Khamosh Pani (Silent Waters) Part 9

[perfectlife4u]

not right

[ZooniIndian]

Before partition of India in 1947, Lahore was a cosmopolitan city with Hindu, Sikh and Jain residents. There were many temples in Lahore.

In 1941, 48% of the population of Lahore was Hindu, Sikh or Jain[1]. Muslims formed about 50.1 percent of Lahore where as 36.3 percent were Hindus and 18.4 percent were Sikhs.

[ghayasbilbees]

@ZooniIndian Stop Quoting to me Wikipedia.......

Stop living under the rock and start living on the ground.

Do what you like but dont be bothered to come out with your bullocks, coz am not bothered about the bugger like you are.

Trust me, had we have a MUSLIM who's a C unt like you, we would have kicked him out as well.

[ZooniIndian]

@ghayasbilbees Hi Everybody, this guy has just showed how much respect Pakistanis have for women. In contrast, Indian culture teaches that even enemy's women should be given their due respect and should be treated with honour. You have shown your own class mr. ghaya..whtever ur name is.

[rhodeadonis]

a greatly executed scene .. love the way they say these dialogues and the emotions

[saeed2r]

agree with nangamujra this movie deserve oscar and also teeching lessen

[MultiKalakhan]

Listen guys- Its Irony for us Muslims, We say Islam means Rehmat, Peace. that's it.. Rehmatul il Alamin mean Rehmat for all ALAMs and whatever is within those...

[varunaagn]

I don't know how this movie disgraces Pakistan as the Pakistanis are stating??  Where on one hand this movie shows extreme elements, it also shows super nice people like Ayesha's husband and the barber....

Moreover the movie is all about woman rights than about religion!!!

[ghayasbilbees]

Pata nahein kis nay yeh Picture banai hai........... This is extremely disgraceful to see such a movie and what is more painful was to know that the director was actually a PAKISTANI!!!

[taurausbull]

@ghayasbilbees you are a low IQ idiot and you should blame your parents for the disgrace that you are. you should hang yourself in shame. it needs brains to understand a masterpiece. monkeys don't have the IQ to understand everything.

[ghayasbilbees]

@taurausbull Thank You.........

[jaydee700]

Sikhs need alot of respect, they have done alot for every nation, but still no one respect them, love and beloved. Lots of love to all of the sikhs.

[MrPunjabi1st]

thx jaydee god bless u lots of lov for all muslims just i know and my god how i lov u all guys take care

[PakLovesIndia]

The story is a real story of every town of Punjab. It is so real.

[ghayasbilbees]

Bakwas story hai bilkul, yeh to hamaray logon k saath Indian Punjab mein hua hai.......

Agar Muslims itnay hi zalim aur safak thay to Sikhs k Gurdwaron ko kion unhon nay baqi rehnay dia?

Us pe sitam yeh k log kharday ho kar tamashbeeni kar rahay hain

[ohwahwah]

right.

[grewaljassu]

haqiqat yeh hai k nuksaan pakistani punjab and indian punjab....dono ko ek saa hee hua thaa....aapne yeh farmaya ki sikho ke gurudware pakistan mein hain..ussi tarah musalmano ki bhi aneko dargaahe aur peero ki kabare india mein hain..jaha pe har religion ke log jaa kar duaaye mangte hain....so is baat ko itna naa uchaala jaaye....hum sabh log jante hain 1940 se le kar ab tak kya hua dono taraf....sabak lena chahiye yhe sabh dekh-sunn kar

[ghayasbilbees]

Bhaijan, India ki 25% poppulation muslim hai, Pakistan mein to 25 Sikh families bhi nahien hongi.... uskay bawujood Pakistan mein ham nay minorities ko protection di hai.

Someone has gt something wrong, the way it was portrayed here in this movie is utterly insane.

Babri Masjid Pakistan mein nahein giri, Gujrat Riots Pakistan mein nahein huay....

[ZooniIndian]

@ghayasbilbees Keep on ignoring the truth.

[ZooniIndian]

@ghayasbilbees Haan sab kuch tum logon ke saath hi hua hai, humare saath toh kuch bhi nahin hua...shame on you.

[ghayasbilbees]

@ZooniIndian Haan tumharay saath kia hua hai? zara batao? hamain bhi pata lagay

[ZooniIndian]

@ghayasbilbees Well we've suffered a lot. Not just during Partition of India, but under the Mughals. Our temples were destroyed, our people were killed, our women were abducted...we've suffered a lot.

[ghayasbilbees]

@ZooniIndian Chanda Stay on the Partition at the moment. Tell me where & what have you suffered?

[ZooniIndian]

@ghayasbilbees Dude we've suffered a lot ok during Partition. Just do research on google. Torture of Sikhs and Hindus during Partition. Our men were killed, our women were abducted, we were forced out of our ancient land.

[ghayasbilbees]

@ZooniIndian Kis nay tumhain nikala hai Pakistan say? Who forced you out of Pakistan......

Still Go and see the rural Sindh and you will find out how many of hindu tribes live there. Dayal Singh, Nausherwanji Dinshaw, Lal Bai etc etc these all are the names of the 'Proud Pakistanis' who lived and worked for the betterment of Pakistan even after the partition.

As a matter of fact the first National Anthem of Pakistan was written by (Late) Jagan Nath Azad.

[ZooniIndian]

@ghayasbilbees Humko toh nikal diya aur ab kehte ho ke kisne nikala hai.  don't try to hurt us more by saying mean things.

[ghayasbilbees]

@ZooniIndian Abay chal hairday, aaj bhi 7% Pakistani hindus hain...... You dont even know SHIT abt Pakistan, So you better SHUT UP!

[ZooniIndian]

@ghayasbilbees acha toh wht happend to the 50 % of the Lahore's Hindu population, where did they disaapear, you loser, you better SHUT UP!

[ghayasbilbees]

@ZooniIndian PONKA 50% population of Hindus in Lahore.... There never was a hindu poppulation in lahore at any time history whatsoever.

Name me a SINGLE BLOODY REFERENCE THAT PROVES YOUR POINT!

In the region where we live, historically the hindus & Sikhs are concentrated in the Rural Sindh, Tribal Pashtun belt, Rural areas of Multan and some in rural areas of Balochistan. The rest were traders.

The only large populous is still in Sukkur, a city in interior Sindh

[ZooniIndian]

@ghayasbilbees Dude until 1947, 50% of the Lahore's populartion consisted of Hindus and Sikhs.

Read this.

[ghayasbilbees]

@ZooniIndian We the Karachities consider Hindus as the Founder of our proud city who enjoy equal rights with their fellow men in the Country.

[Engior]

So sad.

[nangamujra]

what a beautifull location...where has it been shot......story is wonderful. This movie deserve an oscar

[arepha]

This was shot in village of wah

[Iranali786]

It can't be , the scenery and culture and language is from South Punjab ( near Bahawalpur area ). Wah is a fairly Wahhabist place in North Punjab.

[arepha]

This village is shown to be nearby Panja Sahib (hassan abdal). Sabiha Sumar (director) said in one of her interviews that shooting was completed village of wah diagonally opposite to Panja Sahib.

[Iranali786]

No , Wah village in which district ?? Wah village and Wah district is two different places. I am talking about Wah Cantonment Area.

[MrKhurram712]

wah village??...wah is cantt area..may be its area between wah cantt and panja sab.....wah is wahabi area...wow thats a big assumption...come to wah and you will find sikhs,shias,sunnis living together...anyway...really i didn't like the dialogue of namaz and love affair....how can extra marital affairs be justified by saying that i pray and i think...its not me being chauvinistic .. it bothers me when it is showed as if kissing and hugging outside of your marriage is allowed in islam

[somiisb]

@nangamujra its pakistan,wah,near rawalpindi.

[nydesiking]

it,s aa great STORY.