Added: 5 years ago
From: mtriplea
Views: 173,699
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (448)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • every year man, every year!

  • I do applaud you for attempting such a complicated song. Trust me, it's amazing that you were able to perform it so well. However, there is a huge control issue on your part. For the sections that are more complicated, you rush a LOT. I've been playing for 7 years so I know what it feels like to just want to get a section over with! Get a steady tempo that you can nail for the whole song. I usually play this at 113 bpm.  Slow it down, add dynamics, & have a load of fun with this piece:)

  • Great job on them 88"s man!

  • woow you're amazing!!!!

    where did u find the sheet music?

  • that was amazing can you teach me how to do that

  • I hate / admire you all, I would so love to be able to play, very well done, very well played, and I love the sound off your piano

  • Misshapes in keys here and there, still for a song that switches up like that not to bad.

    Keep at it and you'll be able to nail each and every key dead on.

  • cool man you or so good player

  • Liked your little comical quote "...or attempting to perform this..."

  • the part at 2:23 seems a tad rushed, but other than that 5*

  • totally agree it was very fast ...But an amazing preformance no doubt !! :D

  • Very nice job man, one of my favorite songs...and I absolutely love this arragement of it. Check mine out if you get the chance...there's a couple minor slips, but all and all it's pretty decent for my first upload...lol

  • great playing

  • Awesome man

  • this is pretty good

  • omgz lol great!!! i play piano but i cant do it that great!!!

  • Nice job man. Check mine out. I have a few more little mistakes in mine though.

  • This was very worthy to post on the net. You don't give yourself enough credit. Tempo did rush a bit but it still sounded great. Good work!

  • very impressive cover of an intensive arrangment...thank you for posting!

  • Outstanding

  • that was pretty legit. just listened to the actual song. almost dead on. very impressive.

  • Uh Yea.....ok!

  • ive be like addicted to the piano and learning songs i just learned how to play it and ive got like 5 songs down

  • Amazing and beautiful...

    the increases in tempo make it more exciting.

    good job...

  • cute and able to play very well.. ;) impressive :)

  • cool job!

  • Not bad... i am currently learning this song. it's a pain to learn the right hand and left hand together. but overall not a very challenging piece in my opinion.

    nicely done.

  • I know firsthand how difficult George Winston can be to play, especially this piece, and " not too shabby" ugh, it was AMAZING! Not perfect, but still, considering the difficulty of this song.. VERY VERY nice work.

  • Absolutely, incredibly, awesomely amazing!!!!! What astoundingly beautiful music. You have a great gift.

  • That was good.

  • in april? haha thats cool

  • Nice work!

    Sounds great! * * * * *

  • lol the piano looks ancient bro. haaha but nice job

  • Wow... Excellent! Phenomenal job!

    Tempo does slow and speed, but tis all good. Sounds great for a "attempt"

    Also, JC what piano is that? Looks oldish, but still not?

    5*

  • Just a few keys off, but overall splendid work!

  • wow, nice work!

  • WOW!!! sounds just like george winston!!! (my favorit part is at 57 seconds through 1 min) great job

  • yeah, that is my fav part too :)

  • HOLY S**T! THATS AWESOME

  • Pretty good "attempt".

  • awesome

    i am trying to play it in the moment xD

  • pretty damn good!!!

  • Amazing job. <33

  • i love this song, and you play it so well! great job!

  • my favorite part is at 1:46

  • oh wow this is soo amazing...your hands were moving so gently but the music was coming out so vibrant and fast...two thumbs up man, you did a really good job on this~8]

  • dude this is totally awesome! i wished i played as good as you! good job!

  • not worthy? whatever dude rock on!

  • This is very exceptional work.

    Please, i would like to hear more,.

  • can you teach me plz? lol

  • amazing as heck!!!

  • you said you blame the dynamics mistakes partly on the piano, I blame all my mistakes on the piano, poor thing. Very nice playing! Merry Christmas:)

  • yeahh, can you please tell me where you got the sheet music for this? sounds great dude.

  • Toca q te cagas!! y esta canción no es facil... bien hecho!!

  • dude. i always ask my music teach to print stuff out for me and she does. like this one and claire de lune. so nice. and you messed up

  • oooohhh :D :D :D good job!! this is soooo pretty! =]

  • Sweet!

    Check out my duel guitar performence of this song on my page!

  • thats really good, but the staggered melody in the middle was to fast in my opinion, otherwise really good

  • i think thats my cusion!

  • soooooooo beautifulllllll!!!!!!

  • only if i could find the sheet music...

  • That little piano's got amazing tone!

    ...you were good too... ;)

  • Fantastic! what a performance! when is your next concert?

    Keep the music flowing! you've got magic!

    Peace and Happiness to you!

    NB:great recording too!

    my hat to you!

  • Beautiful arrangement

  • this is so beautiful!

  • man this is VERY good...i could never pull this off! hahaha!

  • that was very good!

  • Yea, I got sick of my "easy key" and very poor dynamics piano, so i sold it and used it to pay for part of a yamaha cp33... it sounds amazing and feels WAYYYYY better than the old acoustic i had. Good job, I'm playing this song for my church on Christmas.

  • it's GOOD, but i wish there was a vid on youtube with the original carol of the bells(non vocal/and non trans siberian crew)..

    alas, i cannot find a SINGLE official, non AMV, ro performance, thats not trans siberian

    theirs is good, but shouldnt take over the song....

    i grew up with many versions...

    ...if only there was an instrumental, even..but nope, trans siberian orchestra took over youtube to the extent there

    s none..

    ppl tell me that even things like limewire are only TSO :(

  • u need to make the higher notes(melody) louder at the beging

  • That was really good!

  • ahhh! wonderful.

  • then just google carol of the bells music sheet for _____ (the instrument you play)

  • Wow, I could never play anything like this. 10/10. Awesome!

  • very nice. 10/5

  • pretty good bravo

  • Very well done! Great tonal quality, you're poised and confident.  NOT an easy arrangement to master.

  • never heard this arrangment before. very nice.

  • amazing

  • great for u

  • that is cool!

  • That was great! I might be wrong but the piano sounds a little off...

    Great job though

  • awesome, we have too play this at my school orchestra, it's really easy on cello

  • AMAZING PERFORMANCE!!!!!!!

  • great !

  • r u kidding me? this is beautiful!

  • holy shit your good

  • thats pretty cool!

  • I grew up listening to this version! Thanks so much for playing it! Now I have a song to learn before christmas ^_^

  • OH. MY. GOSH.

    you play this SO beautifully!!!!!!!!!!!

    :')

    Do you think you could do a tutorial? PRETTY PLEASE? I cant read music I play by sight and would LOVE to learn this beautiful song...please? :)

  • lol you commented this same thing on another videoo(:

    lol

  • yeah I did, because you all play it so beautifully, and I wanted to get the request for a tutorial out there incase a few of you didnt want to make them, maybe one of you would! :)

  • It would be so much easier to simply learn how to sight read. It's not a difficult task.

  • hey that's good. I like this version... where did you get the sheet music??

  • I love how you say "attempting to". Don't worry! you did really good!!!

  • You're very good! I could barely tell the difference! Good luck!

  • Gracious. I am going to marry a man like you someday and he is going to sit at the piano all day and play me this song. :] This is fabulous! Have confidence!

  • great playing! i'm learning this piece right now and I hope to play it as good as you have!

  • Please understand how difficult and wonderful George Winston is. Thank you for showing us.

  • BRAVO. I know and love this song. You did it justice.

  • idk if it was him or just the way the piano sounded but out of all the versions ive heard this is my favorite

  • this is deff worthy of the net! Have some confidence...that was GREAT! I have been playing for 8 years...and I loved it.

  • A couple of flated notes, but other than that it was very good.

  • hey good job! im working on this piece myself!! i love the way you play it not counting the crappy piano :o). ur cute too!! =]

  • an few clipped notes and tempo isn't always consistant.. but not bad at all.. kudos

  • wow. I love this arrangement, and now i can see how truly difficult it is! awesome job! i hope one day i'll be able to play that!

  • well you are much better then me. I am just staring it and I am stuck at Marry Marry Marry Christmas when it gets fast I freesLOL

  • Hey, great job ! I just got the scores yesterday myself, it isn't that overly hard to play,but the sound obviously is just great.

    Dude, get a better piano that fits your level of playing, really cool! :-)

  • Nice performance.

  • It is good.

  • O.K. spider fingers....you are awesome!

  • i did a ballet routine to this song for my recital this year! if anyone is interested check it out at kaleighhx33. make sure to leave comments! (:

  • that was so magnificent

  • can you show me how to do that it was AWSOME!

  • does anyone have sheet music for this?

  • wow, you are amazing.

    i love this song and just got the sheet music for it, and it is way too difficult for me.

    i envy your skills. haha

  • well you know, everyone can do so! you just have to work on it for a while...

  • Niiiice

  • Esto fue muy bueno.

  • chinga tu madre puto !!

  • wow thats good

  • Excellent presentation!

  • Amazing, I thought that was great.

  • Wow, good job, I luv...it .... and I like how you say "attempt to"... well you 'attempted' very nicely ....great job ... ^_^

  • From one musician to another I give you 4 stars for this performance. Just a few mistakes that do not matter in the long run. Great job.

  • awsome dude you are great i love this song ! i play the clarinet i am totally lookin for this song . can play some of it !!!!!!!!!!!!!! u rock dude

  • i love this music !! can somebody tell me the name of the sheet music please ?

  • hey . that´s cool (= I really enjoyed it (=

  • Hey, you did prety good with this peace I'm impressed how old are you? This is my favorite peace to play to and i love love love Gorege, the thing that made it easyer for me is try to practice with a metranome, and once you have allready woried about memorization just work on a few transitiond. Good job hope to hear this agin:)

  • wow nice

    i never played da piano but i actually tried playing dis song lols

    but ur really good

  • Ding! Fries are done.

    Lol

    Nice touch, and better sound. Congratulations.

  • The piano has a fantastic sound. It also sounds to be in tune, which is certainly a plus. I really like how you play this rendition.

  • hott.

  • Nice job, enjoyed watching you play. Your piano has a nice sound quality.

  • does anyone know where to get the sheets? .___. wanna try to play it... but i only know to play the beginning...

  • This is great this arrangement i hav it on my fone but i dont no where 2 get the music!! HELP?? =]

    PS really well played =]

  • very minor mistakes :) You did very well dude! Liked it!

  • As a huge GW fan, I must say...you are very worthy. Terrific work my friend!

  • I like how George Winston changes the melody enough to where its new but not overdone, and still recognizable... to me it takes a great master to be able to do that... you made a few mistakes but thats understandable taking into consideration the caliber of the arrangment, overall you did very well... great job...

  • You play really well! Thanks

  • do you know if there is sheet music for tamarack pines from the album forest?? thanks

  • refreshing music

  • Sweet.

  • Thats the same piano I have lol

  • dude ... u rock! It was superb! keep it up!

  • OH MY GOODNESS!!! THAT IS SO GOOD! i kinda have a really wierd request. i kinda play the piano too, just what people teach me. like fur elise, titanic,only hope, phantom of the opera etc. so i was wondering if you could maybe post somthing of you playing and kinda teaching it as you go, its looks pretty simple once you break it down. and just have the camera so i could see the keys good. wow that would be sooo awesome i want to learn how to play it so bad! thanks!

  • Love G. Winston.

    Hate the fact that I told my dad that I din NOT want to learn how to play the piano.

    Great rendition!

  • The work of the right hand is really good, but the work of the left...Could be interesting to add something with it...The using of the bass notes would be nice

  • Nice

  • very worthy of being posted on the net.

    beautiful.

    love this song.

  • thats the same piano i have in my house

  • i cant even play 5 keys without messing up

    i dont play any instruments

  • so beautiful ~*~ very very lovely ~*~ impressive without sheet musik.

  • Great job!!

  • Wow, thats really good. George Winston rocks

  • I liked it. There were a few noticeable errors though but overall it was really good.

    I wouldn't have enough concentration to keep the left hand at that beat while the right hand went that fast, lol. Great job! =]]

  • please tell me where did you get the sheet music???

  • In a sheet music store

  • haha word.

  • u can find it in the book "George Winston Piano Solos"

  • without sheets u rock

  • wow that was interesting, what key was that in?

  • i got my sheet music from the TSO site

  • oh i love this its my favorite carol...

  • I HAVE FOUND SHEET MUSIC! i'm practising right now!

  • where where where!?!?!?!? PLEASE tell me where u found the sheet music!!!!! i need to learn this song by Christmas...

  • aw you're so diffident! that was good.

  • thats so good i wish i could play like that

  • Rabbit*

  • OMG! ur making me cry too. i love that story... T_T

  • I always cry when I hear this song because it reminds me of The Velveteen Rabbi.... this was beautiful thought

  • That is so amazing this is my favorite christmas song i don't know why it is but it is

  • please please please say u have the sheet music!!!

  • That's my favorite song of the holidays... it's so gripping.

  • nice