Will the Doctor's Daughter Come Back? - Matt Smith Answers Fan Question at Comic-Con 2011

[GallifreyanWho]

I Think She Can't Come Cause I Don't Like Him She Married David..

[TheEcoolarg]

SPOILERS

o__o eh... so...eh... im confuse....and sounds kinda incentuos the fact the doctor has a grand daughter that disappear in the thin air, and you know the rule of doctor who, if they dont show the death without regeneration is posible the character could come back...OMG SUSAN is maddam covariant D: Amy just kill her grand daughter(to be fair they are even xD...shit this its a mess)

[ENindustries]

press 1 for kirby!

[Proserpina98]

complicated :D 

[BadWolfRT]

lol, karen's look at the end like what did i miss...

[summerskyfilms]

@nytephoenix25 And get this...their sons name is "TYLER" theyre trolling. I know it.

[Shivierie]

I love this video simply cuz Matt Smith keeps bringing up the fact that Georgia Moffet married David Tennant XD

[LegalVampire]

"Where is he? (Steven Moffat)"

"Sherlock, that's where he is"

AW YEAHH.

[zeva1001]

i love how if you listin closely after steven mofatt is menchen some one also menches sherlock! oh the glory of british television:)

[loveyshadowcat]

the doctor married river song then some army facility from the future cloned a girl version of him when he went on one of his various time travels.

[loveyshadowcat]

now all i say gets messed up because the tardis crashed and mad time wibily wobbly timey whimy

[TheAfroThunder1]

Wibily-Wobbly Timey-Whimy... Incest

[cheesedoodles11]

omg... i never knew he had a daughter! HOW DOES HE HAVE A DAUGHTER... AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH

[kakapobiatch]

'where is he?' 'sherlock, that's where he is'

[stickmanpwner64]

Yo, dawg I heard you like the doctor's daughter...

So the 10th doctor, married his daughter who was in the show, who is the real life daughter of the 5th doctor.

[Arella17]

@stickmanpwner64 lol

[smarty1727374757]

i just got lost in the part when it began

[MissGracieKathy]

thank you moffat for changing the script and letting her live!!

[hossluver1994]

LOL she only survived by accident because Russel said "Oh, that ending's sad, she should live" and the writer went "Oh, okay" and added the bit at the end. xD but she should come back.

[PivotSideEffects]

Amy Pond.failed to watch the whole episode

[ImmaChiaotzu1]

@PivotSideEffects It was rubbish... Sorry people, just my opinion. Karen Gillan probably turned it off in boredom.

[heatran1919]

Just for the sake of further complicating the Doctor's family tree, they should reintroduce the Doctor's grandaughter, which would be Jenny's daughter, and would come back River Song-style. Because why the hell not?

[VampirePrincess2913]

Imagine what family reunions are like....Imagine the shadow that Olive's going to grow up in....talk about a legacy...

[DoctorWho50Years]

its another dangling strand that hasnt been picked up yet. what a shame...

[sonicsophieten]

but they arnt married yet :|

[iloveanime12341]

"Sherlock, that's where he is!" I like that fan

[igoteggigotchicken11]

Haha: i love all these comments about Jenny being the daughter of the Doctor, marrying the Doctor, and having a child with the doctor. XD I cant watch the video right now but can you guys tell me what Matt Smith answered? I'd love to have Jenny come back. They should do a series just for Jenny, like how they did the Torchwood series for Jack.

[TheMidnightwolf15]

lol

'the daleks have taken his hat'

don't worry matt, we'll get u a fez for christmas!

[imranmarshall11]

So the doctor's daughter is River Song!

[Oathkeeper42]

"A Doctor's daughter who played the Doctor's daughter and then had the Doctor's daughter."

Georgia Moffet's TV Tropes description.

[Haxcz]

@Oathkeeper42 -- INCEPTION!!

[Jings0b]

@Oathkeeper42 INCEST!

[PrettiestDemon]

Wait, wait wait... the Doctor actually has a daughter? or are they talking about Tennant's daughter..?

[simpsonman956]

@PrettiestDemon Yeah, the Doctor (in the show) has a "daughter". From what I can gather, someone at somepoint made a clone of the docter who was a woman and he considered her to be his daughter. Then his grandaughter ended up being one of the original companions of the First Doctor.

[OwlCityFan26]

Yeah I think it's funny that David married the woman playing his kid :P

[iloveyouhammie]

@OwlCityFan26 yeh but its cool cos shes buff init ;)

[OmegaII]

@OwlCityFan26 The best part is she actually is the daughter of David Tennet's favorite Doctor.

[Taylorsfan122]

@OmegaII GAHAHAHAHAHA GLORIOUS

[TennantJunkie1993]

David and Georgia are engaged, Matthew Robert Smith. Not married until New Year's Day Next year.

[TennantJunkie1993]

THAT DALEK'S NOT KILLING ANYONE! Not even Olive, when she's old enough to choose between acting and doing something else. But if she does decide to act, perhaps she wil be on Doctor Who. Who knows? Anyway, the point is No Dalek touches Jenny!

[TennantJunkie1993]

Is Jenny coming back? Just curious. Especially if it means getting connected to three more incarnations if Georgia comes back to surprise the Doctor, but save that for the 50th anniversary, shall we?

[Megazord5]

Did this kid seriously have to ask like a fucking Dalek? I really hope he was at the very least dressed in a fully functioning Dalek suit so he doesn't look completely out of his mind.

[Axartsme]

@Megazord5 Yes he was. Did you not hear Matt Smith mention the Dalek take off his head? That was the question-asker.

[StevenFYWong]

@Megazord5 Yes he was. I was there at the panel. He was wearing a Dalek suit with blinking lights for laser.

[ThreePipeProblems]

The Doctor's daughter became the daughter of the doctor, married the Doctor and had a daughter with the doctor.

[TheSkylark56]

@ThreePipeProblems ewwww inbred

[jadimorok]

@ThreePipeProblems Then who are all these zombies? (Robert Heinlein shoutout)

[MrWickeedd]

@ThreePipeProblems familie affairs :> 

[MrWezlum18]

@ThreePipeProblems So basically. . . . the Doctor is a redneck?

[TheAndroia]

@MrWezlum18 Nah! He's just 'timey wimey'. He's too cool to be redneck.

[Id334ler]

@ThreePipeProblems Paradoxes... 

[Kaagh178]

I predict that Olive Moffett (or is it MacDonald as that's David Tennant's real surname) will marry the 20th Doctor. Come on, it just HAS to happen.

[tomboytimelord007]

the doctor's daughter had a daughter... with the doctor. confused? ;)

[Shondrasu]

@tomboytimelord007 The actress that played the Doctor's daughter on the show was actually a "Daughter" of a previous actor that played the doctor(Peter Davison). Then she married "the doctor" David Tennant and they went on to have a daughter together. lol

[tomboytimelord007]

@Shondrasu Yeah I know, but i couldn't resist saying that ;)

[Megazord5]

@Shondrasu That's fucking gross! I know Genny was hot, but come on!

[LuminatedDarknessC8]

And then David's daughter will go on to play the Doctor...

[Namaechan]

@LuminatedDarknessC8 Nah, but she'll probably marry one. She has to. It's family tradition.

[LuminatedDarknessC8]

@Namaechan Or both.

[Namaechan]

@LuminatedDarknessC8 Now that'd be a twist!

[Tattypingu2]

Ok to summon it up Georgia played the doctors daughter but is now engaged to David and they had a daughter together called Olivia

[sternbergzookie]

@Tattypingu2 "A Doctor's daughter who played the Doctor's daughter and then had the Doctor's daughter," as TVTropes puts it.

[Tattypingu2]

@sternbergzookie Yes i do know ;)

[nytephoenix25]

so....

the actual daughter of the fifth doctor played the part of the tenth doctor's daughter, married the the actual tenth doctor, and had the tenth doctor's actual daughter...

[tb635]

@nytephoenix25

well that is bloody confusing isn't it..

[GeekTubee]

@nytephoenix25 PARADOX, doctor who has that effect on people

[ImmaChiaotzu1]

@nytephoenix25 Wimbly Wombly Timey Wimey...

[tokenasian1]

@nytephoenix25 DOCTORCEPTION.

[CaptainAndyman]

@nytephoenix25 It's wibbly wobbly timey wimey...

[BeardedDragonOwl]

@nytephoenix25 that makes no fucking sense lol... (sorry i just started watching doctor who...so......yeah......i got nothin.....)

[TheEmmaHouli]

@BeardedDragonOwl Don't worry, most of that has nothing to do with the actual show, the fans just get a kick out of it... how are you enjoying it thus far?

[TheYoungMariah]

@nytephoenix25 Great. Now I officially HATE my favorite episode of Doctor Who.

[MrWickeedd]

@nytephoenix25 you can say it runs in the familie :>

[diane8cupcake]

@nytephoenix25 That is brilliant in such a confusing way.

[lostsagadragon]

@diane8cupcake it wouldnt be dr who if it wasnt confusing

[pattrick208]

@nytephoenix25 yes, it's that simple.

[HungerGames75]

@nytephoenix25

Wow . . .I think I have a sore head now. . .that's so confusing.

[PoutingXEvoke]

My god the comments are so confusing! Someone please explain and dumb it down considerably?

[TheEmmaHouli]

@PoutingXEvoke I don't think any one replied, but sorry if this is like your 7th answer.

Georgia Moffat is the daughter of Peter Davison (the 5th Doctor). Georgia got the part of Jenny who was the daughter of the Doctor in a David Tennant episode. She and David (in real life) went on to fall in love, get married and then had a daughter themselves

Therefore: the Doctor's Daughter had the Doctor's Daughter

[MrByte2000]

Georgia is engaged to David.  They have a daughter together. Her son is from a previous relationship.

So, The Doctor's Daughter had a Doctor's Daughter...

[Speedythecat7]

"And then she married the doctor!"'

dont forget Matt she is the fifth Doctor daughter too lol

[omgtylorhotner]

I love the angry comments in the background!

[227060]

c'mon Moff bring back Jenny, not only is she awesome but she practially shares your name.

Also it was the Moffat's idea that Jenny should live in the first place

[TheGoydych1564]

"that's a Steven Moffat question"

"WHERE IS HE?" LoL

[EmeraldCrerci]

"That's a Steven Moffat question.."

"Where IS he?" "Sherlock, that's where he is"

HAHAHAHA I love that audience XD

[angeltears6478]

The "Doctors Daughter" is actually the daughter of Peter Davison (the fifth doctor), I find it fun that she's going to marry another Doctor.

[KendrixTermina]

Lucky Chick, got to have DTs babies! Oh, and lucky DT, got to have the hot young daugher of his childhood hero as GF.

[djwasser]

So she is the daughter of 5 and 10 and 10s wife and the doctors daughter had the doctors daughter.

[djwasser]

so wait... she's the daughter of the fifth doctor in life, then the daughter of 10 in the show and married to 11 in life?? And being the doctors wife /doctors daughter she will have the doctors child?? ??? Is that true?

[MrAaronjacques]

@djwasser she married david (10th doctor) not matt smith

[djwasser]

@MrAaronjacques yeah I know I fixed that sorry.

[Rascaduanok]

Sigh. Karen Gillan is heart–achingly beautiful! Oh wait, there was a Doctor there as well?! Can’t say I noticed, hahaha.

[OwlCityFan26]

What? That made it sound like the doctor's daughter married the doctor. Also, that dalek person actually annoys me. They think they're so clever but not really.

[Radocto]

01:05 Amy Spots Her Stalker Lol

[EdwardNJacobOtaku]

0:43

"That's a Stephen Moffat question. He's the man-"

"Where is he!?"

"Sherlock that's where he is."

XD

[Niniischill]

I couldn't hear Matt....did he say they she IS coming back? and lol that dalek is awesome!! :D

[xPsychedelicTRIPx]

he married the daughter of the fifth doctor, right? peter davison was it?

[doctorwhofangirl1]

i didnt kno the doctor had a daughter but that dalek voice was awesome but creepy

[PurplexTypo]

When I first heard of David being Engaged to Georgia I was like: Isn't that kind of incest? Haha since she did played as his Daughter in series 4. An funny that the actress is actually the daughter of the actor who played as the fifth doctor.

[jessiejanesama]

@PurplexTypo

whoa didn't know that. i learn something new everyday.

[slightlyinsaneFTW]

And then she married the Doctor!

Woo...clap...clap...awkward silence...

[starandscour]

@AmyPond174 Good god! How can you be a Doctor Who fan and not know that!

[TheBigLittleM]

I love that: Georgia Moffet was the Doctor's daughter, who portrayed the Doctor's daughter, and then gave birth to the Doctor's daughter.

[jhibbitt1]

georgia moffet married david tennant? :O lol, he dated sophia myles too, seems to be a habit of his to get it on with the guest stars, i dont blame any of them, all 3 of them are very attractive people lolol

[nurileflef1]

I think she married the Doctor... :D :D

[ecokeeffe]

Wait...after the 5th Doctor appeared in the 10th Doctor's TARDIS...the daughter of the 5th Doctor became the clone/daughter of the 10th Doctor and then the Doctor and the Doctor's Daughter got married...and now they have a daughter together?!! Now my head hurts...

[Sharon24567006264246]

Did David and Georgia know each other before that episode of WHO?

[inubaka13]

Wait, was he joking, or did the actress really marry David Tennant?

[emeseg]

@inubaka13 They're engaged to be married and had a daughter together already.

[RedCapeInc]

@emeseg no they are married i believe just recently and yes they have a daughter, olive i think

[epicmonkey96]

@emeseg So... the doctors daughter had a daughter with the doctor, and will soon be the doctor's wife? That is amazing.

[Mrdoctorwhomad]

@epicmonkey96 and the actress who plays the Doctors daughter is the actual daughter of the fifth doctor. Although you might have known that already :D

[macmcseboy]

@emeseg and she is the daughter of the 5th Doctor Peter Davison

[FutureMrsMattSmith03]

@emeseg

0_0

[MrCarbonAtom]

@emeseg

and her actual father just happens to be peter davison the fifth incarnation of the doctor. I love how the world works out!

[WannaBeANerd]

@inubaka13 The actress is engaged to Tennant.

[asdaga2]

@inubaka13 not joking

[XMizzTuraX]

@inubaka13 They are really going to get married and she already has a son he's the step dad too and then they have their new baby.

[knotbox]

@inubaka13 'Their' child is actually david's step-son.

[ashleyzbz]

@knotbox No they had a daughter together. Georgia did however have a son before she was with David.

[SuperGoliath89]

@inubaka13 She's engaged, they haven't gotten married yet though. It's funny, but that woman is just linked by destiny to the title "Doctor's Daughter." She's the daughter of one of the actors who played the Doctor, she played the Doctor's daughter in the show, and now she's given birth to the daughter of a Doctor.

[Scottishgal78]

@inubaka13 she's not married to him yet, they're just engaged just now

[xcutemoo9]

OMG I WAS THE PERSON WHO ASKED THE QUESTION ABOUT THE DOCTOR'S DAUGHTER GRRRRR CHECK OUT MY CHANNEL LOL IT'S DOCTOR WHO EVERYTHIN NEARLY :) check out my uploads, doctor who...and even more...doctor who

[Niniischill]

did he say she IS coming back? i couldnt hear

[viridismonasteriense]

It's not incest, she's a clone. A female clone. It's like marrying yourself. I don't think that's incest. More like masturbation! haha

[Pizzaboyzmvp]

Doctor + Jenny = Incest couple :D

[abiicanfly]

"where is he?!"

"Sherlock, that's where he is!"

[mrwho995]

Karen really shouldn't have to ask that question TBH. I'd expect people not knowing who aren't fans, but cast members, come on!

[79sars79]

And then she married the doctor :D and now there really is a doctors daughter, cause Georgia moffats dad played one of the earlier doctors. That makes me happy :)

[yellowpages2000]

I love Steven moffet, he writes the two best shows in the world dr who and Sherlock, love them both!!!

[kira25queenkid]

The moment of awkward silence at the very end...

[ForeverDreamable]

I mean he should be answering the questions sorry fail.

[ForeverDreamable]

Moffat and his stupid Sherlock you should be taking care of Doctor Who! Doctor Who is way more important than that stupid show and answering the Doctor Who questions!

[BetaArtemis]

@ForeverDreamable Just because you are upset that Steven Moffat isn't at the Doctor Who panel doesn't make Sherlock a stupid show. Sherlock is a wonderfully written show and a brilliantly acted show. Many writers, especially with the schedules in the UK, work on multiple shows at the same time, and while it would be nice to have him at the panel, he is not required to be there. It does not make Doctor Who more important than Sherlock and it's not the end of the world if he isn't at Comic Con.

[EGPicturesStudios]

I was in line to ask but too late. Too many people in the Q&A line.

[Jenner005]

I asked that question!! I was the silver dalek!

[emeseg]

@Jenner005 Awesome costume dude

[inubaka13]

@Jenner005 I never saw you T_T Just on the "Ask a Whovian" specials on tv.

[ljoneill97]

@Jenner005 i fucking love u man! ur a genius

[DyingxToxLivexAgain]

And then she married the Doctor :D

INCEST iS WINCEST, CHILDREN.

<3Tennant

[wrengard]

@DyingxToxLivexAgain LOOOOOOL!! i think its sweet they is getting married!!!

[Ewoke6096]

@DyingxToxLivexAgain The first word that child says has to be either 'Allonsy' or 'Well'! just like David!

[jfrizzlle]

"sherlock, THAT'S where he is"