You couldn't have chosen any better than these two electrifying voices. Carrie and Jackie, in my opinion, are at the top of their genres and the amazing aspect is they've both been given to us via TV talent shows. What a service these types of shows are performing by given voice to talent all over the world - thank you for that. Both of these God talented singers will go down in history among the best that have ever sung.
Try to find a better video of Jackie's performance. The audio is great.
I think Carrie sings it from her heart because she is a believer in Christ....when she sang How Great Thou Art it was because she felt the Holy Spirit. It was amazing!!!
I loved the way Carrie totally killed, "How great thou Art," this year, and that is a song I'd like to hear Jackie sing and think she would also murder. Merry Christmas.
I adore both of these great singers but you can't compare these two renditions, or the singers. Carrie is singing in the key of Ab, a country version, indoors with great acoustics, in a concert setting where she can really let her voice out. Jackie is singing four notes higher in the key of Db, a classic version, outdoors without good acoustics, in a subdued setting where she must sing softly. In singing, louder is not better, and you seperate the women from the girls with the higher notes.
I have not heard nor do I even know who Jackie Evancho is... however EVERYONE knows who Carrie Underwood is... hands down... not knocking Jackie, but I am definitely appreciative of Carrie's God given voice and talent.. I feel blessed just to hear her sing...
@Cowgirltw: Maybe you should find out more about Jackie before you make your comments...because, I'm sure your the only one right now, that don't know who Jackie Evancho is. The rest of the world knows her as one of the youngest platinum debut artist.So go do your research and then come back and make your comment...or after your research you might even change your comment, if you really know music which i doubt.
Yea I don't think they are meant to be compared to one another. One is in her 20's and sings country, the other isn't even in her teens and sings classical crossover. Their styles are complete opposites but they are both angels
For me these are the 2 Best Female Vocalists today and both carry God close in their hearts.I have to correct the Uploader Jackie is not a Opera Singer she is a Classical-Crossover singer thats sings a few Opera Arias,Broadway Songs and Traditional Pop songs.She might one day decide to sing in a Opera but no plans on that to protect her voice.But its awesome and amazing to see these two wonderful vocalist in a clip.I hope one day they Duet together for real,
Both Carrie Underwood and Jackie Evancho are incredible artists, both singing praise to Our Lord. There is no competition here, neither is better than the other. They each bring a unique God-given talent and are both wonderful in their own right.
Our intention on this video was not to compare the artists, it was to praise Jesus Christ our Lord and Savior. It is 2 different genres of music country and opra that span all the genres of music and praise our Lord and Savior on the night of His birth :) + All Of God's Most Precious Blessings From Us To You During This Joyous *Christ*mas Season 2011 ...Karen n Monica, <3
You couldn't have chosen any better than these two electrifying voices. Carrie and Jackie, in my opinion, are at the top of their genres and the amazing aspect is they've both been given to us via TV talent shows. What a service these types of shows are performing by given voice to talent all over the world - thank you for that. Both of these God talented singers will go down in history among the best that have ever sung.
Try to find a better video of Jackie's performance. The audio is great.
dolfen7 4 days ago
aww i thought it was gonna be them singing together
kutekitty97 2 months ago
I think Carrie sings it from her heart because she is a believer in Christ....when she sang How Great Thou Art it was because she felt the Holy Spirit. It was amazing!!!
rluvsk82 2 months ago
I loved the way Carrie totally killed, "How great thou Art," this year, and that is a song I'd like to hear Jackie sing and think she would also murder. Merry Christmas.
davekanak 2 months ago
I adore both of these great singers but you can't compare these two renditions, or the singers. Carrie is singing in the key of Ab, a country version, indoors with great acoustics, in a concert setting where she can really let her voice out. Jackie is singing four notes higher in the key of Db, a classic version, outdoors without good acoustics, in a subdued setting where she must sing softly. In singing, louder is not better, and you seperate the women from the girls with the higher notes.
davekanak 2 months ago
Absolutely my favorite Christmas song. I'm 32 and heard sooooo many people attempt to sing this beautiful song. These two are by FAR the best.
Irishkisskiss4u 2 months ago
I really love it.... They both have beautiful voices!
jmulijawan 2 months ago
Absolutely my favorite version of this....a combination of beautiful vocals and pure faith.
bearball49 2 months ago
I have not heard nor do I even know who Jackie Evancho is... however EVERYONE knows who Carrie Underwood is... hands down... not knocking Jackie, but I am definitely appreciative of Carrie's God given voice and talent.. I feel blessed just to hear her sing...
Cowgirltwo77 2 months ago
@Cowgirltw: Maybe you should find out more about Jackie before you make your comments...because, I'm sure your the only one right now, that don't know who Jackie Evancho is. The rest of the world knows her as one of the youngest platinum debut artist.So go do your research and then come back and make your comment...or after your research you might even change your comment, if you really know music which i doubt.
tha1yang 22 hours ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I'm 16 and just wrote my first song, its on my channal if you want to listen.
NICHOLASJACKSONMUSIC 3 months ago
Carrie underwood s voice is like the angels singing :)
cowboycasanova93 3 months ago
I absolutely ADORE them both! They are both angels who are singing a beautiful song about Jesus Christ.
gymmomsandra 3 months ago 9
Yea I don't think they are meant to be compared to one another. One is in her 20's and sings country, the other isn't even in her teens and sings classical crossover. Their styles are complete opposites but they are both angels
JackieFan123 3 months ago
For me these are the 2 Best Female Vocalists today and both carry God close in their hearts.I have to correct the Uploader Jackie is not a Opera Singer she is a Classical-Crossover singer thats sings a few Opera Arias,Broadway Songs and Traditional Pop songs.She might one day decide to sing in a Opera but no plans on that to protect her voice.But its awesome and amazing to see these two wonderful vocalist in a clip.I hope one day they Duet together for real,
raksan4083 3 months ago
Both Carrie Underwood and Jackie Evancho are incredible artists, both singing praise to Our Lord. There is no competition here, neither is better than the other. They each bring a unique God-given talent and are both wonderful in their own right.
1greatnana 3 months ago
Carrie U and Jackie.....so good!!!! I love this music. They make the song touch heart, many do not have. JESUS LIVE. Thank for the video.
Ivonne0423 3 months ago
This would probably be awsome if they were actually singing together.
MRJRCHICO 3 months ago
Our intention on this video was not to compare the artists, it was to praise Jesus Christ our Lord and Savior. It is 2 different genres of music country and opra that span all the genres of music and praise our Lord and Savior on the night of His birth :) + All Of God's Most Precious Blessings From Us To You During This Joyous *Christ*mas Season 2011 ...Karen n Monica, <3
kmttmn 3 months ago 8
@kmttmn A blessed Christmas to you and yours and to all YouTube viewers!
48gnosis 3 months ago