it's so not her voice! unless she was a lot younger cuz like yeah there are certain parts that sound a lot like her but not enough for me to believe it. maybee but i just doubt it.
It is Amy. This was a demo for Fallen that didn't make the cut. And yes, she was quite a bit younger - I think it also may have been recorded in a different way to make it sound different.
The quality of recording equipment can have an impact on how it sounds after, so it's possible this was lower quality.
If you listen closely, or you listen to Evanescence like a thousand times a day like me lol you'll hear it's quite different. It's like the difference between the fallen and the origin version of my immortal
I prefer this version ... sounds almost ... more real, easier to sing if u get me
it's doesn't even sound like her in the begining it's when she sings has no one told you.... etc. there you can hear that it's really her, how old was she when she wrote this song?
You can get all of their pre-Fallen material for free at evanescencereference . info/music Amy does not want fans to have to pay outrageous amounts for it on ebay, so a fan put it online!!! Pass on the word! It's awesome music!
She's sharp throughto uthe latter half of the song. Hmm... Sounds like she's straining. yes, I have a music degree, so I know what I'm talking about. Anyway, I htink that was why this wasn't released. You can't re-master over this to mask the intonation differences.
No i think it is on this cd called not for your ears? im not sure tho not many ppl have it but i downloaded it from limewire its really good its like older versions of the fallen songs and new ones it was out 2002 but they didnt release it.
i have it! its really good!! They have loads of c.ds but no one no's bout half of them. like
Evanescence Ep
Sound Asleep
Not For Your Ears.
Thye are all Really good!!They Shoudl release them!!
for the one hater, Stfu! This song is awsome, and the demo gives me goosebumps. (In a good way of course..)
NoReturnsCNPSF 1 year ago
Diese Version klingt ehrlicher, als wären die Emotionen, die sie inspriert haben, noch frisch.
Evanescencegirl23 1 year ago
i like this better than the fallen version not to say the fallen version isnt amazing but this is just amazing
mbh4389 1 year ago
WOW!
PutrescentSoul 1 year ago
you can hear the emotion difference to in her voice...
SIKONE122 1 year ago
it kinda dont sound like amy but then again certain parts does lolz but w.e beautiful anyways
idget222 2 years ago
this is Amy.
she sounds so much better with the actual version and not the demo.
daegenjohnson 2 years ago
I can deffinately hear the difference. I listen to every Evanescence song everyday.
pplwatchergirl 2 years ago
i liked more this version than the album´s
Angellicke 2 years ago 3
this is fake.
muffinman22806 2 years ago
why is it? sounds original to me.
9thPhoenix 2 years ago
it's so not her voice! unless she was a lot younger cuz like yeah there are certain parts that sound a lot like her but not enough for me to believe it. maybee but i just doubt it.
muffinman22806 2 years ago
It is Amy. This was a demo for Fallen that didn't make the cut. And yes, she was quite a bit younger - I think it also may have been recorded in a different way to make it sound different.
The quality of recording equipment can have an impact on how it sounds after, so it's possible this was lower quality.
crimrose 2 years ago 8
Hmmm ok... im surprised i didnt hear this already.
muffinman22806 2 years ago
If you listen closely, or you listen to Evanescence like a thousand times a day like me lol you'll hear it's quite different. It's like the difference between the fallen and the origin version of my immortal
I prefer this version ... sounds almost ... more real, easier to sing if u get me
FireflyFanatic3 2 years ago
yes i agree
lordrory101 2 years ago
Says the "Muffinman."
XAlleyXpsychoX 2 years ago
this song is hard to sing if you don't have feelings..
terraberra90 2 years ago
i like this version better its more raw and less produced. its great, thank you
lovelightlucidity 2 years ago 2
"suddenly i know i'm not sleeping" and "has no one told you she's not breathing" are two of the most powerful lines in any song ever.
flygon666 2 years ago 13
My version is has no one told you he's not breathing.....
hello
paperflowers91 3 years ago
its she's not breathing, its about her dead sister
DeliciousXCupcakes 2 years ago
hello.... :(
heloooo :'(
ponka007 3 years ago 2
everytime i hear this song y cry its si sad ... i love amy lee
lacrymosa887 4 years ago
this song is a beautiful song ^_^ and the meaning of it is just powerful. And it was so sad about her sister dying at the young age she did
JonathansGurl91 4 years ago 2
i think the original version is better
klewis9995 4 years ago
same
i do like this one though
paperflowers91 3 years ago
Hello! I started a group! It's for Evanescence lovers!
youtube(dot)com/group/evanfans
Please tell everyone about it and join the group!
Thank you
.TheSamanthaA.
TheSamanthaA 4 years ago
Its on Fallen
The reason that she is ready to breck is because she wrote this song about her sister that died
She cant perform it live because she will go into a serious break down.
OjaiGirls 4 years ago
So that's what the song is about. I didn't know that.
gabrielevanhelsing 4 years ago
it's doesn't even sound like her in the begining it's when she sings has no one told you.... etc. there you can hear that it's really her, how old was she when she wrote this song?
Biopolarity 4 years ago
she sounds ready to break
latin1ofmany 4 years ago
Guys. There is a CD called "Not For Your Ears" but it is NOT an official Evanescence CD.
AeternusAmatorius 4 years ago
are ppl selling it or is it just on lime wire or some place like that?
ilovepiratessomuch 4 years ago
You can get all of their pre-Fallen material for free at evanescencereference . info/music Amy does not want fans to have to pay outrageous amounts for it on ebay, so a fan put it online!!! Pass on the word! It's awesome music!
NaturalLifer 4 years ago 2
i love this version
Luigi122190 5 years ago
She's sharp throughto uthe latter half of the song. Hmm... Sounds like she's straining. yes, I have a music degree, so I know what I'm talking about. Anyway, I htink that was why this wasn't released. You can't re-master over this to mask the intonation differences.
minervasowl 5 years ago
Yeah it does, doesn't it. Not to insult her or anything. But it sounds like she was barely able to manage it.
Hotaru1Tomoe 5 years ago
i think this is on "not for your ears"
nice
yoursweetsacrifice 5 years ago
This is A LOT better than the Fallen version. It's just like other rerecorded songs... T_T
NeoMvsEu 5 years ago
No i think it is on this cd called not for your ears? im not sure tho not many ppl have it but i downloaded it from limewire its really good its like older versions of the fallen songs and new ones it was out 2002 but they didnt release it.
i have it! its really good!! They have loads of c.ds but no one no's bout half of them. like
Evanescence Ep
Sound Asleep
Not For Your Ears.
Thye are all Really good!!They Shoudl release them!!
( btw Gr8 Vid ! lol)
leefrithy 5 years ago
Ha. Not For Your Ears isn't an Evanescence CD. It's a bootleg. These are Evanescence CDs:
Evanescence EP
Sound Asleep\Whisper EP
Origin
Mystary Ep
Fallen
Anywhere But Home
The Open Door.
There are 97-98 Demos and 2001 - 2002 demos as well. Also, some miscellaneous songs.
AeternusAmatorius 5 years ago 2
Finally someone with some brainds about the Evanescence CDs.
Hotaru1Tomoe 4 years ago
Such an amazing, awe inspiring, fantastic and magnifent voice and woman
SeleneCorvin4eva 5 years ago 5
ye i no shes sooo amaizing!!
Xevanescencechick1X 5 years ago
Is this on Origin?
darkempress1066 5 years ago
no its a demo version not on a cd dont think!
Xevanescencechick1X 5 years ago
That is a great version of the song
RockFreak19 5 years ago 2
amazing
tearsdontfall1990 5 years ago
thankyou
Xevanescencechick1X 5 years ago
this is the song with the subliminal message..some shit like that- great job! =)
Chuckis 5 years ago
thanks!
Xevanescencechick1X 5 years ago
Wow I like it good making evanescence music video, I give u 5 star (5/5)
JAC92Autumn 5 years ago
thanks josiah! ace!!
Xevanescencechick1X 5 years ago
ahh one of my fave evanescence songs.. great vid !
himevanescencesilver 5 years ago
thankyou!
Xevanescencechick1X 5 years ago
5/5 from me
ArcticWolf18 5 years ago
thanks hun XxX
Xevanescencechick1X 5 years ago
It's really good! love the song!^^
talledo 5 years ago
thanks!
Xevanescencechick1X 5 years ago
I've seen this song before it is really good!
KingofKings219 5 years ago
cool thanks!
Xevanescencechick1X 5 years ago