i really liked all the detail that you gave in the sidebar thing-a-miajig. i knew that she and the singer from seether had had a relationship that ended in him going to rehab but i had not known that this song was a result of said relationship. now i know
Well, I say one instrument, it's basically, without drums/bass. Acoustics are kinda like the echo I suppose. Like if a room has good acoustics it's usually something like a big hall. A concert hall for example. I'm crap at explaining but yeah....
I agree,, rock music will always change through everything but nothing can ever change the 'way' rock music is,, where as new music is filterd and edited until its compltetely differnt and every song is shallow and most singers are edited to make them sound good anywayy not amy lee.
@iBelieveinDemiLovato uhm...not to point out anything but your user name is "I Believe in Demi Lovato" and u comment about where all the real singers like Amy Lee went??Haha no offense but..yeah;)
@iBelieveinDemiLovato amy scared the hell out of them. they heard amy and were like 'oh shit theres no way i can be that good that girl sings like a goddess" so they had to edit there tracks but they are nothing compared to her
Excellent! I love her voice and both versions of this song. You know someone is talented when they can do an acoustic version. The reason it is more difficult is because it is only your voice and the musical notes of the piano.
SO...beautiful! Amy has an amazing voice. It just makes you want to burst out singing whenever you hear it or play the song over in your mind. I love her acoustic and piano songs and covers. Love you Amy!
I need to sing this song this year, in front of 400 people!! I certainly hope so I will sing as well as she does. I doubt it though, she has a great sound! Acoustic is way way more difficult to sing than the normal version. I don't know why, but it is really tough to sing.. My compliments to Amy=)
Good luck! I'm sure you'll be just wonderful!^___^ Everyone has their own style, so don't follow in the shadow of someone else's (even though Amy Lee is my musical idol xD) Good luck and remember...ROCK!
You know, the pianist and me changed the song one week ago, because she has some problems with it.. Too hard for her=( But now we're going to perform Lithium by evanescence, the acoustic version. And perhaps even with cello and guitar, the whole mess=P Yeah, I love Amy Lee too:):) Her voice is just so.. I can't explain it. Her vocal range is just... incredible! And not to mention the way she plays the piano.. AMAZING!! I'm stunned with her talent:)
-to hcyjtd4x- well good luck, im pretty sure you'll do more than fine! like sweethaunting says, do it with your style. its what make a song beautiful! for me, songs are for everyone who live the song and can make their own with themself in it;) gives us news about it ;)
Well thank you:) I'll try my best not to forget and tell you about it=P You know, there are always people who film the performances, so perhaps I can put it on youtube. If so, I'll tell you okay? But it will take a while because the performance is next year=)
well good luck, im pretty sure you'll do more than fine! like sweethaunting says, do it with your style. its what make a song beautiful! for me, songs are for everyone who live the song and can make their own with themself in it;) gives us news about it ;)
Here's some news about it,, I just did audition with my pianiste (lithium, acoustic), and we made it=) there's one audition still though, but the judge told us we'll definately make it to the stage.. the whole performance will be filmed, so we'll do our best and place it on youtube so you can watch it then;)
I'm so happy for you!!! and sure I want to see this! Well, just another one to pass and you'll be great, I'm pretty sure! Like the first time, I wait news about it :P and I wait the video, until then, see yah and break a leg! ;)
Yes, 'Break a leg' is an expression used by theatrical performers =) It means 'good luck.' They don't say 'good luck' because at one point they told a guy 'good luck' and he broke his leg, thusly theatrical superstition.
my mom was watching a play when she was in school and during one of the fight scenes, she broke a pencil and one of the actors that were "fighting" cried out.
Hi, I promised again I would let you know how it all went.. I had the second audition yesterday, and we made it again, everyone loved us!!=) So we're going to perform somewhere in june.. I'll let you know when it is that far..
How many people end up divorced a year... and split apart? Can you people stop talking about their personal lives.. all i know is that Amy sounds awesome and this is a great song.
Ooh I was actually going to ask if anyone knew who the "Wolf" in the video was, but you have it right there in your awesome vid. description! Thanks a ton for all your video uploads <3
I really don't understand why is this such a big deal. It's just a good song. What they did is none of your busyness. So maybe you should all shut the hell up... I mean you are all like bunch of fucking kids... all you can do is talk shit about people. Get a fucking life
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
And haven't you noticed that ever since Ben left her sorry ass, that all she can write about is Shaun? that's hilarious. Maybe it's because I'm not depressed anymore, but idk... something's up. She has no lyrical talent, all she writes about is bleeding and praying and dying... honestly, I've heard it all a million times. So let's give her a REAL challenge and have her write about something HAPPY for once. cause there's what, like one or two HAPPY evanescence songs?
Good enough. That's happy, and it's about Josh Hartzler. All That I'm Living for is about her career. Lithium is about how she's writing for her career. Like You is about her sister. Lacrymosa is about the chronicals of Narnia. Snow White Queen is about someone with a control complex. Weight of the world is about her pproblems feeling heavy on her. None of those relate to shaun morgan. You have no proof backing your argument. And she didn't write tournaquet. Rocky did.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
EXACTLY MY POINT. Amy Lee fucked Shaun and used the shit out of him and rode him to the top. Broken was way more popular than any Evanescence song. She was the one who convinced Shaun to record it as a duet! I don't personally know either of them, but I stand by Shaun, because even if he HAD a drinking problem, he never publicly bashed somebody or trashed their reputation for fame. It may seem like it, but he didn't even write anything about her on their new album. He took the high road here.
It's not a big deal. If need to vent, vent where people agree with you and support you. Does it really make you feel better when you're angry (although I don't see why you are) and you need to get that anger out, and then people flame you because you make THEM angry? It's a vicious circle, and you're being immature.
Um, just because music is "therapy" for you Amy, doesn't mean you get to go and make songs that trash somebody else or a past relationship and release it to the world.
What releasing this song tells me is "Nah nah nah nah nah Shaun, now everybody knows why we broke up and how you're a drunk".
Unless releasing that song was "therapy" too.
She could've just wrote the song to express herself and be done with it. There was no need to put it on album, that was just immature.
you can't just call someone an idiot because they proved you wrong. The last song I'm wasting on you is about how she's past all the problems ben caused her and how she's not going to lose herself just to make money in the music buisness.
And even if it /were/ a break-up song, that's only two out of thirteen. As far as I can tell, that's not all, it's not even a fourth.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
I used to be a huge Evanescence fan, they were totally my favorite band. But when they released The Open Door I totally lost respect for her. She publicly bashed and trashed on Shaun Morgan. She brought his addiction out into the public and I think that was so immature and so uncalled for. She turned into some stereotypical stick figure chick who only sings about break ups. She has a lot of talent, it's just too bad that she's a bitch. I can't even listen to Evanescence anymore.
I understand what you are saying...but maybe..oh, i don't know...SHAUN MORGAN WAS A BASTARD! That song is obviously about her being abused by a certain singer, and she needed to let it all out. It was her way of coping. I understand that more than your ignorant comment. She needed closure, and in her heart a song was the way to go and say how much she regrets dating that man. She also didn't only sing about a break up, she sang about her not taking any shit from anyone, like always. GO AMY!
My point is Amy Lee was very immature when she wrote this song. She shouldn't have had the right to degrade Shaun as a slobbering drunk. Really, what did Shaun do to her? Nothing, he just drank. Amy didn't like that, so she broke up with him.
Well, firstly you came out with "all he did was drink."
Yes it could have been worse, however, my point being that watching someone you care about, turn into an alcoholic, not only destroys their life, it destroys whomever is involved with that person.
As for calling Amy Lee immature, she wrote it as a sort of therapy to help her get over it. As you can tell, she wears her heart on her sleeve and it takes a strong person to admit to feelings. So for calling her immature, that is something you obviously do not understand.
Yes, she wrote the song as therapy. But was it appropriate for her to just air it all over the world? She knew it would hurt Shaun. It was probably intentional to hurt Shaun, seeming she was so angry.
Plus, just listen to the lyrics. There's so much hatred over a drinking problem. God, why did she write such hateful lyrics anyways? IT WAS A DRINKING PROBLEM. She made it sound like he would beat her every night. And let's not forget Shaun DID go to rehab two or three years ago :)
Of course she wanted to hurt Shaun, she wanted him to wake up and realise what he was doing to himself. She probably hoped he'd hear the song and remember who he was before he had a drinking problem.
Drinking is just as bad as drugs. Just because he's not sniffing it, doesn't mean it's not dangerous. He was slowly killing himself mate.
Plus, they're famous mate, it's going to get out whether they wanted it or not. x
lol, I don't think making him wake up and helping him was her intentions.
besides, HE WENT INTO REHAB.
and again, amy was the one who let the world know why they broke up. Everybody makes mistakes, and I feel really sorry for Shaun. They did have good things in the relationship and shaun used to be really in love with her. I do feel sorry for amy that she had to deal with her boyfriend bein an alcoholic, but I'm even more sorry for Shaun that she did all of that shit and aired their---
dirty laundry to the world. Sure, Shaun wasn't the perfect boyfriend, he had some problems, but he did love her. isn't that what really matters? Obviously amy didn't love him unconditionally, hence she put that song out into the world. So, Amy obviously wasn't the perfect girlfriend either.
Oh, and there are plenty of people out there who aren't celeberities that can find something else to do as therapy. She really didn't need to write that song, that was unnecessary.
Oh, and if amy did love him, then wouldn't she help him? Make him go to rehab so he doesn't get really sick, or possibly die?
Obviously not, since she dumped him and wrote that song, then shoved it in his face and informed the world of the bad things that went on in the relationship.
Yes, I know what an addiction is, I'm not ignorant.
I know it's not easy. Having had one myself.
Amy probably did love him, but just couldn't take anymore, watching him like that. So she ended it, hoping he'd see sense, which is good, because when she released that song, he went to rehab.
She didn't inform the world of everything bad din the relationship, she just said choose addiction or me.
In a way it wouldn't be as harsh, and in a way it would be way more harsh.
The way that it wouldn't be as harsh is that the guy isn't famous, so nobody know who he is.
But the way it would be way more harsh is that the guy isn't famous. Shaun is more used "negative publicity" or whatever. He's more used to getting insults from strangers and other artists probably. If I was dating a guy who was famous, and we broke up then he wrote a song about how much I suck I would freak out, lol
Yeeh, but if you easily listen to gossip without hearing facts, then you're not much of a person are you?
So people whom assume Amy-Lee is innocent and Shaun is a prick, obviously are ignorant wankers, who need to look at themselves and get a life, because again we don't know them; relationships are a two way thing, not one way and they're human; no one is perfect.
Same goes whom think Amy is a bitch and Shaun is innocent.
For one, I didn't hear it from gossip I heard it from facts. I've been looking into interviews from both shaun and amy.
And dude, I never said that shaun was innocent, did you not read what i fucking told you? I said that yeah, shaun did have some problems and he was a drinker, but amy shouldn't have wrote that song.
Moreover, we are both not involved in Amy's personal life, therefore there are things that probably happened in that relationship that we will never know about.
Plus, there are assumptions about the song, that obviously Amy hasn't denied, but you can't blame her, it's none of our business.
she doesn't just sing about breakups. Weight of world lithium cloud nine snow white queen lacrymosa like you lose control your star all that I'm living for Good Enough The Last Song I'm Wasting on You None of those are about break-ups, (I'm not completely sure about Sweet Sacrifice,) and that's most of the songs.
Sweet Sacrifice is kind of a break up song, but i'm pretty sure it's mostly about letting bad things of the past go and forgetting about them and leaving behind.
can you imagine the feeling when you have a relationship and your lover is always so busy working that he is always in a bad mood when you talk to him, and you finally decide to end the relationship and you can't because he's not there for you and you have to call his manager (!) and say that you wanna stop? he really used her, but that's my opinion.
lol, are you for real? I think Amy Lee was pretty busy too, considering that she is in a band.
And how do you know that it ended that way?
And how do you know that he was always in a bad mood?
And how do you know EVERYTHING about their relationship?
Oh, and it's really funny how you say that HE used her. I don't think he used her at all, but the bitch sure did deal with her emotions in an immature way. Just airing out their dirty laundry, as Shaun Morgan said, & let the song out public
Me too. I still like Evanescence, but I've lost my respect for Amy Lee. There was no need to publicly bash Shaun Morgan. If she really needed to express herself that much, then just write the song and don't release it. But I've already said what I had to say on my comment I just wrote :)
Bikinikilled98, stop pretending you knew about their relationship. Maybe Amy was a bitch and hard to live with, maybe Shuan was an asshole who drank to much, maybe they beat each other up....YOU don't know and you will never know, so why don't you enjoy both groups wonderful music and stop worrying about their personal lives.
AMAZING.
ViolettaLilix 3 months ago
7 people aren't sober
TheMrSexyLover 6 months ago 10
@silverwolfb1990 who doesnt? amy's voice sounds like a goddess!
DarknessOfTheStorm 6 months ago
@FireflyFanatics3 THANK YOU :)
DarknessOfTheStorm 6 months ago
This is better than the original song. :)
KayakoRox 9 months ago
I love her. <3
EvanescenceAmyLeeSam 1 year ago
Comment removed
EvanescenceAmyLeeSam 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Russian women on the street ** leefoxnow.info **
NbhgyMkjiu 1 year ago
If this isnt a voice of a goddess I dont know what it is. Amy Lee is absolutely divine. <3
moonstrike047 1 year ago 5
Her voice is angelic
kjeldsen81 1 year ago
A few things you might want to keep in mind for when you watch a video:
--read the description ... she says it's Amy singing at an acoustic performance
--chill ... there are lots of heated comments, so what if someone's mistaken this for a cover? no need to swear and get all angry over it
--enjoy the music ... this video was kindly put here for us to enjoy the music, so calm down and just enjoy Amy's beautiful voice, lyrics and music
:)
FireflyFanatic3 1 year ago 2
haha i like it
smileyluvy 1 year ago
i love her voice so much.......everytime i hear her singing i´ll start crying
Bloodylady1572 1 year ago
God she sounds amazing doing acoustic or regular!
EmoXxChickxX1 1 year ago
have you got mp3?
GiuACDC 1 year ago
Wait, this is YOU?
I kinda figured it sounded different than Amy..It didn't seem like her.
But YOU ARE AMAZING!! Dude, you sound totally like her.
GabbyGasoline 2 years ago
LOL, this IS amy! :D it's an acoustic live version :)
XoSnOwWHiTeQuEEnoX 2 years ago 6
Ohhhh.....I didn't realise because it sounded a bit different...
I feel totally stupid haha.
GabbyGasoline 2 years ago
@GabbyGasoline your brain will develope in time
harlequinsacrifice 1 year ago
Excuse me? I'm pretty damn smart and it's developed completely.
You have no reason to be rude, and no one had reasons to thumbs down me.
The only reason I though it wasn't Amy because at first it sounded like another person and not Amy.
I was reading the other comments, and everyone else was saying this one someone else, so I figured that.
Don't put it all on me. I didn't start the whole thing that this was someone else
GabbyGasoline 1 year ago 5
nice vid but wow this guy isn't too bright ^^
SandStormDota 2 years ago
this is amy lee. a live performance she did a while back. i remember the video
hot1985boy 2 years ago
I know. I finally figured that out, haha.
GabbyGasoline 2 years ago
Don't feel bad I thought the same thing at first XD
NateK314 1 year ago
would have sound better on guitar
thaares 2 years ago
Acoustic = unplugged
gopackers111 2 years ago 6
ah wait.. that wasn't you? sorry. :(
All4YouProductions 2 years ago
omg you sound like her. O_O WHAT?
Amy has sisters besides bonnie?!?!?!?!
All4YouProductions 2 years ago
Yes, her two sisters made the background vocals on the studio version.
Zavedi234 2 years ago
i did not know that lol wow thats kewl
idget222 2 years ago
@All4YouProductions yeah Amy has 3 siblings - Her, then Bonnie then Lori, Carrie and Robby
FireflyFanatic3 1 year ago
i really liked all the detail that you gave in the sidebar thing-a-miajig. i knew that she and the singer from seether had had a relationship that ended in him going to rehab but i had not known that this song was a result of said relationship. now i know
HappyLlamaFilms 2 years ago
OMG this was posted the day before my birthday =D=D=D=D=D=D
badprangel 2 years ago
Amy lee is awesome as usual, but i think there's something wrong with the audio....the piano sounds wrong....
wearefruitcakes 2 years ago 2
this is paino. Accustic is a gutair
MewmewZoey1995 2 years ago
Acoustic can be applied to music that uses just the vocals and one instrument as opposed to all the instruments though.
JDsbassplayer 2 years ago
really?
MewmewZoey1995 2 years ago
Well, I say one instrument, it's basically, without drums/bass. Acoustics are kinda like the echo I suppose. Like if a room has good acoustics it's usually something like a big hall. A concert hall for example. I'm crap at explaining but yeah....
JDsbassplayer 2 years ago
But I think the right word is unplugged then.
Zavedi234 2 years ago
Unplugged works aswell yeah but they basically mean the same thing
JDsbassplayer 2 years ago
@MewmewZoey1995 not always
acoustic is not electric, and last time I checked a piano wasn't electric. All the instruments used are acoustic, therefore it's acoustic
:)
FireflyFanatic3 1 year ago
is this really her!? she sounds amazing!
jasmynewilliams 2 years ago 3
wow very good angel. i could have easily mistaken your voice amys! awsome job keep it up!
gentlemortal 2 years ago 2
Comment removed
TheRevolutionGirlz 2 years ago
WTF? SHUT THE HELL UP!!!!
horseshoequeen 2 years ago
what happened to real singers like amy lee? everyone is just so edited and not real nowadays.
amy's voice is absolutely mesmorizing:)
iBelieveinDemiLovato 2 years ago 66
I agree,, rock music will always change through everything but nothing can ever change the 'way' rock music is,, where as new music is filterd and edited until its compltetely differnt and every song is shallow and most singers are edited to make them sound good anywayy not amy lee.
EatMyCrayonzz 2 years ago
Yes, they really do. It's a shame....the real singers need to come back
alexisstarr514 2 years ago 2
@iBelieveinDemiLovato uhm...not to point out anything but your user name is "I Believe in Demi Lovato" and u comment about where all the real singers like Amy Lee went??Haha no offense but..yeah;)
Peace,William
jabbben 1 year ago 3
@iBelieveinDemiLovato amy scared the hell out of them. they heard amy and were like 'oh shit theres no way i can be that good that girl sings like a goddess" so they had to edit there tracks but they are nothing compared to her
RiverPond17 6 months ago
@iBelieveinDemiLovato everyone on the mainstream anyway
Secretstarz7 2 weeks ago
oh.. kinda.. nice xD
VampirexGuitarist 2 years ago 3
It's good to hear another version of this song. :)
hikarukaze7 2 years ago 5
her voice is really good
anyone said she doesnt have good voice i believe now he has changed his mind!!
Xristina21amy 2 years ago 14
wow you can really hear her voice with acoustic. She sounds beautiful
AlwaysDancingOnWater 2 years ago 7
i love the singer
i love the song
i love the band
wahhh..
and she doesen't need much sound to sing like a bomb !
she is the best
ZheBlackrose 3 years ago 3
i love the way amy plays the piano! her voice is absolutely AMAZING. :)
XoaymeoX 3 years ago
so wait, is this the audio from the same acoustic performance for VH1 where amy did lithium, good enough, and all that i'm living for?
its called unplugged on the site btw
i cant find it anywhere, and if this is it, im gonna download it
-Chris
miracle15c 3 years ago 8
Yup, this is just the audio from VH1.
AngelSacrifice 3 years ago
thanks for uploading it then, i have it on my ipod now
=]
miracle15c 3 years ago
No prob :)
AngelSacrifice 3 years ago
I WANT HER VOICE! IDC IF I'M A GUY XD
JustMe8531 3 years ago
WOW! What the beautiful voice!
JustineDepp14 3 years ago
WOW.
RyanMelody4evervideo 3 years ago
well we'll be patient, we dont have choice ;)
flot01 3 years ago
Excellent! I love her voice and both versions of this song. You know someone is talented when they can do an acoustic version. The reason it is more difficult is because it is only your voice and the musical notes of the piano.
AramisLyge 3 years ago
SO...beautiful! Amy has an amazing voice. It just makes you want to burst out singing whenever you hear it or play the song over in your mind. I love her acoustic and piano songs and covers. Love you Amy!
KatieKatmunk 3 years ago 2
all that matters is Evanescence is the best band in the world.....in my opinion...EVANESCENCE ROCKS!!!!.....
PutrescentSoul 3 years ago
I need to sing this song this year, in front of 400 people!! I certainly hope so I will sing as well as she does. I doubt it though, she has a great sound! Acoustic is way way more difficult to sing than the normal version. I don't know why, but it is really tough to sing.. My compliments to Amy=)
hcyjtd4x 3 years ago
Good luck! I'm sure you'll be just wonderful!^___^ Everyone has their own style, so don't follow in the shadow of someone else's (even though Amy Lee is my musical idol xD) Good luck and remember...ROCK!
SweetHaunting 3 years ago
You know, the pianist and me changed the song one week ago, because she has some problems with it.. Too hard for her=( But now we're going to perform Lithium by evanescence, the acoustic version. And perhaps even with cello and guitar, the whole mess=P Yeah, I love Amy Lee too:):) Her voice is just so.. I can't explain it. Her vocal range is just... incredible! And not to mention the way she plays the piano.. AMAZING!! I'm stunned with her talent:)
hcyjtd4x 3 years ago
-to hcyjtd4x- well good luck, im pretty sure you'll do more than fine! like sweethaunting says, do it with your style. its what make a song beautiful! for me, songs are for everyone who live the song and can make their own with themself in it;) gives us news about it ;)
flot01 3 years ago
Well thank you:) I'll try my best not to forget and tell you about it=P You know, there are always people who film the performances, so perhaps I can put it on youtube. If so, I'll tell you okay? But it will take a while because the performance is next year=)
hcyjtd4x 3 years ago
well good luck, im pretty sure you'll do more than fine! like sweethaunting says, do it with your style. its what make a song beautiful! for me, songs are for everyone who live the song and can make their own with themself in it;) gives us news about it ;)
flot01 3 years ago
Here's some news about it,, I just did audition with my pianiste (lithium, acoustic), and we made it=) there's one audition still though, but the judge told us we'll definately make it to the stage.. the whole performance will be filmed, so we'll do our best and place it on youtube so you can watch it then;)
hcyjtd4x 3 years ago
I'm so happy for you!!! and sure I want to see this! Well, just another one to pass and you'll be great, I'm pretty sure! Like the first time, I wait news about it :P and I wait the video, until then, see yah and break a leg! ;)
flot01 3 years ago
Break a leg??????
Is it an expression? 'Cause if not it's really mean... '_'
Zavedi234 3 years ago
lol yeah its an expression for the artists to say good luck
flot01 3 years ago 4
Ok, well in french we say "merde" which means something like "shit". I guess it's something of that kind...
Zavedi234 3 years ago 2
i know, im french too ^^ well from Qc
flot01 3 years ago
Oh, moi aussi! Tu vis où (ville)?
Oh, me too! In which city do you live?
Zavedi234 3 years ago
st-basile-le-grand, proche de longueuil, qui est proche de montreal... sa sonne trou perdu mais ce lest pas tant que sa XD toi?
flot01 3 years ago
Bah, chez ma mère je vis à Saint-François, laval pis chez mon père à Bois-Des-Filion (sur la rive-nord)
Zavedi234 3 years ago
st-francois (de laval?), je crois que je connais
flot01 3 years ago
C'est vraiment énervant de voir des gens thumbed pour parler une autre langue. Les gens ont besoin de grandir.
It's really irritating to see people thumbed down for speaking another language. People need to grow up.
catdemonninja 2 years ago 2
I think it's really cool you speak another language. I myself am learning to speak French.
Citykitty2000 2 years ago
Actually, I used google translator....
catdemonninja 2 years ago
oh, lol
Citykitty2000 2 years ago
Yes, 'Break a leg' is an expression used by theatrical performers =) It means 'good luck.' They don't say 'good luck' because at one point they told a guy 'good luck' and he broke his leg, thusly theatrical superstition.
AiChiHitokiriSan 2 years ago 4
my mom was watching a play when she was in school and during one of the fight scenes, she broke a pencil and one of the actors that were "fighting" cried out.
catdemonninja 2 years ago
Hi, I promised again I would let you know how it all went.. I had the second audition yesterday, and we made it again, everyone loved us!!=) So we're going to perform somewhere in june.. I'll let you know when it is that far..
hcyjtd4x 2 years ago
nice i knew it!!! keep it on! we're all with you, and i can't wait to june :D
flot01 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
nose, I meant nose. lol
petitanyell 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
She sings well, but sometimes she sings through her noise...
petitanyell 3 years ago
it makes her sound like a violin<3 i think she does it such a way that she can pull it off. it's beautiful
XmusicmeisterX 3 years ago 10
I wanna play piano like her sooo bad
chumchum222 3 years ago 8
i always wanted to sing like her
silverwolfb1990 3 years ago 42
why cant we just listen to the song and shudup about all the harsh non harsh and achohol!
debutant1996 3 years ago 9
THANK YOU!
noobofrnc95 3 years ago
Excuse me?
I think you read my comments wrong, I wasn't on about you in particular, I was saying it in general.
Moreover, who do you think you are swearing at me?
Seriously get over yourself.
consumedbypink 3 years ago 6
you tell him man
GoblinJumperCables 3 years ago
How many people end up divorced a year... and split apart? Can you people stop talking about their personal lives.. all i know is that Amy sounds awesome and this is a great song.
lucianafoti 3 years ago
Ooh I was actually going to ask if anyone knew who the "Wolf" in the video was, but you have it right there in your awesome vid. description! Thanks a ton for all your video uploads <3
Sinsthe2nd 3 years ago
I really don't understand why is this such a big deal. It's just a good song. What they did is none of your busyness. So maybe you should all shut the hell up... I mean you are all like bunch of fucking kids... all you can do is talk shit about people. Get a fucking life
ironsiim 3 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
And haven't you noticed that ever since Ben left her sorry ass, that all she can write about is Shaun? that's hilarious. Maybe it's because I'm not depressed anymore, but idk... something's up. She has no lyrical talent, all she writes about is bleeding and praying and dying... honestly, I've heard it all a million times. So let's give her a REAL challenge and have her write about something HAPPY for once. cause there's what, like one or two HAPPY evanescence songs?
Bikinikilled98 3 years ago
Good enough. That's happy, and it's about Josh Hartzler. All That I'm Living for is about her career. Lithium is about how she's writing for her career. Like You is about her sister. Lacrymosa is about the chronicals of Narnia. Snow White Queen is about someone with a control complex. Weight of the world is about her pproblems feeling heavy on her. None of those relate to shaun morgan. You have no proof backing your argument. And she didn't write tournaquet. Rocky did.
catdemonninja 3 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
EXACTLY MY POINT. Amy Lee fucked Shaun and used the shit out of him and rode him to the top. Broken was way more popular than any Evanescence song. She was the one who convinced Shaun to record it as a duet! I don't personally know either of them, but I stand by Shaun, because even if he HAD a drinking problem, he never publicly bashed somebody or trashed their reputation for fame. It may seem like it, but he didn't even write anything about her on their new album. He took the high road here.
Bikinikilled98 3 years ago
Dude.
Chillax.
It's not a big deal. If need to vent, vent where people agree with you and support you. Does it really make you feel better when you're angry (although I don't see why you are) and you need to get that anger out, and then people flame you because you make THEM angry? It's a vicious circle, and you're being immature.
oscarthefattycat 3 years ago
Um, just because music is "therapy" for you Amy, doesn't mean you get to go and make songs that trash somebody else or a past relationship and release it to the world.
What releasing this song tells me is "Nah nah nah nah nah Shaun, now everybody knows why we broke up and how you're a drunk".
Unless releasing that song was "therapy" too.
She could've just wrote the song to express herself and be done with it. There was no need to put it on album, that was just immature.
ffionluvstina 3 years ago
Yeah but it is her fault that she brought it out into the public. And also, the last song I'm wasting on you is OBVIOUSLY a break up song. idiot.
Bikinikilled98 3 years ago
Actually, that song was just a joke about Ben. It had absolutely nothing to do with Shaun Morgan.
oscarthefattycat 3 years ago 2
you can't just call someone an idiot because they proved you wrong. The last song I'm wasting on you is about how she's past all the problems ben caused her and how she's not going to lose herself just to make money in the music buisness.
And even if it /were/ a break-up song, that's only two out of thirteen. As far as I can tell, that's not all, it's not even a fourth.
catdemonninja 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I used to be a huge Evanescence fan, they were totally my favorite band. But when they released The Open Door I totally lost respect for her. She publicly bashed and trashed on Shaun Morgan. She brought his addiction out into the public and I think that was so immature and so uncalled for. She turned into some stereotypical stick figure chick who only sings about break ups. She has a lot of talent, it's just too bad that she's a bitch. I can't even listen to Evanescence anymore.
Bikinikilled98 3 years ago
I understand what you are saying...but maybe..oh, i don't know...SHAUN MORGAN WAS A BASTARD! That song is obviously about her being abused by a certain singer, and she needed to let it all out. It was her way of coping. I understand that more than your ignorant comment. She needed closure, and in her heart a song was the way to go and say how much she regrets dating that man. She also didn't only sing about a break up, she sang about her not taking any shit from anyone, like always. GO AMY!
Lacerated16 3 years ago
Lacerated16
Okay, all he did was drink. And if he did more, I'm sure she would put it in there.
And I understand that she needed to express herself, but was it really necessary to put it out to the world?
You all act like Shaun actually physically abused her~ beat her up and kicked her around.
But no. All he did was drink. Woah.
I've been through WAYY worse situations, and you don't see me running around saying "oh em gee, so and so did this to me, aren't they a dick?!"
ffionluvstina 3 years ago
Obviously you haven't been around an alcoholic. It ruins people's lives, not just relationships hun.
x
consumedbypink 3 years ago
uhm, okay?
what does that have to do with anything?
My point is Amy Lee was very immature when she wrote this song. She shouldn't have had the right to degrade Shaun as a slobbering drunk. Really, what did Shaun do to her? Nothing, he just drank. Amy didn't like that, so she broke up with him.
I never said it didn't ruin people's lives..
frenzicffion 3 years ago
Well, firstly you came out with "all he did was drink."
Yes it could have been worse, however, my point being that watching someone you care about, turn into an alcoholic, not only destroys their life, it destroys whomever is involved with that person.
consumedbypink 3 years ago
As for calling Amy Lee immature, she wrote it as a sort of therapy to help her get over it. As you can tell, she wears her heart on her sleeve and it takes a strong person to admit to feelings. So for calling her immature, that is something you obviously do not understand.
consumedbypink 3 years ago
Yes, she wrote the song as therapy. But was it appropriate for her to just air it all over the world? She knew it would hurt Shaun. It was probably intentional to hurt Shaun, seeming she was so angry.
Plus, just listen to the lyrics. There's so much hatred over a drinking problem. God, why did she write such hateful lyrics anyways? IT WAS A DRINKING PROBLEM. She made it sound like he would beat her every night. And let's not forget Shaun DID go to rehab two or three years ago :)
frenzicffion 3 years ago
Of course she wanted to hurt Shaun, she wanted him to wake up and realise what he was doing to himself. She probably hoped he'd hear the song and remember who he was before he had a drinking problem.
Drinking is just as bad as drugs. Just because he's not sniffing it, doesn't mean it's not dangerous. He was slowly killing himself mate.
Plus, they're famous mate, it's going to get out whether they wanted it or not. x
consumedbypink 3 years ago
lol, I don't think making him wake up and helping him was her intentions.
besides, HE WENT INTO REHAB.
and again, amy was the one who let the world know why they broke up. Everybody makes mistakes, and I feel really sorry for Shaun. They did have good things in the relationship and shaun used to be really in love with her. I do feel sorry for amy that she had to deal with her boyfriend bein an alcoholic, but I'm even more sorry for Shaun that she did all of that shit and aired their---
frenzicffion 3 years ago
You can't know that for sure.
Yeh he did go to rehab, but perhaps Amy wanted him to know how much she was hurting.
And if he loved her, wouldn't he have listened to her in the first place?
x
consumedbypink 3 years ago
dirty laundry to the world. Sure, Shaun wasn't the perfect boyfriend, he had some problems, but he did love her. isn't that what really matters? Obviously amy didn't love him unconditionally, hence she put that song out into the world. So, Amy obviously wasn't the perfect girlfriend either.
Oh, and there are plenty of people out there who aren't celeberities that can find something else to do as therapy. She really didn't need to write that song, that was unnecessary.
frenzicffion 3 years ago
Lol. Of course they're not perfect. No one is. I never claimed Amy was, I never claimed Shaun was either.
She even told magazines that she wrote as therapy, so perhaps it was necessary to her?
x
consumedbypink 3 years ago
It's an addiction. ADDICTION.
ADDICTION
ADDICTION
ADDICTION
ADDICTION
It's not that easy.
Oh, and if amy did love him, then wouldn't she help him? Make him go to rehab so he doesn't get really sick, or possibly die?
Obviously not, since she dumped him and wrote that song, then shoved it in his face and informed the world of the bad things that went on in the relationship.
(:
frenzicffion 3 years ago
Yes, I know what an addiction is, I'm not ignorant.
I know it's not easy. Having had one myself.
Amy probably did love him, but just couldn't take anymore, watching him like that. So she ended it, hoping he'd see sense, which is good, because when she released that song, he went to rehab.
She didn't inform the world of everything bad din the relationship, she just said choose addiction or me.
x
consumedbypink 3 years ago
lol, sorry I'm not trying to be an asshole but when she said "choose addiction or me" is making me laugh.
First off, ADDICTION. He was ADDICTED to drinking, and you don't just quit it and run off with the one you love. It takes time.
Now she could've helped him, but no.
If I were amy, I would've said you're going to rehab and you're going to like it.
I wouldn't even be thinking about the strength of our relationship, but more of Shaun's health.
frenzicffion 3 years ago
That's the thing sweetie, we're not Amy or Shaun.
... we don't know what happened between them at all.
Yes I would have done the same sweet, i'm not saying you're wrong at all.
consumedbypink 3 years ago
yup, you're right there. We don't know them, so we probably shouldn't talk about this anymore.
But still.. it was really pissy of her to write and release that song to the world, therapy or not.
frenzicffion 3 years ago
Perhaps it was, but if it was written about some other guy who wasn't famous, would it still be harsh?
x
consumedbypink 3 years ago
In a way it wouldn't be as harsh, and in a way it would be way more harsh.
The way that it wouldn't be as harsh is that the guy isn't famous, so nobody know who he is.
But the way it would be way more harsh is that the guy isn't famous. Shaun is more used "negative publicity" or whatever. He's more used to getting insults from strangers and other artists probably. If I was dating a guy who was famous, and we broke up then he wrote a song about how much I suck I would freak out, lol
frenzicffion 3 years ago
LOL. I know what you mean.
But if you/that person was a cunt, then you'd like the fact that you've pissed an ex off. You'd like the attention.
consumedbypink 3 years ago
Yeeh, but if you easily listen to gossip without hearing facts, then you're not much of a person are you?
So people whom assume Amy-Lee is innocent and Shaun is a prick, obviously are ignorant wankers, who need to look at themselves and get a life, because again we don't know them; relationships are a two way thing, not one way and they're human; no one is perfect.
Same goes whom think Amy is a bitch and Shaun is innocent.
consumedbypink 3 years ago
wtf. oh wow.
For one, I didn't hear it from gossip I heard it from facts. I've been looking into interviews from both shaun and amy.
And dude, I never said that shaun was innocent, did you not read what i fucking told you? I said that yeah, shaun did have some problems and he was a drinker, but amy shouldn't have wrote that song.
So maybe you should look into the factss (:
just putting it out there.
frenzicffion 3 years ago
when did she say that in the song?
ashesofher 3 years ago
Moreover, we are both not involved in Amy's personal life, therefore there are things that probably happened in that relationship that we will never know about.
Plus, there are assumptions about the song, that obviously Amy hasn't denied, but you can't blame her, it's none of our business.
Hope you understand.
x
consumedbypink 3 years ago
And she wrote those songs about ben too.
"Oh, i'm mad at this guy. I think I'm going to write pissy songs about them and tell the world so I can get back at them"
Amy really needs to learn to just forget about things and move on.
She needs to just say, whatever
and FORGET about it.
It's not healthy to keep writing all these hateful songs.
frenzicffion 3 years ago
do you not understand the meaning of therapy?
It can help other millions of people going through the same thing all over the word, learn how to express their anger without resorting to violence.
Theree is nothing better than to just scream out a song, better than to do that, then become so bitter.
Her songwriting is her release.
x
consumedbypink 3 years ago
catdemonninja 3 years ago
Sweet Sacrifice is kind of a break up song, but i'm pretty sure it's mostly about letting bad things of the past go and forgetting about them and leaving behind.
I saw it in an interview a couple of months ago.
ffionluvstina 3 years ago 2
can you imagine the feeling when you have a relationship and your lover is always so busy working that he is always in a bad mood when you talk to him, and you finally decide to end the relationship and you can't because he's not there for you and you have to call his manager (!) and say that you wanna stop? he really used her, but that's my opinion.
LooLyeaH 3 years ago
lol, are you for real? I think Amy Lee was pretty busy too, considering that she is in a band.
And how do you know that it ended that way?
And how do you know that he was always in a bad mood?
And how do you know EVERYTHING about their relationship?
Oh, and it's really funny how you say that HE used her. I don't think he used her at all, but the bitch sure did deal with her emotions in an immature way. Just airing out their dirty laundry, as Shaun Morgan said, & let the song out public
ffionluvstina 3 years ago
Oh, and you did know that Amy Lee got a lot of fame because of the song she worked on with Seether, that was written by Seether?
Broken, Seether FEATURING Amy Lee, but everybody thinks it is Amy Lee's song.
I've even seen people post the music video and title it as "Broken, Amy Lee Featuring Seether"
-_-
"he really used her", hm?
ffionluvstina 3 years ago
that's the fans putting it that way. Not Amy putting it that way.
catdemonninja 3 years ago
Me too. I still like Evanescence, but I've lost my respect for Amy Lee. There was no need to publicly bash Shaun Morgan. If she really needed to express herself that much, then just write the song and don't release it. But I've already said what I had to say on my comment I just wrote :)
ffionluvstina 3 years ago
ffionluvstina, if someone broke my heart bad enough, I'd write a song about it. It's Amy's therapy.
You could say she didn't take the high road, but what happened to 'freedom of speech'?
Another thing, when you become a celebrity your business becomes everyone else's anyway.
If she'd written this same song for another nameless non famous guy, I bet no one would have made a fuss. They would have just gone, "Good for her."
EternalDreamspace 3 years ago
Bikinikilled98, stop pretending you knew about their relationship. Maybe Amy was a bitch and hard to live with, maybe Shuan was an asshole who drank to much, maybe they beat each other up....YOU don't know and you will never know, so why don't you enjoy both groups wonderful music and stop worrying about their personal lives.
EternalDreamspace 3 years ago 2
I want that stupid pic...where on earth did you get it from????....ive been googeling a time for it!!!
Augenzeugen 4 years ago
I have it in the open door album paket thing that comes with the cd, with the lyrics and pictures.
irishbitch29 4 years ago
i appreciate the extra info you posted ...nice job its realy interesting
liamoshoro 4 years ago 2
i lik the song but why only one picture? so i give this a 4 out of 5.
pringlelicous22 4 years ago 2
dat pic is so hot!
i love dat pic!
werd u get it?
filomunchkin 4 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
BITCH... SHAUN MORGAN ROCKS!
saronfuck 4 years ago
can't give a thumbs down... so i'm replying to saronfuck with this....
;(x 150= you dying repeatedly from blunt trauma to the head with alot of minuses
leminausa4 4 years ago 3
It's not her fault he ended up addicted to an unknown substance. It's not her fault she had to let it out.
catdemonninja 3 years ago
where did you find that picture????
SmokinAce 4 years ago 2
awsome voice
MontseWentz 4 years ago 8
amy lee is hot.,i like this acoustic version though..........,evanescence rocks!!!!
2487290 4 years ago
Great song ... thanks for uploading the acoustic version
6KillerpilzeFan9 4 years ago 3
Pretty. =)
evanescencelvr07 4 years ago 3
weird it doesnt even sound much like amy lee lol
spongebbob 4 years ago
You're right about that, at first It sounds a little different but if you keep listening you can obviously tell it's definitely her voice.
Sinsthe2nd 3 years ago
i love it! i love both versions but this is really good.
irishbitch29 4 years ago 2