quick bible references for you guys here, NO the bible doesn't say jews go to heaven it just says they don't go to hell, and christianity isn't just about saying jesus was the man and now I can dick around. I find it incredibly ironic how one who pushes christianity so ferverently has the incredible ignorance of her own religion. TJae1 have you seen the piece where ann coulter says that we should remove all practicioners of islam? incredibly funny you should check it out :D
the point of the question is that extreme Republican policies will lead to Americans failure and even republicans know it! No government is worse than communism
She believes everyone should be her religion and that is exactly the mentality that lead religious persecution and sparked intolerance to become the violence we have seen today. I am a Christian...and deeply embarassed and offended by her comments.
all religions are the backward cultural device of ancient man, theres a reason a full blown religion hasnt been made in the past couple hundred years and that reason is science. religion is ancient mans way of explaining things they could understand, or a device used to escape reality and its horrid truth. most "religious" people havnt even read their own books or parchments on the religion they belong to. who cares what a political pundit said or did its not like ann is gonna shake the world.
Keep tryin' ya'll .... I wanna see those ~ wow ~ Ur really on to something ~ comment(s) ~ I hate anne~ won't get it ~ coherent, rational, keen, logic is key ~
Woah, she just denounced a whole race of people and claimed that christians, like herself, were the "perfected" version of those people. The sad thing is that she's definitely not the only person who believes this. What an arrogant bitch. angeljenny55 Ann Coulter's heart is FAR from being even remotely pure. She is ignorance incarnate.
I LOVE Ann Coulter! She's a bulldog in her approach, but her heart is pure and so is her love for America. She certainly could have put her words better, but I think Mr. Deutsche intends to be offended, On other words, if you're looking to have your feelings hurt, it's a guarantee that someone will hurt them. Messianic Jews do have the best of it all, and he should have been more attentive to her intent, rather than just to her words.
Hi, Deutsche didn't try to understand what Ann said. I doubt he even cared what she thought about any religion. He is a lieveral, so he was trying to impugn her politically. It's the way liberals play since they always lose if they play by the rules.
Doesn't she realize the corrupt government embraces the bowels of the other place? I'm Christian, and was raised a Jew. She's never been to my church and I'm not a Democrat or a Republican. Why would we want to equate American politics with God's kingdom? It is an insult to God.
I'm with you, RJ's Grl! Ann never is tactful, she always takes a bulldog's way to say something, but her intent was pure. The NT is the continuation of the OT. If Mr. Deutch choses to be offended, rather than listening, that's on him, not on Ann.
I don't like Ann Coulter at all, but I think this guy is just trying to "trap" her into an offensive answer, and actually, she scores some points here.
All he did was set her up to espouse how "diverse" the world would be if we were all Christians, which is ridiculous.
Lol... bettr; needs more rationalizing ,though. E.G: Discussed Subject(s) w/ honest thought effort. B a hardware "nerd" & treat Anne like the next Xbox, if that helps.
We've obviously heard from the haters; yada, yada; let's try something different, the terms for commenting, for now, are listd below. (Enjoy, U mite find it rewarding)
Ann Cunter is a dumbass, NYC was not happy during the RNC Convention, I'm from here and we were protesting everything like hell and making them not feel welcome at all. She's such a woman who Can't Understand Normal Thinking!
Another right-wing lobotomized piece of shit, so glad Obama one so we can shut you assholes down once and for all. OBAMA IS NOT ISLAMIC, ASSHOLE, AND HE WON, GET OVER IT - NOW TIME FOR REAL CHANGE FOR THE BETTER!
the people at the conventione WERE happy and peaceful, unlike ANY demoncratic convention where they (the libs) riot non stop! There is no peace in the democratic party, they are the hate mongers.
That was great when she said you're not a praticing Jew and he said yes I am. Although he was calm you know on the inside he was like "take that bitch!" Good for him!
Beats the numb-F#ckin' logic of hollyworld-comedy, will they ever stop this idoitic rant, about 100k + home give always... unless 1 enjoys serious debt or likes sharing rent w/3 families, I don't get the punchline. I got a job & I'm in serious debt, but that Dumb F#ck, does'nt? Hahahahaha?
i agree that if we were all christian we would be better off. But thats just because any form of unity on a large scale would be good. Honestly we'd be even better off if we were all buddhist, but thats a matter of opinion.
So cute that little noobs on the inner tubes can cut and paste. What does that prove? I will stick with that statement infact. I like boobs and women, and even your girl friend Ann even though she is a freakishly tall neo nazi blonde. I will say it again if you support this person you are a moron and a nazi. Now ge tthe fuck off my innertubes which i clearly stated before.
Ann Coulter, what a hypocritical bitch! This is why people are so negative about christianaty these days. Its because of Stubborn, close minded, and intolerant people like Ann coulter. It makes me want to vommit. We need to change the way we think about how we treat and what we say to other people who have different beliefs and ideas. So they will be the same way with us. So hopefully one day we can all live in harmony.
An atheist's morality is generally grounded in humanism, the golden rule: "Do unto others..." Famed religious principle; welcome aboard. But now let me ask, what reason would someone who believes in a genocidal God have to be moral? ^^ In a genocidal way, probably.
Ann Coulter has never discussed anything in her political career. Discussion means more than simply repeating the same talking points ad nauseam with the odd insult thrown in for 'comedic' effect.
interesting woman. if she thinks that christians are merely perfected jews, does it follow that she thinks muslims are perfected jews and perfected christians? i wonder is she can cite another seinfeld episode to answer that....
on 1 level she's hilarious & genuinely entertaining. she's a million times more interesting & worthwhile than most public figures.
on the 2nd level i love her the same way i love Britney Spears:she's a hot-mess train-wreck but without Cheetoh breath.
i also love the way Ann is in on the joke. the only thing she takes seriously is her stance on abortion. most everything else she says is just for shock value.
Jesus Christ died on the cross in order to redeem us from our sins. Jews and Gentiles alike need to put their faith in Jesus in order to be saved. This is not anti-Semtic rhetoric. It is Biblical rhetoric. It is truth.
To any Jew that might take offense, let's just put it this way. If you fully obey the 10 Commandments your entire life without deviating from them once, then in theory, you wouldn't need the atoning sacrifice of Christ in order to go to heaven. God bless.
she is fucking great..i hope i find wife just like that..Dam she like a hot conserative boy dream. :) Hey liberal she has the right too say what she want...And it was not offend, she just said What it said IN THE BIBLE...somewhat :( anyways QQ FAGGOT LIBERAL BITCHES..cry some more that all u can do IS CRY CRY AND BITCH lol lol lol lol :)
i don't want you to be offended, buuttt, i am going to offend you without remorse, FUCK!! what a bitch. Why does she dress like a hooker and claim to be a CONSERATIVE? hmmm! Hypocrite whore.
view venomfangx's ~ I believe in second chances ~ video~ that guideline appiles here ~ w/ ~ comment approval (FYI)
TJae1 10 months ago
why does she talk like that
CoPezz 10 months ago
yeah, she is cute
kevinvestal 1 year ago
i wish she wouldn't claim to be a Christian cause she is giving Christ a terrible name.
kevinvestal 1 year ago
@kevinvestal ~ she's actually the bettr of the bunch ~ was considering asking her out ~ myself ~
TJae1 1 year ago
quick bible references for you guys here, NO the bible doesn't say jews go to heaven it just says they don't go to hell, and christianity isn't just about saying jesus was the man and now I can dick around. I find it incredibly ironic how one who pushes christianity so ferverently has the incredible ignorance of her own religion. TJae1 have you seen the piece where ann coulter says that we should remove all practicioners of islam? incredibly funny you should check it out :D
Jh768 1 year ago
the point of the question is that extreme Republican policies will lead to Americans failure and even republicans know it! No government is worse than communism
zxcvbnmjhgfdsa1 1 year ago
she's exactly right..why is he acting like that? Jesus dying for our sins is not hate!
TheBarby82 2 years ago
She believes everyone should be her religion and that is exactly the mentality that lead religious persecution and sparked intolerance to become the violence we have seen today. I am a Christian...and deeply embarassed and offended by her comments.
rthomas789 2 years ago
not to nick pick here.... just an E.G. This isn't exactly accurate... lol... where did Anne declare religious fascism?
TJae1 2 years ago
Ann gets it I think. I think she is a Christian, but I can see exactly why Donny was offended by her comment.
*Saying things clearly without offending has never been Coulter's thing*
I give her bonus points for trying to explain what she meant after the break there, that is pretty good for her.
*I hope this is a "wow" comment! LOL*
ugadawgs1984 2 years ago
I guess If tubers, weren't so, dog-determined, hateful about this ~ the comment content, wouldn't suffer ~ keep tryin' ya'll ~
TJae1 2 years ago
religious exploitation ~ is the major problem~ pure & undefiled religion is pretty cool ~ actually ~
TJae1 2 years ago
all religions are the backward cultural device of ancient man, theres a reason a full blown religion hasnt been made in the past couple hundred years and that reason is science. religion is ancient mans way of explaining things they could understand, or a device used to escape reality and its horrid truth. most "religious" people havnt even read their own books or parchments on the religion they belong to. who cares what a political pundit said or did its not like ann is gonna shake the world.
piscespeter3 2 years ago
Ann Coulter's is the most fail person EVER.
She's a homophobic, rascist, antisemetic biatch.
TehPirateSquid 2 years ago
yah gotta do bettr ~ objectivity ppl ~ try knuckleheadreview ~ think U mite like that ~
TJae1 2 years ago
keep tryin' seestickglue ~
TJae1 2 years ago
damthosetorpedoes~ I luv that name ~ thanxs
TJae1 2 years ago
Keep tryin' ya'll .... I wanna see those ~ wow ~ Ur really on to something ~ comment(s) ~ I hate anne~ won't get it ~ coherent, rational, keen, logic is key ~
TJae1 2 years ago
concentrate on anne's logic & considerately, ellaborate ~ key ~
TJae1 2 years ago
so hmm..theres 50 comments i see. Have you awarded anyone there prize yet?...
chrisadmaley 2 years ago
not yet ~ they haven't always been thoughtful ~
TJae1 2 years ago
Woah, she just denounced a whole race of people and claimed that christians, like herself, were the "perfected" version of those people. The sad thing is that she's definitely not the only person who believes this. What an arrogant bitch. angeljenny55 Ann Coulter's heart is FAR from being even remotely pure. She is ignorance incarnate.
djmateo19 2 years ago 3
don't completely agree; however, Jenny55 can b alot like, U describe ~ I definitely have noticed, corruption in the so-called "christian" community.
TJae1 2 years ago
@djmateo19 What is Anne ignorant about?
KingDingaLing090 1 year ago
49 more to go *
TJae1 2 years ago
comment 1 begins with angeljenny55:
TJae1 2 years ago
I LOVE Ann Coulter! She's a bulldog in her approach, but her heart is pure and so is her love for America. She certainly could have put her words better, but I think Mr. Deutsche intends to be offended, On other words, if you're looking to have your feelings hurt, it's a guarantee that someone will hurt them. Messianic Jews do have the best of it all, and he should have been more attentive to her intent, rather than just to her words.
angeljenny55 2 years ago
Hi, Deutsche didn't try to understand what Ann said. I doubt he even cared what she thought about any religion. He is a lieveral, so he was trying to impugn her politically. It's the way liberals play since they always lose if they play by the rules.
JimQualls 2 years ago
love is a verb, not just words *
TJae1 2 years ago
Doesn't she realize the corrupt government embraces the bowels of the other place? I'm Christian, and was raised a Jew. She's never been to my church and I'm not a Democrat or a Republican. Why would we want to equate American politics with God's kingdom? It is an insult to God.
zorak2025 2 years ago 2
See you next Tuesday!!
SteveKozlo 2 years ago
if he would read the New Testament he would see that she's right. Yeah, she could have worded it with more tact, but she's right.
RJsGrl 2 years ago
I'm with you, RJ's Grl! Ann never is tactful, she always takes a bulldog's way to say something, but her intent was pure. The NT is the continuation of the OT. If Mr. Deutch choses to be offended, rather than listening, that's on him, not on Ann.
angeljenny55 2 years ago
I don't like Ann Coulter at all, but I think this guy is just trying to "trap" her into an offensive answer, and actually, she scores some points here.
All he did was set her up to espouse how "diverse" the world would be if we were all Christians, which is ridiculous.
Argonaut22j 3 years ago
Comment approval pending; so, make it count; make it legitmate; make it thoughtful. I could care less, what wing U R.
TJae1 3 years ago
Gotta love it. He says several offensive things to her but that is ok. She says one and he whines like a baby. Typical liberal media!
beckyhmn 3 years ago
Here's something ya'll can comment on: Is anne coulter's view of christianity correct? if so or not, reason why.
TJae1 3 years ago
PollutionCloud:
I don't have 2 chk back.
Productive comments, yes; pollutive comments, No-No: Nope: F### Anne doesn't qualify.
TJae1 3 years ago
Bichenjon: You want a rational comment?
Yes, less the bichen.
TJae1 3 years ago
OK. How about this:
Ann Coulter really knows how to sell books.
drumrnva 3 years ago
Lol... bettr; needs more rationalizing ,though. E.G: Discussed Subject(s) w/ honest thought effort. B a hardware "nerd" & treat Anne like the next Xbox, if that helps.
TJae1 3 years ago
Ms. Coulter is confused. She can't understand normal thought.
drumrnva 3 years ago
Nope, not quite, Rationalized, meaning reasoned comments, not polite name calling.
TJae1 3 years ago
Keep the comments respectful & rationalized; that's all.
4700 & countin' :)
TJae1 3 years ago
Go fuck yourself with Ann Coulter, she's a man anyway....bye!
twilliger123 3 years ago
This is E.G. of a no-no.
TJae1 3 years ago
Not to say, Anne is all that bad, though.
TJae1 3 years ago
We've obviously heard from the haters; yada, yada; let's try something different, the terms for commenting, for now, are listd below. (Enjoy, U mite find it rewarding)
TJae1 3 years ago
What do ya'll think?
Should this video be limited to moderate comments? U know, comments that are respectful & rationalized.
TJae1 3 years ago
Ann Cunter is a dumbass, NYC was not happy during the RNC Convention, I'm from here and we were protesting everything like hell and making them not feel welcome at all. She's such a woman who Can't Understand Normal Thinking!
twilliger123 3 years ago
Least your page is developed; Nahh... she's a liberal's aching tooth; Truth hurts at times; Well thanxs 4 contributing, I think.
TJae1 3 years ago
Her truth is only hers, unless you're a lobotomized sheep spewing rabid froth like her...are you?
twilliger123 3 years ago
Seems like Anne is acting up on ya :) Complaining won't help; try rationalizing.
TJae1 3 years ago
I think the best T-shirt I saw during that time was a group of women runners wearing them that said, "The only Bush I trust is my own"...LMAO!
twilliger123 3 years ago
Now we have Islamo-Obamo; too much time between the bushes, @@/
Remember 911
TJae1 3 years ago
Another right-wing lobotomized piece of shit, so glad Obama one so we can shut you assholes down once and for all. OBAMA IS NOT ISLAMIC, ASSHOLE, AND HE WON, GET OVER IT - NOW TIME FOR REAL CHANGE FOR THE BETTER!
twilliger123 3 years ago
the people at the conventione WERE happy and peaceful, unlike ANY demoncratic convention where they (the libs) riot non stop! There is no peace in the democratic party, they are the hate mongers.
RJsGrl 2 years ago
I don't agree w/ Grl is saying, however, There are abuses w/ the democratic party, that haters, normally fail to recognize.
TJae1 2 years ago
That was great when she said you're not a praticing Jew and he said yes I am. Although he was calm you know on the inside he was like "take that bitch!" Good for him!
ElMa1788 3 years ago
Beats the numb-F#ckin' logic of hollyworld-comedy, will they ever stop this idoitic rant, about 100k + home give always... unless 1 enjoys serious debt or likes sharing rent w/3 families, I don't get the punchline. I got a job & I'm in serious debt, but that Dumb F#ck, does'nt? Hahahahaha?
TJae1 3 years ago
Im confused about the comment you left my comment. Are you ageeing with the rubbish she is saying, or what? Please explain yourself.
bichenjon 3 years ago
Which comment R U referrin' 2, exactly?
TJae1 3 years ago
i agree that if we were all christian we would be better off. But thats just because any form of unity on a large scale would be good. Honestly we'd be even better off if we were all buddhist, but thats a matter of opinion.
doskido 3 years ago
U don't get 4k+, by being hatd, she's just an aching tooth, agressive libs luv to play with.
SofatKing, Ur a loner, I'm surprised U would say such a thing -
Sooo,
She has 2 pillows to Ur 1, feverd brow.
TJae1 3 years ago
4338 & countin'
TJae1 3 years ago
"TJae1 (8 months ago) Any pro-Coulter comments.... any1?"
"sbauman487 (5 months ago)What could someone say that's good about her?"
You have been wasting your time for 8 months - get over it no one likes her.
She is douche!
LndSofaKing1337 3 years ago
FUCK YOU ANN COULTER
I HAVE A CHIP ON MY SHOULDERS BECAUSE OF YOU BITCH.
If I ever see you I would love to hit a woman in the face for the first time in my life.
LndSofaKing1337 3 years ago
K... not 2 much luv; I can't stand it :P
TJae1 3 years ago
If you support this person you are supporting hate and anti semitic views.
I am a jew and I am offended by her comments.
She has no love she is souless being and should be euthanized and as well as anyone that supports her.
LndSofaKing1337 3 years ago
LndSofaKing1337 (3 months ago) am not a racist at all.
Not sure why you lft me a nasty msg.
Maybe cause I wanted to see some muslim boobies.
I want to so all forms of boobies no matter the color of flesh.
I like black boobies, white boobies, asain boobies, jewish boobies, catholic boobies and yes muslim boobies!
So im not a racist by any means I am more of an American boob connaisseur or a pervert. Either or will do!
TJae1 3 years ago
So cute that little noobs on the inner tubes can cut and paste. What does that prove? I will stick with that statement infact. I like boobs and women, and even your girl friend Ann even though she is a freakishly tall neo nazi blonde. I will say it again if you support this person you are a moron and a nazi. Now ge tthe fuck off my innertubes which i clearly stated before.
LndSofaKing1337 3 years ago
quote reference; So U wouldn't think, any1 was discriminating against ya.
TJae1 3 years ago
K... can't promise anything, though :)
TJae1 3 years ago
the world would be a much better place w/o ppl like anne coulter.
neonchez 3 years ago
Utube would b a much better w/o trollers n' half-az#, talking head Christians. (just a note) Feel free to comment. 4319 & countin'
TJae1 3 years ago
If her brain were as big as her ears,I would be afraid
deepfriedlard 3 years ago
bigger, much bigger.
Be afraid, B very afraid. 4205 & coutin'.
TJae1 3 years ago
3,909 & countin'; go anne coulter :)
TJae1 3 years ago
Yah 4000 hits of negative comments - if you support Ann Coulter you are a Nazi.
This woman should just hang her self. Just a rude ass clown racist.
LndSofaKing1337 3 years ago
Ann Coulter, what a hypocritical bitch! This is why people are so negative about christianaty these days. Its because of Stubborn, close minded, and intolerant people like Ann coulter. It makes me want to vommit. We need to change the way we think about how we treat and what we say to other people who have different beliefs and ideas. So they will be the same way with us. So hopefully one day we can all live in harmony.
bichenjon 3 years ago
Yeah, esp. 4 Christians & Anne Coulter.
TJae1 3 years ago
woah what is she on!!
emmamartini 3 years ago
Like to know; hair looks great :)
TJae1 3 years ago
Anne Coulter is like...... Ruth :)
TJae1 3 years ago
If Anne believes the Old Testament, SHE WOULD NOT BE ABLE TO EVEN DEBATE WITH A MAN!
Woman were simply objects in the old testament and slaves were also accepted.
Racist, bigot and fucking slut.
iamstupidandold 3 years ago 7
i agree with what you say except her being a slut. no man would and shouldn't ever touch that thing!!
dankarlos 3 years ago
Probably b an improvement to Iran; Obama for 09', enjoy.
TJae1 3 years ago
ad nauseam yeah, had that w/ customer service
TJae1 3 years ago
An atheist's morality is generally grounded in humanism, the golden rule: "Do unto others..." Famed religious principle; welcome aboard. But now let me ask, what reason would someone who believes in a genocidal God have to be moral? ^^ In a genocidal way, probably.
TJae1 3 years ago
"Ann Coulter discusses with Donny Deutsch..."
Ann Coulter has never discussed anything in her political career. Discussion means more than simply repeating the same talking points ad nauseam with the odd insult thrown in for 'comedic' effect.
megamarsvin 3 years ago
interesting woman. if she thinks that christians are merely perfected jews, does it follow that she thinks muslims are perfected jews and perfected christians? i wonder is she can cite another seinfeld episode to answer that....
1underminerlover 3 years ago
Screw all that at what point does she shoot D-Man the Beaver?
52barney 3 years ago
1963; That was another show, though.
TJae1 3 years ago
She has great pnts, she's just not queer minded, that's all...
TJae1 3 years ago
i'm a gay liberal & i really do adore Ann.
on 2 levels.
on 1 level she's hilarious & genuinely entertaining. she's a million times more interesting & worthwhile than most public figures.
on the 2nd level i love her the same way i love Britney Spears:she's a hot-mess train-wreck but without Cheetoh breath.
i also love the way Ann is in on the joke. the only thing she takes seriously is her stance on abortion. most everything else she says is just for shock value.
she's smart as hell.
serious22 3 years ago
Yeah, Just have to tell the truth 1st.... Welcome to Utube. Views: 2,738 & counting..
TJae1 3 years ago
I love how she didn't answer the question at all. If she can't do that, how did she even get through school?
BecauseTheTruthHurts 3 years ago
2662 and counting...
TJae1 3 years ago
Anne Coulter is a fucking idiot.
epicwater 3 years ago
Jesus Christ died on the cross in order to redeem us from our sins. Jews and Gentiles alike need to put their faith in Jesus in order to be saved. This is not anti-Semtic rhetoric. It is Biblical rhetoric. It is truth.
To any Jew that might take offense, let's just put it this way. If you fully obey the 10 Commandments your entire life without deviating from them once, then in theory, you wouldn't need the atoning sacrifice of Christ in order to go to heaven. God bless.
ConcernedEngineer 3 years ago
Or you could follow no religion, like me, and not worry about any of that bullshit and live a happy, moral, life!
xchrisxsays 3 years ago 2
What reason(s) would an atheist have for being moral?
TJae1 3 years ago
An atheist's morality is generally grounded in humanism, the golden rule: "Do unto others..."
But now let me ask, what reason would someone who believes in a genocidal God have to be moral? ^^
megamarsvin 3 years ago 2
Plenty, about 1696 good things @ this point.
TJae1 3 years ago
all groups feel that way; she's true to form; truth counts though
TJae1 3 years ago
"If Anne Coulter had any brains she would not say that Jews need to be perfected." God, I love DD.
muyradicool 3 years ago
Yeah, she's pretty... that's 1 way of puttin' it :/
TJae1 3 years ago
Fuck Coulter!
DarthCheney420 3 years ago 3
ahh, knew ya'll were out there :) 1200+ n' counting
TJae1 3 years ago
i love ann coulter
btodacallie 3 years ago
she is fucking great..i hope i find wife just like that..Dam she like a hot conserative boy dream. :) Hey liberal she has the right too say what she want...And it was not offend, she just said What it said IN THE BIBLE...somewhat :( anyways QQ FAGGOT LIBERAL BITCHES..cry some more that all u can do IS CRY CRY AND BITCH lol lol lol lol :)
Crazedknight 3 years ago
This Barbie ain't bad, Give the brave & baiting trebob27 a visit sometime.
TJae1 3 years ago
any reason the nuts, are posting @ my videos? is this a paradox :p
TJae1 3 years ago
879 n' counting.... & no I don't believe, flaunt only barbies, receive this kinda count...
TJae1 3 years ago
569 n' counting....
coulter supporters, I know Ur out there, need not b shy....
TJae1 3 years ago
I would give Anne Coulter a damn thorough boning, although this does not mean that I support or endorse her views. So, is this a paradox?
webb3ro 3 years ago
i don't want you to be offended, buuttt, i am going to offend you without remorse, FUCK!! what a bitch. Why does she dress like a hooker and claim to be a CONSERATIVE? hmmm! Hypocrite whore.
lilpuppetmaster 3 years ago 2
544 views & countin'
TJae1 3 years ago
Any pro-Coulter comments.... any1?
TJae1 3 years ago
No dude...no, lol
TiJayEve 3 years ago
What could someone say that's good about her?
sbauman487 3 years ago
thats a joke right she can't actually believe that christans are perfected jews thats the dumbest shit ive ever heard i hope she gets hit by a bus
blacksabbathwarpigs 3 years ago
Sell your books Annie to the wide eyed sheep......their ancestors were at Nuremberg.
TrumanBarkley 3 years ago