you being in tears btw, i didn't mean it to be that upsetting, :P hehe xD
RosetylerProductions 3 years ago
lurve it!!!
cooldotscool 3 years ago
aww thank you :)
and its nice to know my effort has gone into something that is liked by you and many people.
erm i dunno :S i dont think I'll finish a few of them since i got bored of them, hehe xD
RosetylerProductions 3 years ago
This was truly excellent.
iluffdavidtennant 3 years ago
aww thank you glad you like it and to be honest, i rushed the ending coz i wanted to get it done, hehe xD but still,glad you like it :P
RosetylerProductions 3 years ago
This is really amazing! Especially the ending! :)
Ashley :) :)
ilovemugglenet 3 years ago
oh my god! it was so touching. perfect footage for the music, seriously. i'm not a fan of the song, tho, but you know my taste in music aint so big :/ Hehe, anywhos, thanks for the dedication. i'm always here to help, you knnow <3
CILLEXD 3 years ago
*Watches the end of the video, starts clapping and whistling* its sad but a gr8 job
thexmanx 3 years ago
wow that was amazing loved it your editing is perfect
mchun 3 years ago
this is one of the best videos I have ever seen here on youtube
LucyAllonsyFreak 3 years ago
:O aww thanks for the compliment :)
i really appreciate it :D x
RosetylerProductions 3 years ago
aw that was so sad.
totallyDT 3 years ago
Wow loved it
I did a video to this song too
But i prefer yours!!!
Amaaazing
Lozzeh13 3 years ago
Just letting you know, I received your entry! :D
AisicsRule 3 years ago
Nicely Done!!
Great touch with the B/W footage...
You really caught the Emotions of the Doctor.
5/5!
StelyDn 3 years ago
Remarkable job. I especially like the touch of the b&w for the first part. The effects, clips, song, and emotion conveyed were perfect!
KLady3 3 years ago
wow... just wow! this was amazing, honestly! i loved the effects and the clips u used were perfect for the song and just great job all around!! 5 stars and favorited!
HarryDoesntKnow 3 years ago
wow i love it! great job! Truly tear-jerking!
doctorwholuvr 3 years ago
thank you (: glad you like it :D
i wasn't sure about this video,but glad you like it all the same :)
RosetylerProductions 3 years ago
Brilliant 5*s and Faved [ofcorse :)]
Good luck now then x
Doctorwhofan001 3 years ago