Montserrat Caballé: Agitata da due venti (Vivaldi)

[mirmigatos]

Con todos mis respetos a quien se sube a un escenario. Esta señora sabe lo que está cantando.

[SakumaRyuichiNG]

Caballé is a master!!

...but this is NOT supposed to be sung like this... she's definitely a great singer but other repertory please :D

[roman14032]

i will try not to say the name Bartoli. to say the name Bartoli would be rude.the name Bartoli should never be written on this page.the existence of Bartloi must never be acknowledged,for Bartoli exposes this page for what it is.Bartoli represents a mortal threat to what is on this page.Bartoli makes this page of no relevance.Bartoli ends the lies. everyone just chant"there is no Bartoli'.

[pedrofribeiro]

It doesn't get any worse.

[iroiroironico]

Una Gran voz pero laa neta la cago coon estoo...

[lantis323f]

è inascoltabile!!!!

[19sp70]

Steamroller

[leedshunk]

that is truly horrible !! cecilia bartolli would be turnng in her grave too - if she were dead that is (and i'm very pleased she's not ) lol 

[martapoes]

wig AND coat….. horrible!!!

[maccwosser]

Appaling



[armando25868]

e lo spartito dov è???????in capa ?

[armando25868]

E le agilità dove sono ?

[RVP57]

Agitata in my stomach...

[estefamurrone]

Concuerdo absolutamente. Una vergüenza.

[Ignatiusneumann]

QUE DESASTRE!!!!!!, y lleno de nabos aplaudiendo!, eso no es Vivaldi, parece una versión emputecida de alguna canción boba.. y por qué tan lento????!!, re feo, el pianista lo toca como si fuese del romanticismo, que acaso no estudian?, y la cantante, bue, da lastima, canta la mitad de las notas, y las partes que no le salen se hace la "pajaro"..

[igorlaszlo]

She has spent her hollidays in Moscow ? She did not wake up yet or she is just between two glass of champagne... But she is proud i guess because she could shout a big one at the end...

[vicho081973]

Ups! no me gustaron los arreglos, mejor me quedo cuando canta "Barcelona" con Freddy Mercuri.

[FeDuS27]

Alguien que le saque el SLOWWW!!! 

[AnonBatch]

Utter shit.

[ZPTheart32]

BLEAH!

[roman14032]

wow, i'm totally amazed by that profromance,utterly astounded really.that audiance was just increadible......i would have thrown something at her

[dolofonos]

@roman14032 If your manner of composition in writing at all reflects your manner of public behavior, then I shouldn't be surprised.

[TeressaByrne]

Non \e "agitata da due venti", \e "calma da due venti".

[siglinde86]

si no la hubiera cantado la bartoli que la hace magnificamente.... nadie la criticaria a la caballe.

[Snutih]

God help this poor woman...I was gonna say it's awful due to her old age , then I checked the date....she was never remotely good IMO , always sounded and looked like an old turkey.

[tenor220]

@Snutih You're an idiot. Caballe is one of the most celebrated sopranos of her generation, I would love to see you sing casta diva with the precision and quality of sound that she did. Yes, this performance was bad, but to say she never good is foolish and shows a lack of understanding of the voice on your part.

[dliu84]

This version is much better than the one from Florence Foster Jenkins

[iroiroironico]

No por ser soprano lirico la iba a cantar bieen ... En pocas palabras La regoo...



[Berokymilk]

The worst rendition of this aria evaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaar!

[MusicosinFrontera]

Cauntas Caballé hay por aqui...me da risa..........jijijijijiijijij­ijijijijijiji

[screamhertitsoff]

This is how it would sound if Puccinni had written it?

[MusicosinFrontera]

Oye es l Diva Montserrata y cual es el problema de ella intentar cantar que no le salio bien o no adaptado a su timbre y voz?????Es un ser humano como nosostros y es Montserrat.....criticas si....pero ofensas a esta gran cantante del mund JAMAS. Respecto es bueno y hace bien a el alma. Cunaots pueden cantar al menos 1/10 de que canta Montseerat y que la ciriticaron terriblemente???? Invidia? Celos??

[editorcillo01]

@MusicosinFrontera No es necesario cantar bien para saber cuando alguien está cantando mal.

[mmmaaarrrcccooo]

@MusicosinFrontera Fue detestable, como una cantante pop ópera

[MusicosinFrontera]

@editorcillo lo que importa es que ella es Montserrat Caballe y tu eres quien ?????

[editorcillo01]

@MusicosinFrontera Hay que tener claras las limitaciones de cada uno en sus respectivos campos. Si no es capaz de entender eso es porque pone más corazón que juicio en su evaluación de tan lamentable interpretación.

[Matellini35]

God damn it this woman. what is this thing? it's horrible. this woman destroy my all music life.

[LordHettrick]

When you cannot sing coloraturas, you do not sing an aria which requires fast coloraturas from A to Z...

[curlesismuol]

Que voz tan linda, pero definitivamente me quedo con Cecilia Bartoli's

[lantis323f]

ha veramenta toccato il peggio qui!

[melibea56]

Sinceramente, no es un aria para la Caballé. Creo que alguien como ella debe saber lo que no se adapta a su voz y no debería tenerla en su repertorio. Nada que ver con el colorido de voz y la vitalidad de la versión de Cecilia Bartoli.

[SCarleTT123star]

si infatti agilità.....non pesantezza!!!!!!!!.....non è settecentesca la caballé nn c'è niente da fare!!!!

[onotuoedaul]

its vivaldi, not puccini, mrs caballe!!!!!!!!!!!!

[scobaretto1]

Pero esto es para una mezzosoprano de coloratura!!!! Esto no le va pero ni con chochos

[vocalissimo1]

Awful.

[sofialuz6]

pero ella es una soprano dramática!!!! esto es unaaria para soprano de coloratura Dioss!!!

[bayreuth79]

Compare this with the fire and vocal fireworks of Bartoli's rendition and then you'll know how awful Caballe's version is!

[sagazflausino]

Horrível!!!

[MrJohanncriztian]

Siempre que sea musica me gustan todas las versiones, mi mente esta completamente dispuestas a disfrutar, prefiero otras versiones, pero no trastorno mi mente por escuchar diferentes cantantes. No he visto, escuchado o presenciado a un artista que pueda cantar todos los estilos. Modificaciones, adaptaciones, para los gustos los colores, para los gustos los sabores...

[asiole22]

De verdad no me gusta esta versi{on, y s{e que Caballe es grande. Pero es verdad que una cantante, incluso siendo una gran cantante como Caballé, no esta hecha para cantar TODo tipo de música!

[tietienne12]

Bartoli killed that version forever, hopefully...

[killerbunny123123]

Well...yeah, i totally get why all the negative comments, but do not forget this is written for Mezzo!! A soprano being able to sing this is alrdy a great feat!

[satnitcboy]

It takes some cajones to say Caballe was musically illiterate! She's not a kid in this performance. Give the old girl a break.

[DrRyan87]

What the hell was that? Horrible!!! Everything is wrong with this!

[MusicosinFrontera]

Entonce a subir al scenario y hacer mejor que Caballe.....criticar es muy facil ..peo quien de ustedes puedes ser 0,000000000000000000001% de que fue CabAlle??NADIE

[editorcillo01]

@MusicosinFrontera Una cosa es que podamos hacerlo o no, otra muy distinta es defender el mal gusto de esta señora. Puede cantar muy bien zarzuelas, Rossini, Bizet, etc. Pero esto no. Lo mismo pasa al revés.

[emilytransex]

MADONNA SANTA MA XKE???

[panpypoo]

è fantastica! praticamente ha riscritto l'aria! ahahahahahahahah :D.

[koiny2009]

What a mess! This is a typical example of musical illiteracy.

[gmsoyls]

el senor maestro esta comiendose la peluca...jajaja!

[kicsizuzu1]

:S...



[editorcillo01]

Vivaldi must be eating his wig.

[mistatomsom]

@editorcillo01 as if you really know how it sounded in the times of Vivaldi!?! Please!!! Perhaps he's say this si sublime and Bartolli is doing a shit job...

[mistatomsom]

@mistatomsom

he'd say not he's say...

[ilex50]

Pity!

Lástima!

[luissuccar]

este concierto no es de 1981 es de 1992 o quiza cerca al 2000 , y la señora esta cantando muy mal , es lamentable que nadie le diga lo que no puede hacer

[Vladikism]

Horror!! What are you doing??????!!!!!!!

[troppofiato1]

Caballe made a record of baroque arias around 1980 that was fantastic. She sang a lot of these arias in recitals with piano from the beginning of her career. She was obviously not in her prime for this Moscow concert (which I think is later than 1981.)

[editorcillo01]

@troppofiato1 Baroque arias for baroque singers, Puccini for puccinian singers, etc.

[dannben]

montze eres muy buena.. pero guapa.. el barroco no es para ti... !

[demianvel]

dios, que horror esta version

[caroline5420]

@demianvel si!

[eric0182]

糟透了...bad...male