H. Rajabali lecture 7 (1of5)-Tawheed Imamate & Infallibility

[lightofhaqq]

its a shame in all existence to ever even think prophets and imams can make mistakes. Astaghfirullah.

[courseworkdue]

I owe this man my life. He woke me up a few ramadans ago to get on my deen when he was in London in Willesden.

Allah (swt) bless him!

[TaskiyahEmaani]

no one is infalliable except Allah such sayings are tantamount to kufr and shirk.

[koroigetsuga]

you clearly don't know what infallible means then. Allah swt is omnipotent where as prophets are made infallible by him. Do you get the difference? Would it make sense that Allah swt would send you prophets who make mistakes and committ sins? How reliable would their sunnah then be?

[TaskiyahEmaani]

infaliable means something or someone who CANNOT FAIL. if you presume that prophets are like that then you are equalling man to God and that is shirk.

God created mankind with flaws so that they would not logically say such and such is our God.

may Allah guide you

[koroigetsuga]

Wrong again. Get a clue. Infallible is not the same as being omnipotent. Only God is omnipotent, but God makes his prophets infallible so that they can be proper guides for mankind. If you don't believe that then I'm sorry my friend, but you then are not even a muslim. So please come back to islam for your own good!

[TaskiyahEmaani]

its not for you to judge me but Allah so leave it 2 him and keep your vague oppinions to yourself. i have no interest in insulting people so please try to keep the insults away from discussion.

since you're so clearly ignorant of what the word infallibility means i think its about time we reffered this to the dictionary.

acording 2 the mirriam webster dictionary it says:

"incapable of error : unerring an infallible memory"

no human bieng is like that or will ever be so deal with it

[koroigetsuga]

congratulations you can use a dictionary. And yes you are right that is exactly what infallible means; and that is exactly what islam says about the prophets; that they were made infallible by God. If we didn't have infallible prophets, then we wouldn't have an infallible sunnah as we would repeat their mistakes, but thankfully Allah swt solves this problem by making his prophets sinless. Now please come back to islam; and stop following deviant ideologies.

[TaskiyahEmaani]

how ironic,a shi'ite talking about "sunnah" of the prophet (pbuh), what "sunnah" of his do you follow when your own books insult his dear wife and compannions? such hypocrisy is sickening.

no where in the quran does it say that man is perfect without sin, even the prophet made the error of turning away the blind man when he was asking a quastion. that shows that no man is ever worthy of bieng called "infallabe" no matter how pious they are. it is only ALLAH who is worthy of that station

[sgazaidi71]

brother, In surah al Najm(53) which was revealed before Surah Abas(80), Allah says,

Nor does he (Muhammad) speak out of his desire. It is nothing but revelation that is revealed. (Quran 53:3-4). Please Fear Allah when commenting about His Messenger(saww).

[TaskiyahEmaani]

exactly thats precisely what the quran says, but do u find it saying "all prophets are without mistakes"??, quoting that verse hasnt made ur erronous assumption of infalibility an inche closer to truth.

if u look at the tafsir of that verse u'll find it talking about the revelations not infalibility so please brother get it right.

[lightofhaqq]

Honestly brother, if you refer to chapter 53 verses 1-4 and look how allah swears by the stars, that our Rasul, has not erred nor has he gone astray, it is only a revelation that is revealed! meaning that he can be tied to error! You will then know that Muhammad (saw) can not be fixed to making mistakes. Allah swt puts the messages in his tongue, so when we belittle the magnificence of our prophet, he becomes fallible like us. And to say that he makes mistakes, makes him unworthy to follow

[Musclekay]

@TaskiyahEmaani you have obviously been misguided the wrong path because all u believe in is shirk shirk shirk shirk and shirk... none the less u are an extremist i take it... maybe wahabi? i wish not to kill u though, but kill ur ignorance.. may Allah guide u to the right path and increase ur intellect.

[muss212]

mashallah,MAY ALLAH SWT BLESS HIM AND ALL MUSLIM UMMAH,YA RUB YA KAREEM

[navidnayeri]

hes an example for us all! if we try we too can reach his level (enshallah!)

[mehdymehdy]

mashallah very intellgent man. And the man who truely put his life at the service of allah and giving the truth massage of islam , many will mention him in good names. and Rajabali is one of those great mans. al7amdulelah, and if it wasn't for man like him this earth would no longer worthy of continuing.