This is bringing 70's music to the "young uns" I say thanks Sheryl. Check out Chilli Peppers "Brandy" and the Foo Fighters with John Paul Jones and Jimmy Page. Also the Fighters with Alex Lifeson & Geddy Lee. I have over 5000 vinyl albums & singles...so....what do you need to know. Smile.
Who cares what people think, Sheryl? The song grooves like magic. Talk is cheap because supply exceeds demand. I am a pro drummer and I'd be honored to play with you anywhere, anytime!
I loved it. I'm old and saw Joe W. several times, with the Gang and the Eagles. They and he were great. So is Sheryl. I like all her stuff, cover or not.
Nice rendition. Had "James Gang: Thirds" when I was a teen. There may be haters out there, but c'mon, who is going to expose the next generation to this music unless SOMEBODY covers it? Sheryl keeps the flame burning with some really beautiful choices.
I'm a big James Gang / Joe Walsh fan. My fav. thing about Eagles concerts is always the Joe Walsh break where he usually does Walk Away, '49 and Midnight man along with a solo or two. Seeing Sheryl do this is fine too. Watch again and watch the youngsters in the audiance bouncing. Anything that spreads the faith is food with me.
Bravo, Bravo Sheryl and that comes from a BIG TIME JAMES GANG FAN, almost 40 years of Fan love for the Gang and my idol.....rip, TOMMY BOLIN ! Yes, I know joe plays guitar on that tune but I love Tommy, he's my hero. Anyway....great job sweetheart.
excellent version, one that joe walsh would definitely approve of. and the original is pretty laid back, actually, other than joe's voice straining because it's out of his range.
Hey, Lay off of Sheryl, She is not the greatest singer of all time but she trys and has a few really good songs.Plus doing a cover of a rock legend, Joe Walsh. He is in the top 100 greatest guitarist s list no matter what the Rolling Idiot magazine says.Joan Jett is on the list And she would not make pimple on Joes butt.
Awesome! Two thumbs up! Five stars (out of five)! Thank you, Sheryl from all of us cover band musicians who play tunes like this until the cows come home (or the bar empties out at 4 am)... I know Joe Walsh would kiss your boots after hearing this! Slainte!
@wobrien007 I couldn't agree more - oh wait a minute yes I could !! I have always thought a female voice is better suited to rock than a male voice particularly when there are very high notes !! Some male singers can no longer get to them !!
Someone else with a great voice for hard rock is Ann Wilson of Heart try her versions of Zeppelin songs
I always wanted to hear Zepp with a female voice - She obliged !!
@peteelliedaisy What is truly odd is the number of male rock singers who insist in trying to sing above their natural range - We need women in rock to sing the high notes that men have in their heads but can't always deliver. Robert plant can't scream soprano like he used to - Ann Wilson ( Heart) no problem.
Search Youtube for Heart versions of Zepp - You will be surprised. !! ( honest )
there is nothing wrong with this performance. If I was to critique it would be the drumming. The drummer is great, no doubt about it, but I would have included the explosive drum fills Jim Fox does on his live perfomances. It really adds alot. I think this drummer played it pretty clean, which is fine, but I think the fills add so much to the song. That is just my opinion though.
They come pretty dang close to capturing the spirit of the original - nice job. Nobody is going to match the gravitas of Joe Walsh and the fantastic original drummer of the James Gang.
Negative comments? I'm glad I missed them. come on she's not Joe Walsh, and isn't trying to be. If you've never played this song maybe you could miss how much fun and energy the whole band is putting into this performance. By the way she's doing this in A. get out a bass and play along you'll be hooked. If you don't like it just WALK AWAY!
Sorry, but every version on here by Joe Walsh is terrible! Especially the one with the Eagles in 1977. Some of the James Gang's versions are OK, except for Joe's playing and singing! I know that musicians don't want to play carbon copies of their hits, but in my opinion, if you can't IMPROVE it, then stick with the original arrangement. I do think that Ms. Crow could've put a little more passion in her vocals, but her band just smokes, especially the classic ending......
Sheryl Crow is so talented, plays piano, guitar, and bass on this video even, sings and is a music coach and teacher. She rocks, good job on the video. Great tune.
In defense of Sheryl Crow: I have always appreciated her "laid back" style of this and other songs she has performs..most notably "All I Wanna Do Is Have Some Fun." She's a throwback to the early 1970s..back in my late teens,....and yes she is a lovely lady. Sheryl rocks...'nuff said!
The song is NOT a laid back song, it was never intended or SUNG that way (singer mad) , so singing it that way is STUPID. Second i am a drummer and her drummer really cannot play. I would be embarassed to even try to play the song like that!!
Put me in the "I Love It" camp on this one. Always liked both James Gang and Sheryl and I think she did a great cover on this. She even looks sexy in that funky hat, lol.
I saw James Gang do this several times and jSheryl and her band nail it! This is a great cover in the Crowe style. It is not supposed to be an exact reproduction of the original but an interpretation as this artist sees it. I think even Joe Walsh would be proud.
She should do us all a big favor and walk away. It's a folkie attempting a hard rock song. WTF!? she sounds lobotomized and ready for a nap. The band should have learned this correctly also. Their time is off. Her doing rock classic covers is akin to when Pat Boone tried it many moons ago. It sounds silly.
Very good effort by Cheryl. I appreciate the intention, respect and stretch.
Horgan1956 3 weeks ago
kinda country, but I like Crow
TheDevoDan 3 weeks ago
This is a tribute...its Joe's signature tune and can't be bested...no contest. She does it very well.
hassledguy 3 weeks ago
This is bringing 70's music to the "young uns" I say thanks Sheryl. Check out Chilli Peppers "Brandy" and the Foo Fighters with John Paul Jones and Jimmy Page. Also the Fighters with Alex Lifeson & Geddy Lee. I have over 5000 vinyl albums & singles...so....what do you need to know. Smile.
javelin1010 1 month ago
Sounds good; I like Van Halen version too.
mse1576 1 month ago
Not bad at all.
shouldibehere 1 month ago
Nice version of my favorite James Gang tune.
steve21130 1 month ago
not bad for a different version but i prefer the original...way better than her cover of Black Betty!!!
jasonracer3 1 month ago
No one will ever touch the James Gang. That being said...this is better than the Eagles version.
hassledguy 2 months ago
Nice work!!
tidepoolbay 2 months ago
Who cares what people think, Sheryl? The song grooves like magic. Talk is cheap because supply exceeds demand. I am a pro drummer and I'd be honored to play with you anywhere, anytime!
loachplt 2 months ago
Not bad, I give it a thumbs up.
farfrompukin1974 2 months ago
I loved it. I'm old and saw Joe W. several times, with the Gang and the Eagles. They and he were great. So is Sheryl. I like all her stuff, cover or not.
2253glen 2 months ago
its ok.
bubbatvbitch 3 months ago
totally Soul-Less
lordritchie 3 months ago
I think Van Halen's version might be better. :(
TNMinuteMan 4 months ago
Her voice is weak at best! Totally overrated! Peter Rocks!
scienceisgod1 5 months ago
Yeah Sheryl baby.... rock that James Gang tune!! Go girl...... : )
ogrebattle22763 5 months ago in playlist SHERYL CROW
Nice rendition. Had "James Gang: Thirds" when I was a teen. There may be haters out there, but c'mon, who is going to expose the next generation to this music unless SOMEBODY covers it? Sheryl keeps the flame burning with some really beautiful choices.
kristianjl 6 months ago
I'm a big James Gang / Joe Walsh fan. My fav. thing about Eagles concerts is always the Joe Walsh break where he usually does Walk Away, '49 and Midnight man along with a solo or two. Seeing Sheryl do this is fine too. Watch again and watch the youngsters in the audiance bouncing. Anything that spreads the faith is food with me.
jiminlhc 6 months ago
not going to approve that, are you?
pkrwd 7 months ago
Great song, great and beautiful singer/bass player
mrber44 7 months ago
I heard a local band play this with more feeling and energy. This truly sucks.
spareaxe 7 months ago
PERFECTION
JAMES GANG:
/watch?v=g4Wr5Wq5QHM
ENJOY THE ORIGNAL
gemrouf 8 months ago
Sheryl on Bass?
golyg 10 months ago
I like it
delboy01 10 months ago
yea im gonna walk away from this one
able506 11 months ago 7
Bravo, Bravo Sheryl and that comes from a BIG TIME JAMES GANG FAN, almost 40 years of Fan love for the Gang and my idol.....rip, TOMMY BOLIN ! Yes, I know joe plays guitar on that tune but I love Tommy, he's my hero. Anyway....great job sweetheart.
MrMusic4love 11 months ago
I agree it's the singer not the song.
gene347 1 year ago
excellent version, one that joe walsh would definitely approve of. and the original is pretty laid back, actually, other than joe's voice straining because it's out of his range.
slimturnpike 1 year ago
Ignore the HATERS! Eventually, and thankfully, they will all die off. Crow and her band do a great job covering a Joe Walsh classic. Period. ~
teezeeish 1 year ago
Thank you for posting!
atreb56 1 year ago
Thank for posting
atreb56 1 year ago
She has the right voice for this song.
Kingrob30 1 year ago
Hey, Lay off of Sheryl, She is not the greatest singer of all time but she trys and has a few really good songs.Plus doing a cover of a rock legend, Joe Walsh. He is in the top 100 greatest guitarist s list no matter what the Rolling Idiot magazine says.Joan Jett is on the list And she would not make pimple on Joes butt.
scott4xtc 1 year ago
@scott4xtc Yeah, besides, who's sexier?
B7aug5 1 year ago
She has the right voice to cover this.
Kingrob30 1 year ago
Awesome! Two thumbs up! Five stars (out of five)! Thank you, Sheryl from all of us cover band musicians who play tunes like this until the cows come home (or the bar empties out at 4 am)... I know Joe Walsh would kiss your boots after hearing this! Slainte!
hotdogpoppa 1 year ago
Gotta give Sheryl props. Most chick singers nowdays probably never even heard of The James Gang. She did this song justice. I dig it.
funkster007 1 year ago
She is lame...Priceless! No...Justin Bieber is lame. Her band is bad ass...and she can sing incredibly well..period
iamthemercury 1 year ago
Sounds great to me. Ease up on the girl....
She covers a lot of cool old tunes and shows her influence from them. She's one of the best chick rockers out there.
wobrien007 1 year ago
@wobrien007 I couldn't agree more - oh wait a minute yes I could !! I have always thought a female voice is better suited to rock than a male voice particularly when there are very high notes !! Some male singers can no longer get to them !!
Someone else with a great voice for hard rock is Ann Wilson of Heart try her versions of Zeppelin songs
I always wanted to hear Zepp with a female voice - She obliged !!
domnal 1 year ago
she is lame
iceaxe56 1 year ago
fuckin awesome! 10 stars...
sxxydon 1 year ago
@sxxydon What !! only 10
domnal 1 year ago
Great fan of Joe walsh and Sheryl Crow.. Love sheryl's cover
jetair01 1 year ago
Tesla covers this song much better,it's just odd to hear a chic singing it.
peteelliedaisy 1 year ago
@peteelliedaisy What is truly odd is the number of male rock singers who insist in trying to sing above their natural range - We need women in rock to sing the high notes that men have in their heads but can't always deliver. Robert plant can't scream soprano like he used to - Ann Wilson ( Heart) no problem.
Search Youtube for Heart versions of Zepp - You will be surprised. !! ( honest )
domnal 1 year ago
there is nothing wrong with this performance. If I was to critique it would be the drumming. The drummer is great, no doubt about it, but I would have included the explosive drum fills Jim Fox does on his live perfomances. It really adds alot. I think this drummer played it pretty clean, which is fine, but I think the fills add so much to the song. That is just my opinion though.
uswmsa41 1 year ago
Sheryl is groovin'! She's singing this tune like she does everything else. - w/ class, finesse and she sounds cool as sh*t!
Jaydin113 1 year ago
They come pretty dang close to capturing the spirit of the original - nice job. Nobody is going to match the gravitas of Joe Walsh and the fantastic original drummer of the James Gang.
ebquinn 1 year ago
Negative comments? I'm glad I missed them. come on she's not Joe Walsh, and isn't trying to be. If you've never played this song maybe you could miss how much fun and energy the whole band is putting into this performance. By the way she's doing this in A. get out a bass and play along you'll be hooked. If you don't like it just WALK AWAY!
DenzilShowers 1 year ago 5
@DenzilShowers I think you mean " If you don't like it - Then just turn your pretty head and walk away !!
I did like it. I listened to it twice !! and then down loaded it and walked away !!
domnal 1 year ago
Sorry, but every version on here by Joe Walsh is terrible! Especially the one with the Eagles in 1977. Some of the James Gang's versions are OK, except for Joe's playing and singing! I know that musicians don't want to play carbon copies of their hits, but in my opinion, if you can't IMPROVE it, then stick with the original arrangement. I do think that Ms. Crow could've put a little more passion in her vocals, but her band just smokes, especially the classic ending......
jhm795main 1 year ago
I like this version. What she may supposedly lack in vocal talent is more than made up by the awesome backing musicians.
RavishalBentham 1 year ago
she disfigured another brilliant classic...sob
sneakerino 1 year ago
watered down version.......no feelin like how Joe brought it!!
Skinhitta 1 year ago
Sheryl Crow is so talented, plays piano, guitar, and bass on this video even, sings and is a music coach and teacher. She rocks, good job on the video. Great tune.
billyd28709 1 year ago
In defense of Sheryl Crow: I have always appreciated her "laid back" style of this and other songs she has performs..most notably "All I Wanna Do Is Have Some Fun." She's a throwback to the early 1970s..back in my late teens,....and yes she is a lovely lady. Sheryl rocks...'nuff said!
bluesonthelake 1 year ago
@bluesonthelake
The song is NOT a laid back song, it was never intended or SUNG that way (singer mad) , so singing it that way is STUPID. Second i am a drummer and her drummer really cannot play. I would be embarassed to even try to play the song like that!!
sgalant1 1 year ago
she sings like she's half asleep. boring and passionless. manufactured. stick to the original, it's the only one that matters.
gonzotoo 1 year ago
Oh Hell Yes!!! Finest Kind. Would love to hear her do Funk #49
maple12string 1 year ago 2
I think it would have been better if Sheryl Crow had performed with James Gang. Male AND female harmonics would probably sound pretty cool.
Pyronaut 1 year ago
She is terrible
tapehead004 2 years ago
I just discoverd The James gang a few weeks ago, then stumbled across this.
Boss tune, Very well done.
ss180jay 2 years ago
Put me in the "I Love It" camp on this one. Always liked both James Gang and Sheryl and I think she did a great cover on this. She even looks sexy in that funky hat, lol.
nthom1956 2 years ago
this sucks !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
ironcowboy58 2 years ago
@ironcowboy58 You get up there and do better, THEN run your mouth!!! I'll admit it is not quite as exciting as the JG, but the harmonies are there.
frederickus 1 year ago
Sounded great, although the lead singer would be better at C&W
bhaddow 2 years ago
I saw James Gang do this several times and jSheryl and her band nail it! This is a great cover in the Crowe style. It is not supposed to be an exact reproduction of the original but an interpretation as this artist sees it. I think even Joe Walsh would be proud.
rsgrippo 2 years ago
A fantastic version in my opinion. I might be a bigger fan of Joe Walsh but I think this is very well done.
GU174RM4N 2 years ago 2
@GU174RM4N
I like it, too. It's not as good as Joe's--but then, what ever could be?
TheSanityInspector 2 years ago
She should do us all a big favor and walk away. It's a folkie attempting a hard rock song. WTF!? she sounds lobotomized and ready for a nap. The band should have learned this correctly also. Their time is off. Her doing rock classic covers is akin to when Pat Boone tried it many moons ago. It sounds silly.
kevinneslund 2 years ago 2
that drummer plays washmachine beats
pappydinksmoms 2 years ago
This song is one of the best I have ever heard, BUT this band ruins it !!!!
JustMeOrMaybeNot 2 years ago
the 2 guitarists play with McCartney
1willbescott 2 years ago
She's Always The Best
JukieDaisy 2 years ago
the drummer is a douche.. killed the song..
backdoorman1971 2 years ago
i like the original wayyy more but hes not really playing much different
DBprep8 2 years ago
what the hell are you talking about?
he nailed it
mlmr11 2 years ago
correction, this band including Sheryl Crow killed this song, the orginal had
that great seventies energy. This had the same appeal that all of her covers have, ZERO..
xyz321123 2 years ago
for sure
pappydinksmoms 2 years ago
Whoa, great! WTH did you find this?
Could she be playing a clear Armstrong?
Thanks for posting.
BTW WTH is where the heck.........
LoadInHer 2 years ago
Isn't Sheryl Crow so cool! I love this chick!
ogrebattle22763 3 years ago
Great post man - I love Sheryl Crow & her band....She is an All-American rocker chick & I am down with that!
ogrebattle22763 3 years ago
And you did Joe's solo note for note.
What a pro!!!
You all did the Gang proud!!!
magicmichaelking 3 years ago