I am glad they cut this scene, this episode was like naley's turning point I think, like them becoming a strong couple again and this was kind of a sour scene ... but I think it would have been a really good scene on a different episode when they were still not getting on right I think it would have been kind of hopeful...
You know that Haley couldn't even tell him what she wanted at the time, I mean he gave her the choice of the tour or him and he left without even hearing what she was going to say so really if he stayed maybe Haley would have to or maybe Haley would have asked Nathan to go with her.
i think that we should have seen that scene...because when Nathan goes at her dressing room with the PURPLE FLOWERS mentioning that he keeps screwing up ... we had to assume that it was mostly because of his uncertainty for the Haley performing again...but that scene justifies his reaction and his words.
@gogomih, I totally agree. Also, his second proposal made way more sense because of this scene. I mean they already were married, but he wanted her to feel that he really wanted that. Sort of like finally he said, yes, I would marry you again any time.
I'm sick of people blaming Haley for what happened Nathan didn't tell her not to go he gave her an ultimatum and when he was in the crash he told her not to come home
@StashaSLW: Word! I think people blame Haley because S2 only shows Nathan's side. Haley barely appears. If they had shown us more scenes of her on tour, maybe people would have understood her side better. I myself can kind of understand why an ultimatum would drive someone out the door. And while kissing someone else sucks, it was Chris who kissed Haley, not vice versa (like Carrie kissed Nate later, and he wanted forgiveness, too). Still love Nathan though ;-). Thanks for posting!
i'm glad this didnt get put in tbh i love naley so much i was gutted that there was hardly any naley lovin in scene 5 how fit is nathan i love him an i love naley there like the cuttest couple ever oth is amazin =)
Remember she left him to go on tour the season be4 this- this is during the time when their relationship is getting back on track but they haven't completely healed -- he was just telling the truth. Remember how much pain he was in second season?? I don't blame him for being a little harsh
Yeah i'm glad they didn't air it... that would always be on the back of my mind you know if you asked that to your husband and he basically says yeah some days I regret marrying you.
haley should never had asked and nathan was just being honest like she asked but he should not say sorry haley should if she wasnt ready for the answer dont ask
Nathan shouldn't say yes when Haley asks him if she can ask him a question because he's always getting into trouble
BekiiTheSinger 6 months ago
Haley and Nathen rock!!
partygirl209 11 months ago
I am glad they cut this scene, this episode was like naley's turning point I think, like them becoming a strong couple again and this was kind of a sour scene ... but I think it would have been a really good scene on a different episode when they were still not getting on right I think it would have been kind of hopeful...
FallingAngelxx 1 year ago
i watch this show at onetreehillepisode . org
DrusillaSmerkarify 1 year ago
i watch this show at onetreehillepisode . org
ShawnCormiernytify 1 year ago
i watch this show at onetreehillepisode . org
kourtneynichkelism 1 year ago
You know that Haley couldn't even tell him what she wanted at the time, I mean he gave her the choice of the tour or him and he left without even hearing what she was going to say so really if he stayed maybe Haley would have to or maybe Haley would have asked Nathan to go with her.
SophiaBethanyFan 1 year ago
i think that we should have seen that scene...because when Nathan goes at her dressing room with the PURPLE FLOWERS mentioning that he keeps screwing up ... we had to assume that it was mostly because of his uncertainty for the Haley performing again...but that scene justifies his reaction and his words.
gogomih 2 years ago 2
@gogomih, I totally agree. Also, his second proposal made way more sense because of this scene. I mean they already were married, but he wanted her to feel that he really wanted that. Sort of like finally he said, yes, I would marry you again any time.
uclmu2008 1 year ago 2
I'm sick of people blaming Haley for what happened Nathan didn't tell her not to go he gave her an ultimatum and when he was in the crash he told her not to come home
StashaSLW 2 years ago 12
@StashaSLW: Word! I think people blame Haley because S2 only shows Nathan's side. Haley barely appears. If they had shown us more scenes of her on tour, maybe people would have understood her side better. I myself can kind of understand why an ultimatum would drive someone out the door. And while kissing someone else sucks, it was Chris who kissed Haley, not vice versa (like Carrie kissed Nate later, and he wanted forgiveness, too). Still love Nathan though ;-). Thanks for posting!
uclmu2008 2 years ago
@StashaSLW i am with u 100% and when people give ultimatums it always ends badly well most of the time
iheartdogs824 1 year ago
somedays.... with haley it sould be everyday she is so nice and pretty =) but at least he was honest. ture love is naley♥♥♥
iheartdogs824 2 years ago 3
he wasnt harsh, he was telling the truth. in hindsight some things just arent worth it.
Nazaba09 2 years ago 4
oooo big mistake nathan! i wuda lied if i wer him but i spose she asked him so he told the truth
RoxieMasie 2 years ago
i am sooooo moving to the USA so i can eat cookie do
:P
i woodnt keep it until im heartbroken either, the only cookie do here is ben and jerrys ice cream or homemade, un cooked cookies
1soon2Bfamous5 2 years ago
One of the reasons I want to go to the states is for the food too, things like cookie dough ice cream and peeps
NewMusicFan91 2 years ago
you can't blame him for being honest
tekkenmaster600 2 years ago 2
bad answer :L
i'm glad this didnt get put in tbh i love naley so much i was gutted that there was hardly any naley lovin in scene 5 how fit is nathan i love him an i love naley there like the cuttest couple ever oth is amazin =)
RobynHumesx 2 years ago
Remember she left him to go on tour the season be4 this- this is during the time when their relationship is getting back on track but they haven't completely healed -- he was just telling the truth. Remember how much pain he was in second season?? I don't blame him for being a little harsh
IHEARTCLARK 3 years ago 6
"somedays"
wow...wrong answer bud.
xKB09x 3 years ago 6
wat season is this? :P
ChAzZa12321 3 years ago
it is season 3. i would know, i have seasons 1-5 which are all the ones out.
hairandmakeupgirly1 3 years ago
that was definitely not the right answer!
cheerNlead 3 years ago 4
aweeee =(
vintagebras 3 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
get a life
shiley116 3 years ago
u to!
edlapie 3 years ago 6
Haley's hairstyle is great in this scene
fugeeela 3 years ago 45
Im Glad he Cut that One out...That was kinda sad =(
NaleyAreSoCute :P xxxxxxxx
HomeNawayLuver 3 years ago 11
Yeah i'm glad they didn't air it... that would always be on the back of my mind you know if you asked that to your husband and he basically says yeah some days I regret marrying you.
LEYTONLOVER333 3 years ago 11
HAHAHA 'i don't know, that always seems to get me in trouble'
WHAT A CUTIE <3
swtaznak 3 years ago 10
so sad
onyxmeg 3 years ago 6
AWW THAT'S SAD :(
xXBDlibra96Xx 3 years ago 3
god do i love this show
amanda1242 4 years ago
"im fine" LMAO hahah. i love naley.
allieandannmarie 4 years ago 38
A great scene! Love NALEY!!! =)=)=)
heavenlygal101 4 years ago 4
Its so funny when she says I'm Fine
naleyfan1002 4 years ago 17
i dont know that always seems to get me in troble hahaha great quet nathan
Inuyasharockkz13 4 years ago 9
Thanks for posting it
carolinesph 4 years ago 2
haley should never had asked and nathan was just being honest like she asked but he should not say sorry haley should if she wasnt ready for the answer dont ask
ashiee1994 4 years ago 3
that was so sad...
peyton93 4 years ago
can someone put all the deleted scenes up
goku5991 4 years ago 3
one thing that was funny-
'i dont know that always seems to get me in trouble' haha!!!
xomfyox 4 years ago 2
why would nathan tell her that?!!!!!!!
iluvnaley17 4 years ago 2
yeah why would nathan tell her that
19leeann 3 years ago 3
Poor Haley
mallikahd 4 years ago
yeah, that was weird. Her smile in the beginning was creepy too!!!
bobjanemac 4 years ago 2
i noe i had to laught
Inuyasharockkz13 4 years ago
naaw
missyheart91 4 years ago
Good thing that scene was ommited
lucas4brooke 5 years ago
this is a weird scene, im pretty glad they left it out even though its kinda cute when she scoots up next to him on the sofa
dinosawr123 5 years ago
i kno
Keisha2baby 4 years ago
aww that's sad :(
OneTreeHill247 5 years ago