I wouldn't necessarily call that medley safe. It certainly isn't anti-establishment like tp, but it isn't exactly shotts and dykehead or sfu, either.
I would call that a wonderfully constructed medley of very tasteful music, some original, some more traditional, played by an excellent band with fantastic sound, ensemble and energy. Overall, simply a fantastic presentation of the pipe band idiom.
pen65quin you obviously don't know anything about pipe bands, 78th Frasers are probably one of the most inventive bands in the world - I hope you're not comparing them to Toronto Police and that joke of a medley.
thats not true. some judges will like it and some will appreciate what they are doing. but regardless they playing in the rules and the most the judges can do is grade them unfairly
its innovative because they could take a hip-hop tune like the dizzle and make it into a pipe tune, but what toronto played....o man was that different, just wish the saners played a little more traditional, but still thought it was awesome
The judges in Scotland reacted the same way to the Fraser's medley in 1985 as you just did to Toronto's. Ried Maxwell said " that if the contest was based on the crowds applause they would have won that contest". I think the same can be said for Toronto at Georgetown.
And yet the entire Toronto suite composition is also by Michael Grey who can be seen in the Pipe Sargeant's position in the video of Toronto Police....
Now although that's now a year old medley, it never tires. Absolutely superb. Would someone please tell Toronto Police that this is what innovative is, not like the pile of shite that played at the same competition!!!
Proud to be a Fraser!!!
PriestessPat 4 months ago
now this is what i call a pipeband
grantafanta 10 months ago
Near the beginning you can hear the Toronto Police Pipe Band play their medley. It's a wonder it didin't mess them up. These guys play really well!
Gnosticman00 2 years ago
This is one of my favorite sets of all times. Even the way they march off is awesome!
djclimber 2 years ago
Very nice I piping
mikeman201 3 years ago
Can anyone tell me the name of the strathspeys?
Thanks in advance!
Weirdusername1 3 years ago
The Strathspey is Miss Lily.
rlucas340 3 years ago
Listen to the drones at the beginning! Spotless!
sgknexmaker 3 years ago 4
I met the bass drummer at the world's in 06 he is f-ing huge !!! Good guy though !!
piobrach 3 years ago
oops sorry i read the discription... nvm dont answer my most recent comment
z0mggg 3 years ago
wat place did they come in this year? anyone know?
z0mggg 3 years ago
1st i believe
gwoodfener 3 years ago
1:27
Did he take out his handphone to call Drew Duthart and set the tempo?!
He took out something, held it to his ear, than put it back in his sporran. Am I going nuts?
piperryan 3 years ago
A metronome to set the tempo. Some PM do that.
CanadianSidFan87 3 years ago
now I feel completely stupid. 've never noticed Bill Livingstone doing that before..
piperryan 3 years ago
I love you comment!!!! Made my day!
cjboose 3 years ago
how many pipers did they play that day?
davepiper1 3 years ago
I wouldn't necessarily call that medley safe. It certainly isn't anti-establishment like tp, but it isn't exactly shotts and dykehead or sfu, either.
I would call that a wonderfully constructed medley of very tasteful music, some original, some more traditional, played by an excellent band with fantastic sound, ensemble and energy. Overall, simply a fantastic presentation of the pipe band idiom.
freemanator2000 3 years ago
Didn't they have to submit two medleys? Maybe this just happend to be the one that they drew
cjboose 3 years ago
no, they pick what medely they want to play
imapiper 3 years ago
most judges at solo events just let you pick if you have to sumbit 2 or 3
LSBSPB 3 years ago
I think it is drawn at the same time as your position in the heats for the day.
BigBadBill2323 2 years ago
pen65quin you obviously don't know anything about pipe bands, 78th Frasers are probably one of the most inventive bands in the world - I hope you're not comparing them to Toronto Police and that joke of a medley.
totalpiping 3 years ago
What are you talking about Toronto Police's medley being a joke. It may be different but its certainly not a joke.
shapo812 3 years ago
TP's medley is a joke! If they play that at the worlds (that's if they qualify of course) the judges will laugh them off the park!
totalpiping 3 years ago
that msg is to shapo812
totalpiping 3 years ago
thats not true. some judges will like it and some will appreciate what they are doing. but regardless they playing in the rules and the most the judges can do is grade them unfairly
LSBSPB 3 years ago
You go onto the beer tent and say that and YOU'LL be the joke as well as TP
totalpiping 3 years ago
Sweet
DrummerBolley 3 years ago
another safe medley..nothing special stands out.
pen65quin 3 years ago
its innovative because they could take a hip-hop tune like the dizzle and make it into a pipe tune, but what toronto played....o man was that different, just wish the saners played a little more traditional, but still thought it was awesome
SteveTheScotDrummer 3 years ago
ThereIs OnlyOneStuart: The tune at the end is written by Bill Livingstone, called John Cairns' Double
purv78 3 years ago
WOW.. that is one high pitch!!!!
imapiper 3 years ago
The judges in Scotland reacted the same way to the Fraser's medley in 1985 as you just did to Toronto's. Ried Maxwell said " that if the contest was based on the crowds applause they would have won that contest". I think the same can be said for Toronto at Georgetown.
jjhjklk 3 years ago
I guess if it ain't broke ....
rilinator3 3 years ago
I love how Bill Livingstone is so small he has to wave to stop the band - and the only person who doesn't notice is his Pipe Sergeant!
ThereIsOnlyOneStuart 3 years ago
LOVEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE this medley
wellbecoming 3 years ago
Can anyone tell me what the final tune is called? Is it published anywhere?
iain5517 3 years ago
Personally, the Michael Grey composition at the end is a much more musically engaging tune than anything Toronto played.
ThereIsOnlyOneStuart 3 years ago
And yet the entire Toronto suite composition is also by Michael Grey who can be seen in the Pipe Sargeant's position in the video of Toronto Police....
bryangreenwood 3 years ago
Now although that's now a year old medley, it never tires. Absolutely superb. Would someone please tell Toronto Police that this is what innovative is, not like the pile of shite that played at the same competition!!!
Look forward to hearing you at the Worlds
jobieloon 3 years ago 2
Completely agree with you!
iainwestgate 3 years ago
Ya that's as innovative as the first 100 bands I've listened too this year.
jjhjklk 3 years ago
Cock!
jobieloon 3 years ago
Love this medley. It never gets old.
mcphidelt 3 years ago
they know no better!! sheesht like
sheesht22 3 years ago
new drums look nice
shutdown06 3 years ago
If Anybody finds the Durham Regional Police grade 3 or 4 band here in georgetown 2008 on youtube PLEASE MSG ME.
gwoodfener 3 years ago
I love The Dizzle!!!
nlights31 3 years ago