The percussion on this hymn, I am sad to say, is not totally appropriate.
The Point of Music is not to sound like other music.
Did you all listen to this for historical knowledge, or for the music itself ? Historically accurate or not, I cannot hear over the noise, and can barely help from cracking up. As they say, if historical singers ran off a cliff, would you ?
This is one of my favorite non liturgical hymns, and I am glad to see it getting around. Merry Christmas ! ( gaudeetee ? )
it seems to be choir directors in general that want very nice pices of music to be spoiled by the introduction of african drums tambourines, triangle etc.
It's totally appropriate to use drums, etc. while singing this Medieval/Renaissance Christmas song. Drums and other instruments were used in some parish church festival music, and also at non-church festivals where music like this still would have been sung. The carol comes from a Benedictine hymnal, and monks would have sung is more like chant.
I like the percussion, but they could have done more with the song's characteristic of simple meter. To see what I mean, listen to the Sixteen perform it. Their performance, I think, is the best I've ever heard.
i did this song for county chorus my junior year... i love it... i wish there where men here...but the instruments make up for it lol... wonderful and beautifully done... love the organ but isn't this usually done a capella just curious.
Very nice!
SiggyStern 5 months ago
I loved the voices, but I think that to be perfect those percussion instrumentals should not be used, after all, wasn´t in a Holy Mass?
alonelychild 1 year ago
The percussion on this hymn, I am sad to say, is not totally appropriate.
The Point of Music is not to sound like other music.
Did you all listen to this for historical knowledge, or for the music itself ? Historically accurate or not, I cannot hear over the noise, and can barely help from cracking up. As they say, if historical singers ran off a cliff, would you ?
This is one of my favorite non liturgical hymns, and I am glad to see it getting around. Merry Christmas ! ( gaudeetee ? )
AndrosRex 1 year ago
This is pretty good for high school girls. I wanna this track
origen01 1 year ago
Gr8!
issueagent 2 years ago
Beautiful performance!
synballein70 2 years ago
Very nice, even the tambourine, but what on earth happend to the Organ at 2:10 thats awful...
Annomalie 2 years ago
very good version ... very clear ^^ so cool
Quader4x4 2 years ago
I love their version but their pronunciation on the Solo's is a bit off. But one of the best version on here.
iloveyu4eva 2 years ago
magnificooooooo!!!
amoxicillina82 3 years ago 2
What a shame someone said "lets get some bongos and tambourines". This carol, done as beautifully as this, needs to be a capella.
diddydiddycool 3 years ago 7
Yeah, other than that it's pretty darn good.
shamraig 3 years ago
I didn't think it was too bad, I actually liked it, really. I just wish I could hear it better, but it's still really nice.
FireRupee 2 years ago
it seems to be choir directors in general that want very nice pices of music to be spoiled by the introduction of african drums tambourines, triangle etc.
roberwael05 2 years ago
@roberwael05
It's totally appropriate to use drums, etc. while singing this Medieval/Renaissance Christmas song. Drums and other instruments were used in some parish church festival music, and also at non-church festivals where music like this still would have been sung. The carol comes from a Benedictine hymnal, and monks would have sung is more like chant.
lichtbroeder 1 year ago
@diddydiddycool
It is not a-liturgical, drums were used in Medieval times to happy festivities, that kind of drums, of course!
Loiginer 1 year ago
@diddydiddycool watch Libera's version- it has a drum and recorder but it sounds brilliant (the 2008 version)
chocchipcookiegirl 4 months ago
I recently performed it. I got to solo verse 3! yay!
SurreyViolinHero 3 years ago 2
omg performed this song last year with my choir..they did and excellent job!!
hotladie09 3 years ago 2
I have sung here.
Almost positive.
Choir trip last spring break.
mega777 3 years ago
beautiful!! love the soloists
Arabesque173846 3 years ago 2
I like the percussion, but they could have done more with the song's characteristic of simple meter. To see what I mean, listen to the Sixteen perform it. Their performance, I think, is the best I've ever heard.
moskva40 3 years ago
i did this song for county chorus my junior year... i love it... i wish there where men here...but the instruments make up for it lol... wonderful and beautifully done... love the organ but isn't this usually done a capella just curious.
handelfan610 3 years ago
I love this it is beautiful and i love the use of the original insterments that would of been used when this song was first sung
wiesje666 4 years ago 8
We have to sing this, its not a bad song: Gaudete, gaudete christus est natus ex maria virgine gaudete x2 great song 4star rating.
dxrules120 4 years ago
we have to sing this for our school xmas concert in choir
ecofriendlypanda 4 years ago
we have to sing this for school on xmas too...
sillyxchimp 3 years ago
Sorry, but I hate repertoiry choir....where's the men!! lol But very nice! ^^
BandNazi 4 years ago
it's strange for the choir to sound better than the solos themselves...and anxiety isn't a good excuse...
zippyninny 4 years ago
Yeah, I have to sing it too, but I sing the solo too.
micimacko69 4 years ago
ive got two sing this on my christmas concert
mtanneruk 4 years ago
great but I wish it had been not so rushed
FoxFireFae 4 years ago
I Like It And I'm Only 12
Sora4Deoxys 4 years ago
they pay and sing it as if they were hunted by 1000 devils......
distancetrucker 4 years ago
This is my old school and if you knew the teacher conducting them- well you would not be far wrong.
welshdevondragon 4 years ago
Which school and when?
davidnettleton 3 years ago
what school? is this a school in arizona cause the choir and teacher look so darn familier im unsure of it tho
kuro1546 2 years ago
South Hampstead High school in London! England
lleettyy13 2 years ago
sounds weird with music. . .
ChelseatheHolmesian 4 years ago
its realy great!!!! i love it!
Senaphina 4 years ago
wow! gives a better quali. version? very very nice
Himmelgrau1983 4 years ago
oh its just a school choir concert thing from a while back. thanks for the comment
isyw12 4 years ago
lovely
steiketa 4 years ago
Yay! It's Gaudete!
ow200 5 years ago 2
I agree! Yay!
cutedogprincess 4 years ago