Added: 4 years ago
From: rafa143
Views: 31,570
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (319)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Christinaa!!

    

  • Mariah e Christina!!!

  • aguilera haves the best falseto and is not the best whistle but is really really good mariah really really really good whistle and a good falseto and georgina de best whistle good fallseta i think christina has a most powerful voice i prefer her of the 3 if is singing but in the whistle georgina

  • las tres cantas super bien pero en el agudo pues obiamente georgia bronw ella esganadora del world record en las nltas mas agudas pero las tras cantan super brutal

  • no conosco a giorgia brown pero mi comparacion es esta

    mariah : voz melodiosa y notas altas

    christina : voz de negra en un cuerpo de lblanca

    giogia : gran voz , con tonos agudos

    pero me sigue gustando MARIAH CAREY FOREVER

  • Mariah and Christina

  • Mariah all tha way!! Shes. A legend :)

  • Georgia, does not compare it reaches above 3 notes mariah carey

  • mariah's are studio, one of christina's is live, all of georgia's are not only live, but one song

  • Those notes are kind of scary

  • Mariah, Georgia and X Tina, you all AMAZING!!! I Love Them Both!!!

  • Mariah and Christina ftw! :D

  • I LOVE MIMI AND XTINA, BUT I'M SINCERIOUS, GEORGIA WINS!!!

    SHE'S THE ONLY SINGER IN THE WORLD WHOS CAN HIT AN 8 OCTAVE NOTE.

    BUT I PREFER MARIAH'S NOTES. SHE GETS CONTROL AT THEM.

    Georgia's high note:

    /watch?v=rCWOggzQHBB

  • @ThiaguinhuBrazil Georgia is the only one who can stream an 8 octave

  • @princeroderick thanks! My english is poor! :( 

    hehe

  • Comment removed

  • RESUMO: A Mariah canta mais, incluindo seus melismas, seu controle vocal, seu timbre e etc. A Georgia tem notas mais agudas (canta mto tbm, tecnicamente mto boa). A Aguilera tbm canta demais... e tem a voz mais bonita que a Georgia e é a mais bonita, aliás, lindaa! uma obra prima de Ds!

  • Mariah Wins..:))

    her whistle sounded like an Angel Singing...:))

  • MARIAH WON FROM THE BEGINiNG

  • COMO SE LLAMA LA ULTIMA CANCION DE GEORGIA LA DE AL FINAL

  • Georgia Catalystic !!!!

  • what about the deepest whistle who can do the deepest one 

  • does anyone actually like the whistle anyway sounds like a kettle boiling lol

  • thee reason mariah cant do it all that well is not only because of her age but because she has used her whistle register way too much which causes you to mess up your voice :b just lk an fyi but ya mariah has a lot of control but i personally like georgia :) && christina :D she is amazing well they all r ^^

  • mariah obvio

  • Comment removed

  • eat ur hearts out@chakotay2222 u talk shit!!! mariah still holds the most no.1 ahahaha

  • mariah used to be best yes not anymore with age her voice got deeper. But nobody notice this or care cuz she is making lame generic pop songs that do not demand much of her voice. And those that does are computer manipulated.

  • You're all on about preferences, the ones who like Mariah Carey say that Mariah has control, power and clearity, and that Christina has blah blah blah and that Georgia sucks. Fuck off you all, they're all amazing, and THAT IS IT.

  • Georgia just sucks. She sounds AWFUL in her high whistle notes. I would so rather listen to Adam Lopez than HER.

    Christina is pretty stable in the high head voice and whistle registers. She sounds decent, and can carry the notes really nicely.

    Mariah Carey sends them all toppling head over heels.

  • Qual é a música do segundo agudo da Mariah?

  • Mariaaah is the best

  • well here's the thing, mariah and georgia have something in common, without thier whistle they are LOOSERs, but georgia's whistle ability was recognized by an award giving body which is guinees. in the case of christina,well, she might not have that great whistling ability but she has a great vocal power which mariah and gb does not posses. in short mariah SUCKS. sad but true :)

  • @tonee1205 Mariah can sing!!!!!! Something is obviously wrong w/ yu !!! I mean if yu think Mariah sucks, then I'd love to hear yur opinion on the ppl who got famous and can't sing at all. Cassie, Amelle, Jennifer Lopez., etc...

  • What is the song from 0:22-0:28 ? some plzzz tell me :)

  • @gagahead1

    it's "I wish you knew" from the album"emancipation of mimi":)

  • @rulove999 Thank you veryyyyy much!!!

  • mariah wins!!mariah forever!!

  • Comment removed

  • mariah sings, the others shout!

  • @thithibox that's not true, mariah and christina have one of the best voices of the world, and I love their technique

  • @ismaelgz00 but mariah signs, the others shout!

  • @thithibox you are right, mariah sings and her voice is beautiful and does not sound screaming!1

  • Whats the song called at 0:24 and 0:29?

  • @franche161 I Wish You Knew in the album The Emancipation Of Mimi

  • can anyone tell me what the second, third, and fourth of this video called

  • Vamos lá. Maryah é que tem o timbre mais bonito, esses agudos na voz dela são mais bonitos. A cristina, apesar de ser uma grande voz, não faz tão bem esses agudos como a maryah faz. Mas em relação a extensão, não tem pra ninguém, a georgia alcança as mais altas notas, notas inimagináveis a voz humana, portanto em relação a beleza a maryah ganha e em relação a extensão a georgia ganha.

  • @rafa143 mariah carey is americana and christina aguilera is española

  • Yezzz! whistle. sucks

  • Georgia Brown has a horrible style. I do not like. I prefer the other two singers.

  • mariah carey has so much control gb sucks at that she can only go higher but mariah has so much control over it ans does it in so many ways its jus beautiful mariah carey is #1

  • Georgia Brown is better by far......

  • i like mariah ! She sounds good while whistling its so nice to hear

    christina just force out her voice all over to hit those notes but its not natural

    georgia is amazing , i agree she can't control ..

    all in all i'll go for MARiAH :)

  • Mariah is a better controlling whistler than Christina or Georgia!!

    Christina can't even do'em right!! It's a pain to hear Christina!!

    I like Georgia!!

    But Mariah is my one-and-only favorite!!

  • Georgia!!!!

  • i really think that georgia has the most agile and capable voice but it's not the most beautiful i really think that Xtina's voice is perfect her vocals are the most powerful ones but Mariah's voice is just awesome definitely the girl with that beautiful register she's a legend and anybody can deny it!!!

  • Dejense de tonterias, aqui la unica que tiene potencia, habilidad y control es Gerogia Brown, ademas es la que tiene la voz MAS AGUDA con el register wistle, ni la Carey ni la Aguilera pueden competir con ella, tan simple como eso, si no vean el video donde se presenta en Japon, eso dice mas que mil palabras.

  • @partenongriego como asi que dejarse de tonterias???? una cosa es nada mas hacer un pito agudo que es lo que hace georgia,mariah carey puede llegar hasta hacer una nota igual a la de georgia,pero georgia sabe mantener mas el tono, y porfavor,mariah carey y christina aguilera han ganado premios de las mejores cantantes.las tres tienen una voz exelente,pero me quedo con mariah y christina..que chevre que las tres tienen sangre latina

  • Georgia breaking my ears -_-"""""

  • una cosa es la capacidad de emitir sonidos agudos y otra la capacidad de convertirlo en arte

  • Extensão de voz é uma coisa; saber cantar, ter controle de voz, afinação e beleza de canto é outra completamente diferente. Por favor, não há como comparar as 3.

    Aguilera e Mariah são únicas.

    Voice extention is one thing; knowing how to sing, voice control, tune and beauty is something completely different. Please, stop comparing these singers.

    Aguillera & Mariah are unique.

  • Extensão de voz é uma coisa; saber cantar, ter controle de voz, afinação e beleza de canto é outra completamente diferente.

  • 1.mariah-most pwerful tone and ability

    2.georgia-amazing whistles

    3.christina-beautiful voics

  • Georgia em 1° kkkkkkkkkkk nunca

    1°Mariah carey sempre......

    2°Cristina Aguilhera

    3°???????????

  • Georgia is the best one of the 3, is not only recognized world-wide as such cause it's Brazilian. Now, for me, the better exactly is the Celine Dion.

  • georgia can't control her whistles? mariah and christina are "simple" pop singers?? oh yeah and PIGS CAN FLY TOO!!!

    all three of these singers have different styes and different talents, so we can't really compare them. they are all amazing!

  • @cardcaptorzlove georga sucks hard like chris

  • Georgia can actually control it she performed it in a whole song

    1.Georgia (Based on the fact that her whistle is endless)

    2.Mariah Carey ( Because she put's power behind hers plus is sounds more natural)

    3. Christina ?????

  • @LeAnthony87 Christina barely uses her Whistle Registers.... How dare you put question marks behind a queen.

  • is it me or does georgia brown sound like a theremin??

  • Georgia é brasileira! Brasil, Brazil!

  • ps georgia tiene el record y despues de eia es mariah y cristina keda al ultimo pero ps eso es en rango volcal por k io prefiero a cristina ;D

  • Georgia Brown is'ts the best singer in the world

    mariah and cristina = just simple pop singers

    and Mariah and Christina knows that georgia is the best

  • @shagohod232 What would make her the best singer, hitting those notes? Because if so, she most definitely is not it.

  • @shagohod232 mariah the best of alltime

  • Georgia Brown is'ts the best singer in the world

    mariah and cristina = just simple pop singers

  • georgia and xtina the best!

  • I HATE the overly photoshopped pictures of Mariah. She is so much more beautiful than that.

  • Love Mariah :)

  • Christina and Mariah's voices are far better than Georgia's no matter how high she can sing...

  • aguilera....why do we compare prostitutes like aguilera with someone like mariah or georgia brown?pfffff....

  • Georgia brown can go way higher than anyone thats amazing

  • Also what is the song of Christina's at 0:50??

  • @luke4duke pero me acuerdo de ti (Mi Reflejo cd's) it's seems for live 2001 grammy!

  • @luke4duke pero me acuerdo de ti

  • well Georgia brown has the highest notes but when she sing normally i don't like how she sounds soo im putting mariah carey first, christina second and georgia brown third

  • Where did that "Someday" clip come from?

  • nada mejor que ima sumac , tine lo de las tres juntas

  • es cierto lo que dice maracheski, christina tiene mucha potencia en la voz, maryah tiene mucha agudez, pero georgia tiene las dos cosas, con un poco de practica profesional le bastara.... me quedo con georgia

  • es hermoso, perfectas

  • georgia brown - the best !!! ( Управлять голосом, как она им управляет - мало

    кто может, по крайней мере на планете -Земля )!!! ...from Russia with love ...

  • Para mí la reina sigue siendo Mariah Carey

  • georgia no tiene una buena educacion vocal, a diferencia de Christina y Mariah. La limpieza de las notas agudas de Mariah son sorprendentes, pero en definitiva me quedo con aguilera por la fuerza de su voz ademas de que al llegar a notas mas bajas su registro es mas amplio que el de mariah, y la tecnica que tiene es superior. Dicho por la propia Celine Dion, Christina Aguilera es la mejor vocalista del mundo.

  • @YatenArg toda la razon!!!!!!!

  • @YatenArg que si no tiene muy buen control con sus agudos

  • whats the first song of mariah here?

  • Emotions!!!

  • @josquine emotions

  • @josquine IT'S EMOTIONS

  • @josquine emotions

  • well in what it comes to whistle alone, Georgia is the best. but on the other hand Mariah´s tone is way better as well as her chest/ mixed voice sounds way better controlled. but talking about range and power Georgia Gets it in whistle. but only there

  • Mariah Carey da best!!!!!! gerogia sounds like a dyinq whale lolzzz :P

  • so waht... as long as she attained the voice.... brown has the best voice!

  • As far as the highest note goes, I'd say Georgia but for singing I go with Mariah because even without the high notes her voice still has so much power, and the length of time she holds some of those notes, my god. Georgia is not that great of a singer to me, she sounds sort of like Shakira, but she sure can hit those high notes.

  • georgia brown is the best... no wonder coz she got the highest vocal range awarded by the guiness world of record....

    and she whistle for a long period of time without breathing and also she do it with ease!

  • as far as whistling goes...Georgia has it... Mariah has the control, an then brings it back down to earth which makes hers more powerful an beautiful...Christina, i love her to death, but i dont feel like shes whistling...shes able to hit the high notes no doubt, but to compare her to Mariah an Georgia..nah.... Christinas voice is more soulful an strong...

  • it's I wish you knew at 0:24

  • @ 0:24 whats the name of that song?

    For its Mariah Carey, Christina Aguilera, then Geogia brown

  • A Georgia possui um G10 (14 notas a mais do piano) mas a Mariah tem a sua graciosidade ao cantar q hipnotiza a kualker um.

    A Christina tem uma voz potente mas nao chega a ser algo tao extraordinário como a Georgia e a Mariah.

  • 1. Mariah

    2. Georgia

    I'm sorry, Christina is a great singer and has a strong voice... but she's not great with the whistle register. She had to struggle in the Grammy performance during James Brown song. Mariah could've sang that same note effortlessly.

  • @nsam that was an actual scream, since it was a tribute, she screamed because he used to in his preformances

  • 30 - stunning !

  • georgia brown killed all of em

  • @Treasurespotlight she reaches the notes, but she has to work them a lot, as her chest voice and head voice, but the talent is there...it's not the same when you know how to sing and when you have an spectacular voice...she ha the second one, but there's a lot of experience left

  • 1. Mariah Carey- Power,Clearity and Control

    2. Christina Aguilera- Power and Ability

    3. Georgia Brown- Ability...thats about it lol she is just able to hit those high notes but can't control them

  • @Trae332 moron.....total moron

  • @MSergiuM Don't be mad because I pointed out the truth. So go in a corner and cry about it but don't call me a name because I said absolutely nothing to you.

  • @Trae332 You don't think Georgia brown can control her notes? To me it sounds very much like she hits the notes pretty well. Maybe some of them sound a little out of control but that could also be some controlled singing effect she uses. I'm no expert in this subject, but overall I think she has a lot of control over her voice - else she wouldn't be able to sing these melodies in this tone register.

  • georgia brown only possess the highest note (defenitely, it's frequency)..

    christina oversing high notes............

    mariah only possess the clarity, beauty, and majestically owns the whistle register.

  • @dalevhentetres Owns ? LOL , she owns nothing but a husky, course, and whispersing airy voice YUK!

  • @dalevhentetres I greed with you, you are right, I think mariah is a lot better than them!!!

  • Comment removed

  • we all know!!! that georgia have the highest whistle note here in world!!! but she cant sing better!! unlike mariah carey she can sing and she can whistle mariah`s whistle isz very amazing and very beautiful!! unlike georgia her whistle is lyk a dying dolphin!!! in short......MARIAH IS THE BEST AMONG THE REST!!! and mariah`s whistle is more powerful and much amazing than christina and georgia!!! MARIAH`S WHISTLE NOTE IS THE BEST!!!!!

  • Go MiMI. Muah.

  • Digan lo que digan,el mayor registro vocal y el silbido lo tiene Georgia...hay que aceptarlo!!!!!!!!!!!!de 10!!!!!!!!from Argentine

  • pero georgia no tiene el control, el matiz que tiene mariah carey

  • me gusta mucho el registro de Mariah!!!pero en cuanto al control?????hay que reconocer que Georgia lo sostiene,lo volea magistralmente!!!tan solo ved lo que hace cuando salió en un programa brasilero

  • if i go choose between mariah nad gorgia ill go for ms. butterfly and ofcourse that is mariah carey!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Georgia is the highest note but she cant sing to save her lol Mariah doesnt need her high notes lol

  • it's I wish you knew from The emancipation of mimi. The last one is fly like a bird

  • what is the 3rd mariah carey song?

  • Georgia hauahua ela émto mala, chata AFF.. i don't like her...

    i prefer Aguilera and Mariah... is better than Georgia... She's is complet

  • Mariah's and Christina's have a tune to theirs. Georgia's sounds like sort of a high pitch whine. That being said, they all are fantastic singers!

  • MARIAH THE QUEEN OF WHISTLES

  • Mariah'

  • i know that georgia brown can sing higher than Mariah or Christina but i still love Mariah the most and think she and her music are the best.

  • We all know who the real winner is Mariah has control and a tone that the tranny (georgia) could never rival. Ask yourself this, if Mariah couldn't whistle would she still be renowned as one the best singers of all time? YES! she would. if Georgia couldn't whistle would she even get 1 album sale? no Mariah is the winner and she always will be. get used to it

  • i agee 100% with u mariah is definetly the greatest artest and she can sing even without the whistle notes and georgia is a has been who couldnt compare to mariah at all!

  • thanks. it's nice to know someone agrees

  • tranny? that was rude and uncalled for.

  • as tres são boas...

    e quem quiser abrir a boca pra falar mal...

    antes faça melhor... supere-as !!!

    xauzin

    bjux

    ah amei o video

  • A mi esa Georgia no me gusta, solo sabe gritar!!! eso lo hago yo.... Por el contrario Christina y Mariah cantan afinado y te dan esos agudos excelentes... son unas verdaderas cantantes... Georgia no canta, y escuché un video de ella cantando y desafina casi toda la canción lo único "emocionante" es el gritíto estúpido ese que se tira.

  • Georgia es una zorra

  • Mais uma vez eu digo : Mariah eh a BEST!

    Mariah eh muito alem diisso , Georgia metade das musicas dela eh grito , vc num aguenta escuta 5 musicas seguida, imagina em um show {tadim do meu ouvido . Curto as musicas da Cristina tbm , mas sem comparação.

    Georgia está mais pra cantora di opera do que cantora pop, por isso não se pode comparar as 3.

  • definitely agree grorgia browns voice sounds like a tranny. the only thing she have is that high note.. nothing more...

    Mariah is hot, sexy, beautiful, glam, rich, whistles like no other bitch, sings with a not common voice (not talkin about height) .. Mariah wins 4 sure.. *IM NOT A FAN*

  • Faltou ai a cantora Erika Rodrigues

  • Isto sao agudos em Whitle register e a Erika nao tem isso e nem nunca teve

  • Sorry Georgia is TRASH.. Her singing voice sounds like a transgender drag queen at a cheap bar.. only thing she got going is her whistle.. Thats it.. her singing voice is TERRIBLE. Mariah got the whole package.. beautiful, successful, and notorized for her amazing pipes.. She belted.. she whistled.. and she does studio shit like no other.. Christina don't even belong in this catagory because shes a belter.. put her with Whitney, Aretha, and Patti.

  • everyone is supposed to say Georgia here, because she is the best singer.

  • all i`m saying is give me back the mariah from back in the days with the incredible vocal performances not these little whispering things she does off lately bring back the vision of love mariah for me, thats all i`m saying.

  • mandomariah i`m not disputing the fact about mariah`s success but i love the mariah from back in the day i don`t like this mariah we are seeing now, its just not her style she has too much of a stunning voice to be singing the sorta crap she does today.

  • Christina=thin, soft, easy listening..

    Mariah="crunchy", bold, steady, controlled, angelic..

    Georgia=Louder, soaring, swift, crushing..

  • hahhah Christina soft?

    Georgia Brown is obviously the best, no doubt about that. Christina is seccond, Mariah is third.

  • nO..

    I didn't categorize them into the first best,second best. or third...

    each one of them has their own signature vocal...

    but if we talk about whistle register for sure and absolutely Mariah is the best even if georgia possess a wider range...

    Christina has the soft character in using whistle register...

    see the fact..and think...before you give comment...!!

  • I think you're definitely deaf...

    incapable of distinguishing between giving comment and ranking three of them..

  • You're deaf. Mariah carey is the big loser of this three woman. Deal with it. She isn't the best whistler, she is isn't the best belter, she has not the most powerful voice, she doesn't have the widest range. So accept it. Mariah's voice is weak and soft and that's the reason why she is whistling so much. And I also thought that Georgia was a bad singer, but you should watch some of her video's because she is actually amazing.

  • well..numerous people said that Mariah has the best whistle...just find out!!

    Using particular software which is able to show the height (in Hz) of voice...Mariah has the most "crunchy and bold" whistle...

    I admit that Georgia is awesome...BUT She's just the best in possessing extremely wide whistle range...not for singing in modal or chest voice...see??

  • But this is about whistling, and Georgia brown is just the best at that point. I am a christina aguilera fan and even I can admit it. It's just true, a G10 is very very high, and mariah can't hit a note like that. And actually Georgia's high notes are more beautiful than Mariah's because mariah voice sounds like she is whispering.

  • See!!

    We defend Mariah...She's really a whole pagkage..!!

    no matter how high georgia's voice...Mariah's whistle is the best though her range is not as wide as georgias...G10?

    ya..that belongs on guiness list...can you even hear what's G10 like..??

    Only new born baby who's able to hear it...

    MARIAH's WHISTLE IS THE BEST AMONG OTHERS...THE QUALITY iS PROVEN GREAT!!

  • She is in the guiness book of records? So, you can measure a G10 although you can't hear it. And explain to me, how can Mariah be a better whistler as georgia as she doesn't even come close to Georgia's high whistles? It's typically something for a fan to say this.

  • If you listen to Mariah F#7 compare to georgias...Mariah sounds so staedy!!

    I used to be Mariah's fan..

    As I've told you that georgia won for range not quality...

    I like Mariah but I'm not her huge fan...georgia is also not a belter....great singer are those who can sing in different vocal techniques not just in whistle register...this category belongs to Mariah, Whitney, Celine, Christina, Beyonce, Chaka, Aretha, Patti, and so on!!

    What an exhausting to be a defend of a faker!!

  • Shut up, you don't know were you are talking about. I am a Christina Aguilera fan, but I know my place. Georgia might be the best singer in the world. She has the widest range, the most powerful voice and the best belts.

  • Looser...

    It's you are..because you're blind about music and melodies...

    Georgia is so weak even weakest about belting notes..

    See..People love those singer such as Mariah Carey, Whitney Houston, Celine Dion, Christina Aguilera, Beyonce, Chaka khan, Aretha franklin, Patti Labelle....World has claimed all of them as the greatest singers...Range is nothing rather than what those singers I just mention above had....!!

    It's not worth me while arguing with the stubborn looser!!

  • It's so obvious that you've never listened to Georgia's songs. You haven't a cd of her and you don't know any song of her. Because if you had, you would know that she has got the strongest voice ever. Don't replay me anymore, please.

  • all three of these sexi mamis have got it, no doubt!

  • Christina <3

  • Aaliyahbrandymonica could u do any better than christina? I`m sure u can`t sing 1 note to save your pathetic life.The reason why she only has 3 albums is because she lives life for some time and write her own music rather than running to the hottest producers like all the others. U say chris will always be 2nd to brit, are u stupid chris is on a whole new level while brit is still way down there and as for ms carey today she sings alot of crap i mean touch my body wtf?