The only thing "wrong" with Sorabji is that his music lies outside the traditional boundaries of harmony and melody. In a single word his music can be describe as "raw." It's like a wild tree that hadn't been cut down, sawn, sandpapered, and turned into a shiny piece of furniture -- raw, uncustomized.
@perhapsforever Uncostumized... So, if you'd customize it, how would you do it?
As for "outside the traditional boundaries of harmony and melody", I'd rather say this music pushes those boundaries, remaining - albeit barely - inside of them. A bit like Einstein, after having pushed the boundaries of physics, remains inside the boundaries of physics, albeit outside of those of "traditional", Newtonian physics. If J. S. Bach is the Newton of music, Sorabji resembles an Einstein, so to say.
Haha, it's weird but I actually know why it reminds me of christmas time. I used to listen to this as a kid when my mom used to drive me home from piano lessons (I always pictured myself playing it). The rainy weather with nightfall at 5:00pm fit the christmas lights on the small houses and dreary weather perfectly. I love this piece and this performance.
...and so was I when I learned and performed this monumental piece (without being neither "holy" nor "shit," though!) But it was indeed a 'trascendental' experience to master a work like this.
I know this is like the third time someone's asked this question in this thread, but where do you get sheet music for this piece? Am I literally going to have to contact Sandro Russo and ask him myself?
The only thing that bothers me is the sound the last note on the piano makes. It's like knocking on the wood because the piano is not regulated probably. SUCH BEAUTIFUL PERFORMANCE. I LOVE SORABJI.
Superb performance of an impossibly difficult piece. Sorabji writes often on five staves, and multiple voices sometimes up to five, challenge the pianist.
All of Sorabji's music is available in his Archive in Wales,. Alistair Hinton runs it. You can do an internet search, and find a complete catalogue.then just e mail the Archive.
THe archive is in Bath,England,actually. Both Sorabji and Busoni were musical visionaries,and their respective works based on Carmen have a similar dark, unquiet atmosphere-or a terrifying one,depending on one's own perception. Both were musicians of a titanic order.
Wow.I finaly hear some Sorabji.I hope there is some footage of John Ogdon playing anything.I know he cared for this composer ( Sorabji.) when he was still living in London .
Fab, if poster is player, kudos on you! It makes that horrid piece listenable to. Good playing!
mattgres 4 days ago
Wonderful playing! A great experience! Thank you so much Sandro Russo!
Pianifty 7 months ago in playlist Classical Music
I must confess, I'm not a huge fan of Sorabji's music, generally speaking. . .but this was a magnificent performance.
Bnjolly 9 months ago
Extremely enjoyable to listen, one of the only two pieces i 'Liked' and was extremely impressed with by Mr. Sorabji
Pianophile57 1 year ago
(mind you folks it's just my opinion) This is by far the best transcription made of the Carmen.
Lukecash12 2 years ago
The only thing "wrong" with Sorabji is that his music lies outside the traditional boundaries of harmony and melody. In a single word his music can be describe as "raw." It's like a wild tree that hadn't been cut down, sawn, sandpapered, and turned into a shiny piece of furniture -- raw, uncustomized.
perhapsforever 2 years ago
I don't know why this comment got -2 but "Hehe..." got +1.
sshuck 2 years ago
@perhapsforever Uncostumized... So, if you'd customize it, how would you do it?
As for "outside the traditional boundaries of harmony and melody", I'd rather say this music pushes those boundaries, remaining - albeit barely - inside of them. A bit like Einstein, after having pushed the boundaries of physics, remains inside the boundaries of physics, albeit outside of those of "traditional", Newtonian physics. If J. S. Bach is the Newton of music, Sorabji resembles an Einstein, so to say.
Pianifty 7 months ago in playlist Classical Music
Your opinion sounds crappy; LOL.
mdeonx16 2 years ago
Haha, it's weird but I actually know why it reminds me of christmas time. I used to listen to this as a kid when my mom used to drive me home from piano lessons (I always pictured myself playing it). The rainy weather with nightfall at 5:00pm fit the christmas lights on the small houses and dreary weather perfectly. I love this piece and this performance.
loltheworld 3 years ago
Seduction and passion's plea
Longing and rapture in reverie.
Thank you Sandro for these moments of musing.
RoseMarieRaccioppi 3 years ago 4
Hehe...
Reaper978 3 years ago
Holy shit... 4:00-4:20 is just crazy
georgecziffra 3 years ago
...and so was I when I learned and performed this monumental piece (without being neither "holy" nor "shit," though!) But it was indeed a 'trascendental' experience to master a work like this.
Sanrus 3 years ago 2
very well put, and i bet it was a very amusing piece to play! i love sorabji's pieces and the way they are sporadic and chaotic.
voxinunintelligable 2 years ago
very wonderful piece, intense and enchanting
OceansBoulevard 3 years ago 6
Is it weird that this reminds me of christmas-time?
loltheworld 3 years ago 2
wow sorabji is a genius
callenishss 3 years ago 6
sensitive and beautiful..
I like it very much!
risktakerdaito 3 years ago 4
Sandro, you play with such incredible sensitivity, gentleness and feeling.
I am always amazed at your virtuosity.
BytomGirl 3 years ago 3
Fucking AWESOME!!!
toneeeeeee 3 years ago 11
so far, this is the only Sorabji's work i understand...
Sorabji must be carzy...
rvn10rvn17 4 years ago
I know this is like the third time someone's asked this question in this thread, but where do you get sheet music for this piece? Am I literally going to have to contact Sandro Russo and ask him myself?
loltheworld 4 years ago
I can't say how much I love this piece...
aldebussy 4 years ago 2
The only thing that bothers me is the sound the last note on the piano makes. It's like knocking on the wood because the piano is not regulated probably. SUCH BEAUTIFUL PERFORMANCE. I LOVE SORABJI.
aldebussy 4 years ago
Comment removed
ExVash 3 years ago
i think sorabji was crazy.
LongDriveChamp03 4 years ago 7
I agree.
ultenth 4 years ago 3
so beautiful!!!! this needs an amazing pianist!!!!BRAVO!!
IloveAlexisBledel689 4 years ago 4
that slight pause at 4:56-4:57 sounds so cool.
LongDriveChamp03 4 years ago
Wow!! I would like to get that Sorabji's Pastiche no.2 to play this.
Great performance!
Alvarordonez 4 years ago
that ending part is pretty creepy sounding.
LongDriveChamp03 4 years ago
i've never heard the very bottom A used in a piano piece before. sounds cool.
LongDriveChamp03 4 years ago
Superb performance of an impossibly difficult piece. Sorabji writes often on five staves, and multiple voices sometimes up to five, challenge the pianist.
stephenTGV 4 years ago 2
Fantastic i love it
chrislwill86 4 years ago
All of Sorabji's music is available in his Archive in Wales,. Alistair Hinton runs it. You can do an internet search, and find a complete catalogue.then just e mail the Archive.
herma57 5 years ago
THe archive is in Bath,England,actually. Both Sorabji and Busoni were musical visionaries,and their respective works based on Carmen have a similar dark, unquiet atmosphere-or a terrifying one,depending on one's own perception. Both were musicians of a titanic order.
ric55 5 years ago
Does anyone know where I can get the sheet music/music notes for this piece?
sirvio666 5 years ago
Wow.I finaly hear some Sorabji.I hope there is some footage of John Ogdon playing anything.I know he cared for this composer ( Sorabji.) when he was still living in London .
lovesGenet 5 years ago
yay! any sorabji is impossible to play, lol.
im so amazed when anybody can perform his works well =)
ivrykeys 5 years ago
If this was posted by you, complimenti, Sandro!
Thracozaag 5 years ago
Only posted, NOT "played by" me??? Grazie mille, anyway!!
S.R.
Sanrus 5 years ago
Bravissimo! And, what an amazing piece. I first heard it played by Michael Habermann in 1982 or 3 in Baltimore.
jvinikour 5 years ago
Wicked piece.
KeithWhalen11 5 years ago
Best video on Youtube
damildlyshreddah 5 years ago
Thanks. Ive been looking for any video of Sorabji's works for ages!
Tom
tompilk 5 years ago