Added: 2 years ago
From: bambooie
Views: 10,672
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (92)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Missing NPCs from Guile's stage is unforgivable. The SNES version suffers horrid slowdown - simply an unplayable version, which only won battles in magazine photo comparisons. We all migrated to Sega for this classic when we actually wanted to play the game at home. Needless to say arcade beats both versions.

  • @Eben335 We? Whose we? You're speaking for yourself only here.

  • Genesis has the smoother frame rate

  • the snes had better quality voices but they were shortened,the genesis had the richt length voices but they,re really scratchy.

    the graphics are extraordinairy simmilar.it,s hard to tell any real difference except for the ryu stage with the moon in the background,not seen in the snes version.

    the biggest shame i can imagine is why the snes version has no arcade intro will the genesis version does have it.

    i prefer the music on the snes over the genesis version.

  • I think it's important to note that this wasn't a simultaneous release. The SNES version was released prior to the Genesis version, which seemed unbelievable because the Genesis version of CE was announced long before the idea of making Hyper Fighting for SNES. On top of that, the Genesis version was a bigger cart (24 Mbit to 20) so they were able to add a few features that didn't make it to the SNES version.

    But the real issue is does the game play well, and both succeed.

  • I'd have to hand this one over to SNES simply for nostalgic reasons, since this was the first version I've played. I never played the Genesis version so I can't say much. However, judging from the sound effects of the Genesis, the characters sound like they need some Sucrets because their voices are just scratchy.

  • love snes version

  • Yup, Megadrive's controller shined on this one, especially the six buttoned version of that. MD's D-pad is one of the best D-pad's ever... Sega does blast processing, and does what nintendon't. xD

  • This is were the so called blast processing shows. Stuff move much faster along the screen on the genesis than the snes. Genesis is much better for fast moving objects

  • @Animation1111 The animation for both versions were pretty much a wash. Plus, both games had ridiculous speed settings, up to a nearly unplayable 10 stars.

    The real advantages of the Genesis version were the extras. Capcom sort of rushed Turbo, which was great by all accounts, but it didn't have some things that Special CE had like the arcade attract screen, no need to punch in a code to get upper speed settings, and the tournament mode. The Genesis version was 24-Mbit, compared to SNES 20.

  • Both them shits was tough..

  • is it true that the genesis version is much tinier than the snes version..because i think they are both the same size!!!can someone tell me

  • @Chepito2846

    both use the same resolution (256x224), and sprite size.

  • PC Engine version is the best, but Genesis version is closer to the arcade then the Snes version.

  • @southbr28 estas todo pendejo

  • I'd have to give it to the genesis on this one

  • Both versions are great, really playable. It's just a shame the Genesis had way inferior sound and was in mono, as opposed to stereo sound and rich symphonic music on the SNES. But hey, the Genny is just a bit faster, so....

    Honestly, folks, if you love 16-bit gaming, both the SNES and the Genesis are amazing, classic consoles with a slew of wonderful games each. Just get both consoles. They both have advantages and drawbacks, but it's a win - win.

  • @wildsmiley Agree some games are better on SNES and other games are better on Sega Genesis or Mega Drive. Even the Turbografx-16 had a great Street Fighter port but only release in Japan.

  • @wildsmiley The megadrive has excellent stereo sound, get a mk 1 megadrive connect it to your hifi through the headphone jack, put in streets of rage and you'll hear the best 16 bit music ever :)

  • Why don't you do a comparison for PC-ENGINE and SNES versions??? 

  • SNES version all the way.

    Ahhh, good times.

  • Correction: This is Street Fighter 2 Champion Edition, not the original for the game credits.

    Considering you needed to buy a separate controller to use 6 buttons on the Genesis/Mega Drive I give this to the SNES.

  • i call it a draw

  • genesis version has better graphics, snes versions has better sound

  • OMG, voices in genesis are sooooo BAAAAAD

  • The genesis version actually has better graphics. It's sharper like all of there games. Snes has always had a terrible softening technique they used for all there games. I will take crisp images over soft and overly colorful images. Also there is background images missing from the snes version, plus I always hated that sack of potatoes"sound that strong kicks made on the snes. Genesis voices are crap and that's obvious but I always preferred the sega version as it felt more true to the arcade. 

  • can u do all moves on genesis ?Only 3 burttons how can u handle this u have 3 puches and 3 kicks on snes..

  • @Mosquit you get the greates fighting controller ever made - the sega genesis 6 button controller. After this game out they were standard controllers anyway

  • @Mosquit Fucking moron genesis also had a 6 button controller.

  • @TheDukeljk iam ony asking u cunt of fucking moron.and yes its SUUUUUUCK when must buy a 6 button pad....dont aswer u birainlessuidiot..aim only askin.....dammit.

  • Atary ST can not play music and sound effects toghether!

    For me Genesis version plays better then SNES ( using the 6 buttons controller, and not considering 3DO version), but the SNES version has some awesome music! I mean, listen to the char selection theme, it is just awesome. So awesome that in the 15th An Edition, for XBOX and PS2, I am pretty sure the arranged version for this theme is based on SNES version.

    PC engine version looks great too, and US Gold...well, they made tons of shit

  • the genesis version looks and plays a lot better. look at ryu's stage, theres bats flying in the background, the colors are so much better, and the moon out. the genesis version plays better because of sega's 6 button controller and 6 button arcade stick.

  • megadrive version is better than snes .

  • i think the genesis version has a certain flair

  • I just spent like 3-4 minutes editing that last comment because when I would try to submit it it kept saying "Error... please try again." The only time I've seen this specific error is when you put like WEBSITE(dot)COM except obviously a period instead of (dot). This is better than it used to be when comments would just grey out and you couldn't copy your text.. you just lost it. But no, I just had to refresh.

  • I had both growing up. I always preferred the SNES version for the button layout and the fact that it looked better and sounded better.

    If you want it the most like the arcade... take the graphics and voices of the SNES one and the MUSIC of the genesis. Genesis isn't known for great music but it's because people didn't know how to utilize FM synth chips. Japanese dev's like Capcom and Konami did. But the main thing is that the arcade version used FM synth so the Gen's music is near identical.

  • @LanIost: (part 2)

    Also, I just wanted to note that the Genesis version has it's own nice look. Obviously the SNES has more colors and better graphics and sound in general.. the Genesis one has much more contrast (mostly due to the limited palette). The one striking difference though is in Balrog's stage. I know these stages graphics by heart.. down to minute details. I never noticed the stars in Balrog's stage and how vibrant they are. Seriously, I guarantee you didn't notice. Check that shit.

  • Also, one more quick comment. I had to post this so that I could prevent a flame war over it. And I quote "I always preferred the SNES version for the button layout" - me. I realize that this is blasphemy to SF2 players. Who knows though, maybe someone in here liked the SNES setup. I know some people would make the shoulder buttons medium and make high A/X but I liked the defaults. The six button Genesis was awesome but everyone only had 1 leaving Pl.2 with 3 buttons and start to alt. punch/kick

  • the snes version was near arcade perfect port. i remember playing the snes version for a couple of weeks and going to the genesis verison. lets just say i hanker for the snes version so bad after that..lol

    first thing i noticed was the static sounds that came out of the characters on the genesis version. mind you i also was force to play it with the 3 button genesis controller too..lol horrible experience.

  • The MegaDrive sound is so ugly...

  • i am a sega fan but the color power of the snes wins.... the mega drive was good for fast side scroller because the mega drive got more Mhz

  • 1. Snes

    2. Genesis

  • Best port are always SNES version, as XBOX 360 got the best crossplatform over PS3.

    Get over it, i know my stuffs, i own all these systems, so dont judge unless you can test them.

  • I can't believe there are people that would pick the MegaDrive version over the SNES version. There IS no comparison. The SNES is undeniably better from every perspective - graphics, sound, fanboy.

  • @poshko41: Totally agree. Those that say the Genesis version is better needs to seriously get their eyes & ears checked. 

  • @bluestumpydoo Yeah! That's right - MegaDrive has less colors, but they are much sharper.

  • sega had all the best arcade ports ands its a fact no im no fanboy

  • @toroman112494 I disagree with your whole comment. Sega did have some better ports, but generally the snes had better graphics and far better sound. The snes is capable of more layers and more colours. Also, judging by your completely bias comment, I'd say you're most likely a fanboy.

  • 16 bit, the most creative and best sounding era of gaming for sure. Does any one else spend more of their gaming money down loading old school games on their PS3 than buying the new ones? Love em both but the 16bit era is the best!

  • Megadrive vence !!

    Megadrive is the winner !! *-*

    megadrive forever

  • @gu45boy ur are a fanboy only, in this game snes version is better, but in mortal kombat genesis wins!... in art of fighting.. genesis wins,.. in fatal fury... genesis wins... in street fighter... snes wins

  • @frajaos

    even MK is devided, for MK2 snes wins and for MK3 genesis wins

    but both consoles are awesome in my opinion

  • DRAW

  • The thing that i expect in a game is good music and sound effects...that for me is why SNES is the far superior version, everything sounds ten times better...but the graphics are good in each game but again SNES is better, nothing wrong with MD's graphics but piss poor music and sound.

  • It's not fair to compare the two, the SNES version was just far more superior. The MD(gen) looks and sounds like a retarded kid (no pun intended).

  • @kaox44 The Gen version does have a few edges. A few backgrounds have more animation, such as the moon in Ryu's stage. Plus, the 6-button controller is identical to the controls of the arcade. And the Genesis sound chip is closer in sound to the arcade than the SNES's. The edges aren't too obvious, but the Genesis version holds its own.

  • I like the Megadrive version, however they did take their time releasing it..

    u can play the SEGA version on a plug and play, a little Megadrive box with power on/off, two controllers and six buttons each! It also has Ghouls N Ghosts included too..

    Good fun if you can get it, I got mine for a pound..bargain!

  • @DJDementEatsBabies That's funny because I got mine for a dollar at a flea market! I must say that it was the best dollar I have spent.

  • I'm going to have to go with the SNES version, but mainly because they did the backgrounds better on most of the stages (especially in Ryu's level) and the voices. They're garbled big time on the Genesis. As for music, I'd have to declare it a tie. I'm impressed with some of the Genesis themes, especially Guile's!

  • i felt cheated as a kid when i got to play the sega version, and me and friends have made fun of it ever since lol, poor thing. especially now if you play the turbo version on snes vs this one lol, ooh boy.

  • sounds mega is too bad

  • The SNES wins in any of the Mega Drive game

    Snes forever......................m­ega drive is rotten

  • This isn't even a contest, the SNES is superior in this round.

  • @Richterbelmont365 Speed is better on Megadrive, Music is better on megadrive it's more similar to the arcade, voices I prefer it on SNES and colours too, I think it's a tie.

  • snes version is better. lol@the music on the genesis.

  • @rahnyc4 The Genesis version actually sounds closer to the Arcade version...

  • @SegaFanatic5188 genesis version is just nothing but noise. i use to often find people building arcade cabinets back when i was a kid and using the snes version since it was closer to the arcade.

  • @rahnyc4 The arcade version uses a YM2151 to produce it's sound. The Genesis uses a YM2612. Both are very similar FM synthesizer chips that sound rather alike. The arcade however has a few more channels to allow for more instruments and what not. They still however sound quite similar, especially when you look at the Beta for the Genesis version.

  • SNES version is better. The voices for the characters are scratchy and the sound isn't quite as good. The colors are more vibrant in the SNES version.

  • The snes version looks and sounds better, anyone can see that.

  • Snes huuuuuuaaaa

    Mega Drive huuuuuuuuaaaaaaaaaaarrrrrggg

    Prefiro super nintedo

  • Megadrive version is better. The people moaning about a 3 button pad. Go get the 6 button pad. Kicks ass.

  • Genesis version has a higher screen resolution

  • there is a six button controller for the sega genesis. i own both snes and genesis versions of the game but me and my brother always play the genesis version just cuz of the arcade style six button controllers. genesis owns snes on this game, gameplay wise.

  • That it does. Megadrive version kicks ass.

  • the only reason people said the snes version was better is simple.... Snes had it first, so every one ran out and got it, and back in the day people just played what they had and was happy with there port.

    10 years or so later, people play both version, and imo, the genesis version plays closer to the arcade, and even the sound was closer, just played at a lower sample rate. snes games always sounded like some sort of ehco.

  • in general comparison , Mega Drive is better than SNES but in street fighter, SNES is much better.

  • Megadrive version doesn't cut the music between rounds, the music is nearest at the arcade, and the gameplay is kick ass.

  • You are the first person to bring this up so it's obviously not that big a deal?! All over the place not sure where you got that from! I have recorded all the games at (60FPS) then produce the video in Windows Movie Maker which puts down the playback to 30FPS if there is any slowdown its to do with the game itself.

  • SNES version is better than mega drive version

  • Nice list of comparisons. I caught one extra thing in Balrog's stage, though. In the Genesis version, some of the neons signs don't fade and glow like in the SNES. "Golden Goose" is the clearest example.

  • SNES version looked better, but I feel the Genesis played better..especially with the six button pad.

  • Same here i had the MegaDrive version when i was growing up :)

  • When playing the Genesis version on the Gen-X Dual Station, Balrog's (Boxer) sprite is very glitchy, and the same goes for Sagat. I'm not sure if it's the system, or if it is the game making this happen.

  • Buy an original system and then, you can judge.

  • I'm assuming that the graphical issues when playing this game on the Gen-X are caused by the game not being emulated properly. Other games such as Samurai Shodown and Sonic 1 have some errors in the graphics. Art of Fighting, MK1, MK2 and Shaq-Fu play perfectly as if you were playing on the original Genesis, with no graphical issues. When there are too many sprites on the screen, a game can slow down, and make the control become unresponsive until you shut the system off then turn it back on.

  • I prefer the mega drive version probably cause thats what i had.

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more