Nightwish- Wish I Had An Angel (annete)

[284546]

THATS A SINGER???

i dont think so

[IDI0TBEAUTY]

......my ears bleed.

[Sofyguitar]

Annette I love you!!! Ok no xDD

[jiajordison3]

poor music!

[linedepicard]

outsh that hurts

[dark7700]

es una cancion buena en todo caso, igual el sonido no es de lo mejor, ahi partes que no llego a escuchar a nettie, pero en fin, love tarja and anette :P

[jean15june]

OMG!!!!! WTF!!!!!!

[666Brago]

That's a good song, but it sounds much better with Tarja.

[widomaker66]

i cant belive this, she is great, omg i use to be aggree with the major opinion, but i cant this time

[DEATHEXISTFOREVER]

marco dont sound too great here either but its like hes trying to salvage the situation by trying to shout over annette in the chorus.this was just terrible

[mijail87]

annete shouldn't change the style of the song... she maybe not singing like Tarja but she should will make an effort to sing this song like her.. because we can listening is the diference

[akinraxxie]

WTF is this!!!

[Kandiisu]

WOOOOOOOOOOOOO!

[nessytatekken]

epic fail T_T

[superextranirvana]

omg! it hurts my ears ... PAIN

[Catmam123]

SHIT MY EARS ARE BLEEDING

[ikubak420]

i have to say i said i didnt like annette when at the beginning but the more i listened the more i liked her and now i love her GO ANNETTE!

[scroseFE]

Metalstormer is right by saying "Tarja never did such a thing" he/she didn't mean Traja didn't make mistakes. (S)He meant that Tarja never destroyed a song like THIS!

[VejaUndead]

@scroseFE It's not only Anette's fault, all band sounds horrible in this song, instruments ans singers alike.

[scroseFE]

If Anette will destroy every song of Nightwish like this, I'm gonna kill myself. I hope she didn't yet try to sing Ever dream cuz I love it, and I don't want to be even more sick.

[fluettge]

This is Phycho Terror. Anette, let it be. You are not the half of Tarja!

[steathassassin2000]

i like anettes voice better tarjas got annoying ...

[VejaUndead]

@steathassassin2000 I also think Tarja's voice is annoying at times.

[Luziferofdarkness]

@2yellowdaisies Tarja was for a long time with nightwish. She was a part of it. And suddenly there's a new chic, and she should be nightwish, huh? In a short time, she got, what tarja never was?! Well, I say you're wrong x'3 || Sry Oo I'm german and my english is bad XD

[scroseFE]

@2yellowdaisies Singers do mistakes but not for the whole song. I think Anette wanted to change it not to sound like Tarja, well it didn'tt work. And excuse me, TARJA WAS PART OF NIGHTWISH AND NO ONE SAY SHE DOESN'T BELONG WITH IT!!!!! And if after so long time most of Nightwish fans STILL want Tarja back, IT MEANS SOMETHING IS WRONG WITH ANETTE.

[YourEvilDarkness]

Anette fails at this song, but she is good in the new songs. Admit it.

[AKM1963]

damn, this sucks...

[merienjos]

omg ...... that is cruel

[gattaflora]

after this song I think I could sing one day...

[Darknvo]

I love both of them.

Tarja and Anette.

I love Tarja because she was the first one i listened too.

I love Anette because after Tarja and Nightwish were apart...

Anette is there to keep the music alive. ^^

It dosn't matter who sings better.

Nightwish fan!!! ALL THE WAY!!!

LIVE & LOVE!!! FOR THE MUSIC!!!

[juankbunbury]

@Darknvo it actually matters. i LOVED the former nightwish... the new one sucks, and i'm a fan...

[Bubblesflute1711]

Wow...I love love love Anette, but this is an awful recording. If I heard this on a cd it would probably sound great...For all you Anette haters, I love Tarja too. Both singers are amazing so stop arguing!

[xanith02100]

Wish they'd go ahead and release an album with Annette singing some of the older songs already. I saw them back in 2008 when they were in the states, and this song and Wishmaster blew me away with Annette singing. Would love to own some well-recorded versions.

[Najawarie]

I think Anette is better when she sing 'her' song, if I may say. Otherwise, she's awesome when she sing songs that was not originally singed by Tarja...

[querenthar]

why do you all blame Anette?Nightwish as band made auditions before choosing a new singer if i m not mistaken.the girl does what she cans if fans dont like this they could have found another singer.its not if she s better than Tarja or not.I dont say i like how she sings the songs of "tarja era" but,i want to believe they have a pretty good reason for doing this....and again as it is said"if you dont like it dont listen"

[kelticprincess]

@querenthar finally someone normal who doesn't blame Anette

[18Shadowfox]

shut up already dont like it dont listen >.> tarja's been gone over 4 years now and her new stuff is just as good if your really wanting her go listen to her new album and be happy :D

[Joshtika18]

@18Shadowfox What are some of her new stuff? Where can I find it?

[WHEELYZAKALUIS]

NUCLEAR BLAST EUROPE HERE ON YOUTUBE.. look up NIGHTWISH MADE IN HONG KONG ALBUM TRAILER for a 3-song-preview

[lenayul26]

mierda!!!

con esto le escupieron en la cara a Tarja!!! T.T

NADA COMO LA VERSION ORIGINAL!!!!

[Akaunts]

is she ok? Does she on purpose shiting this beautifull songs?.......the songs from real NIghtWigh!!! She is screaming like freddie cruger slice her..........PUKE!!!!!

[6ppk9]

this song was written for tarja, that's why she sounds bad, but if you could listen tarja singing bye bye beautiful she wolb be also out of tune

[Rafajka023]

She's absolutely out of melody !!!! OMG

[Cerberes666]

She can't and will not EVER beat Tarja in any song....but it's sad when she tries to beat her in the songs like this where she just CAN'T DO.....tarja 4ever :D

[NintendoWarrior]

She tries, but still an Epic Fail... Don't do Tarja's songs Anette Olzon. You only make our ears bleed and not in a good way.

[DEATHEXISTFOREVER]

annette sucks at this song.you can tell marco is TRYING to shout over annette in the chorus to TRY and salvage the situation but it only made him sound bad as well.

[lovemonita3]

i cant belive that people buy tickets to see and hear

this horrible thing

sorry if you dont understand my english

bye

[REGdestRoy]

fail

[CroatianFirecracker]

lol...

this sounds...bad...

[Alasse969]

ho mon dieu c'est quoi cette merde .... TARJA COME BACK PLEASE !!!!!!

[Metalstormer1992]

Holy shit!!!!She doesn't sing even one single note correctly!!!Totally off-tune....Tarja never did such a thing....Don't compare,just enjoy what is better.....And what we all hear in this video doesn't do any good in our ears,she goes off-tune all the time!!!

[2yellowdaisies]

@Metalstormer1992 acctually, tarja kinds sung out of tune singing this song in the end of an era concert. my opinion.

[username4396]

only good songs with annete are amaranth and bye bye beautiful

[Zeldanarian]

I like both Anette and Tarja, but Anette singing Tarja's songs is just wrong. The new songs are better suited to her, and she should stick to them instead of... well, this. Don't get me wrong, she isn't bad, but Tarja was better.

[Grieverjoao]

Nightwish without Tarja equals Nightmare!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Period

[Sylphide95]

è totalmente fuori tonalità!!! X_X

[riddleshade]

FUCK YOU ANETTE!!!!!

[Psicoinsane]

you cant compare all the tarja's trajectory with only one album with anette but i know that anette souldht sing the tarjas songs

[GothikaAir]

lol...Tarja rock`s in nightwish..

but..;))). dont forget..i am fan lordi..

:X:X:X:X:X:X:X is just a magnifiant voice.:X

[causesobad]

OMG I could not even recognize this is Wish I Had an Angel. --___-- Anette, try st else pls!

[GothikaAir]

yes. i agree totaly with TheHippie408

[TheHippie408]

Tarja = win. Annete just..Makes the band look stupid. She makes it look like a poser band, instead of a band with real skill. Especially with songs like this. Tarja sang them soooooooo much better.

[enk2]

that's right!

[k10edd]

Anette isn't a bad singer, but she shouldn't sing any of Tarja's old songs; they were made for Tarja's voice, no one else's

[DollofDreams]

tarja is mutch better!

[seylonk]

TARJA COME BACK ANNET SUX A LOT :(

[MsJUTKA]

Tragedia!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Anette z całym szacunkiem, ale nie pasuje do tych piosenek!!!! :(

[jnagara]

so adorable watching people pretend they know what theyre talking about.

DPP has sold better than once did in the rest of the world and if i remember correctly its done as well once did in finland or close to it.

you may not like anette, but youre in the minority, and youre a cry baby on top of it LOL

[00omg000]

dear anette: i beg of you to plz STFU!!!!! i hate ur singing and stop even trying -.-

with hate: 00omg000(Jelena)

[jnagara]

LOL apparently thoumas doesnt agree with you. you're the kind of fan they didnt care if they lost when they made the change

[00omg000]

well they probably got alot of britney spears fans -.-' now go away from me

[matsou75]

c'est faux du début à la fin !!!!!!!!!!

[AngelOfMine223]

I like Anette's and Tarja's versions. I

[fillip995]

Dear Anette, SHUT THE FUCK UP!!

[midgard1982]

It`s poor,

better wait a year and write own songs, ahe has not the voice to sing the songs written for a professional soran singer!!

I`m happy I saw one of the last concerts with Tarja in switzerland `cause now it`s only mainstream rock!!,

[AnonymousWins]

Ugh..... not happy, she needs to stick to her own shtick

[prahanormal]

So basically Tarja is a bitch and Annete is a shitty singer.

Damn.

[jibber102]

She can do the verse fine. But she does need to work on holding the notes if she wants to do the older songs.

[TheNightwishGirl]

OMG !!!! Ears ache ...

[cosplaygrimlyn]

maybe this is the reason she gets so much shit... your right, these songs were made for traja.... they need to keep making new stuff that she can perform... then they'll stop the comparing game. when she's not singing tarjas songs, i actually think she's good

[024764]

dude what a difference, no... just no

[J0epK4ne]

these songs were made in mind for tarja and they shouldn't have annette singing them. i love annette and i believe she will win everyone over

[hardmaik666]

WE WANT TARJA BACK

FROM MEXICO

[DEATHEXISTFOREVER]

u got thumbed down:

but ur right

[TwilightMidna8D]

WTF??????

Sincerely, it finished with the time band: 3 Why nobody note that Annete you singing equal to a cow with belly ache?

Ok u_u' It is not bad, but in the Nightwish she is yes oO

[YulieAna]

If Anette is equal to a cow in this song, I'm afraid to ask what Tarja is equal to when she never could get this song right.

[inuavajo23]

jaja esa tipa apenas puede kantar jaja no komo tarja k kon su voz impresionante de opera inkreivle ojala k se muera esa tipa

[DEATHEXISTFOREVER]

i like the description of this vid lol:

"0_o" annette is good but she cant

sing tarja songs for nothin

and marco seems off his game here to

but its probably cuz hes tryin ta salvage

the situation by tryin ta drown out annette

but it only made him sound bad as well

[akalith86]

esta tia esta destrozando las mejores canciones de nightwish!!!!!!ya q largaron a tarja x lo menos deberian haber cogido a alguin q cantara como ella(aunq es dificil)

[TUTAMEN2007]

the way i see it is, atm this song sounds shit with annete singing it tbh

[YulieAna]

It sounded no less shit with Tarja. It's a shit song to start with, but at least Anette stays in tune and doesn't hit one flat note after another.

[kendraslay]

definitely please annette don't sing tarja's songs because you can't do it and pitifully this is the result

[YulieAna]

If you seriously think that Tarja did it any better than you are completely tone deaf. The broad could never stay in tune and hit one flat note after another. Yet you still pretend she was better just because she was the original. How fucking stupid.

[umbra1818]

i agree annette can't

[TUTAMEN2007]

WTF??? annete sucks shes off key out of time and sounds like a cat in a tumble dryer tarja was the best she will remain the best and untill nightwish see this they wil always bee in my eyes ordinary and shit ps annette really really sucks

[YulieAna]

Tarja could never sing this song live yet you think she is brilliant? WTF?

[TUTAMEN2007]

jst so u know that was my mate who sent tht message but in al honesty, tarja sounds better bcaus this song was designed for her to sing with an operatic figure to it, as u can tell annete cant sing it, thts my view and sorry bout the nasty comment posted by my mate

[YulieAna]

You've got to be kidding me. This song has operatic vocals? Do you even know what operatic is? Have you even heard Tarja sing it life? She is either out of tune or goes completely flat.

[1AzureSky]

This is perhaps the least classical thing (vocal-wise) that Nightwish has ever done with Tarja. It's hardly made for operatic vocals. Anette just sound sub-par on this song because the song itself is mediocre to begin with.

[TrinFlick]

wtf this is horrible they are all out of tune

[killket]

ANETTE CAN NOT SING TARJAS SONG HER VOICE IS TO HIGH! tarja is better :)

[Qrell]

Actually being a life-long fan of Nightwish, I believe that Annette is perfect and by all means she is not "KILLING THE BAND". If you knew anything about Nightwish you'd know that the other band member hand picked her. If you don't trust their judgment then find a new band. I am glad Nightwish is heading in such a great direction.

[SoraMatt]

it's good to see that someone is firmly in Anette's corner, seeing as the band placed her in Tarja's place.

[Addybattler]

Anette has a cool Rock-voice but Nightwish isn't a ROCK band. In the song "Amaranth" she sings nearly perfect but she will NEVER be Tarja.

Both are good in their individual way but their styles are the most different they could be.

[p3rf3ctl1ght]

she isn't trying to be tarja she is trying to be annette. thats why there styles are so different

[legeon6]

"she isn't trying to be tarja"

She didn't until now.You could go and check the Ghost Love Score performance from Mantova...It is definitely not her style,she tries to sing like Tarja...

[YulieAna]

"Anette has a cool Rock-voice but Nightwish isn't a ROCK band."

Let me guess, you think Tarja's voice is for rock music? How is a classically singer even remotely more suited for metal than a rock singer? Metal is a sub genre of rock so by that standard Anette is a lot more suited for it than Tarja. I am not trying to "bash" Tarja again, but your analogy is just silly.

[samanthabri3]

frist of all she is singing from her thoat get her leasons (now before she kills something) second of all its not a open sound witch means she cant hit those notes or she isnt warming up enough (i think the first one) and third of al SHE IS KILLING THE BAND!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[RikkuYubari]

Hmm...

Idk. I like Tarja's better if only because I heard that first; BUT I think Annette pulled it off alright, all things considered.

[ikubak420]

omfg.... i just puked a lil.... sumone kill her now before SHE KILLS NIGHTWISH!

[SoraMatt]

yeah, well, the band doesn't share your opinion, otherwise, she wouldn't be there.

[mariszemery]

WTF her voice doesnt fit in the song, she's so off and it seems like she cant even reach the high notes.

[raulescalcer]

Annette tiene una voz demasiado pop para mi gusto. me gusta mas la vercion de tarja

[edjuna]

xD tienes toda la razon, esta cancion la canta mejor tarja esta tipa se queda muuuuuuy corta jajaja annette deveria limitarce a cantar unicamente las canciones de su disco xD ya que lo asepten la cagaron en sacar a tarja

[13syzygies]

She's SO off-key. You'd think that as a professional singer, she would be able to sing on pitch. Even if these songs were written for another voice, she should be able to sing them. This just leaves me cold and dead inside. It's even worse than her "Ever Dream" cover.

[TheMadGirl17]

When was she off-key? She sounds great. She brings a new sound to Nightwish, I don't understand why people are being so harsh toward her.

[YulieAna]

"You'd think that as a professional singer, she would be able to sing on pitch."

Tarja couldn't sing this song live for the life of her. She was always off key, off tune, flat notes. And it was written for her. What's your excuse for Tarja? Do you think she is a shitty singer?

[13syzygies]

Tarja's voice blends better with the style of music, for sure.

And she wasn't ALWAYS off-pitch.

Annette happens to not blend very well, especially in this song.

[YulieAna]

This song was written for more mainstream oriented vocals and Tarja always sounded shitting singing it because her lower register is crap and she can't belt.

[somguy33]

Worse than the Tarja version X{

[DarkRonin21]

What are you talking about? I like the Tarjaversion better too, but the way you say it, you make it sound like the Tarja version sucked too. Nightwish with Tarja rules

[somguy33]

well, after listening to Tarja';s version for like the 30th time, it kicks ass... overall Tarja has her ups (this) and downs (Wishmaster among others)

[Ga99be]

Well, look at this way.

Tarja was great and the songs were written for her caliber. it was beautiful.

Annette is great. and the songs will be written for her style. It will be awesome im sure of it.

[neeTHREE]

She killed it... But,this song was made to be sung by Tarja,not by her. She's not to be pointed at fault.

The guys should have just not played the song live...

[MHV1ftw]

i can see why many are fans of the old the Nightwish, its just not the same

[ustanimo]

i must say i dont like it...i have nothing against anette but...ouch, this is BAD! :(

[Ninoklica]

ffs.. she's destroying fckng nightwish.. little girlie from mtv came to sing in great band.. gg -.-' her vocal abilities are for nothing..

[vickeydisneyqueen]

Shes killing classic Nightwish

[krsiBM]

its like the old version but annete not taja

[dancinggoth]

Sorry.. but i am supposed to be listening to I wish i had an angel right?

Cos thats not what i heard,

Marco's parts yes but annette?

Dear god that was shite

[caramanzilias]

oh my god what tha fuck was that!in the ref when tarja just give notes with is voice annete ruin it -.-....i'm sad ;(

[GattacciaMalefica]

Non si può sentire -.-

[lyrics666]

she is a good singer but this just isn't meant for her. the song i mean.

[Hashbrick1234]

Anett cant sing. Nightwish was way netter with Tarja. Because of Anette this band became a piece of shit in my opinion

[Amneysia]

Yeah :(

[hupthehuppie]

omg sux :O

[kozelll333]

that hurts my ears

[square242]

WTF ???????????

[lleidasinlimites]

nightwish is tarja

whats that??

i'm going to kill my self...

[ironheaven]

Anette is great :) but she's not the best in this song.

[cookysvidz]

ok listen up coz ur all fukin thick man!

if nw got another classical singer ud be bitchin bout her not bein as good! annette adds a great essence 2 this band

granted this songs not for her buh if ur in love wiv tarja fuk off an listen 2 her solo albums!

i think both singers are great buh the old nw is GONE

[AlexiIsTheBest]

Fuck you all! Marco sounds bad in this video too! Anette rocks and get over the fact that your queen Tarja fucked off! She is not coming back so stop whining and if you don't like new NW just don't listen to it! Simple as!!!

[rocklee71]

i think anette is good

but tarja gives nightwish an epic escense

whit anette nightwish sounds like within temptation style

[XemnasRoy]

Goddamit

Anette sings not bad in the new songs

like Amaranth

but she ruins the old and good songs of Nightwish

this version is really crappy :/

She should only sing the new songs that she knows and leave Tarja's songs alone

[killhannah10]

She may not suit this exact song, but than again, everyone is used to listening to Tarja's perfomance, and both their voices are very different. I would thank our lucky stars it isn't britney singing this.

[SarahBathory]

How did she dare to sing this song and ruin it like this...I felt like if Britney was trying to sing Nemo...she can't even hold the right tone....

[HankShermann]

she did not sing badly, but is very better Tarja

[wishmasterRO]

Anette sux... she's the worst singer ever. God! How can you listen to that piece of s***t. Tarja means Nightwish... F**k Anette and her voice either.

[DaRkSymphoniCa]

I love anette! but honestly this isn't for her

[Naidanor]

The big problem with the current nightwish is that the songwriters used to write songs needing an extermly big range of voice, which is Anette lacks of. If she would be the first nightwish singer, the songs that she would singed would be awful with Tarja's voice(I mean,maybe someone knows a link to an Dark Passion Play - Tarja mix)

[zefir77777]

tanja singing better

[SarahBathory]

It's Tarja....

[afanofmeanythings]

um.. No, its Anette, obiv'.

[SarahBathory]

Yeah I know that's annette singing I was replying to a guy that wrote TANJA ¬¬

[afanofmeanythings]

Oh right sorry. Its confusing me on you-tube as sometimes you reply to a comment but it does not show as a reply but as a singular comment.... If you understand what I mean?

[SarahBathory]

Yeah I know it's a mess here xD it is difficult to know who is replying to whom!

[monikxxx]

the worse of the world!!!

[framfrit]

tarja es mejor

you know?

jajaa xD

[EricaVeee]

Weird. I love Annette, but I expected this, of all the old Nightwish songs, to be a good fit for her voice. Not her best.

[afanofmeanythings]

Lets just face it, Annette is not right for Tarja's songs, End of.

I have nothing agenst annette and don't perticularily think she is a bad singer, She just dos'nt have an unusual voice like Tarja did, Witch is why fans don't like her, because they are not used to such a voice.

I was a hater of her at first and I called her some pretty nasty things, But think of it as being in ''close-up'' and if you ''zoom out'' and see the whole time-line, you should see that annette isnt that bad

x

[the1vancha]

Just because your used to Tarja singing this song doesn't mean anette is bad. If anette was in nightwish first and tarja second you would be saying it was better with anette because you would be used to it that way. I think they have different voices but on every song I prefer anette.

[afanofmeanythings]

I did'nt just say Annette was bad! I said I used to think so, But now I don't, I just said OTHER fans don't like her as she doesent have a very unusual voice.

And no, I don't think that would be the case.

Read crerefully before you reply please

x

[Suvisime]

omg.. Anette might be a great singer, but not for Nightwish. There's no charisma or required talent. Missing Tarja Turunen..

[tokiohotellover457]

I agree with you completely. I think she is a good singer, but her voice is not fit for the band.

[morgana74]

E' imbarazzante questo tentativo di cantare Wish I Had An Angel. Annette... cara.. non ce l'ho con te ma ti prego... torna a casa e fai tornare TARJA!!!!

[jahjinkha]

WTF?!?!?!?! suck!!! anette fuck you