Added: 5 years ago
From: doogit
Views: 1,017,993
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (945)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I don't have perfect pitch and I find this beautifully fascinating.

  • horns are so overpowering. I've always had an aversion to them. I don't know why I feel the need to mention it.

  • Minor seconds!!!!

  • Do you understand this music or is it just not the point to understand it? I sometimes feel as if I was seeing an abstract painting when listening to jazz.

  • @chistorro12 Having a theory knowledge and digging into more than just the surface really helps you understand and appreciate music, jazz, fusion and classical to be more exact. It'll help you understand more on your particular instrument if you play one too.

  • Thelonious Monk is a genious!

  • It is just not possible to make music like this.  Yet, I just heard it. Amazing genius.

  • Man, people mistake eletric guitar for bass guitar... sax or trumpet are far away from general people knowledge... I am saying that as a music teacher... It is really sad...

  • Added to favorites

  • It seems as though Monk does listen to the music....It seems the music listens to him.

  • anyone else find his piano solo starting at 2:00 scary as hell?

  • @ISt0leTheCookies yea its more disturbing to me than anything, but it's also so logical and beautiful!!!

  • Comment removed

  • Holy mother of God. Geniuses

  • Comment removed

  • seeing this with almost a million views makes me feel good. either more kids are diggin on this or older folks are learning how to work a youtube. either way i'm optimistic for the future...

  • No one like musical ignorance, but at the same time no one like musical arrogance. Believe it or not, every type of music has its redeeming qualities. Listen to what you love, and accept other people's choices.

  • @cdcase29

    Aside from Justin Bieber. There's nothing redeeming about Justin Bieber.

  • @royo90 meh justin bieber's a popular artist. popular artists are not popular for their musicianship, but for the attention they get. Doesn't mean that they are a bad musician, but doesn't mean they're good either. apparently he's doing good at his job because im seeing comments about him all ovr jazz videos, which have nothing at all to do with him.

  • @cdcase29 The Problem with this is: We accept the coices of other people. But we dont accept that Artists with no talent get all the money and guys that have amazing talent have to work much much harder for earning less, and if they get famous, they only get famous after their death. If every music was free, that would not be a problem. But unfortunatley, it is not. 80$ per evening for a jazz musician with shitloads of talent vs. thousands of $ for an untalented prick per eve, that is unfair!..

  • This song makes me feel smug... as if I know something the plebeians do not...

  • Tune...

  • @sonick808 People that like the Grateful Dead are musical simpletons that have done or are doing to many DRUGS. lmao If you are a fan of the Dead so be it. But don't compare legitimate musicians to musical children that can barely tune their guitars. Insstead play Hippee land and smoke a doobie maaan while listening to Casy Jones.

  • This is really good whose the sax player?

  • i can generate or name any pitch in a total vacuum, without any deviation. That's perfect pitch. My guitar teacher noticed it when i was tuning my guitar without a tuner when i was five or six and started taking lessons; to exact center pitch mind you. It is also a curse, since every sonic deviation in your everday life is like torture.

  • @sonick808 That´s not having perfect pitch. It is of course a form of autism. You may be able to tune perfectly, but that´s just a secondary effect of your brain. If you had perfect pitch, some sounds wouldn´t be "torture". A minor 2nd interval can sound good or bad, it depends on the context, for example.

  • @tweenboxyeah "torture" was just conjecture. Of course any interval can be quite pleasing in the proper context. I was flippant with my initial opinion, and it got out of control. Enough. As for PP, you can't generate or name a tone in a vacuum without it. At least this according to 10+ years worth of training on keys and undergrad professors. Sorry for the initial flip comment, but I maintain my >opinion< that this is musically harsh. Time to put this one to bed. Filter on.

  • @sonick808 ok man, maybe I was a bit harsh too.. maybe you don´t like this piece because it lacks a certain "memorable" or "instant recognisable" melody? just wondering...

  • Wow

  • @sonick808 I hate you.

  • :-D

  • i have perfect pitch, and i find this horribly offensive

  • @sonick808 your a perfect bitch ?

  • @sonick808 well yea monk is rude music, if ur offended dont listen 2 it. u cant deny its amazing and innovative jazz tho.

  • @sonick808 I'm guessing he did too

  • @sonick808 You clearly have no idea what perfect pitch is.

  • @RoganGD i see your point though and i should clarify, it is the odd intervals (firsts/sevenths, minor fifths), lack of melody and noodling in totally different keys (when a key is even discernable) that drive me nuts re: this music. I'm not trying to argue it's historical merits, I just stumbled on the video and made an offhand comment that it made my head hurt. Now Grateful Dead, there's melodious noodling that makes musical sense... my two cents and just an opinion. moving along.

  • @sonick808 That's understandable, but it has to do with relative pitch, not perfect pitch. I'm not here to judge your taste in music, your claim just didn't make sense to me.

  • @sonick808 Man are you serious lack of melody. Didn't you hear Monk quote 'Swinging on Nothing' note for note then rip the hell out of it and base his entire solo around that? It's energetic, busy, and even a bit frantic but that's jazz. It's not meant to be nice and neat...

  • @sonick808 you have autism, not perfect pitch. shut the fuck up and learn more about music and consonance/dissonance before you start trying to act like you know things.

  • @mbera11 I still have perfect pitch, and I understand the difference between pleasing and displeasing intervals. No one without PP can name or generate tonally perfect notes in a vacuum or tune a guitar all their lives without a tuner. BTW, you should go back and re-read all of your comments; you probably won't notice it, but to anyone else, your degree of negativity is borderline comical. EVERY comment you make is bashing someone. You are a terrible hyprocrite and a miserable SOB

  • @sonick808 Arguing and expressing dissenting opinions isn't "bashing" or being negative. Sometimes I'm trolling, but not that often. I actually assumed you were trolling at first, because I thought no one could be that self-righteous and smarmy without an intentional desire to cause discord behind it. Apparently you are actually that shitty of a person, though.

  • this a good , very good music , first time i heared

  • Is that Benny Goodman playing the organ?? LOL

  • I can't tell.. is that a tenor sax or a trombone or a trumpet or a french horn?? LOL

  • chaos

  • Monk's solo rocked in this song!

  • It makes me sad that people these days could mistake a saxophone for a trumpet

  • @Miloshevits these days it's more like what's a saxaphone ?

  • @Miloshevits It is very sad thing, Miloševiću. :)

  • @Miloshevits What's a saxophone?

  • @Miloshevits A news producer had me racking my brains for an hour asking me who that Asian classical musician was who played the violin, "he's very famous, everyone knows who he is." Turns out she was talking about Yo-Yo Ma.

    When Isaac Stern died, a prominent news anchor at another station objected to my wanting to run the story, saying, "Nobody but you has ever heard of that obscure violinist guy."

  • @Miloshevits who cares, if they likes the style..

  • Thelonious Monk's music continues beyond bebop.

  • Why is there always that black ghost like orb surrounding the saxaphone mouthpiece on old black and white recordings?

  • @beaprod It's because saxophones are shiny, and the bright light reflecting off of it causes in the old style film a relative area of darkness around the points of over-brightness.

  • Comment removed

  • is that miles davis with the trombone/trumpet? not sure about the instrument

  • @lolaxian not even close buddy, thats a tenor sax, not a trumpet/trombone

  • @lolaxian You mean John Coltrane on the Sax?

  • When others were trying to change the rules of jazz, Monk just went ahead and broke them. Way ahead of his time.

  • Larry Gales is playing bass

  • Anyone know who's playin' bass on this cut? Thanks!

  • @b3l13v3r Gene Ramey

  • toq e qko lud ama ne go razbiram ne6to

  • @kaloyansa What?

  • He is soooo inovative!

  • T.M. é apaixonante! HE IS TO FALL IN LOVE WITH!

  • Seems that Monk had a thing for dissonance...perhaps his way of expression his own personal tensions.

  • Dave chappelle said it best, "he was always off time but perfectly on time"

  • My apologies, I somehow overlooked your reference to Robin Kelley 's biography. I'll check it out.

  • My source is Nellie herself but you can verify it in the incredible biography recently released, written by Robin Kelley with the help and blessing of the family

    You've got to remember that Dyer's book is a piece of fiction - a beautiful one but fiction none the less - he states in his forward that he was loath to let the truth get in the way of a good story - very little of the Monk piece is based in fact

  • @kingcake54 Dyer's book is not entirely fiction , it is in fact semi-fiction. I know this as when reading through I cross-referenced whether various incidents in the book where for real or not. To my surprise, some that seemed outlandish did in fact happen.However, I have only your word at the moment about "Melodious Thunk", so unless proven otherwise, you'll excuse me for still thinking it attributed it to Nellie. Cheers

  • Comment removed

  • Definitely recommend two books: 1. Monk by Robin Kelley and 2. Nica's Dream by David Kastin. And while you read those book, multitask and listen to Monk -- any Monk.

  • 28 dislikes? Id really like to pick those peoples brains...I just dont get them. This is brilliance.

  • Is that Miles Davis on Sax lol

  • I just love the name "Melodious Thunk" that his wife ,Nellie Smith, gave him.

  • @essexccc

    Nellie never called him that and was quite annoyed that people attributed that to her

  • @kingcake54 What's you're source for that ? Mine is Geoff Dyer's excellent book "But Beautiful: A Book About Jazz". Very much recommended.

  • @kingcake54 Of course I meant "your source" .

  • @essexccc

    That's just awesome. No wonder he married her.

  • <33333333333333333333333333333­3333333333

  • monk is beautiful

  • oh no, not the devis!!

  • His main style is dissonance and diminished stuffz

  • One of my favorite jazz quotes is about Monk, from none other than Chico Hamilton, Monk's drummer: “Man, I’ve played with piano players who played all the white keys, and I’ve played with piano players who played all the black keys. But I never played with no motherfucker who played in between the cracks.”

  • its impressive to see his fingers they never bend

  • "There ain't no wrong notes on the piano." Monk

  • Genius is misunderstood. Nobody knows what he was hearing in his head. He was Picasso on piano.

  • Iff you don't get Monk, if you don't like Monk then it's just too bad for you.

  • On the whole "wrong music" thing, check out Larry LaLonde from Primus or better yet, Behold the Arctopus. They create "wrong" music

  • Hitting notes is music. Is there wrong music?

  • all 28 haters are total cocks. Dry as a bone dicks. Don't get it. Your loss.

  • actually, there are wrong notes. the thing is, Thelonius Monk has never hit one

  • duuude thelonious's piano playing is SO AMAZINGLY CREEPY! he's so good he doesn't even need to cut his fingernails!

  • My favorite musicians/composers are unique and can rarely be mistaken for anyone else. Zappa, Bach, Debussy and Monk are right on top!!!!

  • só para o anacrônicos !!!

  • Malandro, saca esse baixista lá atrás esmirilhando!!!!

  • Brilliant.

    

  • Genius ! Life, exactly !

    

  • To Marie 144 cats: Thank you for your input, now I understand why 'Picaso's' Art was so , ahhh!, ''so bad correct.'' Glad Van Gough didn't have two ears, he'd be in big trouble.

  • i got some pretty good ideas for composing death metal from watching this guy haha,

    jazz fucking owns!!!!

  • @thrshr2112 its funny how metalheads can appreciate bepop and fusion. but dude so many death metal bands draw from this stuff, especially atheist

  • Love it. We love it!

  • I like that dude for what he's doing. and to those who doubt....you should at least like him for having such a awesome unreal personality

  • If you are a musician you will no that in jazz there are no wrong notes. If you are playing music, and some one tells you you are playing wrong, tell them " I am playing JAZZ!!"

  • This man has influenced modern jazz enormously...so far ahead of his time that we are still trying to figure it out. True Genius, period.

  • There are no wrong notes here fools...He's improvising. The great artists such as Monk, Tatum, Waller, Ellington and Brubeck, etc. would improvise the notes as they played. You listen to to much of the modern music with simple beats and redundant lyrics.

  • there are no wrong notes in improv

  • Sorry, but I strongly disagree with you marie144cats, mabolzich actually made a valid point. If you study the art of Bebop you'd realize that it is a very expressive form of jazz that often incorporates consonance AND dissonance combined with strong improvisation; which to an untrained ear would seem to be very wrong when in fact it is absolutely right from a musical perspective. That is why it is so difficult for the average listener to grasp. Btw, I am a musician. ;-)

  • i want a button near "i like it"

    ...

    just

    "love it"

  • If the world really is gonna end for us sinners this year,this is my choice for the closing theme!!

  • wow

    f***ing genius!!

    fantastic

  • does anyone know what this "epistrophy" word mean?

  • Comment removed

  • @okito00 a epistrophy is a composition that works toward every note being at once improvisational and intentional.

  • brilliance, all aspects

  • brilliance in all aspects

  • monk had a form of autism. fun fact.

  • @Ijustleavecomments You serious? Well, what do you know hu.

  • @TobbeStorm yepyep. my grandpa was worked with him when he was younger.

  • so talented and heroine ran his life!

  • You can't describe this shit in words...it's all about "personal style".

    Monk is up there with Oscar and McCoy.

    Another level...a master of the keys.

  • @VirtuosoBigD Level with Oscar… nah.

  • Amazing. Every time I hear these guys,or any Monk, it's still and always so astoundingly new. Thank you for posting. 

  • Monk is life

  • @YoshimizRobots I think quantum mechanics need to take into consideration the possibility that Monk is a universe unto itself. And yes, life.

  • @YoshimizRobots Very true

  • @YoshimizRobots

    YES! I have always felt that Monk often approached something not of this world. His melodies were so simple, yet, at the same time, they sounded so awesome and spiritual that he must have had talent on loan from the GODS! I agree- Monk is life!

  • Monk just goes to the boundries of the musical ganra...and beyond...wow that's so great on almost every level...

  • maaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaan. so cool.

  • Love Eric Riley...such a tidy drummer.

  • Damn I love piano sex

  • The piano solo (1:59-3:14) is one of those transcendent moments in jazz, impossible to replicate. In the mid-1960s, at a very early age, I saw TM a few times in Baltimore and Washington and concluded that, as with certain artists and writers, you either get him or you don't--and language doesn't quite explain the appeal.

  • Kendrick wishes he was as smoovvv as Thelonious!!!!! You'll probably never say Perkins was one of the best bball players ever. But for ever you'll say Monk was one of the best keyboard player EVER!!!!

  • Kendrick wishes he was as smoovvv as Thelonious!!!!!

  • This is his first composition (1942).

    It  was a signal that he will be a Master,

    Many years later je became a Sacred Monster.

    xF - Rio de Janeiro

  • For those of you saying what he is playing is wrong... You watch too much modern music. THERE IS NO SUCH THING AS WRONG MUSIC! THAT IS THE WHOLE POINT OF MUSIC! I'M IN SEVETH GRADE AND I KNOW THAT!

  • @marie144cats What an obnoxious kid

  • @marie144cats Well actually, there is. The way thelonious structured his music was soo wrong, but it still sounded amazing and original. If you, as a seventh grader, played music that was deemed "wrong" or "incorrect" it would still be "wrong." Would it be GOOD? perhaps, but as a young musician you won't have the insight to deem what is "good." (unless you're a prodigy). There is also bad correct music, like some new music. Correct and Incorrect exist, but so do good and bad, and dont correlate.

  • @WonderfulMrShyne You learn the rules so you can break them.

  • @WonderfulMrShyne Are you the deciding factor on all things relating to what's right and wrong? There's no such thing as a "wrong" note, when it comes to listening. Sure, you could play a note that would be "wrong" on paper, playing a seventh over a dominant seventh, etc, but, as Bird himself said, "when I'm improvising, my wrong notes become the right notes". There's no such thing as a wrong note. If it swings, it swings. Enough said.

  • @marie144cats So true....

  • @marie144cats thats right

  • @marie144cats Good for you, my young friend. Keep that great attitude.

  • @marie144cats ur the man!!!!

  • @marie144cats yea u rule!

  • @marie144cats theres only two types of music, the good and the bad kind

  • @yadrummer11

    no. there's only music that inspires u or music that doesn't inspire u. each to its own.

  • @flyingsnow00 that was a Duke Ellington quote and there is no such thing as music that doesn't inspire, its just that some music might not inspire you as powerfully as others, all based based on personal tast

  • @yadrummer11

    really? I didn't know that Ellington quote. it came to my mind, as I was browsing youtube, after the Bird movie. anyway, I think I put it too much in a black / white perspective :-) unlike Duke

  • @marie144cats Yeah, there is no wrong music, there are only more or less tasty notes :)

  • @marie144cats what's goin' on nowadays is definitely not music....money plays the keys nowadays... back then, the soul and the mind did.. congrats for havin' such taste, kid...

  • @mrdr00py Go indie

  • @mrdr00py What's going on nowadays is most certainly music. Just not good music, though I still can't generalize, because there are still many legitimate musicians out there today.

  • @marie144cats well I am 47 and I totally agree with you. Hahaha! Cheers to you!

  • @marie144cats wow good that you know that. Very wise.!

  • @marie144cats You are going to go places! Wonderful.

    

  • kendrik perkins looking motherfucker

  • PERFECT song 2 get stoned 2

  • Yessiiiirrrrr! Amazing!

  • very unique just cant put my finger on it thats monk original

  • Genius! A acid jazz band is Orlando called the Absinthe Trio covered this song every Wednesday night for there weekly gig. Purely amazing, respect to Monk baby!

  • Monk, like no other

  • Charlie Rouse is a motherfucker! The combo of Rouse and Monk is inimitable. Look at innovation young boys and girls. It's not happening any more. Ask why not and save the world.

  • heaven is here

  • Charlie Rouse was the man!!! I just love this song...

  • I love the bit that sounds like "Dancing Queen" by ABBA . Hot.