Added: 4 years ago
From: coolday123
Views: 186,982
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (459)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • she's sooooooo goood.....NOT

  • shes' good.. damn

  • hey... good looking isn't enough to be A REALLY ASIAN IDOL, right? ;)

  • Comment removed

  • Terrible. Aside from the pronunciation (no quotes needed around that word), and the butchered lyrics, the singing is is sub par, with flat notes peppered in. The vibrato is overly deliberate.  There is "ah" added at the end of each line. This song is a rock song at core and she's singing like a cheesy lounge singer. It's the easiest song to have fun with and she wasn't able to embrace it. Fail.

  • Have Phuong Vy ever performed in Canada? We have a large Vietnamese community.

  • b.a.d contestant ever!

  • however after that contest , she came back to VN and used that VNese song as her debut song ;) That song is pretty meaningful . You dont understand VNese , check the english  sub instead of leaving stupid comments here ~~

  • Cái bà philipine nói là " Em rất đẹp. Nhưng bài hát của em thiếu tất cả mọi thứ. Nó không phù hợp với một bài hát cho Asian Idol". Bà tôi hoàn toàn đồng ý với bà này.

  • Phương Vi và trương trình này lùi lại vài năm tới bây giờ thì với lượng thuê bao dtdd hiện nay của VN thì Phương Vi có thể thành asia idol :))

  • Minh thich chi Phuong Vy tu luc con di hoc chung voi chi o cap 3. Chi rat la mot nguoi dang hoang, nghiem tuc. Minh tin la tuy chi khong dung xao thuat nhung voi ban linh that cua chi thic hi se ton tai that long. Minh van ung ho chi du khong o Vietnam nhung van luon nghe nhac chi hat.

  • Mình nghĩ Phương Vy hát rất hay và thành idol cũng rất xứng đáng. Có điều cô này đàng hoàng quá, ko chịu lộ hàng hay tung clip thành ra bây giờ chìm nghỉm...

  • xinh dep nhung ma hat thuong thuong... chon bai hat ko duoc khon ngoan lam..

  • Uả cuộc thi này hồi nào vậy nhỉ :D?Cô ấy nói tiếng Anh hay quá ,mình rất tệ tiếng Anh nên hâm mộ ai nói tiếng Anh :)

  • whatever who's country own that voice, I just want to said, it sound like crap, please remove that freaking voice immediately, so ashamed who's native speaker of that crap language!!!

  • @MrNicebuddies : @MrNicebuddies : So, Manglish with ridiculously self-invented Manglish grammar & vocabulary will sound better !? Well, think about this, it tickles me hard! Ah, your obscured sentence which is fulled of errors is laughable enough "oledi". There is no such thing like "crappy language", only "crappy mind" would think that the uniqueness of language is "crap". You seem to have one.

  • @MrNicebuddies what is crap language you were talking abt anyway ? VNese ? oh please u dont know anything 'bout VNese so just shut up !

  • omg her voice is so good but she picked a wrong song to show it off. I love her voice in the Vietnamese Idol contest but this one is too boring.

  • although her English is not very great, this is so sso good

  • co tien viet. chua song bai dac co tien anh lam gi??

  • @pearlduz người tai buộc hát tiếng anh thì hát chứ chú :)

  • tiếc quá Phương Vy tự nhiên chọn bài Lúc mới yêu chi cho nó nhạt vậy. Em luôn ngưỡng mộ sự thông mình của chị nhưng chị chọn bài này đi thi em thấy tiếc quá

    Mà cô SiuBlack cũng biết nói tiếng Anh nữa ạ. Cô là thần tượng của cháu về tính cách thoải mái của mình

  • tiếc quá Phương Vy tự nhiên chọn bài Lúc mới yêu chi cho nó nhạt vậy. Em luôn ngưỡng mộ sự thông mình của chị nhưng chị chọn bài này đi thi em thấy tiếc quá

    Mà cô SiuBlack cũng biết nói tiếng Anh nữa ạ. Cô là thần tượng của cháu về tính cách thoải mái của mình

  • i thinks she's pro va kute

  • chị Pv giõi TA quá , hát hay nữa , ước j ....

  • @bambang66sg.well.wat makes u say malaysian r always jealous of singaporean?u r just making ur country looks bad on the eyes of the other.do u wan people to label u kiasu?

  • @luciabrite maybe he feels more superior saying that Malaysian is jealous with them. *tsk tsk tsk* poor guy.

  • @lynbabysusu....superior? well looks at Malaysian government..what sodomy? tsk tsk poor minister..ha ha ha..new bridge to replace causeway? ha ha ...London bridge is falling down, falling down...mahathir is singing this song....

  • @luciabrite ..kiasu? i think your country old men more kiasu. Sack Badawi becos No bridge. then Najib say 3rd bridge near East Johor and KTM at Tanjong pagar must go..ha ha ha who's kiasu? Kesian..Mahathir sure sakit hati.

  • She was the youngest anyway. At her age she surely showed her talent. Good strong voice! What is wrong for being rich? Wealth helps you but only talent survives. She is GOOD!

  • giong hay qua .... rat truyen cam...

  • I'm a Malaysian and I really think that the Asian Idol should go to any other contestants but ... what's the Singaporean guy's name? He can't even be on par with the other contestants! Look at this talent here!

  • @lynbabysusu>> Malaysian always jealous of Singaporean>>>typical Mahathir's style...

  • @bambang66sg ya ryte,who's the kiasu kiasi here. I think he won coz people voted FIRST for their own country's idol THEN voted for the UNDERDOG

  • @lynbabysusu Exactly my thought when I saw the show. I assume many people voted for their favorite and those who they believed to be less likely to win, so you've got Singapore.

    And @bambang66sg, I'm not Malaysian, and I'm definitely not jealous of Singaporean.

  • @blueofthe7 good to have somebody sensible here ^^

  • Comment removed

  • She's great 

  • hay quaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa­aaaaaaaaa

  • She just not bad. but, to compete with Jac and Mike? she should to practise 100 times before.

  • Maybe girls like vote more than boys ^^ So that guy was be the winner... Hady?

  • i think she won bcz she is a woman thats all

  • @TheGeisha86 excuse me, she didn't win though she really deserved it. but stop being jealous of her talent so much that you only can see her body!!

  • @fuukaze210 I think she deserved it too

  • obaa101...WTF???? Asians got their own talent...they just deserve it!!!!

  • @obaa101 dude its the 21st century, racism isnt cool anymore! Im american and I dont talk shit about other races. We're ones who lost in VN. we're the ones in debt to China. I hope u learn to respect urself and think about what you're going to say next time.

  • @obaa101 you're just jealous cuz no one in your country has a fucking talent for god-sake, so shut your idian ass and show some respect to others.

  • @obaa101 Shut the fuck up you towel head! You hate America so much then what the hell are you doing in america. If you got some self respect then go back to where you came from you sand nigger , camel jockey stupid fuck terrorist that blow yourself up and others for no reason. Don't fuck with AMERICA & ASIANS! Go suck your camels dick!

  • look how bored the audience were during her performance

  • what is the name of the song?

  • Comment removed

  • she's freaking hoooooott

  • She's DROPDEAD HOT! I saw her on TV during the airing of this competition and just liked her instantly... ha ha

  • Very hot singer with a great voice. I do think she didn't pick the best song for her personality and voice though.

  • She is good

  • she is hot

  • She is doing fine with her English. Julio Iglesias, Dalida are legend and they have thick accent when they sing English or French songs. She is talented, she will do good ! I understand every word she sings.

  • i agree with most of people in here, she has a good voice but to sing in English she didn't perform right. Only thing i can hear clearly is "i love you baby, baby". She need learn more English

  • Comment removed

  • I think you should've double-checked your own English before you made that comment!

  • I've understood every single word that she sings. I don't know if her English is weak or yours is worse. So please, be judging more careful next time to avoid unveiling your weaknesses to others.

  • Big mistake to sing in English. The Viet song is failure, which didn't show off her voice.

  • Are people really judging on 'pronunciation'??

    because that's just idiotic. ASIAN idol.

    unless this is Asians-with-good-English Idol, I don't see any need for it.

  • She should be the Asian Idol 2007..she got the look and performance

  • but the problem is her pronounciation, sorry to say that. her voice is great but it can fill the lack in quality of her pronounciation

  • @KenRosaa What performance??!!

  • We she coulb be asian idol . It's Wrong and i don't like examiner of Asian idol

  • great voice. very de thuong.

  • Hope that she will become another Utada Hikaru. Their backgrounds are alike.

  • good...also clear pronunciation. I understand her perfectly..i hope she speaks English as well as she sings.

  • No she's not :D born and raised in Vietnam

  • Comment removed

  • she was born in VN and now studying in VN

  • i SORRY! I typed it wrong....I tried to explaned to NateWerewolf that Phuong VY raised and born in Vn, but just a typing mistake ^^!

  • she is so cute ^^ and how I love the international stage, it's so lively, not rigid as VN's atge and the MCs were cute ^^ it was so great that she had a chance to stand on a stage like this

  • she's great.. woah.. I'm filipino but I think she really deserve to be the asian idol more than mau with her song choices..

    she's pretty, has good projection and all-out..

  • the english song sucks. her English was good but the song wasnt right.

    the viet song's kinda better thou :)

  • Quoc Thien won the Vietnam Idol season 2. He's now preparing for the Asian Idol. But i must say this I don't think that Thien has the confidence like Phuong Vy does. I hope his English is getting better and better. Anyway Luc Moi Yeu is not a good choice. I don't like that song, really. I'm Vietnamese and there are plenty of fantastic songs to perform.

  • Comment removed

  • She's good..

  • she looks like the girl from a korean movie... 200 pounds of beauty.. pretty!

  • what's wrong with the song "Luc Moi Yeu"? I think it's a great song

  • Yes It is, but its just not appropriate to show up the strength of her voice.

  • i think the song is just too easy sing, it doesnt really show the greatness of her voice

  • She's good but not great I guess. I heard a lot better versions. But she got the stage, very pretty

  • haa

  • What does richness have to do with audience liking her performance? I see a lot of jealous people for her amazing performance and complain how she won because she's rich. Grow up fob. She is great at least with her accent :D But yeah she does need more singing experience to be perfect :D

  • i agree with u. so if she won the vietnam idol bcoz she rich so how come she did not win the Asian Idol. The result where she lost to Hady Mirza proved that she won the Vietnam idol bcoz the audience vote for her and not about her wealthy.

  • mostly anything with vietnam has to do with the fame. such as the china's olympics, vietnam was there. but i didn't really notice them in anything.

    i'm vietnamese so i guess vote 4 our kind.

    viet proud 4ever!!

  • i heard that vietnam has another idol and he is the winner of season 2 of vietnam idol. i guess he have a chance to win in Asian Idol 2. but this time the Asian idol 2 will be tougher bcoz majority male singer will battle in this competition. malaysia idol daniel and Singapore Idol Taufik Batisah will be one of the big contender bcoz of their popularity in this region and both of them will get highest vote.

  • i really think they need to do some twist w the voting system like making it as fair as the MW one. or did they do that in the first season already?

  • what r u talking about? theres nothing to do w fame or olympic!

  • i love this

  • wow, soooooooooooooo nice voice!

  • some haters in vietnam said she won the Vietnamese Idol cuz she rich.

    but i think she won cuz she got talent.

    :P

  • agreed...

  • @DoanIsAzn lol

  • @DoanIsAzn what the heck !

  • @DoanIsAzn i think too its not her dreses

  • what's the song?

  • She's hot!

  • She is so beautiful..she has the talent...the performance...should be the winner...damn hot girl

  • i like her and her voice. But the song? *sigh*

  • i love her voice

  • she is studying in international university

  • yup , RMIT

  • listen to her new songs... they r beautiful... i'm her fan now (o^_^o)

  • she sing very good

  • the old lady saying the song lacks everything? how can it lacks everything? she was saying the song doesn't fit for asian idol, but she didn't realize it's the voice, the ability to sing well that counts, not the song. bad judge

  • She's good..

  • I dont think that she just started learning english just a few months before the competition. I think she started learning at very young age. And, that was probably why the judges chose her over the others. The ability to speak and understand English is very important in this competition . Dont take me wrong tho, I like her a lot. She got a great voice and she's cute too.

  • the judge from the philippines is a bitch!

  • not bad! and her english ain't too bad as well, considering she only started learning english a few months before the competition.

  • I think her english's good compared to other non-native speakers....she only learns english for a short time, doesn't speak english on her daily life...so yeah...she really did a good job....btw, i think the female judge (not silkblack) was right...when i read ur commentz, i thought the second song would be a really really good song..but no, this song's just appropriate for a concert, not a competition....just my opinion, no offense to anyone...

  • poor her, actually the perfomance was not that bad

  • i think the judges are too harsh towards her. I personally think she;s amazing!

  • I like her Vietnamese songs more than her English songs!

  • she sang the first song REALLYYY good, but i think not many people like that kind of song, or not many people like that genre of song,.maybe most of people love pop song

  • yeah, that was what I also thought

  • oh my god, she is so good and absolutely stunning!

  • Simply wow,

    shes got some amazing an amazing voice and talent

    though i didnt think her clothes didnt match with her beauty,couldve been better imo

  • OMG- :-) She is a very good singer and she is unbelievably beautiful-probably one of the most charming and prettiest idols ever

  • ok i dont wana be mean but as my music instructor says if your singing English song and your diction is not good, its considered not hitting the right note as well...

  • i'm indonesian and guess what??i'm falling in love at her at the first sight!

    she's so gorgeous!beautiful gorgeous!

    i guess vietnam pick the right one to be the winner of vietnam idol!

  • hey, good thinking!

  • aw guys her english is ok. C'mon shes only ever learnt english in Vietnam and you guys know how bad the learning conditions are in Vietnam. I reckon it's pretty ok. Not perfect but good enough.

  • This song is so beautiful. I am Vietnamese but my mother is German. I like this girl, she is beautiful and has a great voice. I like Vietnam dude

  • she has a different nose here...

  • Ok, music has no border, people don't want to hear her English, they want to hear her voice. Moreover, this is Asian Idol, not American Idol, u guys shouldn't expect too much about their English. But I don't like her English song either XD, I do love her second song, dont know why the female judge said that it lacks everything, perhaps because she lacks Vietnamese to understand it or whatever? She isnt worthy to be a judge base on that comment, I guess

  • omg!my names vy!!

  • does anyone notice she kinda looks like Jessica Alba in this video? ^-^

  • She is great..... beyond my words

  • the judges are filipino

  • Only one judge are filipino. Others are Malaysian, Singaporean, Indian, Vietanamese and Indonesian.

  • hu? ony pilita is there....

  • cuz she was the original judge of philippine idol

    not pinoy idol

  • love her!!! she's very cute!! and sings very well too

  • she's pretty

  • The Indonesian judge doesn't know how to feel soul music.

  • they shouldn't have use asians as judges.

  • phuong vy, u need more practice especially for english song

  • who doesnt need more practice -.-

  • i think her english is great, very clear

  • we're proud of you girl

  • I think she has an amazing voice. Her English singing is also outstanding compared to other singers from non-speaking English countries though. I'm stunned!!!

  • omg i know her english is really good!!! impressed

  • she is cute ^^good girl

  • shes GOOD!

  • English is not her mother's touge. What do you expect her to be sing well like you. Idiot!!

  • remember s