Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (63)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Quite like the beginning, but I think they could've done better with the chorus, for example. Still, they're both great bands

  • im a big smiths fan and a big neil hannon fan, but im not convinced by this :/

  • tempted to jump in front of a ten ton truck after hearing this...( especially after just youtubing Johnny Marr for the last two hours)

  • Truly does justice to this Smiths classic.

  • This is the greatest cover version of anything ever. Its the same song and its a totally new song. Completely wonderful

  • This sounds like a very drunk Scott Walker singing The Smiths...

  • tooooo slow

  • I closed porn for this.

  • @goodoldmanny Greatest comment I've ever read.

  • @goodoldmanny Greatest comment I've ever read.

  • I think this version is pretty good but I absolutely hate it.

    Why?

    Because if you knew the Divine Comedy, you'd never heard this & someone told you they'd covered it - it sounds exactly like you'd imagine it to.

    I'd rather be a little surprised.

  • @anthonyisonfire You should check out the Boo Radley's take on The Queen Is Dead then.

  • The delivery is perfect... almost divine!

  • This is terrible.

  • sob

  • Oh dear, It's fair to say Neil is a very competent songwriter, but this version of the Smiths song has all the grace and gravitas of a steamed sponge pudding with extra helpings of custard for good measure. The Smiths work has rarely been covered well at the best of times (listen to the multiple cover versions out there that are so appalling, one would seriously consider cutting one's wrists in sympathy. Stand up Radiohead) I'm sure Morrissey and Marr would be tickled pink!

  • nice job posting this, never would have heard it otherwise

  • ... I thought: " Oh,God! My chance has come at last."

    But then a strange fear gripped me and I just couldn't ask...

    P.S.: I personally feel this slow cover, has an element that most of the others covers don't have, mostly they try to feet with the original. Divine Comedy dared to go out of the conventionals. Or maybe it's just me who feel it straight in the heart... but I don't care, I don't care.

  • fantastic...

  • Great cover...the best i've ever heart

  • 3 persons have neither taste nor soul

  • i never thoungh someone can sing this song more miserable than morrisey ;)

    but i love them both

    bravo ;)

  • co za głos!

    boska! :)

  • BELLISSIMA....

  • @ConnorFairuza: This cover appears on the tribute album "The Smiths Is Dead", released in 1996 (Track 9). The album was released at the height of the Britpop phenomenon and contained covers by many popular Britpop acts such as The Boo Radleys, Supergrass, Bis and Placebo. Hug!

  • amazing, am so glad to have found this

  • agree with sunboildedonions. always use this example when someone says 'covers are ____...'. in fact, every time he covers another artist, the arrangements are genius. good on ya, young man :D

  • BUFF.... sublime.

    

  • BUFF....

    

  • toooooooooooooooo sllllllllllllllloooooooooooooo­oowwwwwwwwwwww

  • I love The Divine Comedy and The Smiths, but this is the biggest pile of wank I've heard come out of Neil's mouth!

  • @SirBounder totally agree fucking appalling i,d say johnie marr would piss him self if he heard this marr wrote the music and this is a truly pathetic cover version and he,s a shit singer wat ever his name is anyway the divine comedy that sums it up alrite comedy at it,s best

  • A M A Z I N G  cover!

    Sublime and genius indeed!

  • sublime and genius true

  • Somehow the voice reminds me of something of a cross between the vocalist from Arcade Fire and the vocalist from The Doors. Good cover, though.

  • Very very nice music .thank´s for sharing.

    :)

  • Comment removed

  • @1975ANTONIS i dont think that this version is "better", but it sure is a really good cover!

  • Greatest song in the history of Man...and what an incredible cover version this is!

  • This is the bast cover of any smiths song ever

  • As a smiths fan, I believe that

  • fail

  • It would've been better if he didn't slow it down so much. The piano was a brilliant idea, it makes the cover more atmospheric.

  • My God, the only way this could have possibly been pulled off is with a radical reinterpretation, like this one. Otherwise you just couldn't justify it. There's far too many straight up acoustic knock offs, this one genuinely tries to go somewhere different with The Smiths masterpiece. Oh, but you can't beat the original. <3

  • Nice, but the instrumentals are wrong for this song

  • have to agree with yomogasdf below,, but this i sbetter htahn mos tcovers

  • Just what is the point of covering this song?? The whole brilliance of it is linked with Morrisey´s voice, carachter, essence. Take Morrisey out of the song = there´s no song (well, not much left anyhow)

  • Comment removed

  • @yomogiwitch Id have to agree with you, but i'd go further and say its quintessentially the smiths. But without morrisey the effect is dampened.

  • I don't really like this. The voice is beautiful, but I don't think the music fits.

  • Huh, I like this cover. It is a bit slow, but maybe that is because I have a soft spot for Morrissey's voice.

  • Nothing beats the original. But this is a very good cover! Well done!

  • acredito k o morrissey iria ficar orgulhoso desta cover

  • great cover tbh

  • The Queen is Dead, and so are them, but they will never leave us.

  • As a big Smiths' fan I would have to say that I believed this song to be uncoverable. Bravo Neil, you really are a sublime genius.

  • @sunboiledonions Exactly my thoughts, I'm a big fan of Noel Gallagher, but his cover is not as good as this one, and the same happens with Death Cab For Cutie

  • best cover ever

    one of the very few times I

    love a cover more than the original.

  • .............. <3

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more