@DeathBat12051992 Not sad, but true. The message should be clear, and it's not about puppets but about greed. We pay for our mistakes, and most often humans just want and want and want more and more - we deserve a punishment. And when that punishment comes, we regret all too late what we've done.
The piano solo(towards the end of the end of the song) is fantastic although only about 6-7seconds long of itself but continues w/the rest of the instruments for about close to 28seconds.
@DeathBat12051992 "GH is for geeks..." Too right man! I've played it and I'm not amused whatsoever... I'd rather use the guitar controller as a blunt weapon.
I'm not personally a fan of Sonata Arctica, but I have to admit the lyrics for this song are pretty awesome. It's a bit confusing, because I'm not used to metal having good lyrics.. ;)
@Kazumaster yeah, but when that energy and technique is used to support good lyrics it opens up a whole other dimension in the music. Of course, you could cross both streams and listen to some folk metal bands :-)
@Kazumaster it's already a month ago you put the reaction, but if you want some good lyrics in metal, maybe you should check out Avantasia. they're melodic, powermetal ánd 've got strong lyrics.
These are some of the best lyrics I've ever heard. They're original (for once, not about love/sadness/other overused themes) and chilling as the song gets progressively darker.
@reveriehill1614 It is a German novel about a boy called Paul Paulsen ("Pole" is the North-German mode of the name Paul) and the girl he loves who is the daughter of a puppeteer. This puppeteer owns a puppet, the Kaspar or "Kaschperle", which has a great attraction on the protagonist. He visits every show and his only wish is to touch the puppet, the masterpiece of his true love's father. Unfortunately its nose breaks and the star of the shows is damaged and useless.
@reveriehill1614 Unlike to the song the protagonist does not get under the spell of the puppeteer, who is a calm and friendly man, but the incidents of the puppet shows influence his entire life. The Kasper is a symbol used in the novel. It stands for the struggle of reason and desire. While Paul should be a man with high reputation as his parents are, he falls in love with a carney and the phantasy of his little boy's mind. Like the song the novel is about escapism.
@reveriehill1614 By the way: It is a classic novel for children and youngsters. I have read it when I was 12. As far as I know there is NO English translation for it has many sources of old German words which are even for Germans hard to understand today.
Do you know for a fact this is based on that novel or just saying there's the similarities you mentioned? Tony Kakko isn't German, he's Finnish, meaning he might not know it. Still, a lot of the songs he's written are based on literature so it's possible he's read it, if he speaks German or there's a Finnish translation.
@giygasattack No, I do not think it is a fact but I thought about it when I heart it the first time. I don't think the novel has ever been translated. It was just an idea of mine but I wonder if Tony ever thought of he was writing a song with some marked similarities, even though it was just my personal interpretation and, to be honest, nothing more than an interpretation.
Great song! i tried to make a video to it, but i could only get part of the song. check it if youd like (Super Warfare: The Wizards, The Kings, and The Boy Who Wanted to be a Real Puppet)
I love this song. It sounds like something straight out of a fairy tale and, not only that, but the way they set up the music was incredible.( I.E. The third verse with the puppet master.)
this is why american metal is in the shit whole this takes true skill and a great since of story telling. We need more melodic stuff like this in the USA
Metallica, anthrax, megadeth, pantera and motherfucking slayer.
If there are some Bands that can top those, they aren't in the power metal genre. Maybe Black Sabbath, deep purple, led zeppelin or judas fucking priest.
If we;re going outside of Power metal.. Oh my LORD.... There are so many great metal bands in general from all around the world. These guys being one of them. :3
i don't think he wants to be a puppet because a puppet is immortal.... i think he wants to be a puppet to be near the puppet he admires which the master did not sell.
tony really thought of pinochio when he wrote the lyrics.
Sonata is like power metal or hard rock or speed metal it's hard to say what kind of music they play It's like everything i like the stories the music and everything else is good
This remains me of pinocchio but reversing the story, I just love how Tony makes you think, even though it's a fictional story.... There's something magical about this song.....
thought of sasori from naruto when clicked the title - nice job, sasori, this song is great!!!
iloveLorenorZorro 2 weeks ago
Nice song! v=OeA7p4k37WA
Is this Japanese music a parody?
shanshanrien 3 weeks ago
I traveled to page 33 to find the historical two top comments, and didn't find...
[ yes, I have no life :) ]
Brombit 1 month ago 2
my favourite song!
22blaa 1 month ago
rofl at the top comments xD
garumeg 3 months ago 2
jajajajajajajaa top coments are so contrary xD
Itachinata 3 months ago in playlist YouTube Mix for Sonata Arctica 4
I havent listened this song in 2 years and I can still sing along with it every line...
SA will never leave \m/
Venom1246 5 months ago 10
@Venom1246 Well, i listen to it like 50 times a day. Its most epic awesome song ever.
HerrXxVorragend 5 months ago
Would you turn me to a child again?
"No, never, I am your Guide"
O.O" !! *Stunning*
Simpay666 5 months ago 3
This is my one of favorite songs of all time.
blockleg 6 months ago
Such conflicting high comments O_O
BobbalinavsDave 6 months ago 9
very sad story
DeathBat12051992 6 months ago
@DeathBat12051992 Not sad, but true. The message should be clear, and it's not about puppets but about greed. We pay for our mistakes, and most often humans just want and want and want more and more - we deserve a punishment. And when that punishment comes, we regret all too late what we've done.
Namantos 6 months ago in playlist Dragon Age 7
awesome!
SchippOo 6 months ago 5
@SchippOo right !!
ThePejzy 6 months ago
This was the last Sonata Arctica album I liked... RIP =(
Nelisje91 6 months ago
this band has lied so deeply in my life along all these years!
keniapowa 7 months ago 3
everyone should listen sonata.. well, it speaks for itselve. they´re just awesome
dealerbinq 7 months ago
Comment removed
evanescence9314 7 months ago
I find it hilarious that the two top voted comments completely disagree with one another.
giygasattack 7 months ago 8
8 guys don't wanna be a real puppet ç_ç
TomTheWolf1 7 months ago
WE JUST NEED TONY(sonata) .. im a real guitar player.. not a guitar game player.. or you wanna be a puppet for real? xD \m/ KEEP METAL ALIVE
AlxMiNeR 7 months ago 2
@Sano10491 hahahahah that solo is just not human xD
ramiropohle 7 months ago
@ramiropohle its jani ;P i hope ill se him again
AlxMiNeR 7 months ago
@Sano10491 hahaha it's just no human xD
ramiropohle 7 months ago
i love the first part,i like+ the others.
you are my #2!
yarin981 8 months ago
@Sano10491 R you afraid of dont say a word solo ? :P
ramiropohle 8 months ago
good song. seriously it is great.
Penguinzcanfly 8 months ago
that songs title sounds a little familiar . . .
reverse pinocio. :p
HiragaISaito 9 months ago
such a creative name for a song XD!
Dnine1 9 months ago 5
conflicting top rated comments ftw anyone?
KaidenKarnage 9 months ago 5
@Sano10491 what is SA?
MaxRideWizardLord 9 months ago
I listen to this again and again and it never lets me go... Wonderful! Thank you for uploading!!!!!! <3
Herzstein666 9 months ago
The top 2 comments are going to rupture a black hole in the power metal continuum.
FurbyParade226 10 months ago 13
@FurbyParade226 Totally agree with you XD
Emetis1 10 months ago
@FurbyParade226 rofl xD
AQWdragonccc 10 months ago
@FurbyParade226 I'd say if your comment reaches the top comments, the other comment that remains will be the victor ;)
flesjemelk 9 months ago 2
Whole fucking album is a masterpiece. no bad or mediocre song.
WishmasterTheDark 11 months ago 5
amazing and poetic song,as along the sing continue the music become more relexful,and this is make the song more powerful.
viva la arcatica!
yarin981 11 months ago
amazing and poetic song,as along the sing continue the music becom more relexful
yarin981 11 months ago
so to date, 7 Justin Beiber fans have seen this...
RevantheBlack 11 months ago
Amazing SOLO!!!!!!!!!
AppleCaster 1 year ago
nice how both top comments completely contradict each other...
Great song
NinjaDragonsrule 1 year ago 17
@NinjaDragonsrule Lol yeah... hehehe
AppleCaster 1 year ago
@NinjaDragonsrule Now they don't. Thanks a lot asshole. xD
ZalriusLiss2009 1 month ago
one of the best giutar solos i've heard
DJVHANproductions 1 year ago
love this, the combination of good lyrics and melody, all songs from this album are badass
amangonecrazy 1 year ago
@Sano10491 u kno it wood probably boost SAs popularity
XObitchyprincessOX 1 year ago
@XObitchyprincessOX i guess u dont know metal bands like sonata are very popular worldwide already, specially in europe o.o
tuturuturu1 1 year ago
@tuturuturu1 NO SHIT!? im talking about AMERICA
XObitchyprincessOX 1 year ago
@XObitchyprincessOX Don't you mean the States? =P
Nuhuinenna 1 year ago
The piano solo(towards the end of the end of the song) is fantastic although only about 6-7seconds long of itself but continues w/the rest of the instruments for about close to 28seconds.
Emerald4 1 year ago
@Sano10491 So guitar hero ftl?
ultimateanimefighter 1 year ago
I'm just a puppet for all the people around me ¬¬"
VD2306 1 year ago 2
My favorite RN track Sonata needs more songs like this one
GenjiShield310 1 year ago
we SO need a Guitar Hero: Sonata Arctica edition thumbs up if ya agree
XObitchyprincessOX 1 year ago 58
@XObitchyprincessOX I would fail all the songs...xD
evanescence9314 1 year ago
@evanescence9314 i would too dont worry
XObitchyprincessOX 1 year ago
@XObitchyprincessOX haha nice username...^^
SaltiCat0 1 year ago
@SaltiCat0 heh, thanks your is intresting as well
XObitchyprincessOX 1 year ago
@XObitchyprincessOX GH is for geeks. Real rockers play real instruments.
DeathBat12051992 6 months ago
@DeathBat12051992 erm i am a geek
XObitchyprincessOX 6 months ago
@XObitchyprincessOX like I thought
DeathBat12051992 6 months ago
@DeathBat12051992 Im a proud anime geek^^ hell after i post this imma go nd finish Hetalia World Series:)
XObitchyprincessOX 6 months ago
@DeathBat12051992 "GH is for geeks..." Too right man! I've played it and I'm not amused whatsoever... I'd rather use the guitar controller as a blunt weapon.
hiptochromniack 6 months ago
@DeathBat12051992 I play both
imawesome432 6 months ago
@imawesome432 that unusual...
DeathBat12051992 6 months ago
@XObitchyprincessOX guitar hero is dead, the real shit is (try) to play it in a real guitar!!!!!
jamalzi 2 weeks ago
Comment removed
XObitchyprincessOX 1 year ago
Comment removed
XObitchyprincessOX 1 year ago
Comment removed
XObitchyprincessOX 1 year ago
This song got me into listening metal... No turning back ever since. :)
TombaDaMon 1 year ago 5
0:00 - 4:45 best !
luEyaraM 1 year ago
wow, nice lyrics, and yes, kids dont know what they want
johnnyrosales1990 1 year ago
desde parana entre rios argentina " SIMPLEMENTE PERFECTO "
sprint22100 1 year ago
I'm not personally a fan of Sonata Arctica, but I have to admit the lyrics for this song are pretty awesome. It's a bit confusing, because I'm not used to metal having good lyrics.. ;)
Kazumaster 1 year ago
@Kazumaster perhaps you're not listening to the right metal ... lol
Umlatta 1 year ago
@Umlatta Maybe you're right :) I tend to listen to metal for the energy and technique and folk for lyrics, maybe I should expand my tastes.
Kazumaster 1 year ago
@Kazumaster yeah, but when that energy and technique is used to support good lyrics it opens up a whole other dimension in the music. Of course, you could cross both streams and listen to some folk metal bands :-)
Umlatta 1 year ago
@Kazumaster Try out Kamelot.
40plusmpg 1 year ago
@40plusmpg I know Kamelot, not really my thing :)
Kazumaster 1 year ago
@Kazumaster it's already a month ago you put the reaction, but if you want some good lyrics in metal, maybe you should check out Avantasia. they're melodic, powermetal ánd 've got strong lyrics.
SA is an option too, but I prefer Avantasia.
0oDaantje12o0 1 year ago
this album has all story like songs...
mcombes1996 1 year ago
How can you not have Sonata Arctica as one of your favourites band... :)
Angel94angel94 1 year ago
Think this song might have anything to do with The Vice from unia?
Both of them talk about a blind old man... and a young protege.
XaleManix 1 year ago
I want to be real puppet too.. just kidding but any who another great sonata arctica song. Thank you putting this song up.
TheMadmanGrim 1 year ago
chuck norris would've kicked the puppet masters' ass in a jiffy
junio1984 1 year ago
Some things can end with a word, they say
This only ends with a sharp knife (Knife!)
2ilsenzacuore9 1 year ago
My life, by CHUCKY the doll
FlappyMcFlap 1 year ago 2
if you like this song, check out accept - seawinds from '79 and hammerfall - dreams come true from '02
this kinda reminds me of them
insaneoffoe 1 year ago
@Astronesthes Ugh, this is disgusting! #LOL
@RafaelusMaximus The boy accepted to be killed to be made a puppet.
valium97582 1 year ago
These are some of the best lyrics I've ever heard. They're original (for once, not about love/sadness/other overused themes) and chilling as the song gets progressively darker.
NintendoArielle 1 year ago
I love the piano solo!!
lolothe2nd 1 year ago
I can relate to this song since hallucinogens make me feel like I'm a puppet. XD
NintendoArielle 1 year ago
My favorite song of SA.
frankrak654 1 year ago
This song is sex in my ears.
Astronesthes 1 year ago 3
its quite a genius song --> the combination of great pianowork, tough guitars and, most important, the briliantly made lyrics
TheMrBram 1 year ago
My favourite Sonata's song fits perfectly to my favourite character Sasori from my favourite anime Naruto. Could it be better?
Proximity94 1 year ago
Some background: The song is basing on "The puppet who wanted to be a real boy" (Pinnochio) and even the german novel "Pole Poppenspäler".
spacedyevest1986 1 year ago
@spacedyevest1986 What's "Pole Poppenspäler" about, if you don't mind my asking...?
reveriehill1614 1 year ago
@reveriehill1614 It is a German novel about a boy called Paul Paulsen ("Pole" is the North-German mode of the name Paul) and the girl he loves who is the daughter of a puppeteer. This puppeteer owns a puppet, the Kaspar or "Kaschperle", which has a great attraction on the protagonist. He visits every show and his only wish is to touch the puppet, the masterpiece of his true love's father. Unfortunately its nose breaks and the star of the shows is damaged and useless.
spacedyevest1986 1 year ago
@reveriehill1614 Unlike to the song the protagonist does not get under the spell of the puppeteer, who is a calm and friendly man, but the incidents of the puppet shows influence his entire life. The Kasper is a symbol used in the novel. It stands for the struggle of reason and desire. While Paul should be a man with high reputation as his parents are, he falls in love with a carney and the phantasy of his little boy's mind. Like the song the novel is about escapism.
spacedyevest1986 1 year ago
@reveriehill1614 By the way: It is a classic novel for children and youngsters. I have read it when I was 12. As far as I know there is NO English translation for it has many sources of old German words which are even for Germans hard to understand today.
spacedyevest1986 1 year ago
Do you know for a fact this is based on that novel or just saying there's the similarities you mentioned? Tony Kakko isn't German, he's Finnish, meaning he might not know it. Still, a lot of the songs he's written are based on literature so it's possible he's read it, if he speaks German or there's a Finnish translation.
giygasattack 1 year ago
@giygasattack No, I do not think it is a fact but I thought about it when I heart it the first time. I don't think the novel has ever been translated. It was just an idea of mine but I wonder if Tony ever thought of he was writing a song with some marked similarities, even though it was just my personal interpretation and, to be honest, nothing more than an interpretation.
spacedyevest1986 1 year ago
Some background: The song is basing on "The puppet who wanted to be a real boy" (Pinnochio) and even the german novel "Pole Poppenspäler".
spacedyevest1986 1 year ago
Well i think the last line refers to him cutting his own strings to try and free himself from being a puppet
Dragongundam092 1 year ago
Comment removed
Angel94angel94 1 year ago
Great song! i tried to make a video to it, but i could only get part of the song. check it if youd like (Super Warfare: The Wizards, The Kings, and The Boy Who Wanted to be a Real Puppet)
RaoHolythorne 1 year ago
aaaaah, good ol´ sonata!
nuebom 1 year ago
@nuebom yep, just as old as me ;)
marlieswolf96 1 year ago
Epic epic epic
NessaInWonderland 1 year ago 2
a song to my heart! *though i don't want to be a puppet :D*
marlieswolf96 1 year ago
Most of my friend don't even noticed a wolf's behind this ship :D
Bielak999 1 year ago 5
@Bielak999 i do and i like it a lot. a lot of the picture's have a wolf and/or a raven by the way. i think it's cool!
marlieswolf96 1 year ago
@marlieswolf96 It's sure is :)
Bielak999 1 year ago
This album is the best.
moviemaker3000 1 year ago 6
lyrics so epic!
FutureSpeedKills 2 years ago 5
god i love these lyrics
ionucosma 2 years ago
I wish they'd make this into a music video... Would love to see the story visually... Love this song!
reveriehill1614 2 years ago 4
I love this song. It sounds like something straight out of a fairy tale and, not only that, but the way they set up the music was incredible.( I.E. The third verse with the puppet master.)
SasorisPuppet 2 years ago 2
Amazing song,all I have to say
InferiorG 2 years ago
this is why american metal is in the shit whole this takes true skill and a great since of story telling. We need more melodic stuff like this in the USA
Singerboy 2 years ago
@Singerboy
Please... pleaase don't say that again.
mictlantecuhtli93 2 years ago
Singerboy is right..american metal is pure shit..
Gaara5657 2 years ago
@Gaara5657
Metallica, anthrax, megadeth, pantera and motherfucking slayer.
If there are some Bands that can top those, they aren't in the power metal genre. Maybe Black Sabbath, deep purple, led zeppelin or judas fucking priest.
mictlantecuhtli93 2 years ago
@mictlantecuhtli93
well u in wrong style than go back to american trashers btw manowar is american power metal
MrFrosts 2 years ago
@MrFrosts
Gaara5657 wasn't refering to power metal, but in heavy metal in general.
mictlantecuhtli93 2 years ago
If we;re going outside of Power metal.. Oh my LORD.... There are so many great metal bands in general from all around the world. These guys being one of them. :3
SasorisPuppet 2 years ago
kamelot is american and good and disturbed ain't so bad... metallica at least the old stuff. now it is terrible.
timosha21 2 years ago
temaso ta rree weno
chrnocrusade17 2 years ago
PERFECTION!
streetracerm5 2 years ago
pinochio is a puppet who wants to be a human. The Guy in this Story wants to be a puppet, because a puppet is immortal.
lukas01234 2 years ago 3
i don't think he wants to be a puppet because a puppet is immortal.... i think he wants to be a puppet to be near the puppet he admires which the master did not sell.
tony really thought of pinochio when he wrote the lyrics.
kekskruemel2oo9 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@kekskruemel2oo9
No shit sherlock!!
mictlantecuhtli93 2 years ago
your right they are immortal. but a puppet can be destroyed in second, and that also counts as death.
lololer8888 2 years ago
@lukas01234
No shit sherlock!!
mictlantecuhtli93 2 years ago
@lukas01234
Sorry, it was for the other guy ;D
mictlantecuhtli93 2 years ago
this pinochio or whatever in reverse
vallecaucano114 2 years ago
i think this song is awesome because of the story of this song
jahvetti99 2 years ago
They should have made a music video for this song...
reveriehill1614 2 years ago 17
@reveriehill1614
Perhaps you should make a fan video.
Squeaks90 1 year ago
@reveriehill1614 The jury is still out - go make one yourself.
Better yet, go make a short film about it.
outwrangle 1 year ago
best song i ever heard
charlyy1337 2 years ago 7
Sonata is like power metal or hard rock or speed metal it's hard to say what kind of music they play It's like everything i like the stories the music and everything else is good
pirosvillamos 2 years ago 6
Its progressive power metal.
mightyUFO 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
progressive? theres nothing progressive about their style of music, its power metal.
muraganda 2 years ago
Nub, Unia and days of grays are totally going progressive.
mightyUFO 2 years ago 16
@mightyUFO tru, ever since jani left theyve been doing other shit.
xDiego8390x 1 year ago
@mightyUFO still good though!
deadtotheworld00 1 year ago
i know Sonata Arctica like Power Metal
kelvyn616 2 years ago
YA-HA!!! awow man!
topito1994 2 years ago
@pirosvillamos Sonata Arctica is pure and perfect Power Metal yeah!!!
vrigido666 2 years ago 2
actually i think power quest is closer to PURE power metal, its even in the bands name.
solar464 2 years ago
@solar464
So if I made a band called 'Power Metal', it would be the purest Power Metal band ever?
BlackSunSerenade 2 years ago
that was a side note, dumbass. and the only reason you focused on that was for the chance to make me look bad, meaning you can't prove otherwise...
solar464 2 years ago
@BlackSunSerenade
well... METALica has the metal in the name but on load reload they were wasn't relly a metal...
lolothe2nd 2 years ago
Hey...can someone please tell me were sonata fits in?
I only got songs of silence on my pc and I put it on my playlist. I like their music, singer is a bit high but awsome. I just don't get what they are?
Guardian9191 2 years ago
they are Power Metal...? if you want to know dude... yeah!!! :D
kelvyn616 2 years ago
I'll tell ya what they are----COMPLETE FUCKING AWESOMENESS!!!!!!LOL
averytrooper 2 years ago 13
many songs of sonata tell a story, I love that!
wertyhDA 2 years ago 2
This remains me of pinocchio but reversing the story, I just love how Tony makes you think, even though it's a fictional story.... There's something magical about this song.....
venusmlc87 2 years ago 3
What's really epic about this is that the lyrics and the sentiment go so far against the genre it's not even funny
...I need to listen to Eagleheart now...
nux23 2 years ago 4
I simply love that albumcover! it look so awesome!
- but the song is also bamf amazing!
JamaicaGrassEnergy 2 years ago 7
2:36 so Vicious.
jmking182 2 years ago 10
so...epic!
araluen443 2 years ago
amazing lyrics, they make you think
Trommdererste 2 years ago 28
Really sad
MawBTS 2 years ago
trust me i listen to all,every and anything
but hey,maybe i'm just old for ye
hidemehere1 2 years ago
@ hidemehere1 listen to the lyrics, can't hear the word love or something what is equal to it...
darkphoenixT 2 years ago 2
i can i heard it once
eduanizer 2 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
sounds like an 80's love song on a kids show
hidemehere1 2 years ago