Added: 4 years ago
From: JackMcConnell
Views: 146,566
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (369)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • She's gorgeous and she should have won! liek this if you agree!

  • ukh.. what it is? forever, nicole is the best..

  • Song selection was a scam

    They gave Asia a more exciting song with a dance number & slow song to Melissa so they could say she doesn't dance.

    CMON! Asia is not THAT much of a great dancer. besides i think her face is weird

    Asia sings terribly.She's just a backup dancer....liek...made to be far to the back

    Melissa was much more talented, but indeed the chance that she would outshine Nicole was high, but I dont think Nicole liked the final result after all, she hugged Asia with an stoic face.

  • いい艶の黒革手袋!!

  • noooooo she should have won best voice and prettiest!!!!

  • Yup, she looked like Nicole thus didnt win.

  • she is so pretty!

  • Still cheesed after three years that she didn't win.

  • There's too many pussycat dolls anyway. Arent there like 15 of them? The rest of the girls are barely even in the videos because all the shots are focused on nicole. The sad part is that nicole tried a solo career and didn't make it so she went back to being a pussycat doll. Nicole is beautiful but that hasn't helped her stand out by herself.

  • She so should've won.

  • Im so pissed that she didn't make it

    Asia shouldn't have won

    she knew this meant giving up time with her baby and she didn't deserve the spot.

    Also, they were looking for a new nicole, Melissa people!

  • i heard she didnt win cause she looked to much like nicole, such bullshit

  • the only reason she didn't win is cause she can actually sing and hit amazing notes ...something none of the actual pussycat dolls can do :P

  • @101badsinger Yup. Anyway all these are in the past. The NEW PCD will be unveiled soon. The members are already finalised. All will sing and dance.

  • She shouldve won </3

  • she ddnt win coz robin said she looks like nicole

  • 1:20

    Judge guy: She sings as good as Nicole

    Robin: I know

    Im just kidding but i seemed like he siad that

  • @SnSd9Rules

    You were kinda right, actually that guy said Melissa is BETTER than Nicole.

  • She looks too much like Nicole...

  • robin is sooo ugly! gah

  • Nicole is wayy better`

    ```

  • :/.. i think the reason she didnt make it to pcd was cuz she's rly soft.. i dunno.. Asia had that strong voice.. good or bad but i wont judge.. but she should make a solo album.. like.. now XDD

  • I have watched this video a million times in the past 3 years.

    THIS PERFORMANCE WAS PERFECTIONS-Melissa was amazing and for sure should have won.

    I love this performance sooooo much!!!!

  • MELISSA WAS GREAT!

  • When she speaks, she sounds like a girl

    When she sings, she sounds like a woman

    Melissa R, you are the best & you should have won !

  • She seriously should of won! D:

  • She seriously should have won!!

  • ik her i see her everyday at my school and at her house

  • y did they give her a boring/slow jam?

  • I know why she didn't win! Because she's asian....

  • i think that they made her look like Nicole on purpose during this performance so that they would have an excuse not to make her win. she was by far the best singer/dancer.

  • @anothergirl45 Chelsea is the best singer and Asia is the best dancer =="

  • Melissa should've won. But the pussycat dolls knew that Melissa would and can go solo. and be the lead singer. Shes pretty, & she has talent. Something that the pussycats don't have. Jealousy.Pitty. pitty. Melissa should've wonn.!

  • melissa didnt win because like the judges said shes like nicole,, but shes sooo much better. so they thought why not go for the least talented,, dats why they chose asia and that just bit them on ther asses. cause honestly melissa and chelsea are sooooooo much ore talented than asia!

  • shes so beautiful and talented.people like her makes us filipinos even proud to be pinoy!:D and yes she is a filipino:)

  • When I look at the lips of the man at 1:21, I can read "... Nicole" and Robyn answers "I know!!"

    That's why they didn't take her, owerver, she better alone than be a back vocal of Nicole!!

  • Comment removed

  • pecka fakt bomba

  • Man I love Melissa's body when she was on this show. Now she's too skinny and she has bangs which makes her look weird. But she is by far the most beautiful girl on Search for the Next Doll, both seasons :)

  • Wow , She's incredible ! I love her , haha , She should have won , Damn , Robin missed out on an awesome singer and dancer ! :)

  • i think melissa r wasn't picked cause she looks too similar to nicole...

  • she's fucking gorgeous!!!!!!

    thumbs up if you agree!!!!

  • Love her hairs!

  • Stickwitu is one of my favrite numbers of the pussycat dolls!!!

    She sings it sooooo good!!!

  • asia won because IF melissa did she would out shine nicole!!

  • Melissa R SHOULD have won, instead of Asia..

    Mel has a FEMALE voice, Asia looks disguisting and she sounds like a man! Plus Melissa R looks like Nicole anyway haha

  • @jenoshuaxo that's rude Asia did really good But Melissa R. Should of won

  • @jenoshuaxo how in the HELL does asia look like a man you FAG

  • @hoodsters15 if you read correctly, i wrote "she sounds like a man"

  • she's way cooler than any of the girls!

  • I like her more than Asia

  • this was boring. only because it sounds just like nicole. gosh she evn looks like nicole and thats annoyin. thats why asia won, she was different. she could have made a mark in the group

  • the only reason she didnt win is becuz she looks 2 much like nicole they wuddnt tell ha apart

  • She is Gorgeous : ]

  • i looove her!

    sigh its such a waste she didnt win...

    she could lead pcd if nicole ever left... did she? i heard they disbanded??

    and any1 know wat she's doing now?? i know she made a single? album quite a while ago.

  • I loved Melissa R until she said the comment about Asia going home to her daughter. Lost complete respect for her then,

    but she's still talented...

  • She should've won. Atleast she's not a quitter like Asia. What a waste!

  • yea. asia used the show to be solo. she never wanted to be in a group. and look where it got her NO WHERE! she hasn't been seen or heard from in years!!!

  • @kailynnmbaby shes signed with bad boy so shut da hell up nn + shes a model bitch shut da fuck up

  • that may be the case but we haven't seen or heard from her since this show. and she's on bad boy?? she will have a short lived career effin wit diddy. it's not that serious to tell me to shut the fuck up. i have my opinion and i can voice it if i choose to. if u dont like it. so be it. RELAX! it's just an opinion. u act like u know her or somethin.

  • @iaintthelady2messwit : Fckk youu tlkinn boutt , A quiterr ?

  • @iaintthelady2messwit

    be happy she lost, or she would be singing backupfor a group of 30 year old women.

  • @iaintthelady2messwit no because she is too short like the judges said in an interview and she looked too similar to nicole scherzinger's voice.

  • @iaintthelady2messwit u r so right! It's been like 2 months of competition and Asia quit, so Robin did all that work for Nothing! and the whole point was to find another doll :(

  • she's gorgeous!

  • She looks like Nicole...

  • Actually, when I first watched this, I was like

    WTH WHY DIDNT SHE WIN, SHES CLEARLY THE BEST

    But then I thought if she did win, her talent would just be hidden because in PCD, Nicole is ALWAYS singing and Melissa would just be a back up.

    Melissa can also dance her butt off if you look at her youtube clips and she can sing so i'm actually happy she didnt win.

  • i love her... MELISSA R!!!!

  • melissa shoulda won

  • yeh she looks exactly like nicole O.O

  • no lie tho...melissa r n asia kinda look alike 2 me...just a lil bit

  • Melissa has been my favorite sense the beginning!!

  • i think melissa should'a won. :/

  • She really seems like nicole!

    That's why she didn't won =/

    i love her singing..she's so emotive like in I Don't wanna miss a thing..

    she deserved to win...

  • actually in the end i thought it was a good thing she didn't win, cause she deserves a lot more than singing in the background of nicole scherzinger with the other dolls

  • you can see that the one guy judge whispers "she reminds me of nicole" to Robin. haha.

  • i really wanted her to win

    i was pissed when asia won

    like i liked asia to but i like melissa more

  • she luks just like nicole in this video

  • She seems like nicole:)

    That's why she didn't won

    but she is so sweet!

  • Chelsea should of won she was the best singer and melody from the pussycat dolls had no former dance training either

  • nahhh cuz she will have her own carrer with her voice

  • yeah but if chelsea won she wont be singing she'l be the back up dancers and she aint that good at dancing and melody is back up dancer aswell but i guess she picks dance up really quickly

  • I think Melissa R. really lost herself along the way. She started out really nice and friendly and willing to help other people. But by the end, she was agreeing to things that compromised her values and morals, she stopped caring about what her parents thought, she started fights with Asia. It was absolutely ridiculous... but she deserved to win.

  • jealoooooouuussssss!!!!!!!!!!!­!!!!!!!!!!!

    xD!

  • your just jealous tut tut tut

  • She's so beautiful! And her voice is absolutely amazing!! How could they pick Asia over her?

  • agreed, Melissa is WAY prettier..and can sing.. she would probably top Nicole..anyday =]

  • its just horrible she didnt win ,

    asia didn't deserve to .

    she should have just gone home to take care of her kid , melissa has a waaaaaay betttter voice

    i absolutley love her !

    and when they said asia's name in teh end i was truley angry .

  • buhht she wasn't picked cuhhs she looks like nicole! ]: buhht i agree! [:

  • Awsoome she's so talented compared to most asian girls No offense and i think she lost cause she would make nicole look bad

  • i like these gurls there so real well chelsey

  • omg she is nicole !!!!

  • wow is she mellisa r or nicole scherzinger?!

  • Woow she's really good. But I like Nicole's version offcourse more. But Melissa R is very Good.

  • Maybe she could sing a liiiiiiiiiiittle bit higher

  • shes prettier than vanessa hudgens

  • @ipid7798 vanessa hudgens is a slut!!

  • @ipid7798 AND sings better !

  • How in the hell did she not win? She freakin' kicked ass with this performance...

  • she was probly too good for PCD...in my opinion, she tops nicole

  • they dont want someone to replace nicole. If melissa won she wouldnt be a star anymore

  • omg this song is sooooo good sung by melissa. She reminds me of vanessa hudgenss.. :P

  • Just a thousand times better. :)

  • she is so pretty

  • melissa and chelsea were my favorites. :)

  • she or chelsea should've won.

    not asia

  • I wish Melissa Won!!!

    She tottally Deserved it

    Asia Is A Quitter!

  • I love love love melissa, I just think that there would be another nicole in the group if she got in. Melissa's better off doing her own thing. She'll make it big, considering the amount of fans she has now even though she didn't win.

  • she's beautiful.. but she looks more like vanessa hudgens than nicolee

  • she sounds just like nichole and looks a bit like her i think they didnt want somone who was so much like nichole

  • exactly.

  • she looks like vanessa anne hudgens as wel init

  • i wonder wat will happen if melissa signed up to become the next girlicious..like if she became one of them instead of one person from the group right now..i say she'll do great..but its hard..cuz girlicious is so awesome also..hmm...XD

  • I think why the judges pick asia is because she didn't have it all. If she had had it all, she would be the lead singer in PussyCat Dolls. & that's why they didn't pick Melissa cause if she got the part, they people would be begging for Melissa to be the lead singer. That would be sad for Nicole.

  • excellent..!:)

  • I liked Melissa but I didn't want her to a doll. I liked Asia she fit in great. zbesides Asia kinda had that paperazi personality that won't change I think Mel would have changed if she won.

  • omg, she so beautiful <3

  • Asia stoped with the dolls for her daughter she had a chance to be a pussycat doll bud she dind't

    so she take away the chance for Melissa, who maby was right now in the group..

    Iloveuu Melissa! =D

  • i still dont get it asia knew she had a daughter why did she quit when she won

  • what episode was this on? cuz heres her solo wheres asias and chealses?

  • this was on the finale. Asia sang I Don't Need a Man & Chelsea sang Feeling Good ... flawlessly ^^

  • she look like nicole and vannessa OMG!!!

  • She could not have been in PCD because she looks too much like Nicole.Chelsea should have one,she was tall like the PCD and she sang well.

  • She should have won.

    She would actually stick with PCD.

    Not like Asia.

  • OMG i cant belive they picked asia! like what is WRONG with them!! (&&shes not even a part of the group anymore) this sounds even better then nicole!

  • The performance of a lifetime!

    Amazing!

  • see looks like vanessa

  • She and vanessa hudgens really do look alike!!

  • better than nicole *-*

  • she is very pretty and also she has a great voice

  • she should have won

    fuck asia

  • HAHAH !

    so fuckin tru !

  • asias voice makes my ears bleed

    and shes not even part of pcd

  • SOUNDS LIKE NICOLE...

  • no she sounds better

  • they should replace nichole with this chic! =]

  • shes so beautiful ;(

    and she sounds so great!

  • she's good she should like asia is like if she's not ready she shouldn't enter the next pcd

  • omg she is amazing she looks and sound s like nicole

    xxx:)

  • is it just me or does she look like Nicole from the pussycat dolls?

  • ESPECIALLY inthis one she looks aLOT like her. In other ones she can make her own like identity but here itsa lot the same

  • awh, i really enjoyed this performance (:

  • fucn asia shudda fucn lost n melissa shudda won shit asia aint even in the group cuz she back down!

  • Check out my recent dance vids pcd, neyo and britney fans!

  • Comment removed

  • If u read Ron's lips at 1:23 he says, "She sounds almost like Nicole."

  • haha how did you figure that out?? lol

    good job.

  • you are very good at reading lips

  • she didnt win because shes the best,

    her talent wouldnt show. iit wud be in the backround.

  • ugh;asia SUCKS![the girl]

  • they should give her the offer! love her,very talented! good luck MELISSA ^_^

  • yh+ she's like Nicole lol shes good i liked it

  • she´s like nicole scherzinger

  • She's the best! :D

  • Check out my britney freestylin' vid-thanks! Love Melissa!

  • im sorry, but this girl is amazing she should have won the other girl was no where near talelented as melissa this girl is amazing!

  • you can't compare her with nicole cuz they both good, but i like melissa better cuz i just do :)

  • she was the best of thoose 3 left, i was disapointed when asia won...

  • She's beautiful !!! And she looks so much like Nicole :O she should have won!!

  • shes beautiful ! how could they not chose her???? shes young,beautiful,classy,hot and sounds great !

  • I LOVE HER! HOTTIE!

  • i think melissa is better than nicole.

    she did and looked amazing. (:

  • she sounds like nicole shezinger abit!!!:]

  • love this version more than pcd version :)

    but still love the pcd!

  • this is soooooooooooooo much bettah than the original i think :DDD

  • she should have won or the other melissa they were both my fave and aisa dident even go in the group

  • at 1:22 ..."she looks just like nicole!" "i know!" lol btw shes so talented.

  • You don't see her at 1:22 retart

  • shes talking about what the judges are saying? get in the loop hun

  • She's talking about what the judges said at 1:22 lol.

  • what is on her hands??

    someone reply plz :)

  • gloves?

  • glove honey lol

  • I love Melissa R yeeeeeeee!!!