i didnt forget syd or richard just didnt mention them because im talking after the remaining floyd members and sadly Syd and Richard arent with us any more
I listened to this song and as lovely as it is, it's the simple yet stunning sound of the blackbird in the background that reduced me to tears. It reminded me of the film and Jim and Hilda's love until the end when everything has died. Stunning. By the way Margaret Thatcher tried to ban the film because she felt it was derogatory to her war in The Falklands. Enough said!
Paul Carrack sings the "Hey Joe, where ya goin' with that a gun in your hands…" part. That's why it sounds great. I'm not dissing Roger's singing, but give credit where it's due.
I think this is some of the man's best singing, and one of his best songs. There are plenty of songs that he struggles to sing, but he really pegs it here. And no one brings more of their own human pain to their lyrics than Waters. He is an international treasure.
my wife and myself saw Roger waters in manchester this yr...The man is brilliant..no backups to his voice and talent..Just raw roger. I bought this on tape ( audio ) when it came out..
ppl buy dark side of the moon and the wall and say thr pink floyd fans nvr hearing likes of animal.wish you were here,obscured by clouds,the piper at the gates of dawn,ummagumma,momenteral laps of reason or relics to name but a few from the mighty floyds impressive back catalogue or even any of roger waters solo works such as pro's and cons,radio kaos or amused to death.A band that will never die even after Waters,Gilmour and mason are gone
so many ppl claim to be floyd/waters fans and never heard of this song,a bitter sweet film topped with an amazing sound track,ty for uploading this little gem brings a tear to my eye everytime
i didnt forget syd or richard just didnt mention them because im talking after the remaining floyd members and sadly Syd and Richard arent with us any more
humfey1 3 weeks ago
the whole film is so upsetting (though the book was more horrific)
InvincibleChiba73 3 weeks ago in playlist Favorite videos
I listened to this song and as lovely as it is, it's the simple yet stunning sound of the blackbird in the background that reduced me to tears. It reminded me of the film and Jim and Hilda's love until the end when everything has died. Stunning. By the way Margaret Thatcher tried to ban the film because she felt it was derogatory to her war in The Falklands. Enough said!
SylviesBoudoir 3 weeks ago
Comment removed
InvincibleChiba73 3 weeks ago
Paul Carrack sings the "Hey Joe, where ya goin' with that a gun in your hands…" part. That's why it sounds great. I'm not dissing Roger's singing, but give credit where it's due.
stevemenard 1 month ago
one of the best you never hear
bomozy 2 months ago
thank you.
70milYondanBIRI 2 months ago
This song was too good to be wasted on an obscure album ... It should have been on Radio Kaos
shutdafup 2 months ago
I think this is some of the man's best singing, and one of his best songs. There are plenty of songs that he struggles to sing, but he really pegs it here. And no one brings more of their own human pain to their lyrics than Waters. He is an international treasure.
Elidoransgar 2 months ago
As wonderful as scary is the topic sung...unforgettable!
icarosilva16 3 months ago
my wife and myself saw Roger waters in manchester this yr...The man is brilliant..no backups to his voice and talent..Just raw roger. I bought this on tape ( audio ) when it came out..
kawapilot 4 months ago
The music is similar to Brain Damage and Me Or Him xD (sorry my English is fucking terrible)
ELASESINO2OO8 6 months ago
@ELASESINO2OO8
Don't worry *twitch* that's okay.
Brando2600 6 months ago
ppl buy dark side of the moon and the wall and say thr pink floyd fans nvr hearing likes of animal.wish you were here,obscured by clouds,the piper at the gates of dawn,ummagumma,momenteral laps of reason or relics to name but a few from the mighty floyds impressive back catalogue or even any of roger waters solo works such as pro's and cons,radio kaos or amused to death.A band that will never die even after Waters,Gilmour and mason are gone
humfey1 8 months ago 12
@humfey1 forgot final cut .. bad bad humfey :P
banq0o 2 months ago
@humfey1 You forgot Richard and Syd.
mewtwo711 3 weeks ago
Just like dark side of the moon
Guiataristmarshall01 9 months ago
Agreed with the last post in every respect, and noticed there's no dislikes at this time. What's not to like? Great songwriting...
54MURAI 9 months ago
so many ppl claim to be floyd/waters fans and never heard of this song,a bitter sweet film topped with an amazing sound track,ty for uploading this little gem brings a tear to my eye everytime
humfey1 10 months ago
@humfey1 =] i just heard this, does that make it official now? =P
JasonRodzArt 6 months ago
Beautiful what more is there to say
paulallan1000 1 year ago 16
Wonderful one! One of the most underrated Waters' solo songs!
ekecedevoskrive 1 year ago 2