You sound more like you're trying to sing than just singing. Your vibrato sounds a bit forced and this is song that should be sung flat. Closer to spoken word/poetry. You've obviously got the chops, just lose the American Idol pretentions and sing naturally. Oh yeah, and don't ever do an intro like that again.
perhaps someone can help me. this song is featured on another video. the video collaborated lots of hand written quotes and poetry by people overcoming depression.
I've never heard the original song so i can't comment on the likeness, but I thought your singing was pretty good. I'm not a talent scout, just someone who knows what they like, and it was very listenable.
no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no....please stop this is bad. You will see most of the comments are about you and your looks, apart from that you should stop. Have a nice day.
u defiantly fill the son out more u (as others have sed) put more emotion into it and it doesn't fill as cold as the original artist who sung it, no knocking her shes amazing, but u have talent
My first comment ever on this site ! So, I like it, it was beneficial from a musical standpoint. Bravo ! It really set my head to thinking about some important things, musically. I so, so, we are so fortunate she actually has taken the time to do it !
Its pretty rough but i love its honesty. it took balls to post up a video you knew wasnt hitting the spot...its a great document to see how far you've come since the time this was recorded. Theres serious talent in that voice. keep it up
I completely despise this video. I can't even listen to it myself. The only reason I didn't delete it is because it has over 4000 views which is quite a bit... Shallow I know, but I don't know why so many people like it! Thanks for your honesty, and that's true, it's a good document lol to compare progress.
Gotta be honest. At first I was like, 'ut-oh', this is gonna be rough.
Your singing was not half-bad. I was quite impressed, really. On a side note, from one performer to another, the guitar playing was [i]a little[/i] distracting because it was not fully practiced out and performance ready.
I understand though the desire to get your side of the story out. :)
First of all, I want to thank you for giving me the most honest comment ever. Seriously, that's what I like. And this was recorded a VERY long time ago so I just listened to it to remember what it sounds like..... AND I HATE IT. Despise it lol. To be honest myself, I use to post videos just because I felt bad if I didn't, but I've gotten a lot of vocal training since then and everything about this video makes me cringe. It definitely was not performance ready... and I want to make a new one now.
I have a strictly acoustic... and it's a little bigger than I am lol. And also it's antique.. well about 40 years old. But yeah the strings are so far away from the fret board and it's just a pain to play, but if you can manage to play that guitar then you can play any instrument in the world. I'll see if I can play this song on that guitar though.
Guiltily; your looks distract me from your music, but several others have covered that.
I wish I could have heard you playing a traditional acoustic with this song; this guitar's tone is a bit too twangy for such a mellow aura, but your voice is excellent.
I think her singing was delightful thank you very much. And I am sure she would like the comments to be more appropriate, I mean, I swear and all, but that was just insulting. I agree though, she is very cute.
hey could you show me how to play this song. i like it. but i cant play guitar. i will try to play it. it must be not so dificult? show me evry tap on video. please!!!!! carri15
lovely voice :)
tokyosan1 2 months ago
now this song is on Gears of War 3 :)
Monkgangsta 4 months ago
good job.....well done
smellyasss 4 months ago
Amazing boobs:)
YektenMarjinal 4 months ago 9
I Love your voice! Awesome!
christrealized 4 months ago
totally awesome
TheMuttonator 4 months ago
Horrible, Lessons woman.... Take them.
xvision321 4 months ago
That was theBrooke with an e!
djangolad 4 months ago
TheBrook's version is the best since Mazzy Star's
This one is a bit shite!
djangolad 4 months ago
wow, that was great
metalhijinx 4 months ago
wowowowow! sosoososo good and sososossoso hot!
theMAXILOPEZpsycho 4 months ago
You probably see it much more critically than most. Me, I really appreicate it. I love the emotion you put into. Thanks for sharing.
lennieblue 5 months ago
Excellent job! And will you marry me?!
wingedangel81 5 months ago
This rivals the actual mazzy star version! :O WOW
WetFingerGamingHD 5 months ago
great' job on into dust you sound real good.
DrMetalism 5 months ago
very very good u have a lovely sweet voice!
stevolaaad 5 months ago
tits...
web4lifeit 5 months ago
Love this song! Good job cutie! Can you come over and sing me this song? I will melt in your arms.. :)
metterg 5 months ago
your music moves me inside it doesn't even need words as far as I am concerned I fell what you feel
nealmeal2000 5 months ago
Nice voice. Guitar is too "techy", too much twang. Suggest a Martin D10. Rich tones. Or a Laravee.............plain, but unbelievable rich tone
Dave
davh72able 5 months ago
thats a beautiful guitar.
beanseeker 5 months ago
very nice :) mahalo
TheWayFinders 5 months ago
You have a wonderful voice
RadicalBlackMonkeyII 5 months ago
Gr8 job, chica!! Keep it up and let's more more vids.
steve95382 5 months ago
Good voice girl, I really enjoyed it ;)
metralla0004 5 months ago
You should be in video game commercials. And I like your hair.
ClandestineOstrich 5 months ago
Very, very good!!!
themrchemist123 5 months ago
beautiful
robinson842 5 months ago
You sound more like you're trying to sing than just singing. Your vibrato sounds a bit forced and this is song that should be sung flat. Closer to spoken word/poetry. You've obviously got the chops, just lose the American Idol pretentions and sing naturally. Oh yeah, and don't ever do an intro like that again.
LeCutter 5 months ago
to full of herself
mrfizzzzzzzy 5 months ago
Gears of War 3 Dust to Dust trailer brought me here, i took the most nice-looking one, and i am satisfied
DarionMograine11153 6 months ago
j'aime vraiment ta cover, elle est nature et efficace :-)!!!
whishes63 6 months ago
excellent cover! and god bless at the man who listen her voice and kiss her lips,
EMIGA033 7 months ago
nice cover! can u tell me something about the beautifull fireplace behind u? is it an antique or a reproduction?
mjt11860 8 months ago
my poor ears! :P. I first heard this on The Oc, good job.
elfmagnet101 8 months ago
umm, yeah, this is meh. you're certainly no Hope.
cruzdavid72 8 months ago
YOUR VOICE!!!!!!!!!
karenfgonza 9 months ago
not sure why u hate this video so much,you have a great voice!
AUTIGER4LIFE26 1 year ago
HE'S MY THING! LOVE IT!
hablodeldiablo 1 year ago
You sorta look like her. o.o
DJMiilk 1 year ago
Comment removed
thebrowniesaur22 1 year ago
Great job little lady. you have skills..
73puck 1 year ago
Great job
73puck 1 year ago
wow
echelonarmy1 1 year ago
aww..she's beautiful
pacalyte 1 year ago
Very good:) A lot better then I can play it and the singing was amazing!
hipcrio2 1 year ago
My God are talented! Aside from the original your version is so fresh and i have to say that i might just like your singing better. Keep on!
goombanuts 1 year ago 4
@goombanuts Oh my gosh... wow thank you! I honestly don't like this video at all but I still appreciate the compliment :)
sexciilivie 1 year ago
i like it a lot hun x
charliegirl17 1 year ago
Pretty damn good effort! The Original is one of the best songs... ever. :o)
perkin2000 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
perhaps someone can help me. this song is featured on another video. the video collaborated lots of hand written quotes and poetry by people overcoming depression.
i keep trying to find it, but to no avail.
Evantheowl 1 year ago
perfect!!!
ozzychoker 1 year ago
haha its true, they are nice apples. great cover.
Roche1983 2 years ago 2
This was worth it just to see the apples propped up on the guitar! :) Beautiful fireplace btw.
geminilegend 2 years ago
5/5 ale nie przeciagaj tak
elokisiel 2 years ago
I would like to see you on a stage with better microphones and monitor amps to give you feedback on what your doing. Good job!
detroitbob58 2 years ago
the drifting pitch is tolerable but the modern breathy thing doesn't sound good....sounds too superficial,like your typical american idol singer.
singers today suck,not a good idea to emulate their plastic brand of artistry
spentonmediocrity 2 years ago
I dig any girl who plays mazzy star!
jamesbondaygee 2 years ago
Great job! love this song :)
dreamwildly 2 years ago
I've never heard the original song so i can't comment on the likeness, but I thought your singing was pretty good. I'm not a talent scout, just someone who knows what they like, and it was very listenable.
PLCJockey 2 years ago 2
nice job
infinitalocura 2 years ago
Thank you!! nice job! Merry X-mas
xticone 2 years ago
Nice fireplace. It was good, but some re verb would make it much better.
thealmightyval 2 years ago
no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no....please stop this is bad. You will see most of the comments are about you and your looks, apart from that you should stop. Have a nice day.
antoireland09 2 years ago
You really look like Hope Sandoval!
Rioth 2 years ago
those ARE some REALLY nice tits. hope sandoval forever!
digitalsidewalk 2 years ago
Thanks so much for this - I loved Mazzy Star back then... This makes me tune into a lot of old memories... Great stuff. Cheers from Germany
radchaot 2 years ago
Nice song nice place nice voice nice guitar Nice artist Nice cover. Very talented.
scwomanchangeling2 2 years ago
belle minne!
denterotto 2 years ago
Dunno my opinion matters but I thought you did great. What kind of house do you live in? Fire place is too nice.
PHOENIXFEAN 2 years ago
let me tell you something you are already famous
just so you know,you are superb
mrllapjani 2 years ago
Aw thank you so much!
sexciilivie 2 years ago
nice tits
shaolin21 2 years ago 41
@shaolin21 tht made me lol!
winbigfindtheclue 1 year ago
@shaolin21 Yes they are.
goacc2k9 5 months ago
@shaolin21 Hahahaha
MrAwesome2210 4 months ago
Great cover! Your voice is amazing!
vita210 2 years ago
Jesus H. Christ... Your cover is great, but the choice of intro music couldn't be worse. That's like a slap in the face.
lifelikeweeds819 2 years ago 26
nice 1 keep it up
junction180 2 years ago
u defiantly fill the son out more u (as others have sed) put more emotion into it and it doesn't fill as cold as the original artist who sung it, no knocking her shes amazing, but u have talent
NippyRadams 2 years ago 2
thats was really good. love your voice and emotion put into song. nice guitar too =]
DiggyJPWC 2 years ago
My first comment ever on this site ! So, I like it, it was beneficial from a musical standpoint. Bravo ! It really set my head to thinking about some important things, musically. I so, so, we are so fortunate she actually has taken the time to do it !
survivor99999 2 years ago
Its pretty rough but i love its honesty. it took balls to post up a video you knew wasnt hitting the spot...its a great document to see how far you've come since the time this was recorded. Theres serious talent in that voice. keep it up
nerp23 2 years ago
I completely despise this video. I can't even listen to it myself. The only reason I didn't delete it is because it has over 4000 views which is quite a bit... Shallow I know, but I don't know why so many people like it! Thanks for your honesty, and that's true, it's a good document lol to compare progress.
sexciilivie 2 years ago
Hope Sandoval all the way, its amazing everytime i watch your vids I realize how much you just completely wow me!!!
And ROCK!!!
cloverhoseman325 2 years ago
shit! you have a fantastic house!
tandard5 2 years ago
I would love to see/hear you cover 5 String Serenade. Its my favorite, and I think you could do it some justice with your talent.
Great stuff Liv.
moneraths 2 years ago
I heard a flub or two here and there, but nothing keeping me from saying "this was really good."
So.... This was really good!
VilkacisMusic 2 years ago
I think boys just watch these videos because there is a cute girl singing. Guys are pigs, myself included.
meginis8 2 years ago
cute?
TheHairybean 2 years ago
Gotta be honest. At first I was like, 'ut-oh', this is gonna be rough.
Your singing was not half-bad. I was quite impressed, really. On a side note, from one performer to another, the guitar playing was [i]a little[/i] distracting because it was not fully practiced out and performance ready.
I understand though the desire to get your side of the story out. :)
musicmatt09 2 years ago
First of all, I want to thank you for giving me the most honest comment ever. Seriously, that's what I like. And this was recorded a VERY long time ago so I just listened to it to remember what it sounds like..... AND I HATE IT. Despise it lol. To be honest myself, I use to post videos just because I felt bad if I didn't, but I've gotten a lot of vocal training since then and everything about this video makes me cringe. It definitely was not performance ready... and I want to make a new one now.
sexciilivie 2 years ago
Good deal. Were you able to get a hold of a true acoustic?
musicmatt09 2 years ago
I have a strictly acoustic... and it's a little bigger than I am lol. And also it's antique.. well about 40 years old. But yeah the strings are so far away from the fret board and it's just a pain to play, but if you can manage to play that guitar then you can play any instrument in the world. I'll see if I can play this song on that guitar though.
sexciilivie 2 years ago
Guiltily; your looks distract me from your music, but several others have covered that.
I wish I could have heard you playing a traditional acoustic with this song; this guitar's tone is a bit too twangy for such a mellow aura, but your voice is excellent.
Novantii 2 years ago
very nice tits...and your voice is very pretty too. =) but great boobs. good guitar strum. i really liked it.
shayd828 2 years ago
you have a great voice. keep it up.
tacomuybueno 2 years ago
youre trying too much.. and youre playing too fast.
lithiumed27 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
well your singing sucks, but you're kinda cute. You'd look even better with a wad of my cum dripping of your chin.
butt555 3 years ago
I think her singing was delightful thank you very much. And I am sure she would like the comments to be more appropriate, I mean, I swear and all, but that was just insulting. I agree though, she is very cute.
XterierD 3 years ago
thank you :)
sexciilivie 3 years ago
My pleasure!
XterierD 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Fuck you cunt.
butt555 3 years ago
wow, what kind of guitar is that?
SOJ144 3 years ago
This is very good.
colorblind557 3 years ago
Excellent!
SoulObject 3 years ago
Good job. Just slow down a bit and try to lose the "soul" from your voice.
Btw, nice rack! ;-)
NoirHammer 3 years ago 3
lol
SOJ144 3 years ago
hey i have that same guitar! nice cover
friggyFilms 3 years ago
Once I started learning the guitar I realised how simple this is to play.. but it's very satisfying to pluck!
ifedthehorse 3 years ago
amazing cover of Into Dust.when i first heard this song it broke my heart your version does too great job.
JanisFan68 3 years ago
Thank you, that means a lot to me.
sexciilivie 3 years ago
wow olivia this is amazinggg!
- julie d ;)
julzd03 3 years ago
your voice is beautiful lady
collettegina 3 years ago 2
please show me how to play this song. step by step. carri15
carri15 3 years ago
hey could you show me how to play this song. i like it. but i cant play guitar. i will try to play it. it must be not so dificult? show me evry tap on video. please!!!!! carri15
carri15 3 years ago
nice cover, great song
xiasweetcjy182 3 years ago
great success, very nice
25manginas 3 years ago 3
i miss you!
underscoredashperiod 3 years ago
I admire this song and band...
will you marry me?
methiu2 3 years ago
Awesome job! 5/5
jtodd900 3 years ago