Added: 5 years ago
From: kingy17
Views: 3,712,234
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (5,491)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • i wonder how long simon spent thinking of that plan :P

  • Like if your watching this in 2012 ;)

  • This video proves to me anyone can live their dream, godbless you Leona

  • boy can she sing but i liked FAntasia Barrinos performance of this song better! ...you really feel the song when fantasia sang it!

  • truly an amazing singer, and im VERY hard to impress when it comes to mainstream "pop" singers. so so so so so talented. love her, wish she would make more music...

  • This is my favorite song. THE BEST PERFORMANCES EVER in any talent show!!!

    I love you Leona.

  • A great version of the single most covered song in music history.

  • I agree with the top comment, I saw this 5 years ago too and it still gives me goosebumps

  • Better than Fantasia, DEFINITELY better than stacy francis this performance is UNTOUCHABLE!!!

    love leona!! :D

  • Voting closed !!!!!!!!!!

  • BEST PERFORMANCE EVER!!!!!!

  • Christina Aguilera? xD

  • Beautiful and talented .. what a great package!!! Just love her!!

  • She's really a beautiful girl

  • For me, this one performance immortalized her and I've been a fan ever since. She really is untouchable.

  • If you get a chance, please take a look at my rendition of this song on my channel. Thanks x

  • wow I didnt  even hear about her tell I watched the x factor usa I was always voting for melanie I thought no one could compare untell I heard her damn I must live under a rock she is so good

  • leona has the voice of a angel she grew up in hackney where im from

  • after that performance i knew she would win the x factor, still gives me goosebumps even now, she is amazing in concert too =D

  • this is one of the best performances ever ! i love her reintrerpretation of this song ! AMAZING VOICE !

  • How is this even possible?! She is bending the limits of human vocal possibilities. She is my music idol <3

  • is this a joke? .. RIP Ella.

  • Many people see this as the performance that won her the show, even though this was the 3rd or 4th week

  • only Ella can sing Summertime. There is no sorrow here, so soul, no jazz..... just a 2006 tv sow. i'm sad.

  • @cicci0salsicci0 Nah, I think Ella's version is soulless and limp compared to Sarah Vaughan's and Carmen Mcrae's versions... Ella doesn't seem to have any distinctive vocal qualities.

  • Stacy Francis did it better lmfao!

  • now a day people on x factor are shit! Leona are the best ! no one could beat that!

  • 6:15 what a sweetheart

  • that shit just gave me goosebumps lol or maybe im just cold *shrugs* who knows

  • what makes me laugh is that every performance on the x factor 2011 receives a standing ovation and yet only Simon stood up! This is the type of performance that standing ovations should be reserved for not good kareoke like Marcus or Amelia lol

  • @sallybumbas she is awful

  • @sallybumbas  Agreed.

  • In my person opinion, this version of the song has no soul. Just another emotionless cover. She's got a good voice sure, but a good voice won't get you anywhere if there's no heart felt emotion. :/

  • @L0ver80y awkward how it did get her somewhere chief.......

  • Acojonante!!!

    

  • the singing is great but the original is a soft lullaby so i'm torn in between liking it and not liking it

  • @dahulkoliver well no one expects whitney to sing 'I will always love u' the Dolly Parton way...

  • Stacy francis's performance of this song was better.

  • Flawless!

  • a contestant with this performance?! She could just win in that week (week 3) lol

  • Love the way she sings 'cot-ton is hiiiiiigh'. Wish she'd let her hair go ringletty again. Stay true to your curls Leona!

  • who was the person who orginally sang this???

  • @TheShazababy the original is by George Gerschwin, from the musical 'Porgy And Bess'

  • @TheShazababy Janis Joplin

  • @Joujaification Completely incorrect.

  • @Joujaification don't you dare saying this ! she did sing this, but it comes from Gershwin's Porgy and Bess opera first.

  • SHE. IS. A.MA.ZING!!!!!

  • I am SPEECHLESS!

  • This performance is actually underrated... this should have been on the news like the few other talent show performances that was featured on the news... Leona is so freaking underrated I hate it!

  • amazing performance, like simon said... the x factor was so much more fun back then :(

  • Lord know I love Biliie Holidays version but this one blow me away I Love this version IT IS the best in my opinion of Summertime.

    

  • Really, I prefer the original song, that is sang by Sam Cooke, I am not saying that is a bad performance, because she sings like an angel but I love Sam Cooke and the original version is the best for me. Maybe Leona could have sung a similar version to the original.

  • are u serious...this is better than fantasia? i love me some leona n i think she did good on this song but she wasnt feeling it! Fantasia nailed this song by miles!!

  • She's brilliant in this, much beter than Fantasia

  • Good lord she is so unbelievably beautiful..

  • Best Talent TV show performance for all time..

  • Como Elle Fitzgerald ninguna... no le da el toque, lo siento. Tiene una gran voz, nada más, igual que Christina Aguilera.

    Like Elle Fitzgerald, no one... she doesn't quite fit, sorry. She have a powerful voice, nothing else, as Christina Aguilera.

  • 5 years on and still still blows me away. best ever performance on the x factor

  • @Hutette There are over 30,000 known recorded versions of "Summertime". It seems that the first singer who recorded it was Billie Holiday in 1936.

  • @sdavica7 and? I wasn't stupid enough to think Leona was the first person to sing it. It's a timeless song and this is the best x factor performance by anyone by a mile.

  • @Hutette Sorry. I made a mistake. My answer was to TheShazababy who said that the first who recorded this song was Janis Joplin.

  • The song starts at 1:41

  • singing the words,and tuneful- but she aint feelin it,she could be singin about jam, or shoes, or hamsters

  • Wow, she spoilt the song. Need to switch back to Sam Cooke to get back the soul.

  • I liked this video, can't say anything bad about her voice. Something about her voice just pierces me wrong, i just didn't like how she sang this song... I think her voice is higher than what i would like this song to be, it was too loud, where this song is very peaceful and easy going, and not energetic, like this rendition. OF COURSE HER VOICE IS AMAzing.... so don't say i said otherwise.

  • There is no one who can sing like Ella Fizgerald

  • MY GOD! This has to be one of the best performances on x factor! Amazing !! O.O

  • CHILLS THROUGHOUT THE HOLE SONG!!

  • I agree with the top comment.why in world, when she clearly has vocal talent like this does she churn out cheap autotuned songs? i guess this is the difference between a music industry drone that's in it for the album sales and real artists that.. while they won't say no(nor should they) to a few million bucks actually care about the music too..as for her rendition of this song.. i have to say it's the best female performance I've heard so far my fav. all time version is Sam Cooke's

  • This is really the best I've ever heard from her....incredible.

  • Best version by ANY artist period, effortless and amazing crisp clean vocals...

  • i like this but i think Fantasia's version is much better. i got the chill factor with her sitting in one place belting out the song

  • amazing version man whoo wee !

  • where are her shoes?? :D

  • Comment removed

  • 1:40 for the song

  • is she wearing shoes?

    ahah

  • WOW!

  • AMAZING!!!!!!!! Never will there be another on Xfactor that can sing like that.

  • First time I hear her. Very good. Nice eyes too.

  • i don't like the arrangement. 

  • leona did a beautiful job she was pitch perfect and controlled...on the other hand i felt like it lacked soul i know im not a music critic or anything but when i listen to the lyrics of summertime i hear the emotion i feel it and i felt like she just sung the song just because it was required.. still love u leona but i think fantasia told the story better

  • @grandviewloner Wow, thanks. You just summed up what I wanted to say. I don't like how people think that yelling it to the loudest and highest means it's the best. I mean, she has a good voice and all, but seriously, enough with the loud & high.

  • @loveydovey1ful I can't even think of a way to properly sum up the idiocy of your statement. I'm sitting here trying to figure out how to explain to you that vocal range is an integral part of singing, but I can't get over the fact that you're comment was basically that "singers shouldn't try anything hard"

  • If you want to judge on power and control then she has got to be one of the best people to sing this song, ever. BUT if you add the emotion to the equation (which you basically have to) then yea she drops down the list. This is still amazing though

  • her voice is nice but this song was never meant to be sung like this and there's a reason for it. all feeling is lost. this is an old bluesy style 'slave' song, for want of a better description, and she's jazzed it up to sound almost burlesque style. sounds very bond styled, but she's got too shallow a voice do give this song its true feeling! i know its a cover version, but still. i await your negative votes fanbase.

  • simon used the money for shoes to buy condoms offcoarse

  • I urge you to seriously listen to Sam Cooke singing this. Seriously!!!

  • can anyone tell why she doesnt have any shoes on?

  • @matisoul2011 She's poor.Shoes are a luxury.

  • @vicpur looks like expensive dress though lol she aint poor now!

  • Everybody has their opinion and can voice it... however I would love to see the 287 people who disliked this to stand on that podium and do better than Leona....just saying.....

  • Leona is good but Anita Baker, Ella Fitzgerald, Sarah Vaughn and Fantasia Barrino sang it much much better. You really have to have the SOUL to sing a song like this. Congratulations to Leona, but she still has a bunch of shoes to fill. Simon, although I like him very much, is sometimes full of bologna!

  • lol cheryl cole was in Idol :P......>"not been very good" tooo right!!!

  • She's to the X-factor what Kelly Clarkson was to Idol. Never will be anyone as good.

  • lol not wearing shoes :P

  • Lullaby? Anyone? Try putting a child to sleep with that. Poor sod would probably die from fright

  • Ok, no doubt Leona can sing and has AN AMAZING voice + i like bare-footed singers BUT this song was not meant to have such a vocal range, i still prefer Ella Fitzgerald's slow, deep lullaby

  • lol why did simon kiss sharon?

  • I wish people would have kept fkin quiet till the end!!! I dont like the studio version as much as this, damn audience.

  • This has to be the best performance of this song, by any artist, at any time..........purely beautiful.

  • This was amazing I got chills honestly I don't know why people are comparing versions though it is possible to like all versions (gasp)

  • 5:34... amazing

    

  • absolutly fantastic ,

  • Definitely the best contestant EVER! by my estimation. I am just so surprised that it took the X factor to bring her to light. She has become the benchmark as far as reality singing contestant is concerned. She blows me away everytime she sings. She's just spot on. And humble too.

  • Golden Girl. And she's still .. a girl, a young girl.

  • apart from over the rainbow there has never been a woman sing as good as that...and both are sung by leona ......shes so good what can i say...oh yes and i do know eva cassidey sang it but come on...........

  • well if i want goosebumps now i know where to come

  • WOW!! This performance gave me CHILLS!!

  • @kcl060 SAme here, her voice is amazing!

  • Summertime es una nana... esto suena a casi todo menos a dormir a un niño. Debería haber escogido otro tema para "soul-ear"... de resto, la chica es buena, desde luego!

  • Lewy: "I think its probably one of the best performances of the night."

    Understatement much? One of the best performances on UK x-factor of all time. Only rivalled by other Leona performances.

  • I don't understand why if she can sing like this, she is singing autotuned songs like collide! she has so so much talent and I love her, but her new stuff just doesnt do her justice :(

  • @L0tteJones

    It is a travesty to hear her doing some of the material she is doing, I was shocked to hear that collide song. We just don't hear performances like this one in her own material. Really is a shame.

  • @SamCoreJ it is her own material, it is not auto tuned and she told producers its what she wanted to do, she was tired of doing depressed songs, its on a youtube video, look it up :)

  • @elanieMB

    No one said Collide isn't her own material. I was referring to this x-factor video 'Summertime' as not being her own material. But all professional pop music productions will use some sort of vocal software to finely sculpture the vocal.

    It is interesting to know it was her decision to do Collide but it still doesn't change what I think of the track!

  • @SamCoreJ :)

  • @L0tteJones shes trying to appeal to a bigger crowd and right now this type of music isnt as popular sadly

  • @model16 I guess it's good that this is keeping her going, but it just seems such a waste of talent :/

  • @L0tteJones collide is definitely not auto tuned she said herself she'll never be auto tuned even though producers tried to push it on her, she doesn't want it, she said it makes her sound like a robot and she'll never do it, she rather not do the song at all

  • @L0tteJones I totally agree! She needs new writers or she needs writers, not to put down her new stuff and not being any good, she needs someone like me to write her hits.

  • @L0tteJones i suppose the idea of money and being the perfect popstar took over. :( but her live performances must still be exceptional!

  • Goosebumps

  • Janis Joplin does this with a million times more soul and affliction than this.

  • @LunaKissBand but does Joplin sing this with such power, melisma, range, liberation and technique? Nevermind the sexual tones she hits which make it a ton more of a passionate and mysterious ballad than ella or janis ever made it... Such a fantastic version. Leona ftw.

  • Sorry Fantasia killed this song

  • When she can sing like this why is Cowell forcing her to sing his manufactured shit- hot air from a Cowell when she can sing songs that will change the world!!

  • Comment removed

  • she used to look so much better back then when she was natural..she had her natural hair and nose and was stunning...hollywood messes up people's perception's of beauty!

  • she used to look so much better back then when she was natural..she had her natural hair and nose and was stunning...hollywood messes up people's perception's of beauty!

  • me likes

  • i did not like it

  • just sittin' here runnin'thru youtube stuff... this possibly is the best version of this song and very possibly the best xfactor performance to date.

  • @justeddi31 Well we cant all have good taste:D

  • I love coming back here to refresh why Leona Lewis is and will remain the best X factor contestant ever :)

  • /watch?v=NCDXCXiSLG0

  • Leona's nothing like Ella, but she's fine, i think.

  • Leona did it better...

  • he says "across IDOL, across any of these shows all the girls singers havnt been very good until now" simon i couldnt say it better mysekf. she sings better than fantasia, carrie, kelly, all of them! by far.

  • @BestBieberVideos Nahh Not Fantasia! Fantasia's version of Summertime is the BEST YET!

  • @BestBieberVideos Simons a contradiction..he echoed the same words to kelly and carrie.and to be fair...carrie has sold more records than leona..and so has kelly!!! they are both awesome..i do leona though...she is world class

  • @BestBieberVideos fantasia?

  • She is so pretty. Fantasia gave the song a more soulful sound, and Leona more sultry and jazzy. I love them BOTH SO MUCH :-D

  • is she wearing shoes?

  • I feel like throwing up

  • This is outstanding. Never heard it sung better than this

  • can't say anything but "WOW!!!!!!!!"

  • this best version EVER heard of this song

  • @MR0SQUIGGLEZ18 she is lovely but maybe its the only one uve heard? watch?v=iCaPno7QChY

  • lol she actually did pretty good on this one. She did this song justice, BUT to this day I have yet to hear someone sing summertime better then Sam Cooke 4/5

  • jesus cristo

    nao tem mariah nao tem cristina e outra diva internacional

    q bata a leona

    so um loco pra falar q leona nao cheega nos pes das divas

    vai cantar assim no meu ouvido

    

  • holy wow =] chills

  • yes she is

    a star

  • i remember watching this and getting chills, it still gives me chills now.Can't remember most of the performances on these talent shows but this one always stuck in my head.love leona shes a superstar no other winners have come close

  • Leona Lewis is definitely the best female singer in the world!!

  • amazing performance and amazing dress ;)

  • Comment removed

  • @SparkMyWorld who cares she was new then give her a break if she sang it now she would sing is better leona is more sucessful fantasia is gone and dusted

  • @IncredibleLyrics No arguments. I just stated facts. The arrangement is the same as Fantasia's, and she's even barefoot like Fantasia. Also, she sang that song with no soul, emotion, and authenticity of the "Porgy and Bess" play it came from---Fantasia did. And Leona has flopped on her 2nd album in the U.S. Fantasia made 4 million dollars last year---so I'll rather get unnoticed and make 4 million than get offended over the truth. Leona is my favorite new singer, but fact is fact! No offense!

  • @SparkMyWorld it maybe flopped in the us cause had no promo but done fine in the UK

  • Comment removed

  • @SparkMyWorld Fantasia is a US artist ofc shes more famous in the states comparing a UK artist who had 0 promo there and like wasnt around in the press all year ofc she had low sales

    Fantasia? is not even in my mind cause i could give to shits about her leona is a star who cracked the US which only a few have done cracking the UK is easy

  • @IncredibleLyrics Fantasia & Leona are equally known in their home countries. Leona is more relevant in the UK than Fantasia, because Tasia hardly gets mainstream promotion like Jennifer Hudson & Beyonce. Fantasia is targeted straight to r&b and adult contemporary markets. But, Tasia has a lot "industry veterans" who respects her talent, but her reputation in the public has been marred. Leona got bad promotion in the U.S. on her last cd, and so did Fantasia--except for the suicide attempt.

  • @SparkMyWorld fantasia has a great voice stop comparing :p idc which is better tbh i dont like the song

  • @IncredibleLyrics I'm done. I never compared the vocals. I just said Leona didn't stay true to "Porgy and Bess," but focused more on entertainment. You called Fantasia a flop, which was uncalled for, since she made 4 million dolllars last year---more than Kelly Clarkson.

  • @SparkMyWorld kelly flopped and making 4millon dollars in 1 year is not alot and idc about how much earns i care about album sales

  • @IncredibleLyrics How has Kelly flopped?

  • @IncredibleLyrics Leona cracked the U.S. because of Simon Cowell and the Mariah Carey buzz----from Simon Cowell, who got her booked on Oprah, and the popular morning shows. Even American artists don't get that kind of promotion.

  • @IncredibleLyrics Child, Fantasia will never be gone and dusted. Leona can sing but she always sound like she is in falsetto. Kelly kills her. Fantasia slays her. Just because Simon feels she is the greatest singer does not mean she is.

  • @JumperSC she is the greatest singer around now deal with it

  • @IncredibleLyrics She is talented, but nowhere near the greatest. Im not being rude but she's not

  • Comment removed

  • Five years on- this is still the best performance of anything, by anyone. Ever. 3.22 - 4.05 is staggeringly good.

  • you can tell she wants to win!! :) lol