My Immortal

[Emmerlii]

This will always remain my number 1 favourite LOTR YouTube video of all time<3

xXx

[cymrutvxq]

I just cried once again at the hug at the end! I hate that part when Frodo has to leave Sam! :( Gets to me every time!

This vid was so beautiful! Showed the true love and friendship between Frodo and Sam perfectly! <3

[Ailargent]

just... beautiful !

[jaelamartin]

that was so beautiful

[angryboy2k9]

Does anyone else think their gay when Frodo kisses Sam on the head? Its like, ur NOT royalty, and that was WAAAY to long.

You at least shall go with him. It is hardly possible ti seoarate you from him, even when he is summond to a secret council and you are not.

[Emmerlii]

@angryboy2k9 They're not gay! Only people who don't understand the true meaning of the word "love" tink they are.

[NJDUVM]

Im taking a class in college called "Tolkien's Middle Earth" and for it we had a Tolkien conference today and one of the presentations was titled "Traditional Storytelling, Tolkien and Contemporary Fandom" and the presenter used a part of this video.

It inspired me to change my term paper for the class to "Frodo and Sam: The Fellowship of Two." Really like this video. Good job.

[gunngirl1]

Good Video! It is realy hard to read the words though.

[FarorLukas]

mann ich kenn jeden kommentar aus jeder scene des films ^^

[VampireOutlaw]

*ANGST* :'( </3 This may very well be the most heartbreaking song in the history of music in itself but when combined to this particular friendship it gets even worse. </3 :'( *ANGST*

5/5 and faved.

[Imaryana1]

Awesome! *sobbs*

[confidentcheerer]

omg this is amzing i cried !

i love frodo hes hott!

[duckling1800]

Ok, this seriously brought tears to my eyes. Wonderful job *wipes away tear* lol ^.^

Not to mention it's the the LOTR vid I've seen that actually has had work done on it instead of just throwing in unfitting clips XD

[Blunka796]

I love this song

I love those two

I love the Tales of The Lord Of The Rings

I love this freakin video !

[Cocmorph]

And by the way,this is the first video that I've commented on in Youtube-it was so so brilliantly done that I couldn't help it!

[Cocmorph]

Oh my goodness Elvira-I hate you so much!I cried for about 15 minutes after watching this video,and that's something I've never done after watching any other vid on Youtube!Frodo has always had a part of me,if not 'all of me',and your video made me realise once again the pain and loss and hurt he had to bear.

I was kidding,kudos for putting together the video so well,magnificent job.I've always loved this song,and as for the characters-I've no words to describe my feelings :-)

[GabbieGirl00]

aw this is so sweet i love evanescence

[eirlstarr05]

This was very touching. The song is absolutely perfect for Frodo and Sam's friendship. They went through so much together and it only made their connection grow stronger along the way.

[ineendubh]

Always thought this song was perfect for Frodo and Sam. Lovely vid!

[54spiritedwill54]

Brilliant video to go with one of my all time favourite Evanescence songs.

[jujuhoerteinhu]

I totally agree with Anorwna.

This friendship is special and your video made me cry. Very very good!

[rose13red]

Really and truly beautiful. So wonderful to see such a special tribute to an immortal and selfless love.

[Kaycee110]

OMFG I LOVE IT Made mr cry T_T LUV THE VID LUV THE MOVIE AND LUV ALL 4 HOBBITS

[Anorwna]

Every year in september I read the books and go with them on their journey. Every year i am deeply touched by the friendship between Frodo and Sam. Thank you for giving them such a beautiful tribute :)

[Ps2hunter]

I LOVE this video so much!

[zoinks07]

so beautiful!the first time i heard this song i thought it was perfect for frodo and sam!<3

[gracelightening900]

OH im so glad someone made a video like this. me and my girl friend (note to you crazies there is a space between girl and friend) always thought "my immortal" sounded like a song written for Sam and Frodo. you did such a wonderful job. 5/5 faves

[Lyernai]

That was beautiful indeed...Thank you so much :) Many people see nothing more than wars and monsters on the Lord of The Rings and this video proves there is something MORE :) The friendship between Frodo and Sam is just amazing. A really really great job!!

[coconut994777]

I swear, I have watched this many times, still can't stop loving it!

For anyone here who hasn't watched the many bonus features for LOTR: FOTR, it was Sir Ian's (Gandalf) suggestion for Sean Astin (Sam) to hold Elijah's (Frodo) hand like in the book. YAY! So glad he did!

[GRosiecotton]

That was beautiful! It made me cry! I only hope God grants me a freind like that...you have a talent girl!

[coconut994777]

*sob*

So gorgeous.... *sob*

[UKfan71]

Your video is awesome! I keep watching it over and over again! And it makes me wanna watch the whole movie again! Everything is absolutely well thought through: the music, the clips and the text. Great job!

[cazzykay23]

i love this video ti so cool

[jubealee]

Very nicely done! I love this song, it made me cry.

Sam is the best character of lord of the rings, he stuck to frodo even when frodo was being possesed by the ring.

[omgitsjustme]

beautiful. can i have the link to download it please? id like to have it. its beautiful, good job.

[Elvira27]

Thanks omgitsjustme =) If you'd like to download it, all my LotR vids are available at my Elvira Productions website ~ elviralady [Dot] tripod [Dot]com

Glad you like it.

[tardismouth]

that was so beautiful. thank you so much for posting this, it made me smile :)

[Sevysssoul]

Wow....so beautiful

[omgitsjustme]

amazing video thanx

[CrocodileIndeed]

This made me cry! Realy beautiful!

[UKfan71]

God, how I miss LOTR! Last weekend I rewatched the entire extended trilogy, but I'm still craving for more! This gorgeous video eases the pain a bit, though. Excellent job!

[Unicorn100]

This is the only video I ever liked with this song to it. Elvira you rock!

The fellowship forever!

[waylander101]

Never ever shall i forget the themes and lessons of the most amazing trillogy i've ever seen and i doubt it wil be emulated in my time. Thanks so much for this vid

[Tiassale]

i don't really know how i want to put words together for a comment here, so i'll just say that this was amazing. i almost cried when i saw the song paired with LOTR clips..before watching any of it. i love the black and white clips. that adds a lot to it. nice job.

[WanderdFromTheShire]

to busy crying to leave a comment right now

[Sevyssoul]

Hi!

Just wanted to say, BRILLIANT vid. I love it.

And I made a vid. response, with the same song and GANDALF :D. Hope you accept it.

[AEagleGirl86]

:cries:

Brilliant video to go with one of my all time favourite Evanescence songs. Great job.

[ToriBartley]

i liked it it was sad

[deetigger]

i have no words...i finally saw "return of the kiing" when they played the trilogy on tv the week before christmas...and cried my eyes out the last 45 of the movie. this vid reminds me of all the things that touched my heart in that film, and i'm utterly blown away. It is one of the best LOTR tributes on youtube, let alone the net. utterly perfect, for i cry every single time i watch it ...

[Stan1275]

Elvira27, you're a bloody genious! This is so sad and briliant! I kept rewinding it back to where Frodo kisses Sam on the forehead. I've only seen the first LOTR and I'm going to see the other two soon. Once again, amazing five stars forever! T_T

[EQGirl]

this is awesome...

[haleydebi]

omg beautiful song, and beautiful Movie!!! thank you

[lotr01fan]

this song made me cry. it was so beautiful. i loved it

[jedipenguiin]

Brilliant! Loved it! Got me obsessed with LOTR and Sam and Frodo (which is a good thing, of course :))

[KwansPrayerWarrior]

I just NOW got done watching the TRILOGY ON TNT. But one question I don't understand? Why did Frodo have to leave in the end? What for?? That puzzles me

[CrwlingNMySkn97]

I never quite understood his voyage into the Gray Havens myself, but I have come to the conclusion that because the ring weakened his Spirit and his stab-wound never truly healed (it probably currupted his soul in some way) That him leaving was probably not only best for him, but for the entire shire. (rhyming not intended)

Amazing Video, btw. <3

[lovebug345]

I am speechless. I really don't know what to sya but that this is the best lotr music video I've ever seen. Beautiful....

[Jwoman]

I cried while watching this... their friendship is so beautiful

[marywood24]

My tears fall down...

[sven95]

Ohh Goosebumps. Gorgeous truly brilliant.

[kagorumusashi]

ROX ROX ROX ROX !!!! MADE MORE VIDDEOS, THEY ARE MY PREEEEEECIOUS ;p

[AlongForTheRide]

Beautiful, just beautiful.

[ElijahFan85]

This is one of only a very few videos that have made me cry. You did an absolute fantastic job on this video! I know that if Sean or Elijah have seen it, they would have said the same thing! Keep up the fantastic work!

[gillianinoz]

Thanks for reminding me why I fell in love with those two hobbits. :-)

[Dallienat]

OMG that was amazing! I love Frodo and Sam! *huggles* hehe.

[UKfan71]

Gorgeous video and gorgeous music! How I miss LOTR! And how beautiful friendship is...!

[emileeirene]

Beautiful! Gave me chills

[augmentedheart]

This video is beautiful.

[mistysuzie]

I nearly cried. thank you...you are very talented..dont stop..you never know where you will end up..well done :)

[Danguard]

Really nice work, i liked it :D

[dladymuse]

I love your work hun :) *waves* This is one of my all time favorites!

[Elvira27]

*waves back*

Thank you Muse:) It's good to see you on here ^_^

[phantastic233]

i love it! Sam is such a loyal friend

[myttast]

very nice can you use the same song for harry potter

[acoupleanutcases]

Very, very well put together. That song has always irked me for some reason, but the video itself really is quite lovely.

[loreelei]

Words cannot describe this - wonderful

[elvishmistress]

That was awsome! Goin right to my favorites ^_^

[reklamedame]

just great. ever thought about becoming a director?

[7thcardinalsin]

This is so beautiful!! I loved it!

[LLHHJP17]

I Love It.

[dgmatt516]

nice

[elizabeth1977]

love this very moving

[theshieldmaiden]

yea! ^-^

[Elvira27]

Thanks!

I've friended you:)

[theshieldmaiden]

very very good!