Added: 7 months ago
From: EminemOfficiallMusic
Views: 159,194
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (361)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • life is hard for me, and it is for many others.. and im not trying to get sympothy or anything trust me, but my life is full of god taking people close to me or hurting the people i love... im 13 and 2 months ago i lost my bestfriend from a decease called "c.f" he was a fighter and he was like my brother.. my dad is always sick, hes 53 and has had 4 strokes and this stuff hurts but when i listen to eminem it makes me feel a little better and i want to be a hero like him..so listen for josh reid

  • Rest In Peace Kevin "Kage" Davis. I wish I was with you that night at that party. I know I could of did something to change the outcome. You were just an innocent bystander man. Then to top it off they left you on the ground for the cops to find you as you tried to crawl for help. You just started turning your life around too. I'd trade my life for yours any day. I swear I'm going to make it in the music world just like I promised you. I love you Kage!

  • WTF seriously, why must everything have dislikes. WHO THE FUCK DISLIKES THIS

  • Bless Eminem ... He didnt right a couris to this because he didn't think it would be good enough for proof ....

  • Why do people open up in the comments acting like we want to read their sob story?

  • @steelershw86wr Its called Publicly expressing there emotions

  • @steelershw86wr Eminem makes his songs about his own life, a lot of them are sad stories, so the people commenting are like little Marshalls saying their sad stories. Theirs just don't rhyme and don't have a beat behind them.

  • R.I.P Proof<3

  • My heart go's out too you EMINEM keep ur head up ur girls need u as do ur fans

  • @wildlunatic21 ...that blunt i smoke on 420 will b for ur bro

  • </3

  • yo this is for everyone who lost a lovedone. youre not the only one feeling down. eventhough you miss someone, you have lost someone you cared and still care about, this aint a reason to be feel down. keep yo head up, make everyone proud. cause losing someone you cared about is hard, but be tough, it will make you stronger and do something with your life, so when you look back, you can say youre proud of yo'self.

    be tough, be strong, keep your head up and move on.

  • @FatRh1no couldnt have said it better myself.....preach it

  • @EminemOfficiallMusic could u upload the instrumental

  • He's on about ja rule, check out hailes revenge (jarule diss)

  • i dont know if ya'll know but this song is about proof AFTER HE DIED

  • Who is em on about whe he said he should have turned up at the funeral?

  • ITS SO FUCKING ANNOYING HOW KIDS ARE LIKE I LOVE EMINEM!!! AND THEY DNT NO ANYTHING ABOUT HIM THEY DNT NO ANYTHING BESIDES MAINSTREAM SHIT THEY DNT REALIZE THE LIFE HES LED AND WHERE HE CAME FROM AND WHAT HES GONE THROUGH. THEY DNT NO ANY SONGS FROM AN ALBUM BEFORE MMLP AND THEY DNT NO ABOUT D12 OR ANYTHING... thats all i have to say

  • @KarbohnIsHAM wow dont get attatched personally to someone who doesnt know you idiot. your the deffinition of a dumb fan. you get angry over other eminem fans, let them be and get the fuck over it cunt.

  • @iWentToNam look at ur channel comments guy... u jst go to videos and troll calling me a cunt u dnt even no me u hypocritical fuck and im going to get angry when songs like this one here are a look into his soul at the time he wrote it thats why he wrote the song it was a way for him to get what he was feeling out so dont go saying that kids who are like "love the way you lie is the best song ever i love him" are true fans of his... people who dont know who proof is arent real fans

  • so fucking true. those people have no idea what the fuck re talkin bout. and hey iWentToNam, rnt u doing the same fucking thing u dumbass? some of us get attatched because we can relate to how hes feeling and what hes gone through. u dont deserve to listen to this man express himself.

  • To you ppl fighting if this about Royce your fucking retarded clearly about Proof his bestfriend and maybe the best in D12 yea I said it. Searching for Jerry Garcia gonna bump it now some real shit real Proof fans know what im sayin

  • @Snown1gga22 100% true star!

  • i think im crying because is such a good song

  • great song... only got to listen to 10 seconds of it because vevo sucks. oh and btw FUCK VEVO

  • @bippitybopitty This isn't vevo?

  • @SupaflyLP no he's not i thought that at first but royce made it clear that it wasnt aimed at him so i looked into it and its about mud because he jus left proof when he got shot nd he might of set it up

  • @liamsteer it wasnt set up. proof actually threw the first punch in the fight that led to him getting shot

  • RIP Big Proof, never forgotten. 

  • what year is this song ????????????

  • @marco85424 2006

  • Fuck all this people ho leak songs.....and fuck the idiots ho support them..... because of this idiots a lot of amazing songs dont get to the albums including this

  • like this if u can understand what this song truely is about

  • This is a awesome song but the chorus could be better

  • @crazydrummer597 How can you criticize the chorus? This tunes from the heart.. C'mon king you know what I mean!

  • Is this fore a new album???

  • SHIT this song is so awesome, it let me cry, but still feeling happy!!

  • honestly....it made me cry....im in tears he is the only one who can do this to me....get better Marshall

  • I posted this on my ex-girlfriends fb wall didnt make a diff shes died ina car wreck:(

  • @Alphapwn70 did yall brake up n she died ina wreck or did she die ina wreck when yall were 2gether anywho im sorry that happen =:[

  • He talks about mud when he says he'll punch him.in the fucking face

  • @liamsteer actually, he's talking about Royce, when he made this track, Em & Royce still had a feud...

  • @SupaflyLP Dude this about Proof. If you were a true fan you would know this. Deudy was Eminems and Proofs nickname for eachother. And plus it says ''I put em in your casket'' This is his tribute for his best friend. Please do your research.

  • Difficult as it sound....he is speaking from his heart! At least he know how he is feeling...much love to that.

  • He didn't release the song because why would he wanna make money off of his best friends death. Rip proof

  • @JeeSixx Its an unoffical song u can look it up on iTunes but it won't show anything it was never really released it just came out and spread

  • I dont think people dislike the song coz they dont like it but coz eminem dont want any one to hear it coz its really deep n personal.

  • eminem is the only raper that can make me cry

  • You freaking can hear him cry...

  • R.I.P. Proof. Remembered in D12 and solo. They say only the good die young.

  • I feel like I just walked into Eminem's heart.

  • When did this Song come out ? was it in any album?

  • eminem is king of rap without a doubt

  • Fucking killed me at 2:53.

  • Big Proof Forever !!!

  • The cool sounds are for effect and to attract the listener to the song more

  • @WZKmontage No I think those are there to bypass whatever copyrights music.

  • R.I.P Proof

  • 7 people get off over there mum undressing

  • Comment removed

  • one of his finest from the finest

  • i had a brother who commetted suicide 4 20 10 and he was my best friend too this song is on point. Matthew Todd Chestine was my only sibling and i miss him with all my heart , he shoot his self in front of me and my mother and thats an image that i can not erase, i left behide and 14 month old son who is tha spitting image of him and i thank god every day that i have him.

    R.I.P. my bigbrother Matthew Todd Chestine, 3/8/1986 - 4/20/2010

  • @wildlunatic21 i would say i can relate, but i cant, but i can feel your pain man, damn

  • @wildlunatic21 this hit me so hard ='(

  • @wildlunatic21 i am so sorry for your loss

    

  • I want this song played at my funeral NO DOUBT

  • it sounds a little weird, there are another versions on YT that sounds a lot better

  • was the whiney sound for the drunkness?

    Love you and Trudy always,

    Riia

  • This aint slim shady or eminem. This is Marshall.

  • Yo this video says this song is from 2011, it’s not. It was recorded in 2006 a bit after Proof’s death. If you can’t tell his voice is slurred a bit, and during 2006 he was still trying to become sober. And by the devastation in the song, you can tell it’s closer to the time of Proof’s death

  • Eminem Is Class Rest In Peace Proof Eminem Done A Great Job On This

  • I just lost my Mother December 20 2011. My best friend and the one person i know i could turn to in any situation. She had my back no matter what. Rest peacefully DEBORAH GAYLE ARDUENGO. I LOVE AND MISS YOU.

  • a genius dont matter what..

  • this song reminds me off my nan ...i never got the chance to tell her how much i loved her and i know she cnt hear me ...i beat myself up every day for not telling or showing her it

  • r.i.p proof

  • 5 Peope are GAY, EMINEM THE BEST

  • why the hell did you add Flanger into the song ?.. i dont know what it is but i really hate it when people do that. and i know Marshal or his team added it, is it because you wanna be a part of the song ?? lol ok now i stop, thanks for the upload tho! :)

  • @GamersOnFire Marshal and his team did not i mean

  • Man this shit gets me everytime. I know how it feels to have a bestfriend die. It fuckin sucks! Like Em says you don't want to believe it even years after it happened. RIP PROOF

  • Wtf. "he was high" "he was drunk" who fucking cares. High, drunk or sober. He lost his best friend, have some fuckin respect. Appreciate the song and stop critiquing. Ems a fucking legend and always will be.

  • 1 fag

  • I LOVE THIS SONG!

  • R.I.P. proof

  • Lil Wayne log in to his 5 different accounts and disliked this song. Bastard!

    

  • @evilliveable He Made 4 more D;

  • @evilliveable how can u joke about this sad song dont u have respect for the best

  • @evilliveable also t pain

  • @evilliveable well done, you used hate talk on a video dedicated to something so terrible and unfortunate. how fucking thoughtfull of you.

  • Can anyone find the love button for me

  • fuck 5 people

  • this song gets me every time.. cherish the people you got.

    R.I.P Proof<3

  • i cant watch or listyen to this without a tear coming to my eye!! :'(

  • @SuperSmurf1998 me to a especially whe he mentions the boys :(

  • yo this shit is deep....i dont know what its like to lose a friend....but i think he gave me an idea....

  • you five that disliked this are just fucking pricks and im sure you would feel different if this happened to you >:'(

  • eminem forever!!! R.I.P proof :'(

  • RIP big proof. Keep goin em, You rippin em daily ..Shady Records 4 Life

  • 5 DICKHEADS ...

  • Reminds me of Derek, Best friend for 13 years then got ran over... now im 19 and i cant stop comparing every friend to him... no one could be him. Cant wait till i get to see him again :'( RIP Derek 2005

  • 5 retards can dislike

  • sorry for holding the loptop upside down 5 times:(

  • First time I cried in a long time

  • them bitches who disliked this like dumb ass Justin Bieber!Fuck them Eminem was in pain!love man love

  • I heard this and I can relate to what Em says and his pain I thought about my best friend Austin was murdered when I was locked up this song made me cry ;( Austin was my proof so I can relate to this... R.I.P A- DAWG and R.I.P.PROOF

  • I can feel the pain in Em's voice...

  • The 5 ppl who disliked this prolly had tears in there eyes and couldnt see the buttons

  • @twoheadz73 damn right!those motherfuckers don´t even know the pain eminem´s been through!

  • so sad but really good

  • FUCK the haters they don't know shit faggots that like justin beiber and shit i wanna punch em all i mean if you don't like don't watch

  • for those 4 people who disliked this imagine on facebook you write my mom just died in the hospital and someone liked it or laughed at it well thats excectly what you just did

  • WTF man.

    How the hell cud u dislike this?

    so wat if u wrote a song for someone and they hated it?

    u pour out everything into it and no one gives a crap.

    tell me. cuz that's wat u just did .

    this is one of my favorites by EMINEM because it has meaning behind it.

    guesss u dont realize that.

  • Fuckin hell Proof n him werefriend forever of you don't know shit don't say anything pointless Rip Proof plus Ems Clean wtf is it some of you'd rather c him fucked up little older n wiser is all

  • EMINEM is the only rapper that can make me cry like a bitch,laugh like crazy thats why he has so mach influence on me

  • they shouldn't permit a dislike space on Eminem songs..

  • I just simply love the tone of his voice! Don't even get me started on his beautiful lyrics!..<3

  • who could dislike this song???

  • @DjblankTv  Twats thats who

  • @DjblankTv 5 People..

  • @DjblankTv 6 idiots who fell into a dark hole, and never could find the like button against the wall. They all tryed.

  • @DjblankTv true but da 6 fukers dat do can get a fukin dog up em.

  • @DjblankTv There heartless :/

  • @DjblankTv Some people like him strictly for his Slim Shady persona... I love his music no matter the tone or subject. Except Rainman...that's probably the worst song i've ever heard in my life lol.

  • @DjblankTv heartless bastards

  • It is just that Eminem is the best rapper. It is just that he is a very smart and nice guy.

    It is just that I will listen to his songs all my life.

    Em is the only god I know.

  • this song make me wanna hug Em and never let go

  • how can you not rest in peace with a tribute like that!?... so amazing, RIP Proof

  • Proof will live forever RIP

  • after hearing this i feel like i have actually know and met Proof any1 else feel the same way

  • We all miss you proof3

  • Made me break down and cry..God Bless Proof and Eminem ..RIP Proof

  • @Schrumunc  sTRAIGHT uP

    I cRY 2

  • Is this not on iTunes?

  • @CashRaining no its not

  • Some people just don't have a friend that's always been there for them.

  • ssaa

  • 3 people lives are easy, they get everything and never have problems.

  • This man's words are by far the most amazing thing ever to go threw my ears, this song, is by far one of the most beautiful things I have ever heard. The first time i heard it I literally sat here and listened to it 20 times in row. Em, You are a god given angle.

  • Alright assholes quit posting those retarded "your crush will kiss you" chain messages and telling people to check out your channel. Jesus Christ, have some fucking respect for the dead. Shut up and listen to the massive smounts of real music this guy has put outfor the last 16 years. Fuck Nikki, Wayne, Miller, and all those fake little bitches who are slowly taking over the music industry with their autotune piece of shit albums. Long live the King of Rap

  • @xXCiNdErLlAMaNxX you are ignorant your comment is irrelevant

  • @whoseline18 you are a horse's ass you can shut the fuck up

  • @xXCiNdErLlAMaNxX like i said, ignorant.

  • @whoseline18 dude, it's youtube so please get off your period and just watch the goddamn video

  • its difficult to pick a new song

  • i just raped replay button

  • King couldnt be Fighted go die LiliWiwi

  • @gordonjiz get the facts right, then u can start talkin..

  • Cuz this song is about a friend that died that he hasn't seen in a long time, I think his DJ black friend from 8mile died.

  • @gordonjz Proof (of D12), died 2005.

    He was Lil' Tic in the 8Mile movie, the guy "Rabbit" chokes' to.

  • @BSIJeba He died in 2006 or not?

  • he kinda sounds drunk.. great song though

  • first, i didn't like this song but then i lost a friend myself and i can't desribe the pain i feel. the beat, the sound of his voice, it represents the way i feel now.

  • it seems that wi wont see eminem smile never again

    its a shame the life he had to live, i cant even imagine wath would i do if i grow up without my father, my mother dosnt support me, i got no money.. and when i get famous and rich i cant enjoy it cause my friends are murder, i do drugs, or i am on a beef.

    rip proof, and rest in peace marshal mathers happiness

  • Can't stand when people say Eminem best rapper alive. You got it wrong. BEST RAPPER EVER

    IN THE 90S THE BEST

    IN THE 00S THE BEST

    IN THE 10S THE BEST

  • @emieldegraaf He is not the best ever. Check out a rapper called Tupac because obviously you haven't heard of him before

  • @Mike51252 Obviously I find Eminem better. And I listen to rap almost 15 years now. So I do know what im talking about.

  • @emieldegraaf Sorry but you don't. Eminem is a genius but Tupac is a god

  • @Mike51252 Excuse me? Its a matter of opinion. If a douche says I find Lil Wayne better, that's his opinion. Maybe he likes slow swag rap. You can not make it a fact that Tupac is better, cause in your eyes he is. In my eyes Eminem is. But hey, to make u feel better, 2Pac is def #2 on MY list.

  • This is so sad:( Eminem is the best. This song is so real.

    R.I.P proof :( :(

  • This version is the better one, because you can actually hear his real voice. The other versions of this song, he's got his slang, and his accent, and he's not showing how he really feels. Here, you can here the anguish and sadness in his voice. Respect, Respect.

  • The song is very sad,but very good :D

  • Enough said.

  • 1.You are reading the comment

    2. You are realizing that this is a stupid facts

    4. You are realizing that i skipped 3 and you are checking now

    6. You are smiling

    7. You are still reading this comment

    9. You do not realize i skipped 8

    10. You are checking again and smiling about how you fell for it again

    11 You are enjoying this. You probally did not realize there was only supossed to be ten facts COPY AND PASTE THIS TO ON OTHER VIDEO & YOUR CRUSH WILL KISS YOU TOMOROW

  • @obi462 Go fuck yourself

  • @obi462 How Could I Smile? Q_Q