to be honest when i saw it was a guy playing one of the best ani songs i assumed it was gona be trash. I'm pleasantly surprised and that is true beauty and heart. Not too many can do an ani cover with such success!
...in all seriousness, are you the guy that was in shortbus? you sound, look and give me the emotional chill eerily similar of that person.. i guess i can just check imdb. either way, kudos, sir. well done.
ive been listening to ani since 3rd grade and am a 20 year old male,i always dreamed and prayed that there was a guy singer and lyricist like her,she keeps me moving and motivated.glad to see a guy covering this.im hopefully and finally going to see my fav musician play soon.
omg i cant believe that u did this song! i love u! this is my favorite by ani i think i just fell in love with u more. u r amazing! keep doing what u r doing and i know u will go far in life with a voice and looks like that! play on jay play on
we used your cover in our school dance show and EVERYONE that went loved this song and started to sing it :D yeah i would call that a win! i looooove your cover of this song!!!
I really love this version rather than the one u put into the album(They're both good BTW). Could it be possible to make this as the studio version Jay?
i prefer the old version of ani than the new one..this song is too sweet to make an electric version...or perhaps is me, who likes the folk rather than rock, i dunno...
That was beautiful. This is the song that I was listening to when I fell in love for the first time, and your voice delivered it so beautifully that it brought back emotions I haven't felt in years. Thank you for this.
beautiful :) I love how your in an area where it echo's the acustic, it reminds me of the echo chambers they use, and have used to record artists like Frank Sinatra. Awesome Work. You should do Untouchable Face next
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Yea, great job there buddy, but capo's, killer reverb, and finger picking are all clever shortcuts to awesomeness. As a musician, i know what you're doing, but credit is due, you have a decent voice.
Love the song, these rather eerie sound FX take me back to a distant time and life in the city. Thanks for being true, for keeping it REAL Jay! Most of ALL...Thanks for not selling your soul somewhere down the American Idol pathway. You're just great, just the way you are... but of course, you already know it!
thanks to you i learnt how to say "syndrome du canal carpien" in English, and I learnt "splint" too. (Made me realize i didn't fully understand the beginning of your "clarification" video therefore).
Brilliant. You should release a collection of "Learn English with Jay Brannan" DVDs.
Very beautiful, as always. Love the sound ! But what's that noise at 2'44" ? ;-)
Oh and you should start your tour with Canada. Hint : a show in Vancouver, BC on June 29th or 30th and Calgary, AB between July 5th and 9th... Just a thought. ;-)
Good! Dynamic! The Best! I like you! Powerful! Wonderful, far above average! You get a A.... Damn I can not come up with the correct word! " like your Videos Jay."
Dude, this is one of Ani Defranco's best songs. Nice to hear your cover of it. You've come at it from a whole new perspective, and perspective means so much in a song. There's such a strong sense of hesitancy or delay in the way you sing it.
so are you coming to toronto at all cus i hav about 100 people that wanna hear you sting half boyfriend - ive been spreading the word of your super amazingness around
LOVE THIS SONG. i've known that you're a fan of ani and i'm so glad to see you cover this. i love everything you do and i'm not picky whatsoever, but could you PLEASE do a fiona cover too? would love you to do paper bag or extraordinary machine, think they'd suit you.
The combination of you, one of my favorite artists, and this song, one of my constant favorites that has gotten me through some rough times, is almost too much for me to handle. :)
Beautiful.
melissabrundage 1 month ago
This is the best song to listen to during a gentle rain.
Aurhora 3 months ago in playlist Aurhora's favorites
Man, what a great voice.
bonder2010 4 months ago
Wunderbar! Loved your turn in 'Shortbus' as well.
Blaqueheart666 5 months ago
to be honest when i saw it was a guy playing one of the best ani songs i assumed it was gona be trash. I'm pleasantly surprised and that is true beauty and heart. Not too many can do an ani cover with such success!
Briinna
PCRoseInk 6 months ago
...in all seriousness, are you the guy that was in shortbus? you sound, look and give me the emotional chill eerily similar of that person.. i guess i can just check imdb. either way, kudos, sir. well done.
deebrahdeeb 6 months ago
holy shit i checked it and you happen to be exactly who i thought you were. well hooly palooza, as they say. i work in hollywood, we should chill.
deebrahdeeb 6 months ago
@deebrahdeeb Yes he is. If you watch a couple of his other videos I think he says that he was in it.
phoenixdown2621 2 months ago
The acoustics are amazing, this is an amazing cover
TheFreakScene 6 months ago
Good job guy!
kewaryan 6 months ago
WOW YOU ARE THE BEST UN-FAMOUS SINGER ON YOUTUBE BY FAR.
4dimentional 10 months ago 5
ive been listening to ani since 3rd grade and am a 20 year old male,i always dreamed and prayed that there was a guy singer and lyricist like her,she keeps me moving and motivated.glad to see a guy covering this.im hopefully and finally going to see my fav musician play soon.
out4blood129 10 months ago
you do such a good job with this song, it sounds better than the oringial.
at my dance studio we took your version of this song to do a lryical competitive number. amazing job it sounds great, i just keep replaying it
taylorshack13 11 months ago
THIS SOUNDS AWESOME!!!! GREAT JOB DUDE!!
maiganjayde2012 1 year ago
I love this song so much. Having you sing this Ani song is a dream come true.
Keichiokami 1 year ago
This is great, I only wish you hadn't done it in a stairwell :)
LeThALKitTEn26 1 year ago
I love the song.
Cheering you on.
<3
cottoncandycloud4you 1 year ago
omg i cant believe that u did this song! i love u! this is my favorite by ani i think i just fell in love with u more. u r amazing! keep doing what u r doing and i know u will go far in life with a voice and looks like that! play on jay play on
smallvillerocks5 1 year ago
we used your cover in our school dance show and EVERYONE that went loved this song and started to sing it :D yeah i would call that a win! i looooove your cover of this song!!!
KatKatastrophee 1 year ago
Ok, good song, good voice, ¿good place? But, you are not pretty than Ani... ;-)
Thanks, from Spain
aportaz 1 year ago
lovely voice
gorgeousalphawoman 2 years ago
great version....that stairwell sound is incredible.
silentfrwy 2 years ago 7
God, what a sublime voice. Jay makes a cover song his own like no one else.
DanPat121 2 years ago
<3<3<3
I really love this version rather than the one u put into the album(They're both good BTW). Could it be possible to make this as the studio version Jay?
Oishasan 2 years ago 5
Wonderful cover!
Knew I *heart* you both for a reason.
deeniebee 2 years ago
i just melted
mueslily 2 years ago 4
This is too much goodness combined. Jay, you sincerely rock. Love - C
CCarmen 2 years ago
good use of an acoustic area... really makes this song sound how lovely.. this song is
sillyduckling86 2 years ago 2
what a beautiful lil' cover... I'm sure Ani would not object...
At first, I was like "oh no... here's some jerk gonna piss me off" but I listened and I actually like it. Good Job.
informatist 2 years ago
I just fell in love with your voice!
<3 & Much respect!
electrixtears 2 years ago
You have no idea how much I love your version Jay, if I'm gonna die someday my only last hope is "let me watch one more time" Love you
maywong537 2 years ago 2
Okay I will ALWAYS love Ani...but this kicked ass. This song sung from a guys point of view...rocks...very nice
wantingsweetdreams77 2 years ago
Jay Brannan just kicked Ani's ass....just sayin
Sorry Ani, you know I love you still
BewareOfDancer07 2 years ago
i prefer the old version of ani than the new one..this song is too sweet to make an electric version...or perhaps is me, who likes the folk rather than rock, i dunno...
insomniacsuicide 2 years ago 2
I know I'm going to get shit for this...
But I like your version better than Ani's.
ToxicPopsicle 2 years ago
why would you get shit for honesty
myporchlight 2 years ago
i am just in love!!!! this boy is an angel and his voice is like an angel too....
insomniacsuicide 2 years ago 5
Jay this is amazing. i've been sitting here listening to this for about the last hour and can't get enough of it
hoocairz 2 years ago 2
Pure beauty.
epictimes190 3 years ago 4
That was beautiful. This is the song that I was listening to when I fell in love for the first time, and your voice delivered it so beautifully that it brought back emotions I haven't felt in years. Thank you for this.
irishbeatle59 3 years ago
=] amazing.
triciak1288 3 years ago
woah dude, great job. i agree... the acoustics are amazing!! probably the only guy i've heard who can sing this (including me)
word up buddy
campaignbassist or
whispercampaign on myspace
guineken 3 years ago
oh jay, you know how to please the lesbians, too. :)
kefidler 3 years ago 13
beautiful :) I love how your in an area where it echo's the acustic, it reminds me of the echo chambers they use, and have used to record artists like Frank Sinatra. Awesome Work. You should do Untouchable Face next
russellsangel 3 years ago
great choice of space to sing.
the acoustics are amazing:)
fattmoleyy 3 years ago
I could watch you play this all day.
rkwyckoff 3 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Yea, great job there buddy, but capo's, killer reverb, and finger picking are all clever shortcuts to awesomeness. As a musician, i know what you're doing, but credit is due, you have a decent voice.
SaintSkyler 3 years ago
i fell in love when i herd this you are amazing!
swooosht00 3 years ago
I just say OMG! I almost fell in love with you when I heard this beautiful version of Ani Difrancos best song! Please come to Sweden. Hugs, Jennie
Aelwa 3 years ago
He is coming to Kägelbanan, Sthlm, on October 22. Go see him! He is soo good live.
sofie379 3 years ago
how beautiful. love this jay.
browneyedbecca 3 years ago
Nice cover. But should you be covering this or any other Ani song if you have carpal tunnel? It's kinda hard on your wrist, don't you think?
feelquiet 3 years ago 2
even better that it's your c.t. brace...and the song is called both hands....just the humor, if you see it, which, i'm sure you do!!!! mmmua
sheldy29 3 years ago
i love you even more for covering this song. beautiful!
snatchface06 3 years ago
i like this version better, personally.
krissyheartyou 3 years ago
ah! love! thank you so much for coming to boston! we love you.
lndsy984 3 years ago
I love this song and have for years nice job covering it. All should here the version of this song on Living in Clip, which is one of Ani's cd's.
Jay you are so cute.
bnvus7 3 years ago
wow, this is fantastic. this is such an amazing song, and you did such a great job covering it!
zman918 3 years ago
Oh wow!
This is one of my fave songs EVER.
Nice cover.
myEpitome 3 years ago
GOD i love the leather glove accessory. u're so gay! and U don't even like boys.
therayees 3 years ago
Um..Jay Brannan is as bent as a tire. You're funny. You should watch shortbus; it's very good.
orujah 3 years ago
I love Jay and Ani, now both taste great together, mmmmmmmmm
davidis0k 3 years ago
I think you should wear that splint as an accessory from now on.
Oh, and great song, can't wait to see you in concert in Chicago on July 28th!
SenorCardgageFan87 3 years ago
i love the resonant sound :)
drewdmartin 3 years ago
thanks for doint this
Morgenrtl 3 years ago
Love the song, these rather eerie sound FX take me back to a distant time and life in the city. Thanks for being true, for keeping it REAL Jay! Most of ALL...Thanks for not selling your soul somewhere down the American Idol pathway. You're just great, just the way you are... but of course, you already know it!
rockyMTN57 3 years ago
don't you love stairwells?
Alexanadu 3 years ago
Wow.
crdav1 3 years ago
gave me chills. rad cover. :)
doit4thejoyitbrings5 3 years ago
thanks to you i learnt how to say "syndrome du canal carpien" in English, and I learnt "splint" too. (Made me realize i didn't fully understand the beginning of your "clarification" video therefore).
Brilliant. You should release a collection of "Learn English with Jay Brannan" DVDs.
With karaokes, video lessons and all. haha
choupinou69 3 years ago
Great job Jay! :)
GreekViP22 3 years ago
after sifting through various other covers..i can safely say, this, my dear, is the best cover on here.
mynamekeisha 3 years ago 2
Eres magnifico... me encantas! espero que entiendas algo de español! ya que te lo digo y repito! TE AMO!!! (I LOVE YOU)
elbetillogarcia 3 years ago
Awesome!
luxapollo 3 years ago
This is Awesome Jay!!
Gordieiati 3 years ago
This song rocks! Great job!
Ephraim1227 3 years ago
100 million times better than the original. xx
twinklekink 3 years ago 2
i love this song!!
and I admire your efforts to make your album!! that is boy!!
love you
Gracie Grace
graceinrainbows 3 years ago
Awesome!! The stairwell makes it sound incredible.
stevieray777 3 years ago
great song.
great voice like always.
Though where are you singing ? In background, it sounds weird, like you're near a crowded street...
yanndick 3 years ago
OMG I LOVE LOVE LOVE Ani DiFranco, "Both Hands" Is One Of My Favorite Songs She Does, Its Wonderful Too Hear You Sing It Jay :)
PS. You Should Do Untouchable Face, Or Gravel, Both Good Songs That I Think You Could Connect With :)
meowfeb1988 3 years ago
Awesome, My fave Ani song. Great job.
sebastianee 3 years ago
such a unique amazing voice... never change jay your voice sooths the weakest souls.. xx
rachellaing89 3 years ago
This actually made me tear up, Jay. That's my favourite Ani song but...dare I say it...I liked your version more.
Thank you.
tam358 3 years ago
Hauntingly beautiful Jay.
z0ltarr 3 years ago
спасибо!
nowhereisrighthere 3 years ago
It's like ur singing in a coliseum
Lab et!
:D
biatch0706 3 years ago
Very beautiful, as always. Love the sound ! But what's that noise at 2'44" ? ;-)
Oh and you should start your tour with Canada. Hint : a show in Vancouver, BC on June 29th or 30th and Calgary, AB between July 5th and 9th... Just a thought. ;-)
xo And please come back to France soon.
choupinou69 3 years ago
wow jay first of all love the song, and second the stairwell makes it sound incredible. love your music.
kilterdude 3 years ago
accoustics sounds great..
angelic your voice is..
Fairydustglitter 3 years ago
love ani, love you, love, love, love. thanks for offering a show in TX. i will do whatever i can to be there.
puccaleo 3 years ago
Brilliant. I can't stop listening to this.
page1bm 3 years ago
How fun! LOVE Ani, and great version. You can write graffiti on my body anytime babe ;-)
Oshaunasy 3 years ago
the exact same chords as on the song "Alles Is Liefde" (All is Love) that was so weird.
But lets get to the point: you rock.
Janzah 3 years ago
Alright for stairwell acoustics...you sound amazing. My favorite Ani song...and you did it proud. :)
nightsashke 3 years ago
I've always loved this song. And your version is beautiful
Karkar82 3 years ago
You are simply fantastic! Don't never stop you! ;D
emptyskyline 3 years ago
Great rendition of one of my favorite Ani tunes! I can really hear her influence in your original pieces.
meashman56 3 years ago
there is no chance you could come to argentina, right? hahah
your lyrics are so .. crap, i cant find the right words to describe them, they take my breath.
i love you :)
camigag 3 years ago
love this song...it's cool how you as a man, are singing it.
jameskernan 3 years ago
I love this song! It's so perfect that you did a cover of it.
ilobilo 3 years ago
Ok ! This one is just AWESOME !
leroisolitaire 3 years ago
Jay, Come to Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada for a show plz It would make my life!!!!
love a Gay Boy :)
smokeme23 3 years ago
Great sound. Dreamy.
Flanole 3 years ago
The echo made it sound like a church!..For some reason i cried!!!...and im a guy!!! DAMN YOU JAY!
ronniesaywhat 3 years ago 2
Love. :)
KarlSolenoidIV 3 years ago
Amazing. Great acoustics, and the reverberation makes your voice sound so full, not that it isn't usually, but this brought it to a whole new level.
You're so unreal.
=]
bummercucumber 3 years ago
I love you , you are so damn cute and your lyrics are just so powerful, thrutful and meaningful. Do you know If I can get your album on Mexico ?
sjrg 3 years ago
Good! Dynamic! The Best! I like you! Powerful! Wonderful, far above average! You get a A.... Damn I can not come up with the correct word! " like your Videos Jay."
k6tpl 3 years ago
Leather glove accessory. lol.
Dude, this is one of Ani Defranco's best songs. Nice to hear your cover of it. You've come at it from a whole new perspective, and perspective means so much in a song. There's such a strong sense of hesitancy or delay in the way you sing it.
2:30 into the chorus is really beautiful.
normanthepig 3 years ago
such a beautiful voice. ;)
Kinbarii 3 years ago
Great acoustics in that stairwell. Your voice just floats in the air. Simply beautiful.
dafttool 3 years ago
wow
Cherribudd 3 years ago
beautiful
seNCationDrop 3 years ago
i like how all the notes started to blend together.
DREAML0SER 3 years ago
Dude you are so brilliant. Aaaw...
nfolkving 3 years ago
See you in Boston!! I can't wait!
perfectchef 3 years ago
Oh wow those acoustics add to the song so much. Brilliant.
topcatrox 3 years ago
the echoing of the staircase fits nice with the song..it sounds as if your on stage in a concert! <3 awesome!
hipster101 3 years ago
dear jay brannan.
marry me?
najaha05 3 years ago
Hey Jay,
How r u?
Where about r u going to perform on tour?
Mx
celobraza 3 years ago
Most awesome acoustics ever. Where were you playing?
CaptainRandom 3 years ago
youre the bomb
PrinceA 3 years ago
Understanding that it may be uncomfortable, but I hope not too painful, still the glove-thingy looks kinda cool on you. (:
The song was beautiful.
brainstormy 3 years ago
awesome. love the echoes :)
ThatIsWhatWeAimFor 3 years ago
love your voice and the echoes of it!!! NICE!!
:)
agusbong85 3 years ago
..............:)
IVANNONO 3 years ago
Please write graffiti on my body. While singing. Much love. Positive vibes to heal that hand.
3vil1 3 years ago
so are you coming to toronto at all cus i hav about 100 people that wanna hear you sting half boyfriend - ive been spreading the word of your super amazingness around
SupaDupaStar90 3 years ago
Wow, I love Ani, love this song and your version was great, too.
felixdelmar 3 years ago
absolutely amazing!! the stairwell aspect and the echoing just added to the greatness of your voice! love, annette
dancintherain17 3 years ago
LOVE THIS SONG. i've known that you're a fan of ani and i'm so glad to see you cover this. i love everything you do and i'm not picky whatsoever, but could you PLEASE do a fiona cover too? would love you to do paper bag or extraordinary machine, think they'd suit you.
JuiceCityBlog 3 years ago
i am head over heels in love with this video jay! wow!
amerbamers0o0o0o 3 years ago
amazing!! plus i love ani difranco.
royalicecream 3 years ago
love it.
you make every song amazing[er].
ae7593 3 years ago
I love the way the spin sounds in a stairwell. Sounds great Jay!
scism3 3 years ago 2
youre amazing, ive always loved this song & your version is perfect<33
niceasboats 3 years ago 2
aw hunny i love your music, i both your CD, just waiting for it to come in the mail =)
goaskher8 3 years ago
I wish I was actually there hearing you sing it live. =)
minhman13 3 years ago 2
The combination of you, one of my favorite artists, and this song, one of my constant favorites that has gotten me through some rough times, is almost too much for me to handle. :)
See you in July!
leeranaka 3 years ago
you are truly inpirational
trevftmac 3 years ago
great as usual jay :)
doUknow29 3 years ago
Beautiful. The echo makes this song even better. I love you!!!
Firs to comment. Little, meaningless things make me feel special.
VegaBruin 3 years ago
your voice is so beautiful.. thanks for this
thej0sher 3 years ago
i really like the effect of the stairwell
it suits ur voice and the song really well
it sets the tone
ParkingLotVow91 3 years ago 2