Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (318)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Jenni is good Melanie is PERFECT

  • mj would have cried

  • I would have liked to see a little more spirit on Jennfier's part, but she did sing beautifully.

  • @zienkai whaaaaat???? she had so much passion..and her voice apparently is a different key than michaels..she could have been putting as much passion as he would but it would have sound different

  • @stichez55 I'm only saying it because she was so stationary... move a little more, clap a little... Just draw the audience more fully into the music... She did perform beautifully, I'm just saying a little more action would have made it a much more intense and stirring performance.

  • @zienkai move? the woman looks like she could've popped the kid out any day.

  • @SH7861WeezyBabyy Walking three or four steps in time ot the music wouldn't have hurt her... And not really even just walking... but even clapping would've been better... Just showing a little more spirit.

  • Comment removed

  • Amazing performance, makes me cry every time... Thank you so much... X

  • Excellent performance by JHud!!!!!!!

  • J. Hudson did an AMAZING job... considering what happened around the time she performed this :P

  • i shouldn't be looking at this right now, but my spirit was feeling low. MJ's birthday is coming and I have a heavy heart... Love you Mcihael... Wish you were still here... just crying this was the worst times of my life....Michael you are always in my heart

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • i still dont understand why this is the only version that say "my painS'. the others all say pain...

  • One of his all-time most magnificent songs!!(; I will never forget him he has touched my heart my soul and my spirit to this very day!!(: GOD BLESS U MJ (RIP).

  • esto parece mas un recital que un velorio :@ que verguenza :/

    te amo michael jackson

  • Nothing can ever compare to the original, especially with MJ, but give her props! We love the King of Pop!

  • she,s a grate singer but michael was the gratest at singing that son gi really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really wish that was him up there singing that song poor michael the evil people wanted him dead and now thanks to them and their evil kids and the doctor the fake doctor damn races i hate you all what yall do to michael you wanted him dead and it was wroung there will be justice for michael just you wait

  • A beautifil tribute.......

  • Jennifer is amazing and this was a beautiful tribute!

  • Looks like she was fighting back tears.

  • the greatest man of all times

  • the greatest man of all times

  • everyone needs to quit giving her crap for the way she sangf this song (which i believe was BEAUTIFUL). she just had a tragedy in her family, losing her mother, and then MJ was gone. also she was pregnant. get off her back it was almost 2 yrs ago

  • this is sad these comments ripping her a part for her performance. IT IS WHAT IS SHE PAYING HOMAGE TO A WONDERFUL GREAT MUSIC LEGEND. Its easy to criticize then it is to applaud her for her courage.

  • you guys have to remember that she lost her family to a gruesome just murder months before she was very strong its crazy, it takes heart to come on stage baring a child at one of the greatest entertainer of our lifetime.

  • Thumbs up for this great video in the memory of MJ. Thumbs down for puttin Rihanna's bullshit in the description of an MJ video.

  • The first person ever who is worthy to cover a michael jackson song

  • @LaFloful sorry mate, thats Stevei Wonder.

    She totally murdered this song :( I mean come on, she is only human :)

  • @LaFloful I agree!

  • At least one time the right person one on American Idol.

  • It was okay. Sure, she has the power, but her creativity and phrasing was mediocre to me. Especially when the choir started. A good singer knows when not to sing.

  • VERY GUD JOB JENNIFER.....I MUSS SAY J HUD HAZ THE MOST POWERFUL VOICE RITE NOW IN THE INDUSTRY HANDZ DOWN...R.I.P. MJ DA KING

  • Is it me?!?! or did she do a great job on this?

  • @ashelay2011 its u :)

    go listen to the MJ version...humans cant do justice :P

  • did anyone else cry like a freakin' baby when they watched this performance live?

    i love you michael.

    always have, always will.

    you'll never be forgotten.

  • @Cla900 It's so beautiful. All MJ's songs go to the heart. I still feel a lump in my throat when I listen.

  • Would you let him look after your children ??????

  • @MN0151 why not.

  • @MN0151 honestly yes

  • @MN0151 Most defentely! He had fucking children this is a quote from his 12 year old daughter

    I kinda felt like no one understands what a good father he was. I’d say he was the best cook ever. He made the best French toast in the world. He was just a normal dad, except he was the best dad.

  • @MN0151 you must be crazy,mike just love kids,he will never touch a kid .or do sexual act to them.

  • its decided, im paying tribute to MJ or talent show im doing this and smooth criminal

  • Its just like it was yesterday such a tragic end to a remarkable life RIP

  • You just wonder what the hell was going through the dancers' mind at that point... weeks away from the beginning of bright careers and not to mention the most amazing year of their lives, cut short in a breath! God bless you brother...

  • Jennifer Hudson did such an amazing job on this song. Its sad to see kids today think Justin Biber and Lady Gaga are great musicans....those musicans wouldnt be here if it wasnt for Micheal Jackson....they wouldnt have the coolest beets or the coolest dance moves!

  • omg she did the song so well!! I remember I first heard it while in primary school in Kenya, Africa some 15 years ago, when we had only one radio station and TV stations started transmitting programs at 4:00 pm. Yes, they weren't kidding when they said he was known all over the world :). Rest in Peace Michael...

  • she was carryin my baby brother...2 OF THE BEST R&B SINGERS...R.I.P MJ!!!! <3 <3

  • her voice does not suit this song at all. Dissapointing performance.

    Man i miss MJ

  • @bortous Agreed, its a song that shouldn't been touched only MJ could sing it..

  • @Leandraxx1 This performance is actually embarrassing. People have got hearing problems if they compliment it.

  • @bortous nobody can cover his songs, nobody. But this stuff was done to honor him so i let her slide...

  • @EQTrax yes i know but still, they should at least pick someone that can do a decent job of it.

  • obviously mj is amazing, epic, the best but oh god i just gotta say how brilliant is jennifers voice i could listen to her all day shes just incredible

  • at first when I saw the memorial I started crying my eyes out cuz it finally strike me!..I can't believe he's gone!!why why WHY!!someone tell me why somebody like mj had 2 be taken away so fast!!

  • A day doesnt go by where I dont cry for him..I never used to cry.

  • Jennifer hat ne hammer geile stimme

  • loved mj when he was alive cant belive the way he passed miss u mj alsways and forever xx

  • i was just talking to my brother and we were like how funny it is that when this beautiful child of GOD was alive, everybody was too busy attacking him. Now he is gone and those same people are like oh we love MJ and we miss MJ...Yeah right...get it right, keep it right... if you did't have respect for him when he was here, do what you've been doing and let him rest in peace..

  • @bone12348 i feel you on that. i have alwayz loved micheal from that frist time i heard his lovely voice and i miss him dearly.

  • wow i just broked dwn as soon as i heard Michael s voice missing u dance M.J.

  • Chaque fois que j'entends sa voix, ça me fait pleurer...

  • i think it was bad most ppl had to find out she was prgo frm here that was just crazi

  • gosh. ok the beauty in this song is the tenderness and delicate handling of every syllable. she ate the song in my opinion.

  • I agree....but Jenifer did a good job.....and Im pretty sure it waz hard for her....tat woman has gone to hell and back with her family

    R.I.P Michael Jackson

  • Nobody can sing this song like Michael. A nice gesture, yes, but not even near the original...

    RIP Michael...

  • i've seen her do better in my opinionthis wasnt good at all..

  • @WhatsTheBuzz101 she was pregnant then and goin thru her personal situation with her moms. she did an incredible job considering the circumstances. could u do better?...........i thought so  lol

  • @rickunc your not defending anyone seeing im already a fan... and concidering the circumstances yes.. its still not the best performance shes done so i dont see why your acting like she sang the song of her life... Jenn Hudson is a gr8 singer but her voice was weak in this song.. thats just how it is

  • boyce avenue version, is much much better ( my opinion)

  • Thanks for everything MJ...you were the real deal...I can't wait to meet you, I know you will be there waiting for us in heaven and you are much happier there.

  • they made a typo its supposed to be will you be there not you will be there its soo funnny how they change it fast LOL =P

  • we will learn zo live with it we will never get over it because he filled our childhoods with happiness and joy.

    see you in heaven, micheal. i know they treat you good there!

  • nobody does this song better than Michael. But that performance is heartbreaking!.

    I will never forget the 25 of June, 2009.

    I miss you Michael. 'I'll never let you part, for you're always in my heart'.

  • i cry still i lost my nana the same day he died.

    love u mj thank you my favorite song.

    :"( tell my nana & papa and grandpa

    HI for me MJ and let them kno i love

    them very much.. :'(

  • your comment made me cry

  • Michael, you r always in my heart! I cried for 7 months, I am still crying. Everybody is here, except you, we miss you sooooo much!

  • hi...remember haiti and chili where thousands of people died and families and homes were destroyed forever...so yea i dont think EVERYBODY is here..

  • this is perfect, but Jackson is above the perfection

    <3

  • sure you are so right my dear......

  • The G.O.A.T!! nuff said

  • i cry at his poem ... i cried the night he died .... im starting to tear ;) i miss mj ....

  • perfect

  • supab singer that was a great performance

  • I was there and i began 2 cry and i still am! R.I.P MJ

  • Jennifer did MJ and his wonderful song justice. RIP MJ

  • am infactuacted about micheal and couldn't believe his dead till now without giving my love...

    i will be there for you micheal in heavens ...

    xxxxx cos am in love with you..

  • i want to bring to your attention that in the end of this song michael speaks the rest. in the original song he says "in my anguish and in my pain" in the memorial he says "in may anguish and in my PAINS"

  • Isn't it weird that more people haven't noticed this?! And I've searched for the "pains" version without luck... Gives me hope ;)

  • I wish I could have been there for you.

    Your art is your triumph over all injuries.

    It comforts me now and forever.

  • @TheMJlight Yes, Michael's art is his triumph over all injuries!!!

  • Great!!! But no one can sing it as good as MJ  RIP MJ 

  • I feel so so blessed to have been alive when he was, in the same life time to witness the magic coming from him...

  • @jossylabe yup :)

    But this girl just murdered the song :(

    why do people even bother to cover him...

  • i cry from what mj say by this song it so bautiful (ll)

    MJ IMissYou

  • but the way she sang that song, hmmm sry but I was really bad, I really don't know wye the other singers sound so crap when they sing MJ songs? ;o aaaah, cuz MJ is to BEAUTIFUL too DUBLICATE & too TALENTED to IMITATE! ;)

  • omg, when he talks it KILLS ME, listend to that beautiful angelic voice, oh oh oh michaeeeeel.. <3 But guys is it not weird that MJ is saying "pains" instead of "pain" and the way he talks here is different than the others? did he make a new version? xP all the other say "pain" not "pains" ? hmm suspicious :S but i loved it, and it give me goosebums and makes me sad <'3

  • I've never memorized this performace :/

  • Can anybody tell me the name of the dancer (short, with long front hair)  standing on the right but one. ...?

  • Oh my word, my head was swolen after this song. Especially the part where he spoke. Wow!

  • I honestly do not think anyone will ever leave and make as big of a legacy as michael jackson. The man was the worlds most prized artist, and one of our most treasures souls. Evryone is equal but in the eyes of the worl MJ was incredible. Just as someone said it is un-real and It is so odd to hear other people sing his songs. He has written so many of the greatest hits ever. Michael Jackson We love you R.I.P

  • so true fact is he is the most successful artist and no haters will change that hate all u want but facts and truth tell long before the rubbish is long forgotten. long live the king!!!

  • Get it Ms Hudson!

  • love this song and it's a beautiful song makes me wanna cry and she looked beautiful when she was there

  • My favorite mj song since age:2

    Im 16 now and mj is my hero.

    I lost my nana the same day he died :'(

    I miss and love mj

    id watch free-willy when i was 2 and at the end of the video the music video would come on and id sing and dance along with mj. Doesn't seem real i just wish we could bring him back.you did great! sad day but this isnt it!

    See ya later mj its ever goodbye!

    -xoxox love and miss u my man!

  • Es tut wahnsinnig weh diesen Song von jemand anderen zu hören als von Michael..

    Das tödlichste ist der Schluss, wo Michaels Stimme zu hören ist.......verdammt du fehlst uns Michael

  • tsang?? this aint no fuckin performance at the GREAT WALL of CHINA Tsing SaO!!

  • hahahahahahahaha too funny sang*

  • its so weird to see someone else perform will you be there and not michael jackson

    its just no the same

  • NO SHIIIIIIIIIIIIT!!!! he died numnuts!!! he can't be there.. they wouldn't get some bumb like you off the street to perform it!!

  • umm ok sure whatever.

    and ye i can amit i cant sing

    u retard hater who just wastes his time putting people down. oh and numnuts GET A NEW WORD

  • okk.. its SOOO WEIRD to see someone else perform it right??? stupid ass!! ur a retarded hater who wastes time trying to comeback with weak ass lines!! U change your mind cuz ur whack!!

  • ye, no sorry

    now piss off

  • if u hate it and dont like mj then dont leave nasty mean rude comments comman since u suck!

  • lmao.... what a kidd bringing up wrestling to this video ROFL!!

    Seems like Someone Hasnt Matured Yet! hahaha

  • He is and he'll be the best!! Always!

  • RIP Micheal Jackson

  • so overused!! think of something else numnuts!!

  • Love u Michael, u should not have left us this early :( rest in heaven, Michael <3

  • WE WILL ALWAYS CARE RIP MICHAEL

  • I MISS YOU AND LOVE YOU M.J. R.I.P

  • ---Rest In Peace---

  • @alexandrarop.....whats the big deal about the letter s...for the love of GOD...She sung this song beautifully and with such elegance and class. This song is an example of why he wrote these lyrics. Critism beyond belief...sing it JHUD

  • people You are sick? He is not alive..imagine if he could do this to his children? If he had no children I would believe but not when he has...he loved children too much to do such horrible thing to them....

  • Ortega said MJ had re-recorded the vocals a week before his passing. So, perhaps he intentionally added the 'S' to specify more than one kind of pain.

  • yes , like my brother ozakisound says

  • very beautiful ... but READ and LISTEN the last words that Michael is saying:and my ... , and my...., to my... and my "painS" . o_O... wait i thought that the ORIGINAL song was "pain", without "S"... so you decide

  • Yes the original song, on the album version he says " pain" and here in this performance you can clearly hear " pains" .This is strange. What if Michael is alive and he was singing live at his own memorial and he accidenataly or intentionally said "pains" because I have listened the album version and that "S" does not exist there.

  • i think he is alive... look at the old man with an yellow hat, big glasses, a glove in the right hand, big mustache, white hair... he is michael ... search out for the others disguises^^

    sorry for bad english

  • That's a really bad theory.

  • But that's the truth! On the album version that "s" doesn't exist.Only here in this performance you can clearly hear "pains".That's why it's strange! I don't know I've heard that Kenny Ortega said that Michael re-recorded the song before his London Concert and he added that "s" but I don't know if it's true, I don't know if Ortega really said that. I have no guarantee .

  • No, I realize that he adds the "s" in this particular recording but that doesn't inicate he was singing it live. Between the year he made the original recording of this song and this past year he very well could have recorded it again and made some minor changes.

  • yes, the original one is without s

  • Jennifer put all her living soul into this performance, to honor Michael, resonate, and bring his message across. Please see the vid of aliveagain2006. It speaks for itself. Will you be there? Michael is alive in other realms, and we are challenged, to understand and live, inside-out-within, the legacy of his music and lyrics.

    Namaste,

    Lisa

  • That was beautiful Jennifer... brought a tear to my eye... god bless!

  • Jennifer did a fabulous job singing his song,but of course Michael sang it way better,I also love the picture of him from his Bad Era.

  • I get major goosebumps every time I hear this song whether Michael is singing of Jennifer is singing. She did him proud.

  • Thank you, so much, Michael Jackson, for all the wonderful music and lyrics.

    You are alive in other realms.

    Namaste,

    Lisa

  • She Has A Beautiful Voice

  • Nice very moving 2:46

  • I cried though the whole Memorial service. This part especailly!! and when Jamanine sang the song "smile". :-(

    The most beautiful Memorial i had ever witness. R I P MJ - U will forever be in our hearts....

  • Just listening to her sing this brought goosebumps to my skin she is so talanted and u could see she poured all her emotion into this song RIP Michael u will always be in our hearts

  • she has such a big voice, i think she did great.. :)

  • :'(