AmAzing singer Amazing actor seriously just beautiful a love this and i love part two its so sad made me cry myself to sleep selfish person jkjk wo ai ni han geng
@cksghchl oh really? show me this show and where he said it. in his interviews he doesn't even speak badly about SM after what they did to him, so i highly doubt that he would say anything about Koreans fans who have supported him.
@cksghchl he doesnt hate korea...he feels as close to korea as he feels for his home town....d media personeels has spread dis wrong things n taken out wrong meanings from his chinese interviews .......
@mishalaki ...i'm korean, i watched Members in super junior said it on radio star , they said " hankyung has some bad feeling by korea .,even they do not know what they have problem to hankyun , they just said sorry for hankyun... ,also , i saw news about hankyung in chinese TV show said " korean fans are suck " because , they are rudeness, but chinese fans are very good Manners" he said like this -_-;
@cksghchl Hangeng haven't said these words anymore. you just heard his members' words, and never listen to his word personally. Recently Hangeng said "he thanks to the SM company and thanks the special experience in Korea which makes him better. He still likes his members and has connection with some of them.He just wants a good work environment and he can get respect from his work team, besides he can put forward many ideas for his work which he could't do that before ".
I don't know why his members said these words about Hangeng, but I know after they said these words, Hangeng didn't say any bad words about his members and Korea. Please listen to words from both sides, that's will be fair.
@cksghchl if u blindly trust media reports den its useles...u shud see how he was all these years n den make speculations...........n he nver said he hate korea.............itd d media who reported dat way...he is jus sayin dat he is sad how things turned out for him in korea n dat he wil always be obliged to korea n like it till end.....pls dont bias yur mind like a narrow minded fan n face d reality...
@mishalaki In Chinese TV shows, the MC would ask Hangeng about the differences in the fans of each country, and Hangeng would say that 'My gengfans are all very polite.' Hangeng has only spoke negatively about SME. Even then,it wasn't to an excessive; he generally avoid those questions even when the MCs push him to answer. The Korean media however are very biased Hangeng due to SME's power, so a lot of news are from faulty translations and can hardly be trusted.
@cksghchl excuse me, when did hangeng ever say he hate korea, he has NEVER SAID THE WORD HATE BEFORE. dont defame him just becos of some biased media reports. u can see all his interviews, all he has is gratitude for SM. DESPITE ALL THE DISGUSTING THINGS SM HAS DONE, hangeng has chosen to regard all that as part and parcel of his life.
why did that guy that got slapped, the one with the mustache, hate Siwon so badly??? I've watched the second one and it's Siwon he is targeting. And did Hankyung just go into shock? Like is that why he fell and got sick and stuff?
@shamanking48 dat mustache guy wanted siwons role so was pushin him n got slapped n hankyung got shocked bcoz indirectly he was d one who hit siwon wid that blade even if he didnt want too.......
in the beginning, hangeng and li yin went to the same school. those 2 stupid boys don't relate to the story. hangeng always had a crush on liyin, drew pictures of her and when he took the blame for her, she started liking him too. they met siwon around their neighborhood. as they grew up, they became best friends. in the show, a man got mad at siwon because he got the part and not him. he switched hangeng's blade to frame him...
it's wierd how in Timeless, siwon killed hankyung and then in this, hankyung killed siwon. O.o people, don't bash me for this if i offended you somehow.
They are also known as the Timeless trio or couple, because they also acted in her Timeless MV and now again. Too ba they don't apear in Moving On. But Donghae does ㅆ
I saw this video a year ago and I never knew that Siwon and Hangeng were in this mv! Well, Super Junior weren`t yet famous then until the October of 2009 in the Philippines. I like saw this last March/Feb/April 2009.
what is this from plzzzzzzzzzzzz tell me >>> is it from move or drama or what >>???? plz i have to know or els iam going crazy .......i have toooo watch it because iam hangeng Biggest fan .....so plz help me T_T
if you're such a big fan you'd realize he did a series of music videos with siwon, including 2 other for jang ri'in (and xiah of dbsk) for her song called Timeless
@Valentine179 the bad guy wanted to kill Siwon because he wanted the same part as Siwon did and he didn't get the part and so he wanted to kill him because he had the part that's why ^_^ that's it :D its so sad though I cried so much on :(
hankyung and siwon were friends of her since they were young and both loved her ...one day they were practicing a play were hankyung stamp siwon with a fake sword , that evil guy put a real sword before the real play so hankyung stamp siwon for real .....siwon thought hankyung did that because he want that girl for him ....and hankyung felt guilty because siwon is his best friend ...any way you'll find out the end at part 2
muy lindo el video , triste y lo que le sigue, de verdad que los asiticos hacen sus videos con mucho sentimiento por eso amo su musika mucho mucho, gracias besos
the story of the three's past lives.. it's no way connected.. xD i'll understand if u meant for the line "past lives" by being their "1st lives".. then in this "i will-happiness left shore" MVs..it's their "2nd lives".. xD
She sings better in chinese than singing in korean. The Emotion feeling from her song is deeper when she sings in chinese. Still lack of a little technic (except her singing power) I wanna her to be world super star.
...this is a really beautiful songs..i love mvs with a story in it...i loved the timeless one..seeing hankyungs face made me shatter...that evil guy...
T_T her voice is beautiful...but her MV is sadistic D: siwonnn! hankyunggg! And Hankyung's painful face when Siwon was showing the girl that jade pendant was heartwrenching. ): ): ):
siwon never kill hankyung...it is hankyung who blocked the bullet to save siwon's life..the bullet is released by the same man who made the plot by replacing the fake sword wif a real one.
Duh....siwon killed hankyung in timeless but at here..it ain't hankyung's fault..it was a plot made by a man..and siwon ain't dead..the one that is dead is hankyung..watch part 2!
honestly I dont understand why her fans keep on complaining about how SM treats her, she's the only artist under SM who got such well made MV with a storyline and actors/actresses. Most of SM artists who earn big bucks have cheap looking MV, standing and dancing with a colorful background only.
this girl can sing but gosh, I cant seem to support her cause of how complaining her fans are.
It's amusing to see a complain on the "complaining" fans. You'll understand why the moment you become a true chocolate - when decided to give her your support, get to know a whole lot more of her and her career for all this time.
It is best to be less naive in perceiving things, dear. SM did those MVs of hers not for Liyin's sake only. He's trying to kill a lot of birds with one stone.
I LOVE U ZHANG LIYIN!
mickeymui1 2 months ago
who is the girl who is acting not the girl who is singing
BBmomoka 3 months ago
@BBmomoka Lee Yeon He
04AznBoy 3 months ago
I just love her! Zhang li yin fighting!!
mickeymui1 4 months ago
i'm guessing the bullied boy in the beginning and the shorter boy when they're a bit older is hangeng???
winduser 4 months ago
OMGosh! the boy that plays little Han Geng is soooo CUTE! I think he would grow up to be very good looking just like Hang Geng... XD
CpopNinja 5 months ago
荷蘭和美國人民已經 compromizing由SMINE網絡和網絡 DOG Palmgreasing smine貨幣地位的sSOS
TPaternity 5 months ago
This would be a great movie. Still loving this song in 2011. ^_^
KimiHer81 6 months ago 2
AmAzing singer Amazing actor seriously just beautiful a love this and i love part two its so sad made me cry myself to sleep selfish person jkjk wo ai ni han geng
Heyyitseric 7 months ago
WOOO! she is amazing singer :O and is he siwon? 2:32 in the muddle :D
Hirasukytha 7 months ago
我很喜欢
从泰国。。。。。。。。。。。。。
0877746961 7 months ago
我很喜欢阿!! 真好听!!!
0877746961 7 months ago
zhang li yin... so are a great singer... your mv's are awesome... *cry cry
myeolchijhae 8 months ago
whats this song called?
BrittanyduhQueen 8 months ago
God.
Jang Ri In,Siwon and Hangeng together are always epic
LucifersSweetAngel 8 months ago
who is tht guy tht switched the sword?? why is he lik this?
iisophiex3 8 months ago
nvm
iisophiex3 8 months ago
where is part 2 of this?
iisophiex3 8 months ago
Comment removed
six0704 9 months ago
love it .just keep moving on ~
MOMOAT19 9 months ago
We need people like Jang Ri In to come back and bring a change to the korean music industry.
upondlite 9 months ago 2
@cksghchl oh really? show me this show and where he said it. in his interviews he doesn't even speak badly about SM after what they did to him, so i highly doubt that he would say anything about Koreans fans who have supported him.
ltrannx 10 months ago 2
@__________@
انا مستغربه اني اول مره اشوف هالشي !!!!!!!!!!!!!
شيووون جميييييييييييييل قبل تنمو عضلاته اللي الحين من دون هالعضلات احلى بواجد
و هآآآآن وش اقوول قلب علي الموواحع هالحقييير :"(( بقووشبتآآآآ
505mhawy 10 months ago
all clip which HanKyung and Siwon make together. HanKyung always dies
silverpro89 10 months ago
why does my Wonnie always have a sad role, never being loved????? TT_TT
hathuhuong92 10 months ago
At 0:23 - 0:28... she kinda reminded me of Moon Geun Young @.@
dhooslhaaber 11 months ago
it's too bad about hankyung hate korea....
cksghchl 11 months ago
@cksghchl he doesnt hate korea...he feels as close to korea as he feels for his home town....d media personeels has spread dis wrong things n taken out wrong meanings from his chinese interviews .......
mishalaki 11 months ago 2
@mishalaki ...i'm korean, i watched Members in super junior said it on radio star , they said " hankyung has some bad feeling by korea .,even they do not know what they have problem to hankyun , they just said sorry for hankyun... ,also , i saw news about hankyung in chinese TV show said " korean fans are suck " because , they are rudeness, but chinese fans are very good Manners" he said like this -_-;
cksghchl 11 months ago
Comment removed
six0704 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@cksghchl Hangeng haven't said these words anymore. you just heard his members' words, and never listen to his word personally. Recently Hangeng said "he thanks to the SM company and thanks the special experience in Korea which makes him better. He still likes his members and has connection with some of them.He just wants a good work environment and he can get respect from his work team, besides he can put forward many ideas for his work which he could't do that before ".
six0704 9 months ago
评论此视频...
I don't know why his members said these words about Hangeng, but I know after they said these words, Hangeng didn't say any bad words about his members and Korea. Please listen to words from both sides, that's will be fair.
six0704 9 months ago 2
Comment removed
ItsCalledObsession 6 months ago
@mishalaki this meaning shouldn't be wrong
cksghchl 11 months ago
@cksghchl if u blindly trust media reports den its useles...u shud see how he was all these years n den make speculations...........n he nver said he hate korea.............itd d media who reported dat way...he is jus sayin dat he is sad how things turned out for him in korea n dat he wil always be obliged to korea n like it till end.....pls dont bias yur mind like a narrow minded fan n face d reality...
mishalaki 11 months ago 2
@mishalaki In Chinese TV shows, the MC would ask Hangeng about the differences in the fans of each country, and Hangeng would say that 'My gengfans are all very polite.' Hangeng has only spoke negatively about SME. Even then,it wasn't to an excessive; he generally avoid those questions even when the MCs push him to answer. The Korean media however are very biased Hangeng due to SME's power, so a lot of news are from faulty translations and can hardly be trusted.
ItsCalledObsession 6 months ago
@ItsCalledObsession i know dat is exactly wat i meant.....hangeng is not bad ........d media is making him look bad :(
mishalaki 6 months ago
@cksghchl excuse me, when did hangeng ever say he hate korea, he has NEVER SAID THE WORD HATE BEFORE. dont defame him just becos of some biased media reports. u can see all his interviews, all he has is gratitude for SM. DESPITE ALL THE DISGUSTING THINGS SM HAS DONE, hangeng has chosen to regard all that as part and parcel of his life.
jean1571991 11 months ago 2
why is that asian videos has to be always that sad?
Clausita26preciosa 11 months ago
whats the story
marakia78 1 year ago
siwon and hankyung are awesome! and the girl has an amazing voice. :)
springbaby485 1 year ago 2
@yuazchan It's just a two-parted epic music video by Zhang Liyin.
Ft. The Timeless trio; Hangeng, Choi Siwon and Lee Yeonhee.
FarewelI 1 year ago
is this like some sort of movie ??
if so please tell me wat it is called...
im so confused and so desperate
please explain if it is just an mv or a fan vid :D
sushi3206 1 year ago
@sushi3206 i think this is just MV ^_____^ but i really hope this is a movie,, for sure i will watch it~~!!!! >,<
SIHAN THE BEST~~~
yuazchan 1 year ago
is it me or does the girl look kinda like Sungmin o__o maybe im just seeing things >.<
Shikafan555 1 year ago
is it me or does the girl look kinda like Sungmin o__o maybe im just seeing things >.,
Shikafan555 1 year ago
why did that guy that got slapped, the one with the mustache, hate Siwon so badly??? I've watched the second one and it's Siwon he is targeting. And did Hankyung just go into shock? Like is that why he fell and got sick and stuff?
shamanking48 1 year ago
@shamanking48 dat mustache guy wanted siwons role so was pushin him n got slapped n hankyung got shocked bcoz indirectly he was d one who hit siwon wid that blade even if he didnt want too.......
i hope now u r a bit clear n it helped... :D
mishalaki 11 months ago
Comment removed
shamanking48 1 year ago
why is Lee yeon hee and Hangkyung pairs? together with siwon? like in timeless?
unknownprincessjacqu 1 year ago
why is Lee yeon hee and Hangkyung pairs?
unknownprincessjacqu 1 year ago
Is this from a film? If yes, can somebody tell, whats the title, I'd like to see it.
MrLoviiee 1 year ago
TT__TT i wish there was a sequel...
AkaneOkami 1 year ago
Siwon would be a good Chinese-Korean XD
Mistr3ssBlack 1 year ago
why everytime I see this mv. I thought hangeng and siwon r in love. hahahaha
MsAcangie 1 year ago 8
LOL you could so tell Hangeng dropped the stick on purpose.
Omg i love him and Liyin. Damn they make a good couple.
Hope4freedom76 1 year ago
it took a while for me to get this at first.
in the beginning, hangeng and li yin went to the same school. those 2 stupid boys don't relate to the story. hangeng always had a crush on liyin, drew pictures of her and when he took the blame for her, she started liking him too. they met siwon around their neighborhood. as they grew up, they became best friends. in the show, a man got mad at siwon because he got the part and not him. he switched hangeng's blade to frame him...
i miss them so bad.
12zuzus 1 year ago 4
@12zuzus sorry, just wanted to correct one little detail: the girl in the MV is not Liyin but Lee Yeon Hee. :)
Mixxsu 1 year ago
張力伊I WILL ~中文版
candice71926 1 year ago
first i watched "Timeless", then this one "I Will", then the second part of this song Left the shore something ^^" sorry i forgot the name.....
and i also watched hangeng's MVs from his 2010 solo album and wow....
a fact i realised....
why does Hangeng keeps dying everytime?? LOL it really made me sad T_T
but i do enjoy watching the beautiful MV ^o^
Hangeng and Siwon are great actors!!
Snowpuppet 1 year ago 19
it's wierd how in Timeless, siwon killed hankyung and then in this, hankyung killed siwon. O.o people, don't bash me for this if i offended you somehow.
davidaandJoBrofan95 1 year ago
@davidaandJoBrofan95 Hangeng didn't kill Siwon. He just wounded him on accident...
airiaram 1 year ago
@airiaram i know, but i was just stating how it's ironic.
davidaandJoBrofan95 1 year ago
siwon's really the best
acquaisces 1 year ago
SIWON!!!!!!!!!!!!!
SHAKAxSHIKIxKADSUKI 1 year ago
one of the bests i saw also on-line at
watc h ZQD las t mov ies . ZQD c o o o m ( d ele t e ZQD)
DannetteSassoneer 1 year ago
Siwon doesnt get the girl but Hankyung always dies.. ;'(
its too sad watching this.
shootinstar2396 1 year ago 3
li yin jang! she has it in her to be one of asia's brightest R&B stars, beautiful with absolutely sublime vocals...she just needs her big break :)
ulquiorra 1 year ago
lols poor shiwon XD lawls he never got the girl in I will or timeless XD
aqua09aura 1 year ago
where did u get the song?
yuna15angel 1 year ago
i miss hankyung ;( huhuhu
smittenbysuju 1 year ago
that girl has a very pretty voice. this is the second song i hear of her, and she's good
meralys21 1 year ago
me encantan estos videos
solandra14 1 year ago
cute kids
mariothao 1 year ago
they're both pretty boys :D
but still <3 han geng
apathiena 1 year ago
Siwon:'(
katgaw 1 year ago 2
ah siwon and hankyung are cute. I MISS HANKYUNG!! :(
the girl in here is pretty. and the singer has a nice voice!
chongyboo93 1 year ago 3
I love you, HanGeng
13131818456 1 year ago 3
They are also known as the Timeless trio or couple, because they also acted in her Timeless MV and now again. Too ba they don't apear in Moving On. But Donghae does ㅆ
FarewelI 1 year ago
Yeonhee look like Sungmin in that make up. haha. so cute! Im lovin Zhang li yin's songs. bec of siwon and hangeng!:D
beratclau 1 year ago
This is the first time that I cried over a music Video
twinlight18 1 year ago 2
is this song a remake? cuz i know i've heard it somewhere before..anyways beautiful song, sad mv =(
dorky887 1 year ago
WHOA!
I saw this video a year ago and I never knew that Siwon and Hangeng were in this mv! Well, Super Junior weren`t yet famous then until the October of 2009 in the Philippines. I like saw this last March/Feb/April 2009.
*state of shock* O_o
jpmalanog7 2 years ago
what is this from plzzzzzzzzzzzz tell me >>> is it from move or drama or what >>???? plz i have to know or els iam going crazy .......i have toooo watch it because iam hangeng Biggest fan .....so plz help me T_T
anfal1ify 2 years ago
@anfal1ify it's not from any drama or movie =)
It's was just filmed for this MV... it's just MV in two parts with story... nothing more.
MiyungYun 2 years ago
if you're such a big fan you'd realize he did a series of music videos with siwon, including 2 other for jang ri'in (and xiah of dbsk) for her song called Timeless
PockyParadiso 2 years ago
what's the girl actor's name?
val0793harbuz 2 years ago
the girl is so cute
val0793harbuz 2 years ago
The three boys in the begining, who is who?
Suju13elieve 2 years ago 2
wow hankyung and siwon are both great actors...they should be in a movie together!!
yfs88 2 years ago 112
@yfs88 hopefully HanKyung doesn't die in it.
reddeathm 6 months ago
what's the purpose of the bad guy??? what relations did he have with them??? i don't get it....why did he try to pick a fight with them??
valentine179 2 years ago
@Valentine179 the bad guy wanted to kill Siwon because he wanted the same part as Siwon did and he didn't get the part and so he wanted to kill him because he had the part that's why ^_^ that's it :D its so sad though I cried so much on :(
Magbsb 2 years ago 2
coco lee type~ very strong voice! i like it XD
ashley50329 2 years ago
the girl is also from timeless right? XD
kissthepants123 2 years ago 2
yes^^
x8xsumix8x 2 years ago
arent they ALL from timeless? (3 characters, not killer)
JulieN229 2 years ago 2
huh, i don't get this mv, can someone explain?
raspberrysays 2 years ago
hankyung and siwon were friends of her since they were young and both loved her ...one day they were practicing a play were hankyung stamp siwon with a fake sword , that evil guy put a real sword before the real play so hankyung stamp siwon for real .....siwon thought hankyung did that because he want that girl for him ....and hankyung felt guilty because siwon is his best friend ...any way you'll find out the end at part 2
origamisnake 2 years ago 25
I like this song
woaini089 2 years ago 3
hankyung & siwon<3<3<3<3
HelleyNguyen 2 years ago 4
poor Hankyung, he was framed
redbutterfly456 2 years ago 2
We can hear a male voice singing the back-vocals that sounds amazing!! Can anyone tell me the name of the mysterious male singer? ^^~
visualcheshire 2 years ago
I think he's xiah (junsu )from DBSK because in the korean version he sang with her ^^ ..I'm not sooo sure
origamisnake 2 years ago
thank you very much~! ^^
visualcheshire 2 years ago 2
i dont really know which boy is which guy...
is han kyung the one drawing? and the shorter and plumper boy is the bad guy?
kindlett 2 years ago
is that. . .
is that hankyungie nd siwonie????
oooh coooool!!!!
i have no idea what she is saying but its so sad!!
KpOpdork 2 years ago 2
muy lindo el video , triste y lo que le sigue, de verdad que los asiticos hacen sus videos con mucho sentimiento por eso amo su musika mucho mucho, gracias besos
bye.
kimjakeful 2 years ago
Is there a second part of this song?
lildreams44 2 years ago
yeah, the next part is called 'THE LEFT SHORE OF HAPPINESS' you can find it in the related videos. :)
100ghostangel 2 years ago 3
Thanks =)
lildreams44 2 years ago
what film is it??
LillyLoewenherz 2 years ago
it's not an acual movie, it's just an MV with a storyline.
NotSoBoyCrazy 2 years ago 3
I love SiHan..
I wish they made more videos together..
and ZLY's voice is beautiful.. ^___^
DanyYumeChan 2 years ago 9
y is it always hangeng siwon&riin in mv's like timeless? not lik im complainin siwon&hangeng r hot & riin is really pretty..but ya know
girlsrul9 2 years ago
it tells the stories of the three's past lives in timeless
strawberrysquib 2 years ago 2
the story of the three's past lives.. it's no way connected.. xD i'll understand if u meant for the line "past lives" by being their "1st lives".. then in this "i will-happiness left shore" MVs..it's their "2nd lives".. xD
chriscyd02 2 years ago
wats the story4 the2 parts
girlsrul9 2 years ago
omg...soo sad, especially the ending to part 2! i cried....
maxginjiro1990 2 years ago 4
i did too, it was sooo sad!! poor hankyung!
strawberrysquib 2 years ago 4
This song plus the mv made we want to cry, i'm lost for words.
Smexyflower 2 years ago 3
She sings better in chinese than singing in korean. The Emotion feeling from her song is deeper when she sings in chinese. Still lack of a little technic (except her singing power) I wanna her to be world super star.
asfreeas 2 years ago
she's chinese ^^
she's just in SM because she wants to be. :)
actually... hangeng, victoria, amber, and zhang li yin herself are all chinese in SM :D
go zhang li yin!
12zuzus 2 years ago 6
Is she Korean or Chinese? Her mandarin is good.
mlal1027 2 years ago
she's chinese
girlsrul9 2 years ago
Thank you.
mlal1027 2 years ago
welcome
girlsrul9 2 years ago
love them both..han geng and siwon...hehehehe they both can act well...han geng...go go go.
kugmoe 2 years ago 3
this mv remind me of stormrider somehow...two guys over a girl...but its hard to choose between hangeng n shiwon!!! both are hottt!!!
juita2cute 2 years ago 2
i love how sihan works together <3333
hellosama 2 years ago 5
oh man...that guy who change the sharp is sooo ridiculous!!!
merryyuna 2 years ago 4
my Sihan couple <3
nph9x 2 years ago 54
@nph9x later Heechul jealous XP
MrLovess501 1 year ago
que padre la cancion... me gusta el sentimiento aunque no se que dice jeje
otra vez los mismos poarticipandojuntos
pero con papel inverso? o no le entendi ... solo que el final de este no me gusto mucho , dice que tiene parte 2 lo vere XD
kokotzin1 2 years ago
OMg her voice is incredible.
0:15 ~ hellooo ;) haha, Hangeng looked so cute there.
YesungIsAmazing 2 years ago 7
I just love her voice! ^^
thedebster367 2 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
Does this song got a Korean Version??
Cause i don't like Chinese much..
I'm not saying that this song is not nice but i juz dun like Chinese!!
Plz, if someone knows, plz tell!! I wanna download Korean version one!!
Joan8336 2 years ago
SIWON and HANKYUNG are SUPER HANDSOME!!!
rainbowromanceabc 2 years ago 8
sinlaoo
lagatitadulcelove 2 years ago
EY! S.E.S sang this song
DBSK100 2 years ago
...this is a really beautiful songs..i love mvs with a story in it...i loved the timeless one..seeing hankyungs face made me shatter...that evil guy...
xXSugaFernii 2 years ago 2
omg! its so cute! the 2 boi's (siwon and hangeng) ish so cute! part 2 ish just sad
nouv94 2 years ago 2
omg hankyung and siwon rocked this mv. XD
lov3fahrEnheit 2 years ago 2
i dont get it.... but its soo sad :(
PJCNA 2 years ago
isit there siwon?
dumxmylove 2 years ago
Timeless and I Will/Happiness Left Shore has nothing to do with one another :<
heartquakexx 2 years ago 4
T_T her voice is beautiful...but her MV is sadistic D: siwonnn! hankyunggg! And Hankyung's painful face when Siwon was showing the girl that jade pendant was heartwrenching. ): ): ):
grinobsession 2 years ago 16
<33333333 Favourite song !!
awesomeivee 2 years ago
I absolutely love this song. Zhang LiYin is my favorite soloist & female artist. (: Waiting for your comeback~ <3
luminousxdoll 2 years ago 5
ahahha the girl in chinese opera makeup looks like kangin
sawsee28 2 years ago
That sucks, man why does my man kill your and than yours kills mine, ahhh revenge.. :(
Kimmy3999 2 years ago
Wow. In Timeless Siwon killed Hankyung. Now Hankyung gets revengs and kills Siwon!
FayDKurogane 2 years ago
ahaha! watch part two! si won kills han kyung!
lazyangel5 2 years ago
I know! Its in a perpetual spiral of Hankyung killing! :P
FayDKurogane 2 years ago
siwon never kill hankyung...it is hankyung who blocked the bullet to save siwon's life..the bullet is released by the same man who made the plot by replacing the fake sword wif a real one.
LVDonghaeLV 2 years ago 3
By Why does hankyung always gotta die?
He's always somehow saving Siwon!
WHY!?
lilipute 2 years ago 5
i dunno....ask the script writer n director....i live so far from them...hahaXD
LVDonghaeLV 2 years ago
i know right. that sucks. The HANDSOME one always has to die.
DBSK100 2 years ago 7
Duh....siwon killed hankyung in timeless but at here..it ain't hankyung's fault..it was a plot made by a man..and siwon ain't dead..the one that is dead is hankyung..watch part 2!
LVDonghaeLV 2 years ago 7
I have seen it now. Quit being so... stiff.
FayDKurogane 2 years ago
HAN GENG!!!!!!!!!!!
candiwandi12 2 years ago
It is the song mas beautiful that listens is really beautiful I cannot stop crying it(he,she) is so sad and she sings it with so much(many) feeling
o0okathyoOo 2 years ago
Oh Han Geng! The look of sadness on his face when she picked Siwon's necklace over his.
bubble80 2 years ago 6
seeing both Siwon & Hankyung in Chinese Opera costumes and makeup is PRICELESS.
i'll never watch Chinese Opera the same way again.
swtgal125 2 years ago 3
she has the best voice ever love this song this song is timeless
littlemoonsilver 2 years ago 8
But well, the MV is made well.
caprishiqi 2 years ago
the storyline is soo cute..but i hate the ending T_T
whyyy~
but dude...GENG IS SOO FREAKING HOT HERE! then again he always is...
and shiwon's dimple smile @ 3:15 xD too cute
but i still love geng more :P hes so shy here(its his character but he still does it beautifully!)
dumastoryy 2 years ago 7
its so cool how they all grew up together!
tis so cute how they BOTH like her, too!
actually,
its such a coincidence because:
Hankyung gets shot 2x in "Timeless" (but dies)
and
Siwon gets treatment again in "Timeless".
randumbutts 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
honestly I dont understand why her fans keep on complaining about how SM treats her, she's the only artist under SM who got such well made MV with a storyline and actors/actresses. Most of SM artists who earn big bucks have cheap looking MV, standing and dancing with a colorful background only.
this girl can sing but gosh, I cant seem to support her cause of how complaining her fans are.
oooogie 2 years ago
It's amusing to see a complain on the "complaining" fans. You'll understand why the moment you become a true chocolate - when decided to give her your support, get to know a whole lot more of her and her career for all this time.
It is best to be less naive in perceiving things, dear. SM did those MVs of hers not for Liyin's sake only. He's trying to kill a lot of birds with one stone.
daydreamer11587 2 years ago 4
Well said Faridah ^^
chocosweetbow 2 years ago