It's funny that it seems a bit weird to see Alex "sing' the SUBDIVISIONS part of the song when they do it live, when clearly it's not his vocal part on Signals....yet, there in this debut of the song you can clearly here his less than awesome(yet noble effort!) vocals for the "SUBDIVISIONS", and backing the "Any escape might help to smooth the unattractive truth..." vocal bridge!
@bluff2501 i was born in 84 and i love Rush, i used to fantasize about Geddy when i was a teenager and draw pictures of him. i love his voice and long hair. Rush is awesome, i love their music. If had been a teenager when their music came out, i probably would have been a crazed fan, then again come to think of it, i am anyway, so there's no difference :P :D RUSH is Real Rock!!!!!!
I really liked Rush, then Signals came out. Moving Pictures began their pop transition and was the last good album made by the group. This song is alright, but it lacks... what made Rush Rush in the 70's. Still the most talented group ever, but they will never return to the music as good as Permanent Waves and everything before
@throwsand how can you say that moving pictures was the last good album? there are tons of amazing albums they came out with after, like Signals G.U.P, and power windows was amazing as well. and there other heavier albums like counterparts, RTB, and test for echo! and dont forget snakes and arrows! all amazing!
I used to hate Rush. I thought Tom Sawyer was cool but that was it. Then one day I was kicking back at buddie's apartment and getting really stoned and he played Signals. I was blown away by Subdivisions. It has become my personal anthem. I've been a Rush freak ever since.
Just saw Rush for the first time Saturday Night in Greensboro NC on their Time Machine Tour. By far the best concert I've ever seen. I'm 19 and My Dad is 50, he's been a rush fan since the 70s and I'm so glad that he has passed on the love of Rush to me. The first cassette in my Walkman was a Rush tape, Rush inspired me to start playing and now I teach drums, guitar, and bass. I don't know where I would be at without Rush. Thanks guys for who you are!
When Clockwork Angels comes out I will download it on iTunes and change the album title to "That's Bullshit!!!"(or at at least until they get into the rock and roll hall of fame)
Saw them play this live twice prior to release. There was something about it even then that was really special and 30 years later it is still a favourite of mine!
july 2010: after all those years, i think i love rush more then ever. i just see theme at ottawa (time machine tour) and it make me the number 1 fan again. rush is gold and seriously, nothing came close to that band. wath do you think about this?
Being the "old fart" that I am... 52. I can tell you that "Signals" did not get released on CD. Thet didn't make CD's on 9-9-1982... I have the original vinyl release... great cover... the dog with the fire hydrant and all... one of Rush's best albums in my opinion... if not the best. Thanks, Steve
@gsisola you'r enot an old fart. im 17 and I have everything from 1974- Rush to 1991- Roll the Bones including all live releases on vinyl. vinyl is so much better fuck CD's
@ericplayzbass2 i perfer cassetes actully but CD's are fine JUST NOT MP3 BULLSHIT i hate mp3's i still buy cd's and cassetes and some vinyl need a turntable
Rush would sometimes do a mini-tour before heading into the studio to cut a new album. They used to come to Florida during the Hollywood Sportatorium days in the spring so Geddy could catch some spring training games while getting the bands chops ready for the studio.
I dig these "larval" versions of Rush tunes, but their sound quality is so poor one can barely pick out the details. And Rush is/was always best appreciated through their details.
Still, it's fun to check out the bigger, more obvious changes/differences between these versions and what ended up as the 'official' versions.
this song is a real reflection of my life growing up as a kid in alaska with my friends, the only difference is we had plenty of girls and bud to offset the growing pains.long live the rush family!
Mobile Fidelity Sound Lab (MFSL). They release Audiophile grade vinyl and CDs, the CD I have of Signals is actually gold on the read side, and the jewel case is different, when you open the case all the way, it gently lifts the disc at an angle.
just do a Google search of them, really interesting stuff.
This version has such a dated sound, I LOVE it! Perhaps my favorite version of the song, even though some parts of the actual version have been omitted. The synth solos here especially captivate and inspire.
I can remember hearing Rush for the first time(other than Tom Sawyer of course). It's hard to explain exactly how I felt, but I know that it was so good that it freaked me out a little. The music totally envelopes you when you hear it for the first time...esp. this song, 2112, Trees and Red Barchetta for me. It's been 22 years since that day, and I'll never forget it.
The synthesizer has a different mix, at least in the beginning. Less bass, more twang to it. Love those analogue synthesizers. I think Rush used a Prophet-5 for this one, since it was pretty much the state of the art in synthesizers then.
I think we've listened to the originals so much it's a treat to hear these live versions that trail some from the original sound; as is expected from a live performance. But they nail the songs in regards to note and timing.
This recording is the very epitome of a rough draft. It's great to hear it because it's very interesting, but this just isn't as good as the studio version. I've heard a few pre release versions of Rush songs, and this is the roughest I've heard.
I dunno why they didnt use a voice synthesizer to give the celestial voice a bit of resonation as opposed to the flat sounding version when he says 'subdivisions' live.
Just like all masterpieces, it began with a ball of clay and molded into perfection. In other words they didn't know how it was going to turn out until it was finished.
Ive been listening to Rush for 25 years, I listen to their music to the degree that most ppl would find disturbing, that being said, I can tell you this is certainly Rush.
I've seen Rush twice this summer and I know for a fact this is Rush. When Alex says "subdivisions" it sounds just like him. And nobody can imitate Geddy's voice that well.
alex doesnt say subdivisions.... its a footpedel control that uses the voice from the wether man from the toronto news..... the one on the actual recording. he just acts like he does.
I saw them do this on the Moving Pictures tour at Wembley before Signals came out. It's definitely them. Bass, voice, the whole lot. Any Rush aficionado can tell that so belt up.
It's funny that it seems a bit weird to see Alex "sing' the SUBDIVISIONS part of the song when they do it live, when clearly it's not his vocal part on Signals....yet, there in this debut of the song you can clearly here his less than awesome(yet noble effort!) vocals for the "SUBDIVISIONS", and backing the "Any escape might help to smooth the unattractive truth..." vocal bridge!
Very cool!!!
You rock, Big Al!
:)
Islander2112 3 weeks ago
can farm or bee cast ouuwwwwt
miamigroove 2 months ago
I fricken loved this whole album when it came out, instant fav in my car played 24/7...was lucky to see them live in 83/84.
bluff2501 5 months ago
@bluff2501 i was born in 84 and i love Rush, i used to fantasize about Geddy when i was a teenager and draw pictures of him. i love his voice and long hair. Rush is awesome, i love their music. If had been a teenager when their music came out, i probably would have been a crazed fan, then again come to think of it, i am anyway, so there's no difference :P :D RUSH is Real Rock!!!!!!
PetChickenz 1 month ago
I really liked Rush, then Signals came out. Moving Pictures began their pop transition and was the last good album made by the group. This song is alright, but it lacks... what made Rush Rush in the 70's. Still the most talented group ever, but they will never return to the music as good as Permanent Waves and everything before
throwsand 5 months ago
@throwsand Oh yes they did!: you need to listen to their last two albums. Pure magic.
vivelavidarocka 5 months ago
@throwsand how can you say that moving pictures was the last good album? there are tons of amazing albums they came out with after, like Signals G.U.P, and power windows was amazing as well. and there other heavier albums like counterparts, RTB, and test for echo! and dont forget snakes and arrows! all amazing!
Zombieman27 5 months ago
i love this song along with Limelight its my favorite
CSX8663 6 months ago
Such a song, all of these albums just remind me of my teenage years, the bomb
AJAM69 6 months ago
Comment removed
krlowe 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Cool upload! Sounds a tick sped up. I fixed it!!!!! Click my username and my videos to see the correct speed(and pitch)
krlowe 6 months ago
Thanks for posting Andy, Rush truely are THE best band in the world, period!!!
wheelywot 7 months ago
Yeah I heard that too...the keys voicing was a bit different in the studio but none the less this is really cool
ghero1123 7 months ago
on the studio recording, there is that drum groove that neil plays that should be at 00:35 but the lyrics come in instead....i miss that part
funzobunzo25 7 months ago
Rush must've played this around 1980 or 1981 before the release of the LP, "Signals."
musicman451 8 months ago
I used to hate Rush. I thought Tom Sawyer was cool but that was it. Then one day I was kicking back at buddie's apartment and getting really stoned and he played Signals. I was blown away by Subdivisions. It has become my personal anthem. I've been a Rush freak ever since.
nev594 8 months ago 2
Just saw Rush for the first time Saturday Night in Greensboro NC on their Time Machine Tour. By far the best concert I've ever seen. I'm 19 and My Dad is 50, he's been a rush fan since the 70s and I'm so glad that he has passed on the love of Rush to me. The first cassette in my Walkman was a Rush tape, Rush inspired me to start playing and now I teach drums, guitar, and bass. I don't know where I would be at without Rush. Thanks guys for who you are!
AdventOctober 10 months ago
Cant get enough of the Washing Machine amps
CavemanJesus4Life 1 year ago
they should record one song where alex sings it would be kinda cool
zackjp 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
God, I really miss the Rickenbacker...
Thanks for posting this; I love the pre-releases. Alex's voice really comes through on the chorus.
glennorange 1 year ago
God, I really miss the Rickenbacker...
Thanks for posting this; I love the pre-releases. You can really hear Alex well on the chorus.
glennorange 1 year ago
God, I really miss the Rickenbacker...
glennorange 1 year ago
BTW good post, I love these pre release cuts
OdyBeRidin 1 year ago
BTW good post
OdyBeRidin 1 year ago
I just saw Rush in Tulsa Oklahoma this week and they did a prerelease of two new songs. I think they are on youtube
OdyBeRidin 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
When Clockwork Angels comes out I will download it on iTunes and change the album title to "That's Bullshit!!!"(or at at least until they get into the rock and roll hall of fame)
happyface4444 1 year ago
Saw them play this live twice prior to release. There was something about it even then that was really special and 30 years later it is still a favourite of mine!
PhilipPorter 1 year ago
It never came out on CD. I actually bought it on vinyl. Just an FYI.
PokyMtnBiker 1 year ago
@PokyMtnBiker You,re right there was no such thing as a CD in 1982
MrBillydoo 1 year ago
This was from a bootleg, so for all of you saying it's not Rush, it is. They used to do prerelease shows and preview songs.
splent 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Call LOCAL ROCK RADIO STATIONS AND REQUEST "Caravan"!
LAST WEEK #5 ON THE CHARTS...#1....
RUSH1200 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Call LOCAL ROCK RADIO STATIONS AND REQUEST "Caravan"!
LAST WEEK #5 ON THE CHARTS...#1....
RUSH1200 1 year ago
this song/band is a part of canadian music history
21neveroddoreven12 1 year ago
july 2010: after all those years, i think i love rush more then ever. i just see theme at ottawa (time machine tour) and it make me the number 1 fan again. rush is gold and seriously, nothing came close to that band. wath do you think about this?
ericrob2112 1 year ago
I could be wrong about all of that cd stuff.... thanks for the post.... Steve
gsisola 1 year ago
Being the "old fart" that I am... 52. I can tell you that "Signals" did not get released on CD. Thet didn't make CD's on 9-9-1982... I have the original vinyl release... great cover... the dog with the fire hydrant and all... one of Rush's best albums in my opinion... if not the best. Thanks, Steve
gsisola 1 year ago
@gsisola you'r enot an old fart. im 17 and I have everything from 1974- Rush to 1991- Roll the Bones including all live releases on vinyl. vinyl is so much better fuck CD's
ericplayzbass2 1 year ago
@ericplayzbass2 i perfer cassetes actully but CD's are fine JUST NOT MP3 BULLSHIT i hate mp3's i still buy cd's and cassetes and some vinyl need a turntable
zackjp 1 year ago
@zackjp i still buy all of rush's CDs but i convert them to mp3's so they dont get scratched
Brickdump 11 months ago
Brilliant Lyrics!
gowhitesox12 1 year ago 2
Where do you get these versions of these songs?
Stevemiller09191972 1 year ago
Rush is going on tour this summer! They're playing all of Moving Pictures!!!
Cheese71 1 year ago
@TheSKCProductions go to you local cd store like hmv or sunrise
MajorVagina 1 year ago
Hey sgtpepper, let me guess, you own the new remastered sgt pepper album on vinyl?? If not get it, its awesome.
Celtic78 1 year ago
Geddy has such a sexy voice, he can sing me to bed any time :)
Celtic78 2 years ago 15
wow, this is faster than usual, I love it when bands play faster than their recordings (which didn't happen yet in this case)
abstract37 2 years ago
Rush would sometimes do a mini-tour before heading into the studio to cut a new album. They used to come to Florida during the Hollywood Sportatorium days in the spring so Geddy could catch some spring training games while getting the bands chops ready for the studio.
blakesdad38 2 years ago
I dig these "larval" versions of Rush tunes, but their sound quality is so poor one can barely pick out the details. And Rush is/was always best appreciated through their details.
Still, it's fun to check out the bigger, more obvious changes/differences between these versions and what ended up as the 'official' versions.
Thanks Maxey5150.
66drummer 2 years ago 2
Woah, Geddy can still jump!
Koolkitties 2 years ago 3
Be cool, or be cast out.
bassjammer14 2 years ago 3
this song is a real reflection of my life growing up as a kid in alaska with my friends, the only difference is we had plenty of girls and bud to offset the growing pains.long live the rush family!
morats8up 2 years ago
I just bought Signals on vinyl at a record store for 3 bucks
and a couple of years ago I bought the MFSL gold cd
sgtpepper1138 2 years ago
what is msfsl?
heinzpo 2 years ago
Mobile Fidelity Sound Lab (MFSL). They release Audiophile grade vinyl and CDs, the CD I have of Signals is actually gold on the read side, and the jewel case is different, when you open the case all the way, it gently lifts the disc at an angle.
just do a Google search of them, really interesting stuff.
sgtpepper1138 2 years ago
here on video, the Geddy`s voice is very nice...
santyrush 2 years ago
It never came out on CD...this is 1982.
mooghammondb3 2 years ago
This version has such a dated sound, I LOVE it! Perhaps my favorite version of the song, even though some parts of the actual version have been omitted. The synth solos here especially captivate and inspire.
TheSalvationist24 2 years ago
I remember the first time I heard this song... I was instantly blown away and changed forever...
dolmadakia 2 years ago 39
i agree with you my bro
luisoncln 2 years ago
I can remember hearing Rush for the first time(other than Tom Sawyer of course). It's hard to explain exactly how I felt, but I know that it was so good that it freaked me out a little. The music totally envelopes you when you hear it for the first time...esp. this song, 2112, Trees and Red Barchetta for me. It's been 22 years since that day, and I'll never forget it.
theoneil100 2 years ago 5
Totally agree
jigar12346 2 years ago 2
@dolmadakia ...
LOLKloklok 6 months ago
nice to hear it, albeit it is almost the same...just some different drums and the solo bit.
501W 2 years ago
The synthesizer has a different mix, at least in the beginning. Less bass, more twang to it. Love those analogue synthesizers. I think Rush used a Prophet-5 for this one, since it was pretty much the state of the art in synthesizers then.
warszawianka 2 years ago
thank`s for post it, I like sound different the original .
santyrush 2 years ago 2
I think we've listened to the originals so much it's a treat to hear these live versions that trail some from the original sound; as is expected from a live performance. But they nail the songs in regards to note and timing.
Manito9 2 years ago
i like the beat to this version better than the original
grimraper666 3 years ago
cool historical document. too bad about the gap at 0:48 though.
pngilman 3 years ago
Cool, I've never heard this before. It's always interesting to hear what changes went into a song before it was released.
RyanGuitar007 3 years ago
Sounds more upbeat. Subdivisions is my favorite song of all time.
21rush12 3 years ago 2
before it came out on CD? don't you mean LP cassette and 8 track?
zappawizard 3 years ago 2
Yup, I agree, CDs were to be used from 1983 or 1984 and on..
pdeleon9 3 years ago
the voice who says "subdivisions" is supposed to be a news caster for Toronto station City Tv, Mr, Mark Dailey
smitty9999 3 years ago
Alex lifeson does it
Cook1eh3ad 2 years ago
mark dailey does it
smitty9999 2 years ago 3
Alex doesn't
PackersBrewersROCK 2 years ago
Ya this is my favorite Rush song... if you didn't notice the sign on name.
rushsubdivisions 3 years ago 2
Comment removed
elwoodsfriend 3 years ago
Rush is such a BA!!!
rushrocks88 3 years ago 2
verrrrry different from the original lol its good tho
caressxofxsteel 3 years ago
This recording is the very epitome of a rough draft. It's great to hear it because it's very interesting, but this just isn't as good as the studio version. I've heard a few pre release versions of Rush songs, and this is the roughest I've heard.
fanofthemusic1090 3 years ago
It is live and it is the first time they did it. It is alway different in the studio ain't it!
pickzzzzzz 3 years ago
I dunno why they didnt use a voice synthesizer to give the celestial voice a bit of resonation as opposed to the flat sounding version when he says 'subdivisions' live.
*shrugs*
RallyCat909 3 years ago
its pre release... :P
larrylar2112 3 years ago
I mean overall. :p
RallyCat909 3 years ago
Just like all masterpieces, it began with a ball of clay and molded into perfection. In other words they didn't know how it was going to turn out until it was finished.
givmetube1 3 years ago
Ive been listening to Rush for 25 years, I listen to their music to the degree that most ppl would find disturbing, that being said, I can tell you this is certainly Rush.
RallyCat909 3 years ago 3
I know exactly what you mean. I don't find it disturbing at all. However my wife might disagree with us!!
VDrums2112 3 years ago
I've seen Rush twice this summer and I know for a fact this is Rush. When Alex says "subdivisions" it sounds just like him. And nobody can imitate Geddy's voice that well.
Exr1c219 3 years ago
alex doesnt say subdivisions.... its a footpedel control that uses the voice from the wether man from the toronto news..... the one on the actual recording. he just acts like he does.
apassageto2112 3 years ago
Ya think?
pickzzzzzz 3 years ago
NICE!!! ive been looking for this for awhile. very awesome. its more upbeat. yeah this or the studio version is very hard to decide.
superhomsar2112 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
are you kidding? this is ovbiously not Rush. you're all out of your mind or you're the ones who posted this recording.
thomaswayne1 3 years ago
yeah because it sounds nothing like them right...... any real rush fan would know geddy's voice
maxey5150 3 years ago
Definitely geddy's voice, and bass playing I might add.
rushrocks88 3 years ago
@maxey5150 That's dumb. Of course that's Geddy.
rufio2001 1 year ago
I saw them do this on the Moving Pictures tour at Wembley before Signals came out. It's definitely them. Bass, voice, the whole lot. Any Rush aficionado can tell that so belt up.
NannyWhip 3 years ago
Dude, you are a fucking idiot if you can't tell that this is RUSH.
VDrums2112 3 years ago
Are you high?
fanofthemusic1090 3 years ago
Dude, are you having fun? You got 'em.
ToolsnFire 3 years ago
@thomaswayne1 Um...this is definitely Rush. Geddy's voice is unmistakable.
proudlyrushian 1 year ago
whether this version is better than the studio version or not is VERY debatable
nym312005 3 years ago
Agreed completly.
JaggerSavage 3 years ago
Awesome
JaggerSavage 3 years ago