One of the best song, one of the best band, too bad...in these day, I still can't find any new band or singer as good as the old day!... BEYOND! You always in our heart!!
I can;t sing the chorus. Its too painful to sing... He made it too sad to sing. I cried when i try singing the song. I can feel his brother feeling when he sing back for him..
I'm Malaysian n I love this song very much.I'd like to try sing this song but I can't understand Chinese words..I need this song lyric in english(ABC)...somebody help me please.......
i can help u send me your email address or add me as your friend on you tube then i can send u the video with this song and lyrics this song does have lyrics but not sure if u believe in it hehe!!!
For all you fuckers that disliked this vid, the guy who's singing, lost his brother (their former lead singer) a few years ago. That's why he almost cannot sing.
真係睇唔落去....
sdutango 1 day ago
Time flies, but BEYOND is always LEGEND for asian-music :)
elwinsaa 4 days ago
最後個段solo真係...太悲傷了
ka725ho896 6 days ago
在国外苦逼留学听听这个真的很感动。
君生我未生,我生君已老。
wintertum 1 week ago in playlist Favorite videos
結他都好似係度哭泣...
UFOo9o3 1 week ago
可能我呢個cm大家會覺得好無聊好白痴 但係我每次睇,聽呢個live果陣 都會感動到動淚
我發覺到我自己中意e家d歌星,同人講好中意佢係假既
但係我可以好大聲好大聲係人面前同人講 我好中意BEYOND
B1AcKbEaN 1 week ago
依家D香港歌相信唔洗點講都知有幾爛...我係一個90後,同時係鐘意K-POP既。請原諒我冇辨法全心全意地去欣賞/支持本地音樂,因為好歌要隔好耐時間先有一首...BAND既話更加唔洗講,「先生」最初出道我覺得OK,但依家轉變到接近反感,「橡筋」好似慢左落黎咁樣,「卡拿」「SM」「紅月」似乎係叫原創Feel,D歌叫做有意思...我唔係想表達D咩野,我只係想講,點解香港樂壇紅既係著重包裝既東西,而唔係真正對音樂有熱誠既人,商業化係唔係愈來愈將音樂既意義捨棄左?我地依家部分人鐘意K-POP,日文化,我覺得根本係冇理由怪我地唔支持本地歌手,現在有D歌手企係台度唱4分鐘,但廳完係唔知佢唱咩的;廳K-POP果D當然一樣唔係字幕唔知佢UP咩,但起碼係佢地身上你會見到佢地有拎心機訓練過先出黎,多謝歌迷OR工作人員既時候唔會馬乎OR巴之閉咁......但係香港呢度...原諒我眼細,我真係見唔到。當初我唔明點解鐘意既歌手eg.阿田,阿詩 要離開香港去其他地方發展,依家我明啦...香港樂壇已經慢慢變興,再唔係以前細個廳果D咁有HREAT既歌既時代,一切都變左。要廳好歌,就只可以係電腦前一再回味。歌手們請加油。
bikellkudos 2 weeks ago
@bikellkudos 我都係同時中意K-POP的,,,我有好幾次都想去中意番HK SONG但真係唔得,,,其實我覺得以前D歌同宜家跟本冇得比!!我聽歌係只要聽到唱OR演奏那個人係有心唱,有一股力量係好感動,,好想哭的,,但宜家HK D歌手真係冇咩幾個,可以話係冇,,,我本身係FTI=PRI,聽到弘基的:不要相愛"我都會哭,.,,這哩都係,,,我雖然係90後,但哩首歌都算係我同我D表哥表姐在我小時已經常常唱,好中意既一首歌!!真係好經典!!
kimikam047 1 day ago
好鍾意隻歌, 歌詞同旋律! 海闊天空=家駒, 永遠喜歡/掛念家駒!
taipocat 2 weeks ago
每一次看這段影片都有一種心酸的 每一字,每一音節,均帶有強烈時感情,思念,在望見家強流淚的臉龐時,我的眼淚不知不覺地從眼角滑下....感覺
oscar236754 3 weeks ago
邊看邊流淚
oscar236754 3 weeks ago
每一字,每一音節,均帶有強烈時感情,思念,在望見家強流淚的臉龐時,我的眼淚不知不覺地從眼角滑下....
怨恨我自己不早點出生,錯過了真正天皇巨星時代
香港有黃家駒,台灣有張雨生,兩個都31歲去世,兩個都在我出生前去世,上天太狠心了
fyw0311171 1 month ago 7
其實真的聽得出的 原MV的海闊天空SOLO是一種高坑,闊大的感覺 而這裡的 就是悲傷 悲憤的感覺...
lamrainng 1 month ago 7
omg, perfect guitar solo
xpanda92 1 month ago
家強唱的好傷心............
holdenfoong9935 1 month ago
看一次哭一次,音樂中聽到他們三個對家駒的悲傷&不捨...
後面的solo每次聽完都有種觸碰到我心靈的感覺. 好touching.
choclatezzz 1 month ago 2
世榮的鼓聲也能夠聽出一股哀傷,悲憤的感覺,其實他們所以的都是,
最後他們三個一起唱的時候很感動
lamrainng 1 month ago
家強喊成咁,個33個人都要比dislike,真係一d同情心都冇呀!!!!!!!!!!!!
DevilZEnka 2 months ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
SOLO好淒厲
lamrainng 2 months ago
paul的solo很有感情~~
shampooyuki 2 months ago
Such a nice solo at the end! Very touching!
graye4 2 months ago
Beyond~加油 隨然家駒走了..你們還是最棒的樂團!!!
280totyta 2 months ago
Beyond 係無法取代,他們是一個傳奇,我第一首有深刻印象的歌就是這首,我細個已經鍾意首歌同埋佢地的聲音,當我依家十四歲,我先開始慢慢明白歌詞,真的很勵志,令我每一次聽,我都很感動,我會流眼淚,多謝你 Beyond I Love You
oscar236754 2 months ago 2
不一定失望的 我個人認識一些香港本地,玩音樂玩得很好的90後朋友
經常一起jam 只是他但還沒有機會讓人認識他們的音樂
bossey7684 2 months ago
身邊的人都在聽情歌,偶像歌
但這才是音樂,振奮人心的.. (我是90後)
家駒,再一次致敬!
bossey7684 2 months ago 2
@bossey7684
90後 真的讓人很失望
亞洲還沒讓我找到Beyond的接班人
我曾在五月天跟信樂團只到些光芒
但式風格不一樣
原諒我這一生不機放縱愛自由~
oh~
coldplay0211 2 months ago 5
this video is so touching...everytime i see it, i cry and think about what a tremendous loss we have in the music industry
johok626 2 months ago
beyond係一個傳奇!不但係香港人驕傲,亦係所以華人驕傲!
star0919ywh 2 months ago 2
每一次看這段影片都有一種心酸的感覺
天才往往死後才得到應有榮譽,真是一種悲哀
fung004912 2 months ago 3
paul这个结尾solo真的弹的很悲很痛的感觉。。最喜欢这个solo
sammax3579 3 months ago 7
你離開了…活著的人卻是這麼想你!……
aj963852 3 months ago
如果不知道這首歌的人就不是香港人
因爲他們是我們香港人的驕傲
youaremylover520 3 months ago 9
家駒係一個好聰明既音樂人
rosezmccandy 3 months ago 4
聽到心都碎了 I love you Beyond
Blair0402 3 months ago 3
One of the best song, one of the best band, too bad...in these day, I still can't find any new band or singer as good as the old day!... BEYOND! You always in our heart!!
fakeid412 3 months ago 3
Paul 的結他哭了!
steve87325 3 months ago 9
真的好想睇一次佢地開演唱會囉!!~~
錯過了,,,因為當年的我還是一個小孩子,大個了真的想睇一次BEYOND的演唱會
Yan131452008 3 months ago 4
駒哥從來沒有離開我們...
衹因我們心中一直有著他 :'-)
benwcc 3 months ago 2
譲人感動,淚流滿面
chtapi 3 months ago
30個不喜歡 因為害他們哭了
cpblsinon1 3 months ago
歌词好感动!
wmffre7 3 months ago
I can;t sing the chorus. Its too painful to sing... He made it too sad to sing. I cried when i try singing the song. I can feel his brother feeling when he sing back for him..
imanovic86 3 months ago
呢段SOLO相信係最令人感觸的...
從PAUL的吉他聲中,聽出了他們三位對家駒的懷念!!
我相信現在要PAUL再演奏一次,都未必彈得返
畢竟彈出來每一個音或推弦都是有感情的!!!
DanielYipWF 3 months ago 9
This has been flagged as spam show
这么多年过去,再看这个视频 仍旧泪流满面
jojobeyond 4 months ago
真的好感動~我又哭了~你們要加油`你們真的好棒~~
2lguagiu 4 months ago
Beyond代表左香港精神。
hokaching 4 months ago
原諒我這一生不羈放縱愛自由
好鍾意呢句
camilla0207 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
希望youtube唔好Delete呢條片喇...............
Crazy19970520 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
懂事以來一聽呢首歌就想喊
Crazy19970520 4 months ago
我都有D想喊
kayeechoy 4 months ago in playlist kayeechoy's Favorited Videos
I don't understand one word from this song, but it is so beautiful... !!!
Yipper2601 4 months ago
这么多年过去,再看这个视频 仍旧泪流满面
liquidhearty 4 months ago 4
almost all the chinese people who live in indonesia love this song very much,..
for us,..its really the best song,...
marvinoliviera99 4 months ago
神曲
Chinnyou1207 4 months ago 4
神曲
Chinnyou1207 4 months ago
Very powerful song. This song was big in many countries not just Hong Kong.
alphamale88888 4 months ago
自古英雄出少年,但恨英雄不假年。
TheMayflover 4 months ago
每一次睇E個Concert 我都係會喊....
libra81lie 5 months ago 4
感動已經滿溢了!
wenli0521 5 months ago
有30個人不喜歡沒有了家駒.
happyandy183 5 months ago 60
@happyandy183 前一首演出的歌《祝你愉快》中,Paul講過是4個人,家駒在
Raye1796453 5 months ago
在這遙遠陌生的古老建築裡聆聽這首永恆之聲
在土耳其的空白日記裡填上自己對Beyond的感動註解
自己的片段早已成碎片留在過往的旅人踏過的石板裂痕裡
照相機拍成的今天 不是挺重要的
重要的自己能夠做些什麼 僅管只是改變地球的一點點自轉周期
也不估負對逝去的父親以及學長的承諾
pamirkuo 5 months ago 20
那种一股无可形容的感觉打动了你我的心 唱出了BEYOND 对音乐的热爱 #^_^
waitat94 5 months ago
這是香港的神曲
keithzxsa1 5 months ago 5
家駒長存在熱愛Beyond的我們心中
hugowong99 5 months ago
同光輝歲月一樣,超好廳
sk07010 5 months ago 4
amazing
seriesfive 6 months ago
看到家強的真情流露~真的讓人看了也跟著一陣鼻酸~
dunhill444 6 months ago 6
感動。。。
wyt04 6 months ago
beyond無人可以超越到
ahming914 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
歌是好歌,主唱SUCKS,哎,家驹过去后,竟然队里连个会唱歌的都没有,真悲哀
Patrickzcl 6 months ago
@Patrickzcl
他們不會唱歌,難道你會?!
DevilZEnka 6 months ago 5
@Patrickzcl 你才悲哀吧~微不足道卻妄下狂語,自以為是的批判曝露自己的卑劣及無知,惋惜。
is57show 5 months ago in playlist BEYOND 4
from 80s to 90s the small window where true artists can spread love in music
Adocompo 6 months ago
雖然我係90後既人,但係我都喜歡beyond的歌
hoikicheung 6 months ago 3
Beyond是個神話!!
聽完Beyond既歌,可以振作起來,感謝您們!
tickychan123 6 months ago
感人的曲子,不死的歌詞。 :)
KiraYamato636 6 months ago 5
你們是最好的band
betty78123 6 months ago
我是一位九十後 但我愛他們的歌
betty78123 6 months ago 5
setiap kali tgk video ni, airmata x berhenti menitis..sian ka keong!
ctkmdsr 6 months ago
Every time I hear this song sing along or even think about it...I still drop some tear!
fakeid412 6 months ago
感激我過有幸聽到這樣好的歌..
有意思有味道的歌比現在的情歌還要好聽
為什麼現在的前生仔女都不懂得欣賞.自問我都係一個90後但係我熱愛這些歌多一點
好的歌沒有時間之分,一隻好歌永遠都在大家的心中.
90後的一個朋友上
Yan131452008 6 months ago 3
每一個禁入來,睇過喱段片既人,都係熱愛Beyond的音樂.
睇過喱段片既人,都會心酸.
睇過喱段片既人,都想哭.
我是90後,真感慨自己不是Beyond的年代.
我就算對Beyond的經歷,但我從佢地既音樂睇到佢地既努力,對音樂既熱成!
R.I.P Beyond
aassboy2009 6 months ago 4
每次聽你既歌刀會喊,若果可以比我選擇,我好希望可以出生系你既年代,至少我可以親身去你既演唱會,禁樣,已經沒遺憾!縱使我只系90後..但我愛你既程度..已經好瘋狂...koma ....真的很想念你!!
Miranda7939 6 months ago 7
1996年的“live and basic"。。。“海阔天空“。。。是我为一位最喜爱,最尊敬,最疼爱的黄家驹及BEYOND流泪最多的一首歌。。。你的声音和音乐是我的生命上的支持!!!!!!
pckp83 7 months ago 2
讚 不知BEYOND還會開演唱會嗎 我超級無敵愛BEYOND
japan4721 7 months ago
中間那個位置...永遠也沒有人可以代替...
RosMelon 7 months ago 3
2011.7.1, you are still alive.
vicariousshame 7 months ago
永遠嘅beyond,永遠嘅家駒,永遠在我們的心中。
7love3for 7 months ago
聽過,看過,哭過,笑過……
家駒,我很興幸出生於你還在生和在全剩時期的年代
很遺憾你這顆巨星要在最光輝的時候墜落……
永遠懷念你,家駒
blacksheep903 7 months ago
加油
angel999182 7 months ago
今天是家駒逝世18年的忌日 我們都還在聽你的音樂喔家駒!
TOUMINGMAGAZINE 7 months ago 6
This comment has received too many negative votes show
似台下人唱多過佢..- -'''
TalesRunner207 7 months ago
吉他在哭泣....直到現在都是
peteroo147852 7 months ago 15
一塊美玉總有些瑕疵污點...就像有30個混球DILIKE.........
MatChlau4 7 months ago 7
心酸 感嘆
chiumason 7 months ago
replay左唔知幾多次
ktp22089 7 months ago 3
家駒 生日快樂
komating 7 months ago
家駒...生日快樂 !
Terrybape 7 months ago
生日快樂呀 家駒.
ioio000123789 7 months ago
生日快樂,家駒!!
aaronto2073 7 months ago
Comment removed
aaronto2073 7 months ago
黄家驹
staphy82 7 months ago
Comment removed
sky331148 8 months ago
他們是傳奇 遺憾無法在這世代聽到他們的音樂
當我聽起這首歌 我媽也會在旁邊回味~
sky331148 8 months ago
結尾SOLO好聽過CD版!!!!
stardream12410 8 months ago
回顧現在.. 香港樂壇還有誰能創作出這樣的音樂?
chan20045 8 months ago 4
我好慶幸,當年中學時期既我係其中一個站於場中既人. 今日睇返, 回想起當日既感動....感覺有增無減... 試問仲有一個香港人舉辦既演唱會值得你會全場由頭到尾 (well 中間unplugged度幾隻歌坐左一陣咁大把) 可以企晌度開心,企晌度嗌,企晌度傷感,企晌度全場一齊喊的嗎? 唔會再有的了.... 因為屬於香港的, 再沒有一支哭泣中的結他,再沒有一個人,一隊樂隊, 可以令音樂跟心靈連成一線去感動到你.
heartdead2 8 months ago 89
見到家強咁真係心都up埋...家強一定係最痛苦嗰個咖喇,始終佢哋係親兄弟,而且仲咁好感情,呢種兄弟情係幾好嘅朋友都比唔上嘅...其實到依家,見到有啲訪問提到家駒,家強眼中都會閃過傷感嘅神情,我諗家駒真係佢心底永遠的痛...
ThePeternat 8 months ago 8
i cried when i saw this video. but when he got to that line... i just couldn't imagine his pain
AthenaPF 8 months ago
@AthenaPF Do you happen to have english lyrics for this song? I would LOVE to see it
innocentgirl007 5 months ago
我真係唔明o個30 條友點解可以唔like 呢個video?
Beyond forever!
kurt0905 9 months ago 8
@kurt0905 佢地可能係D肉棒迷黎搞事,正一仆街!!!!!!!!!!
DevilZEnka 9 months ago
5 like,冇家駒
1228shirley 9 months ago
my heart is so pain ...
bingbingontherocks 9 months ago
想快d突破100萬la!
DevilZEnka 9 months ago
唔知重有冇機會睇到beyond嘅演唱會呢?我真係好想可以親身睇到佢哋嘅演唱會!
家強、世榮、Paul加油呀!
ThePeternat 9 months ago 2
在我心目中.有個BAND.風不可吹.有一個永不放棄的心!
個個BAND就是BEYOND!
我2011的我只有12 old
我覺得現時的香港音樂愈來愈差!
香港音樂裹已沒有實力派的名子.
香港音樂有1.D人係有實力.
有的不過很少
我真的好想可以親身聽BEYOND演唱會.
希望重開多次!!
horace112233 9 months ago 21
@horace112233 仲有好多band有實力 只係d聽眾轉哂聽埋果d韓國歌
taeleung14795 3 months ago
@taeleung14795 冇錯 就好似kolor由家強一手提攜 佢地真係好有heart
TheCheukchung 3 months ago
HÉy_Î_fËël_sO_lÖÑèlÿ_töÐAY
CutieioJaymeaa769 9 months ago
Super awesum. Beyond in my heart!
kivi0410 10 months ago
不喜欢粤语歌曲,因为听不懂。但是beyond的除外
realkk47 10 months ago
那30個人必定沒有親人
DevilZEnka 10 months ago
@DevilZEnka 佢地可能係d 00日後~~
Yan131452008 10 months ago
N多年后每次看这段视频我都想哭
TimYeyuqing 10 months ago
@TimYeyuqing 有同感......
Yan131452008 10 months ago
家強抬起頭吧!
還有很多人支持您們的:)
不要放棄自己音樂的理想:)
lovegillgill 10 months ago 2
家駒哥哥,我們永遠懷念您
kam1996to 10 months ago
謝了家駒,留下一首永垂不朽嘅的歌
jackal585 10 months ago 4
您的名字會响遍香港,全世界,甚至响遍天堂
keungbabi 10 months ago
我睇完喊左出黎.
Yan131452008 11 months ago
想喊
lawkinlong 11 months ago
睇到都想喊
lawkinlong 11 months ago
我發現我天天都要看一次
實在太好聽
faibee1 11 months ago 2
I'm Malaysian n I love this song very much.I'd like to try sing this song but I can't understand Chinese words..I need this song lyric in english(ABC)...somebody help me please.......
TheMynrd 11 months ago
@TheMynrd
i can help u send me your email address or add me as your friend on you tube then i can send u the video with this song and lyrics this song does have lyrics but not sure if u believe in it hehe!!!
larrainewong 7 months ago
這歌簡直能代表華人甚至整個亞洲....
猶如國歌一樣...歌與詞寫得多麼好...多麼完美......
ngkk1306 11 months ago 3
原諒我這一生不羈放縱愛自由
也會怕有一天會跌倒
eicohuang 11 months ago
@eicohuang
跌了
mioo448 10 months ago
好感動,beyond唱歌...
MrKint1129 11 months ago
十年都唔會再有比海闊天空更好既歌
tommyman2008 11 months ago 6
I was born long after this song was made, and yet I still know and love it.
heat1kill 11 months ago
i am crying at the moment actually....as if he have just died only yesterday.
Watiamatilda 11 months ago
阿Paul一直在留意着家强。
当家强唱不下去时,还帮忙他接唱,之后还鼓励他唱回去。
最后的一段吉他SOLO,永远都会是经典之中的经典。
BEYOND FOREVER~~
kinosukai 11 months ago 19
@kinosukai 這就是beyond成員之間的兄弟情....
narakuharaikotsu 7 months ago 4
第1次睇, 呀paul好有型
he214ab 11 months ago
這個LIVE真的太感動了~~~
這是我第一次唱歌唱到哽咽~~
真的太感人了~~~
james83801 1 year ago
没有人能beyond他們, 因為他們是Beyond!
BrianCuber 1 year ago 2
the guitar solo rocks!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
woodywu2011 1 year ago
i will never forget this video i will never forget them i will always loved their music love them love ka kui forever until i am dead
larrainewong 1 year ago 4
没有人能超越他们...
long910211 1 year ago
聽了很心酸, 家駒哭了, 每個喜歡他的人都哭了
沒有任何一band隊可以再像他們那樣深深烙印在我們心中
他們是beyond, 他們是"超越", 他們劃時代地永遠寄進在心內
好想念你,,,你在天堂, 仍然這樣熱愛音樂嗎?
blisstan 1 year ago 106
7分鐘的旋律,牽起17年的感動。
縱使17年前我尚未出生,但所擁有的感動大大超越7分鐘。
lungreen224 1 year ago 7
「也會怕有一天會跌倒」,點解跌倒既你唔支沒落去T.T(慯心)
ellencheung8 1 year ago
人,為什麼失去了,才懂得珍惜?
calvinkahing2004 1 year ago 6
比著我 我都可能一時之間接受唔到呢個事實
將心比心 如果係自己既哥哥突然離去自己的身邊
也許 比他更激動
happyandy183 1 year ago
我想到100個理由like這段片
可我想不到1個理由要dislike
siuming705 1 year ago 5
when ever i watch this video i feel his pain over and over again
larrainewong 1 year ago
a song deserve you shed tears
nancyin20000 1 year ago
My eye balls got a little bit wet....
jacklyw 1 year ago
Anyone know the hanyu piyin lyrics for this song??
84gunZ 1 year ago
@84gunZ
are u asking for the english lyrics? yeah i do type under a vast sky that plays this song and has the lyrics too go check it out
larrainewong 1 year ago
家驅我永遠鐘意~
ChoiFungWa 1 year ago
I Love U....Beyond.....
hfhfefef 1 year ago
就是听不腻啊
huhan100 1 year ago
睇完.喊左出黎
太感動
hang12513 1 year ago
Comment removed
hang12513 1 year ago
吉他....哭了.............
peteroo147852 1 year ago 3
This song is really mean a lot for Beyond Fans ...... I always cry when listen to this song
sun35 1 year ago 4
Whenever I watch, I can't stop crying!
jw4988 1 year ago 3
@jw4988 same here
eddygolf 1 year ago
For all you fuckers that disliked this vid, the guy who's singing, lost his brother (their former lead singer) a few years ago. That's why he almost cannot sing.
zreau 1 year ago 4
@zreau Agree...... and It's a very sad and losing for the music industry because we lost one of the most talented musician >_>
sun35 1 year ago
太感動了 睇左一次喊一次
kimr028954 1 year ago 2
真正係唱歌既歌手得返好少嫁啦 微乎其微
kimr028954 1 year ago 2
雖然我係戈年既2月出世 but都係冇去
戈陣都仲係個bb仔 邊識得咁多野
宜家睇返 唉~只有可惜二字 只能懷念過去
只可說 真係要珍惜眼前
海闊天空 真係識唱歌既人宜家又有幾個 唉~
kimr028954 1 year ago
看到最后家强站在那里想这哥哥的一刻,, 太可惜了, 永远怀念他,,!! 感动..!
GGjill 1 year ago
Comment removed
ViPKin 1 year ago