the moment the other aspect, which is music appreciation, is completely negated. Personal preferance is fine. I prefer DT over SG and Symphony X. Does this mean I hate Sg and SX? No. It just means I prefer DT's sound. If you really want to get niddy griddy about music composition on who is better, study all their albums, study creativity, theory used, chord structures, and everything else many people have a lack thereof in knowledge about.
Clearly, everyone here needs to have their minds reset.
So...
Here is the issue, the definition of comparing is distorted by people to the point where the word "compare" means to see who is better than another. Almost like to see who's balls are bigger. Since that is how the modern day and age think(sad right?) its almost assumed that is what compare means in terms of bands. So to clarify, to compare is to see any similiarities or differences. The moment is a ball size contest.... (cont)
if by comparing apples to cherries you make a useless point about the two which barely has anything to do with the topic it is supposedly related to, you are making it hopeless, then at any given time somebody somewhere may compare cherries to apples since by doing so it makes all hope lost. Yet at the same time they can't since not all hope has been lost before they do compare them.
The new lead singer is alright. Not nearly as powerful as Mike Baker was. Though, this is the first album without the lovely Mike behind the microphone. RIP Mike. Your legacy is not left behind.
Do I really read comparisons with SG and DT?! I hate it... comparisons are just the attempt of people to strongen weak ideas. Especially comparing apples and cherries; they are both from the same type (fruits), but they differ. Do you compare them? No! Only when all means are lost.
@MIND4eva I can compare cherries and apples just fine. Cherries have more of a bite, but are softer to chew on than apples. Also apples are more of a meal than cherries, those are more for snacking.
If one cannot compare bands with each other, than there´s no way to say if a band makes good music. Of course to a certain point they are incomparable, but let´s face it: This song sounds like DT with Queen influences.
@puddingball Finally somebody said it. It seems that nowadays people don't know what 'compare' means anymore. Only if things are different there is a point in comparing at all. It does not mean to equalize, it means to make out differences.
I feel so bad to hear that the singer of this group passed away though. My heart goes out to the friends and family he left behind. I feel like poop now.
I feel so bad to hear that the singer of this group passed away though. My heart goes out to the friends and family he left behind. I feel like poop now.
It took me long enough to accept DreamTheaters singer, but goodness there is no way I can get by these vocals. The musicians sounds pretty good though.
great song, also good vocals, brian ashland's vocal's sometimes remind me of geoff tate of queensryche. Btw, this song is far better than under a glass moon by dream theater, although that is a good song as well. such power and emotion in this song, a masterpiece!
@dicktravolta I mean...dude writes some solid melodies, and hes got the range...I just really dont like the tonal quality of his voice, it sounds like hes got a stick up his ass to me... I mean, I know he's a solid vocalist, I cant in good conscious argue that, but I really dont dig him...personal taste
Why is Dream Theater ALWAYS a topic when listening to ANY progressive metal band? Why?
yournotjohn 4 days ago
They are all fantastic bands. Lets not stoop to the level of 8 year olds fighting over small things.
Appreciate SG, DT, and Symph X, they deserve it greatly for the music they put out there for all of us to listen too.
Cheers Everyone~
Shreddfase 3 weeks ago
@Shreddfase I so agree with you!!! Shadow Gallery, Dream Theater, and Symphony X are my three favorite bands!
SGRev1 1 week ago
the moment the other aspect, which is music appreciation, is completely negated. Personal preferance is fine. I prefer DT over SG and Symphony X. Does this mean I hate Sg and SX? No. It just means I prefer DT's sound. If you really want to get niddy griddy about music composition on who is better, study all their albums, study creativity, theory used, chord structures, and everything else many people have a lack thereof in knowledge about.
So, lets share opinions, not argue.
Shreddfase 3 weeks ago
Clearly, everyone here needs to have their minds reset.
So...
Here is the issue, the definition of comparing is distorted by people to the point where the word "compare" means to see who is better than another. Almost like to see who's balls are bigger. Since that is how the modern day and age think(sad right?) its almost assumed that is what compare means in terms of bands. So to clarify, to compare is to see any similiarities or differences. The moment is a ball size contest.... (cont)
Shreddfase 3 weeks ago
@puddingball
really? You had to actually compare cherries and apples...? Clearly all hope is lost.
@MIND4eva
if by comparing apples to cherries you make a useless point about the two which barely has anything to do with the topic it is supposedly related to, you are making it hopeless, then at any given time somebody somewhere may compare cherries to apples since by doing so it makes all hope lost. Yet at the same time they can't since not all hope has been lost before they do compare them.
NotessimoGod 2 months ago
Comment removed
NotessimoGod 2 months ago
Comment removed
NotessimoGod 2 months ago
Comment removed
NotessimoGod 2 months ago
need more of this band!
GodheadsDamnation 6 months ago
The new lead singer is alright. Not nearly as powerful as Mike Baker was. Though, this is the first album without the lovely Mike behind the microphone. RIP Mike. Your legacy is not left behind.
revolvingdoorholder 9 months ago
suenan bien los muchachos
iulaises9 1 year ago
WOW! This was my first time listening to SG, and I'm floored!
Evilvengeance666 1 year ago
Do I really read comparisons with SG and DT?! I hate it... comparisons are just the attempt of people to strongen weak ideas. Especially comparing apples and cherries; they are both from the same type (fruits), but they differ. Do you compare them? No! Only when all means are lost.
MIND4eva 1 year ago 8
@MIND4eva I agree! People should judge music for what it is, rather than comparing it with other music
kobana23 5 months ago
@MIND4eva I can compare cherries and apples just fine. Cherries have more of a bite, but are softer to chew on than apples. Also apples are more of a meal than cherries, those are more for snacking.
If one cannot compare bands with each other, than there´s no way to say if a band makes good music. Of course to a certain point they are incomparable, but let´s face it: This song sounds like DT with Queen influences.
puddingball 5 months ago 3
@puddingball Finally somebody said it. It seems that nowadays people don't know what 'compare' means anymore. Only if things are different there is a point in comparing at all. It does not mean to equalize, it means to make out differences.
ZGoten 2 months ago
Don't touch me "Tyranny"
I'm waiting them in Italy, next 6th october 2010
thecoroner75 1 year ago
this is not the best album but i think is a great comeback!!
kardios 1 year ago
I feel so bad to hear that the singer of this group passed away though. My heart goes out to the friends and family he left behind. I feel like poop now.
ForeverLacey09 1 year ago
I feel so bad to hear that the singer of this group passed away though. My heart goes out to the friends and family he left behind. I feel like poop now.
ForeverLacey09 1 year ago
It took me long enough to accept DreamTheaters singer, but goodness there is no way I can get by these vocals. The musicians sounds pretty good though.
ForeverLacey09 1 year ago
great song, also good vocals, brian ashland's vocal's sometimes remind me of geoff tate of queensryche. Btw, this song is far better than under a glass moon by dream theater, although that is a good song as well. such power and emotion in this song, a masterpiece!
SLQWERTY 2 years ago
i love shadow gallery, but c'mom dude this song is not "far better" than Under a Glass Moon.
awilds02 2 years ago 15
@awilds02 I beg to differ. I like this song more...it has more emotion. And their singer isn't a bitch.
MetallicaBLS 1 year ago
@MetallicaBLS Really dude...are you saying James Labrie is a bitch?
I have to hear more of your argument because that statement holds no water!
Both are great bands with prgressive styles that are different!
dicktravolta 1 year ago
@dicktravolta I mean...dude writes some solid melodies, and hes got the range...I just really dont like the tonal quality of his voice, it sounds like hes got a stick up his ass to me... I mean, I know he's a solid vocalist, I cant in good conscious argue that, but I really dont dig him...personal taste
MetallicaBLS 1 year ago
@awilds02 Yea that'd be like saying Pull Me Under is better than Stiletto in the Sand!
MikeToddOnline 10 months ago
The singer almost sounds like Tobais Sammet.xD
SpartanLaserCanon 2 years ago
uff what a bad NEWS about MIKE BAKER PASSED AWAY. . . I really miss his voice. . . to him on heaven RIP
rubendrakkar 2 years ago
Fucking awesome. I thought they broke up after the passing away of their singer (RIP). But Im amazed they still produce those master-pieces :D!!!
Haldirchan 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
The first 2 minutes of this song are a cover of Dream Theater's "Under a glass moon".... shame....
katdna 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Only shame on this video is you.
DogThatRoars4Fire93 2 years ago
lol under a glass moon no dream theater is good too i think b etter but this is absolutly not drema theater
Kahn2580 2 years ago
@katdna Well, I can see how you might thinks so..... The rhythm's are vaguely the same, I guess..... A bit of a stretch, though.
anotherdrummer23 1 year ago
great band great song, this album is problably the better of their careers.
adio845 2 years ago
maravilhoso....shadow gallery
rickerbs 2 years ago