Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (1,980)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I think she has a truly beautiful tone. I like this version a lot. However, I think Adele can put much more her heart when she sing this. It seems, to me, more chilling when the original singer sings it.

    It's my point of view, but I have to admit that she's got a great kind of voice...

    I didn't talk about the music, but it's just amazing <3  (:

  • I like this version, however I still feel that the best performer for this song is the original artist, Adele.

  • Slick, original rendition!

  • Sexy voice

  • This is very awesome! Well done! The vocalist is wonderful! She totally put her own vocal style to this song! She kind of reminds me of Norah Jones if Norah Jones was a soprano. Very good!

  • its more beautiful than original

    sooooooooooo beautifull

  • Might be the first cover where someone - at last - doesn't try to be a 2nd Adele. Thank you for giving my ears a pleasure to listen to "Rolling in the Deep"!!

  • Wonderful :)

  • Amanda is cool (and HOT :p ) as she didnt try to be the 'second' Adele and tried to sing this song with her own style but still , adele is still the COOL-EST ! but ThePianoGuys is much superbly-cool-awsome! <3

  • The girl can sing. It is a nice voice. A very weak voice. She won't be necessarily be filling arenas until she either gains confidence or power, but she has potential.

  • @Mchenrjld pffftt if you didn't get chills listening to her sing there's something wrong with you

  • @misshevyn01 Did I not say that she could sing. "She has potential." But yes, say I am messed up because I wasn't floored by her performance. That's the mature reaction!

  • @Mchenrjld i completely agree with you, she could sing really good, but it didn't efect me in such a way to fall in love with her tone

  • Wooooooooooouuuuuu, que se puede decir sino más que te toca las más intima de las fibras.

    Saludos desde Chile. Jaime Bobadilla S.

  • Amanda has a more classy voice than Adele. While I would normally prefer that, this song is far from 'classy'. It's more of a saddened woman trying to make sense of a bad situation which, to anyone who's dealt with an emotional woman, is far from classy. Adele's voice just matches the feel of the song so much better. However, I do prefer this version because of ThePianoGuys' amazing rendition.

  • Girl, please - Adele knocks your soul free version out of the water.

  • yeaaaaaahhhh

    I love !!!!

  • amazing !!! 10 10 10 

  • Love this song. Can't stop listening.

  • should play break your heart

  • what I like in Amanda`s performance is that she didn`t try to copy Adele but she sung the song like it should be sang : Sad not furious ...

  • This is such a hard song to cover 'cause most musicians try too hard to sound like Adele.

    Love her singing this song, very emotional, I had goosebumps and almost cried

  • try covering artic monkeys

  • I LOVE Adele, she's my fav artist.

    But honestly, I like Amanda's version better.. it suits the music :)

  • THIS IS CRIMINAL!!!! MINT

  • the singer is amazing! she sounds soo good and has such control over her voice. and shes pretty :) Great job guys, your stuff sounds amazing!

  • this is such a different style >< cant describe with words..

  • Оригинально и очень Классно !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Спасибо .

  • I had never heard of Adele this song until I listened to your cover. Aside from having this loaded on my MP3 player to listen to at work, I also bought Adele's album. Thank you for playing such wonderful music with such incredible skill and devotion to your craft. And thank you for continuously broadening my horizons.

  • You guys should make more Adele songs! it would be awesome!

  • This is actually nice keep going won't you guys would like any special guest like the artist itself to sing ?

  • That Linkin Park cover is SHIT. Chester, THIS is textbook.

  • perfect version! not heavy but relaxing

  • Definitely prefer Adele singing this song. This version is just lighter, and I think I like a deeper, darker tone for this song.

  • Ew shutup top comment. This is so much more better than the original. I personally think Adele is shit. But the Piano Guys make her song so much more better.

  • Totally disagree with the top rated comment. I love Adele, but goddamn, that woman rocked it!

  • @DoubleDoppel

    And I totally disagree with you. That's a soul/blues song. Amanda Scot turns it into a pop. When singing blues you have to pull secondary tones down. Being perfectly tuned with the secondary tones doesn't make it better. I hated the vocal part because it destroyed any soul characteristics this song has.

  • Where is this being shot? I love the space. Any one have any idea what venue this is?

  • @Freck1886 Remember looking the information below the video, they usually put that in there. This place is:

    SunRiver St. George Community Center

    4275 S. Country Club Dr.

    St. George, UT 84790

  • nice and clean cover, atleast i could understand the text is version

  • wow... great cover! you really made your own version and i love this way to cover a song...

    even if adele put much more expression to all this..

    but you're not adele so it actually doesn't matter.

    keep on!

  • This is the Noble version of the song :)

  • *-*

  • I don't know why!! but i really love this version more than Adele original one ... Great job guys

  • I like her interpretation... she put some personality to the song. Arrangements: no words. Love them

  • i find that shiny hardwood floor very sexy.

  • great arrangement - lovely vocals - just discovered these guys - what a sound!

  • Like u r slow on the singing a little faster and that's how I get it ok but so great love ya awsome

  • Hermoso

  • best cover i have heard so far!!!! BY FAR! I LIKE IT MORE THEN THE ORIGONAL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Best vocal cover I have heard of this song: /watch?v=DBWUZESTmII&feature=p­lcp&context=C3e1c6dcUDOEgsToPD­skKm5W9CpWHXjkDijRCsQ-MJ

  • Yah !

    The version of Adele bores me to be honest.

    I like this version tho ^^

    This sounds somewhat more active :D

  • 321 thought it's dis-i-like button! :D sorry guys :D

  • I litsen to song a few times a day. She sings it better than the original. Just my thoughts.

  • Fantastic!!!

  • one m0:00re time

  • Luv it *-*

  • Nah... Sorry... (n) =/

  • amanda scott has a unique voice, you guys should make another video with her :)

  • not bad, but i still prefer linkin parks cover of this song.

  • I love you guys for sharing your talents to people!I mean like people love it when they see someone play the piano or any other instrument that good.Isn't it just so beautiful?!Amanda,you have a really great voice!!I don't know why you guys are still here making videos and not out there having an awesome time being famous.Although,I'd rather have you guys here doing videos too. :) x

  • always compare with original.. come on man.. without the original.. this cover dont even exist.. zzz just enjoy..

  • @ThePianoGuys please one more song with Amanda.

    Thank you for make listening this a real sensation!

  • Awesome...loved it...everything was well balanced and the singer was great.

  • better than the original! ;)

  • I don't think she has any feet. o.o;

  • QUE CREACIÒN!!!...ME ENCANTA!!, ESPECTACULAR!!!...

  • better than original

  • you know a cover is good when you get the shivers

  • @DarkBoonEspardo and i dont get them i dont like how she sings its kinda posh and that doesnt fit well to this song

  • @mousy32

    everyones entitled to their own opinion as long as its not harsh and doesnt make other people feel bad so im all for you not liking it its your opinion.

  • THESE PEOPLE ARE AMAZING!!!! GENIUS!! PURE EPICNESS!!! TOTALLY LEGIT!! ALL SWAG!!! (any body not get the message? Just listen to the video)

  • Love this! So sweet and sad at the same time. It almost makes me want to cry cause I feel your heartbreak!

  • If this gets played on the radio then no one will ever listen to the Adele version ever again. Just like Peponi you guys did it better.

  • @JcXtreme72 Nah Adele sings her songs with real passion,anger,resentment,she pours her heart in it while this doesn't have that much emotions attached to it :P

  • love this :x

  • I choose Adele... In my opinion Adele's voice is .. AWESOME!

  • Amanda sings it better than Adele, I think. :)

  • Finally, I can understand the words + the emotion. Lovely.  Thanks!

  • They don't just do music, they do music justice!

  • A hundred million times better than the original

  • The vazquez sound not compares with this , THIS IS GREAT!!!

  • Esta canción tiene muchos covers pero esta chica lo hace a la parfección

  • @jffilms2010 no penso... la altura es demasiado alto... la altura bajo es fundamental. Y esta chica canta demasiado rápido en algunas partes... parfección? No. Muy bueno? Sí.

  • But what beautiful voice! i love her voice , apart of adele.

  • It is an incredibly elegant version. Brilliant!

  • So much better than then original -.- Omgeh LOL

  • :D

    

  • i really love this song:X:X

  • I feel that this is a more elegant version of the song and they chose the right singer.

  • Great video but Adele makes it sound so much deeper (literally and figuratively). I love you guys as always though the instruments only are perfect. She is a good singer too but I feel she would do better in other songs. Please don't hate my comment I'm just saying what I think I still love them.

  • This is a classic example of how people have a hard time with anything new.

  • @GAMESTOPxLOVER Hey, your entiteled to your opinion, but honestly I really think that this version of the song so much better. Adele's is dark (the video makes it even more so) and while I'm sure this wasn't meant to be a happy song, the video and vocals in this one really make it far more enjoyable in my opinion. And the instrumental arrangement here is sooooooo much better. Adele should hire these guys to arrange her next song instead of whoever she's using...

  • Holst! The Planets! Jupiter, the Bringer of Jollity!

  • Mitici! Stupendi!!

    ---SongMan---

  • she is a beautiful great singer. :)

  • I don't know why, but when I listen this I cry. THAT'S SO AMAZING!!

  • Chills... 

  • By the way, the video is good anyway. She's a very good singer!

  • The voice doesn't make the song. The artist makes it.

  • Don't forget that Adele has invented the song. If the song is good, that's because of her. Now, someone else can sing it and do it better than Adele. However, she's still the songwriter of that song.

  • Whenever people try to sing Adele's song, they try to make their voice sound like her voice and it sounds really bad. I love she uses her own voice.

  • the editor is a god.... wow.....

  • Its will be more AMAZING if the singer is Adele... =)

  • I would like to hear "The beauty of the Cross" and "More Beautiful You" both are by Jonny Diaz.

  • Singer:

    She's ok. I think Adele is amazing, though, and after hearing the real version... she's just not as good. Also, @tiffanyalvord has a much better cover of this song.

  • i wish i could sing this song with the piano guys

  • who spilled kool-aid in the likes bar?

  • Comment removed

  • good, but the suckish singer ruins it

  • I am Brazilian, and I found wonderful, it makes you want to sing with you, and if there is an opportunity, you can count on me.

    Congratulations!

  • The best cover on youtube, or anywhere in fact. Like always with the piano guys!

  • Grat Love it so much

  • wow *__* wounderfull better then the original song :)) and she sings very very good.

    Well done. !! I love it (:

  • Amazing choreography, music and video skills!

  • Lol I play the violin xD

  • to compare her vocals to adeles would be cruel, but the music is phenomanal

  • @wozthedevil you can appreciate the music without making a negative comment toward the singer. I thought that each version had their own special touch and that they each focused on a different emotion in their song.

  • I heard the original version yesterday on radio, and I started singing to it. Midway I finally noticed that something was wrong. Then I realiced, that I had been singing it in this version! But oh well, I love this version much more than I do the original, so I went on : D <3

  • the beauty of real music

  • When Adele sings it it sounds angry, when Amanda sings it, it sounds really sad and heartbroken (in a good way)

  • @FlugelHorn117 fapfapfapfap

  • No way...Amanda singging looks like an adolescent that broke with her one week boyfriend. I liked the video, but the instrumental is much better, Adele put lots more of emotion on it !

  • @FlugelHorn117 adele wrote it because her boyfriend basically dumped her that was the whole insperation to her album 21.

    9/11 was an inside job

    ron paul for president

  • @chimichonga59 AGREED 100%!!!!!!!!! :D

  • @FlugelHorn117 Adele sounds angry because...well, have you listened to the lyrics? It's an emotionally charged song...an "angry" song. She's hurt and feels used. That's enough to make anyone angry.

    Both Amanda and Adele are amazingly talented in their personally unique ways. :)

  • @FlugelHorn117 To me it does not sound angry (the adele version) To me it sounds like belting tears so to speak

  • Her voice sounds like it belongs in some time decades ago... its AWESONE!

  • muy buenos los intrumentos pero sinceramente no me gusta la voz, casi llegando al final mas que arreglo parece que desafina totalmente, queda pésimo. Prefiero totalmente la versión de Adele y sin ofender hasta de la nena (los vazquez) que canta la canción a que esta versión. He escuchado también la versión sin vocalista y eso si suena muy bien.

  • @sopeconpelos como se nota que no sabes nada de musica

  • @helenagpy

    pues yo creo que aunque la música instrumental está mejor, está mejor la voz en la original o incluso la de Vázquez, ojo, yo no he dicho que esta este mal, está muy bien pero sinceramente, en lo que respecta a la música vocal no termina de convencerme esta canción

    por vocal me refiero a la voz principal

  • @helenagpy pues como se nota que tu sabes menos aun ;)

  • This is one of the most beautiful cover I have ever heard ...

    C'est une des plus belle reprises que j'ai jamais entendue ...

  • Okay, so, she doesn't have the talent Adele has, but her voice suites Adele's music better than Adele herself singing it.

    Great cover Amanda. I hope to hear your talent more and more. :)

  • I FRIGGIN LOVE THIS!!

  • she is awesome and the piano guys are awesome just found new channel for music yeah!!!

  • Killer vocals! :O

  • Fukc man i fukcn love her fukcn voice and she is beautiful no fukcn lie.. Damn i would fukcn love to make a song with her :)

  • also is that jupiter in the beginning?

  • Damn this woman has a nice voice. Terrific job piano guys & amanda

  • She's so beautiful !! So is the music

  • Comment removed

  • te corres con su voz!!!

  • but i won't say that this is bad, cause i like your cover.!

  • 1 fact; there is only 1 woman who can sing this perfectly and that is adele. ;p

  • @melissa75523 you do realize what a 'cover' is about, yes? By all means love Adele's original BEST! A cover is about a different style and perspective

  • i want to learn to play the cello now :)

  • @dharokio ditto!

  • GOSH THESE GUYS ARE SO FREAKIN GOOOOD! And they always accompany their instruments with really amazing vocalists! I absolutely adore this version! :)

    BRAVO!

  • Really nice girl.

  • I really liked Amanda's voice, I look forward to hearing her again, Amanda please do more covers. Texasroper

  • AMAZING! 

  • Gah!!! I loved this when he played Jupiter!!!!!

  • I'd use this song for my school music contest. Piano of cuz.

  • Great job! Congratulations!

    

  • May I use this song and version for my school's talent show? I would really like to use the instrument version....SO may I use this as music in my talent show?

  • It's called a 'cover' for a reason people. This isn't the original. In my opinion, it's as good, because they really did do justice for the great song sung by Adele. This girl tried her best to sound as good as Adele, yet add her own style to it. Don't hate or dislike this video just because you're a hardcover Adele fan. Accept that thepianoguys love Adele so much they decided to make this to show their gratitude.

  • What a great job to the piano guys and the vocalist in this video. absolutely outstanding job

  • I think Amanda has a beautiful voice. This rendition was great. I'll admit, I've never heard the original, but the song is still great!

  • They've mixed it in with i vow to be my country!

  • @TheZevans01 what is your country?

  • they change the tune slightly but they didnt change the main essence of the song. Good job :)

  • Ohhhh ...i love it .really new and nice cover

  • YAY!

  • Love the cover. Does the original GREAT justice.

  • It would be awesome to hear a cover of "She's not there" by Zombies. It seems it would be a fun song to make an instrumental out of, though I like the vocal version of "Glee" better than the original (different times, different tastes) :).

    There are so many songs I love that I would love to hear played by your amazing team, like "One in a million" Bosson, or "If today was your last day" Nickelback, or maybe "Almost lover" by A fine frenzy", or even "Hit the road, Jack".

  • I loved Amanda's voice, I would say it is unique; I liked very much how she sang, and I loved the cello and piano (as always).