Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (8,220)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • My piano teacher told me: "You can not play the piano with long nails." He lied.

    I am proud to be a fan of Lady gaga. I respected her and her work. <3

  • Nothing more ore less than deeply unexpected and stunning.

  • That is some voice

  • Comment removed

  • If I meet with GaGa, I will be the happiest person in the world!!!<3 I love you gaga you made me feel I am beautiful and you gave me self-confidence. Thank you GaGa I'm your little monster forever<3<3<3

  • You are beautiful. I love you live more then recorded and I never like anyone live. Xoxo

  • This make so proud. I love you Lady Gaga so much. You're my Mother Monster 4ever. Hope I can meet you one day...

  • Choose your level:

    Justin Bieber

    Easy

    Medium

    Hard

    Impossible

    Lady GaGa

  • i like heavy metal and i LIKE this

  • She should do an acoustic album. I like this raw version of her music. More soul.

  • Join the MFG - (Metalheads For Gaga)

  • I always believed. Paws and all ♥

  • I could appreciate her much more if she would tone down the theatrics.Very talented but all the freakiness kinda gets in the way of it.

  • I never liked lady gaga and thought she just used auto tune and crappy pop beats to get her message across. Then I watch this stripped down version and realized I was very wrong. I even went as far as covering this song to prove my point that I am no longer a gaga "hater." Let me know what ya think if you get a chance.

  • good god who married him? :[

  • She's the real deal and nothing like these no talent, over glorified, lip syncing twits like Brittany Spears, Janet Jackson....etc. Lady Gaga writes all her own material and is a classically trained musician.

  • had no idea she was this good

  • she drops the crazy persona, and does this only, id love

  • That's what I look like when I take a shit after taco bell^^^^c:

  • wow amazing how different it sounds without auto tune

  • @69heheh69 Lol people like you need to get some new material. Such a stupid joke now.

  • SO POWERFUL!!!

  • I dont like howard stern, but my dad showed me this video and its so insparational

  • back when she was sane

  • @pigpoo101 six months ago. yeah. all the way back then.

  • @thekingoffunnyfaces hey that's all it takes sometimes lol

  • Thank GOD for this performance.

  • Shes the only superstar that actually lives upto the hype. Can sing and play piano like a motherfucker!!! We've never seen anything like Gaga before! Love her!

  • PLEASE RELEASE A ROCK ALBUM. YOU HAVE TALENT, BUT YOUR IN THE WRONG GENRE. YOU DON'T NEED BULLSHIT AUTO TUNE OR SYNTHS.

  • I think she is always like this singing this song ^.^

  • Hurry up vote for lady gaga on vh1 webite!

  • it's funny to see how Howard is really disapointed at the end of the song when he congratulates GaGa. Like a kid ! hi, hi ! He eats his words, so cute. <3 MotherMonster <3

  • Comment removed

  • I'm a metal fan but i'm also a fan of a good voice and to be honest I really didn't like or respect lady gaga until I saw this wow she is awesome

  • Beautiful! 

  • actually "The Edge of Glory" should hav won the GRAMMY for best pop solo vocal performance!! and RECORD OF THE YEAR!!! i think that the critics are DEAF nowadays, and the composition is so beautiful, comparing this to Rolling in the Deep (which is outstanding) The Edge of Glory is BEYONG WORDS!!! and GaGa's singing is her best yet!

  • Good God she should have won a grammy

  • @travt123 She's won 5!

  • She's so amazing and a true artist that is able to sound just like her album. Boo to Britney and cheers to Lady Gaga!

  • that woman is amazing!

  • SOO MUCH PASSION 

  • If had a choice that i could meet one person in this world dead or alive, i would choose her... she said so much... she has so much to say!!! #inspirationlovepeacefuturetru­th

  • i luv her voice(:

  • Who's this guy calling himself lady?

  • @JonO387 Larry Gaga

  • @Yeahuh0Kay Ooohhhhhhhh. I see.

  • What a beautiful voice...I like it better acoustic than on the CD. She might be different, but I know her heart is in the right place, and that's all that matters.

  • And she's "reductive" for being such a copycat plagiarist with Madonna's music.

  • i love that she's not afraid to be ugly

  • @johnnytheory It's not about "being pretty" or "being ugly", she says that she defines beauty for herself, society doesn't define her beauty. And she expects others to do the same.

  • Comment removed

  • Aaaa, listening to music for forty years , gaga is special, something there no one else has.

  • i love this video. its like she plays the piano with her whole body. i just love it and i love her <3

  • It's amazing how clueless people who say she has no talent are. Gaga <3

  • Howard Stern totally has the hots for gaga.

  • Try this Madonna!!

  • This song has gotten me through so much and I'm always amazed by her every time I watch this.

  • So many months later....I'm still blown away by this performance

  • Wow. This just blew me away. Such a beautiful and strong voice. You can just see how much she loves to sing and perform. She looks so sweet and cute here its hard for a guy like me to watch this and not be taken with her.

  • She is extremely sexy and talented. Date me, Gaga?

  • Oh my. Howard's comment makes me want to cry. And GaGa's beautiful talent is oozing everywhere! my ear was raped by GaGa and I love it! <3

  • What people need to understand is this song isn't about falling in love. It's about having a love that lasts until death like the one her grandfather and grandmother had.

  • Madonna, Queen of Pop; Stef Germanotta, Queen of Music!! ;D

  • doesnt she look like booxy here ??

  • I love her voice here.

  • I sure as hell have never heard Madonna sing like this.

  • So perfect .. I love her so much <3

  • I wonder if Madonna has seen this video. Wow. GAGA is amazing!

  • i am not a fan of her , but great performance !

  • @therealbologna2 THE IRAQ WAR OVER ... THIS TIME FOR REALSIES? the user is @sxephil

  • Lady Gaga singing like an angel and playing piano with her long-ass new york nails here when no one really payed to watch her and Madonna is lip-syncing in Super Bowl where thousands of people pay truck loads of money to buy a ticket. You do the math.

  • When is she going to start winning awards for her live performances?

  • Over 2.5 million views and 447 dislikes? I have to guess that 447 deaf people watched this, so far.

  • @scottdiamond74 Comments about dislikes are fucking stupid.

  • I'm speechless, Gaga is incredible

  • my god... howard is a god

  • Comment removed

  • I like fish.

  • Te Amooo Gaga <3

  • This is so epic

  • To say her voice is striking would be the understatement of the decade.Ive never seen a more talented and interesting singer ever.

  • Comment removed

  • Why is it that every time she opens her fucking mouth I burst into tears..........?? = )

  • Comment removed

  • This is why I'm a Gaga fan. This right here. <3

  • I am not a fan of her but she has outstanding talent, far ahead madonna ...

  • @Monchaichai That's because Madonna is The Queen of Pop, but Lady Gaga is The Goddess of Pop. Respect, both ways.

  • @Monchaichai her idol is madonna btw

  • "sit right there i gotta ask you something, that was beautiful!" haha! nice questions there pal!!! =P

  • lady gaga has one of those voices that is very pleasant to listen to,,,the only voice that it feels good to listen beside hers is Mariah's

  • @80Jellybean and bob marley

  • Fucking beautiful

  • I cried just watchin

  • Song about her grandpa...singing about falling in love...

  • I'd bet any hater would change their mind if they see her perform live like this.

  • Wow . got chillzzzz >_> eyes poping out and stuf....... and a ear-gasm... Good job.

    Just a thought: She seems like she could be as normal as everyone else if people did not stare into the fame.

  • Like a boss!

  • Why is this song so captivating, only this version. I never paid much attention to her, love her on the piano. I wake up in the morn. and this song/version is in my head some days. More Gaga on the Piano. Bravo!

  • I always thought Howard Stern guest's only consist of pornstars, the black guy with the funny teeth and members of the kkk. Not someone as big as Lady Gaga.

  • It's also knowing in your heart, that you may never reach that glorious moment until you die....fucking love this chick!

  • SO LITTLE MONSTERS WHAT DO YOU THINK ABOUT NASTY NICKI MINAJ WANTING TO BE LIKE GAGA ? I THINK SHE IS TRYING TO HARD, FIRST DUETING WITH MADONNA, THEN THE CRAZY THINGS AT GRAMMY, AND NOW A SONG WITH RED ONE ? NICKI NEEDS JUST TO BE HERSELF. A RAPPER NOT POP ARTIST

  • Sounds great but the lyrics are as fucked up as can get. These are supposed to be for her grandfather?? Doesn't make sense. What about when lyrics were what they were. Lyrics are cryptic, satanic and whacked!

  • Id like to see Nikki, or Katy, or Brittany, or Rihanna, or Madonna try doing this and see if they come anywhere close to as good this.

  • Lady GaGa, Me quito el sombrero! I loved it! I wanna sing this to my friends tomorrow in the university!

  • this is what people should call talent!

  • have a great voice, play piano wonderfully, make shitty albums.. scumbag gaga!

  • I'm no Lady Gaga fan but this was an amazing performance. Don't forget this performance was at like 7-8am, most singers simply don't have the voice at that hour. The album version of this song pales in comparison, it's just a techno pop song with the electronic music behind it... But when it's just her and her piano, mistakes and all, it's really a great song. This really sets her apart from the rest of the pop singers hiding behind auto-tune and songs they didn't write themselves.

  • Realy bad..

  • @ValentinaCoenen Really bad grammar? I think so.

  • Christina Aguilera who?

  • I only listen to this instead of the studio version, 20x better.

  • Wow, she is the only talented and hard working person in the music industry right now and your argument is SO invalid. You may contain your jealousy, because it is impossible not to see her talent and difference from the other popular cheesy and shitty "artists."

  • @doguhankarasu the ''only''! that's a very silly statement.

  • DA BRIVIDI!

  • I'm always coming back here since I've heard it for the first time and it still blows me away how good this is!

  • Her talent is RAW

  • Fishy

  • I think this has to be her greatest performance to date, I keep coming back to it every month or so.

  • NO EDGE!!!!!!

  • Steve my old and new school Agent word for word:with London CIA Agency uhm,just to say hello to us on hints here man before or after this Entourage of mine here,2278 ****RINGS OVER RINGS****,YOU KNOW WHAT SPAD'S TABLE CRACKER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!

  • No one else could do this

  • Bold, fierce, powerful, talented, musician, singer, and 100 other things layed at your feet Mother Monster!!!!!!!! My paws are UP!\

  • How fascinatingly powerful she is. I love how she doesn't care what they think at all. Her energy is stunning (:

  • she can do so much better than puh-puh-puh-poker face. -.-

  • @miralawlessxx wow poker face came out like 3 years ago....gaga doesn't even make songs like that anymore -.-

  • 4:03 WITH ShOE WITH SHOE WITH SHOE. xD haha love gaga

  • @Uncompelable loool.

  • This is why she's my lady! :)

    She moves something in me no one else ever managed to move.

  • VERY BEAUTIFUL

  • who the fuck disliked this??? 442 douchebags

  • @CutiePants2006 Don't insult the hearing impaired! Those people must be deaf!

  • I was never a Gaga fan but Wow! That song is a lot deeper that I knew. Impressive

  • @Brine49 No?

  • Whitney's edge of glory

  • Lady gaga is amazing in everything she does!

  • It's so beautiful that she got a story behind almost all of her songs :')

    Put your Paws up :)

  • Awesome solo. I'm learning some of her singles right now. I will never be as good as Mother Monster herself. LONG LIVE LADY GAGA!!!!!!!

  • I can't stop rewinding this amazing performance.

  • I cried ...

  • Comment removed

  • magra mgeris magram ar mevaseba yvela makiajit lamaziaa magram es umakiajot iseti maxinjia eshmaki rom shexedavs pirjvars gadaiwersssss:P

  • This is perfect guys. I'm in love with you Gaga

  • AMAZING <3

  • veenaacVAlee... :* magaraii Qaliiaaa ;|\\ <3

    

  • Madonna who?

  • @the3471kronos I know what's going on uhm let me see here,alright ******* City one Vamp Osama off the map will say/)/)/)/)/) anways and anybody going over some Hard Weird uhm use Nascar again,well just bring it up that Koleski on my Grandma here lol,Koleski grabbed 3 Nationwides and 3 Sprints doing 2011/)/)/)/)/) well well wel the Seals that died two weeks after Osama the 6 aprt of the Soama take down were in the Helicopter well then Jeff Gordon won a few tight ones after,oh Tom Watson won also.

  • @MrCourtyC so uhm Tom Watson grabs the Seniors PGA Championship,ok ill get to the point you'll here this one did someone give oyu a sunburn on your Wikipedia,well here we go,oh before I get staretd they got to stop putting mine,Uncle Vinnie's,and Dale Junior's drawings on the air.Well get that Vamp in Sherrif's custody next season on some RAIN!!! ^Acts like Dale Junior accent lol^ uhm You Guy's want to know what really really pined this,becide being on my Dad's and Luke's for Sports and notes.

  • @MrCourtyC Here it goes Stern get a Pen,in the End I sent Producer's Quentin Tarantino,Kurt Sutter Frances,Len Wiseman,Orlando Steven Speilberg,myself,Carl Edwards Nascar Driver etc. after the information I gathered "Euegene very very very Gay on word for word,and very very interesting Mr. Vance and and good stuff" int he End some People told me I sent them some real real real REAL REAL REAL REAL REAL REAL REAL REAL REAL REAL REAL REAL REAL IN THE WORD REAL TIMES 10 BILLION OF BEING DOG SH***T!!

  • @MrCourtyC UHM BEFORE YOU GET INTO THIS,UHM LIKE REAL AND STEVE MY OLD AGENT DO NOT MISS THE GOOGLE SEARCH ETC. TARANTINO.INFO WEBSITE WHEN MY Uncle Armand Actor etc. speaks kinda like those two comments I just explained and looking into these notes,don't miss him

    !

    !

    !

  • @MrCourtyC Ohh do not miss him,ill cover that one TIME FOR AN IMAGE!!!!,TIME TO TALK ABOUT KRAMER THE VAMP AND THE GAME!!!!

  • @MrCourtyC Ohh do not miss the Uncle Actor Armand Guide here lol,thers another Guide try to work with me,ohh a Pleasure to be on my Green Jacket here,check this out another YOUTUBE.COM FROM Marcus Schekenberg the Supermodel Google search do not miss that action or Kennedy **** Stickers will say with normal milk spills,JESUS!!! OHH I EXPLAIN IT PERFECT,DO NOT MISS 10 WWE OR WWF WRESLER'S 5 FOOT 8 ALSO UHM and some Coffee Please

    !

    !

    !

    !

    !

    !

    !

    !

  • @MrCourtyC yea don't miss that one "Thank you Marcus!!!" whatever that issue,you know the Secret Servie gave me the Purpose Kitty Meow's some real Horse Sh***T!! WHAT DO MEAN ONTHE SWEAR IN,ARMAND GOLF GENUIS THEY GAVE ME THE ONE THAT LOOKED LIKE JUDGE DUD ******** HURHURHUR!!!!!,Keith don't talk abou that SH***T!! in front of little Eric anymore it Ended in a Wine Sh***T!! ROOM!!!,IM STILL CLEAR THIS VERY DAY' '

    ^FIRE AND OPERA,that's it they gave Severity the Highest,see AJAX^

  • @MrCourtyC IF YOU DON'T FEEL LIKE SEARCHING THEN YOU CAN SEE IT ALL RIGHT HERE SOME REAL REAL REAL DOG SH***T!! WAS SENT TO THOSE PRODUCER'S I MEAN REALIEST OF DOG SH***T!! THEY EVER EVER EVER SEEN!!! AND GREGORY DOESN'T MISS A GOLDEN TICKET ALL HANDLED RIGHT!!!

  • Thumbs up if you're on the edge

  • Thumbs up if you're on the edge

  • I was never a fan of her... But now that I've heard some live presentations..I respect her..

  • Madonna who??

    Look! There's a part of Marry The Night that is better than "Hung Up" by this....madonna...

  • @the3471kronos Like a prayer is better than Just Dance , Poker face And Judas

  • @HausOfSims15 problem being that Like A Prayer is probably Madonna's only good song.

  • @ThatIsSoChaz Papa don't Preach ? Live to tell ? Masterpiece ? La Isla Bonita ????

  • @Gnasheress She clearly speaks for their women.

  • Now THIS is what you call TALENT.

  • @solmartinezf MEATLOAF REBORN