@SqueezeMyLemonBabe I think it's much worse. It breaks the the carefully balanced unity of the piece. The bible, in my opinion, doesn't have nearly as much artistic value as Bach's music, and can stand a little editing. Maybe I'm just not much of a literature appreciator, though.
@guyboy625 I dont like it as well, metal is about noise, speed and agressiveness, far away from real music. I don't classify metal as music, for me it is at most an attitude. Music however comprises beauty, atmosphere, detail, a palette of colours and feelings. Metal is more of a monochromatic style.
@DrSmokeTrees Well, assuming that you enjoy metal, a comment such as yours is not surprising at all. An individual is at the same level of what he/she likes. The difference between my comment and your comment could be compared with the difference between classical music and metal. Just notice.
@guyboy625 Well, it depends on how you look at it, but the reason I compared them is because of a Bible verse talks about how he who takes pieces from the Book will be taken from the book, and he who adds pieces to the Book that weren't there will be also taken from the Book. I am comparing the Bible to the musical realm. Whoever made this piece will never be known as Bach was known, simply because he mis-interpreted Bach's genius, like a jackass.
No it isn't you fucking idiot. you bible is a piece of shit, myth book, and they did take most of the OC out of it. Your bible, only dates back 1,000 years. It isn't even linked to the dead sea scrolls, which are the actual foundation of your christ cults.
All the cults of christ are bullshit. The Jews were just poor people living in a ghetto outside of Rome, making up these stories to make themselves feel better about not being the rich and powerful
@DrSmokeTrees Ha. am I preaching about Jesus or the new testament here?
It doesn't matter what your religious beliefs are and I'm not going to get into an argument about Biblical interpretations.
What I was referring to when I said taking a piece of out of a Bach piece is like taking a piece out of the Bible is an actual Bible verse that you would know had you read.
which is why I made the comparison to begin with, don't insult me out of ignorance.
Sorry, though there are some classical songs that do really well when converted into a metal format (Night on a bald mountain springs to mind) I think Toccata and Fugue is one of those that just don't work. There's a contrast in the original, between the harshness of the main line, the harps and so many other varients that just putting in metal guitars and drums looses, and the song suffers for it.
@commodore256 rap is not REAL music its not played by human but is made by computer. rock is played by real people with guitars and drums and rap? now u understand what i mean?
@bumbulika1 The computer is the instrument of the producer, just as the guitar is the instrument of a guitar player. The only difference is that the computer controls the live playing of the sound, which has been built from the ground up by the producer.
It's all music in its own right, but some just prefer some types over others.
@commodore256 because if you transpose metal into classical instrument you realize metal roots come from classical music not the pop and rap crap these days... and of course vice versa
@commodore256 There are some excellent rap artist out there. Some are just more difficult to find than others. Army of Pharaohs, Immortal Technique, Jedi Mind Tricks, GZA the Genius, and Canibus being a few.
SOOOOOO many missing notes. Seems the guitarist isn't familiar enough with BWV 565 to perform a full transciption. Also, he's cut out about HALF(!) the piece, since it runs eight minutes. For a quality [acoustic] recording search for Philip Hii or the California Guitar Trio.
who is the palyer?
elisabolognesi 3 days ago in playlist Liked videos
Reminds me of Kind Diamond
Wotansvolk1972 3 days ago
What did Bach ever do to you??
yaysinoquiero 4 days ago
amazingggg!!!
nevo20111 5 days ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Vedete questo fisarmonicista russo che la esegue con il BAYAN:
Toccata et fuga Dmoll-J S ILFIR MANAPOV
2003cater 6 days ago
It's a shame for metal and classic music, and as a musician, I like both. Listen ti Epica
aitruesie 1 week ago
stop bullshitting and listen to the music for once.
Punjab35 1 week ago
The original composition on a pipe organ is a hell of a lot more metal than this.
weezylone 1 week ago
@weezylone i second that
mannymann321 15 hours ago
Y U NO HAV BASS??
EminencePhront 3 weeks ago
@EminencePhront can you not hear? there is plenty of bass in there
woodythewoodchuck1 3 weeks ago
@woodythewoodchuck1 I'm not referring to the instrument. I'm referring to the tinny, buzzy, trebly sound and the lack of low end.
EminencePhront 3 weeks ago
@EminencePhront Agreed, the recording quality is fucking shocking.
Asdayasman 2 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@EminencePhront Agreed, the recording quality is fucking shocking.
Asdayasman 2 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I never liked heavy metal but
that was fucking awesome
Dubickimus 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I never liked heavy metal but
that was fucking awesome
Dubickimus 1 month ago
I never liked heavy metal but
that was fucking awesome
Dubickimus 1 month ago
I never liked heavy metal but
that was fucking awesome
Dubickimus 1 month ago
@YouTubaEnDo Fuck ya.
makakamakaki 1 month ago
Hard Barock :D
TheSrXoN 1 month ago
its the same fucking notes.
the genius is still there even when shrouded by distortion and ugly sounds.
it can be appreciated by those who like to listen to this style of music.
it just sounds so much better without all the unnecessary extra textures.
SqueezeMyLemonBabe 1 month ago
@SqueezeMyLemonBabe It's been shortened at places. Not a good idea.
guyboy625 1 month ago
@guyboy625
indeed.
taking out of a Bach piece is like taking verses out of the Bible.
SqueezeMyLemonBabe 1 month ago
@SqueezeMyLemonBabe I think it's much worse. It breaks the the carefully balanced unity of the piece. The bible, in my opinion, doesn't have nearly as much artistic value as Bach's music, and can stand a little editing. Maybe I'm just not much of a literature appreciator, though.
guyboy625 1 month ago
@guyboy625 I dont like it as well, metal is about noise, speed and agressiveness, far away from real music. I don't classify metal as music, for me it is at most an attitude. Music however comprises beauty, atmosphere, detail, a palette of colours and feelings. Metal is more of a monochromatic style.
afsartori 1 month ago
@afsartori
You are a fucking idiot. Metal > you.
DrSmokeTrees 1 month ago
@DrSmokeTrees Well, assuming that you enjoy metal, a comment such as yours is not surprising at all. An individual is at the same level of what he/she likes. The difference between my comment and your comment could be compared with the difference between classical music and metal. Just notice.
afsartori 1 month ago
@guyboy625
Not much of a comparison, the bible is bullshit.
DrSmokeTrees 1 month ago
@DrSmokeTrees It is if you're looking for a book with true stuff in it. But it's valid literature nevertheless. I just don't think it's very good.
guyboy625 1 month ago
@guyboy625 Well, it depends on how you look at it, but the reason I compared them is because of a Bible verse talks about how he who takes pieces from the Book will be taken from the book, and he who adds pieces to the Book that weren't there will be also taken from the Book. I am comparing the Bible to the musical realm. Whoever made this piece will never be known as Bach was known, simply because he mis-interpreted Bach's genius, like a jackass.
SqueezeMyLemonBabe 1 month ago
@SqueezeMyLemonBabe
No it isn't you fucking idiot. you bible is a piece of shit, myth book, and they did take most of the OC out of it. Your bible, only dates back 1,000 years. It isn't even linked to the dead sea scrolls, which are the actual foundation of your christ cults.
All the cults of christ are bullshit. The Jews were just poor people living in a ghetto outside of Rome, making up these stories to make themselves feel better about not being the rich and powerful
DrSmokeTrees 1 month ago
@DrSmokeTrees Ha. am I preaching about Jesus or the new testament here?
It doesn't matter what your religious beliefs are and I'm not going to get into an argument about Biblical interpretations.
What I was referring to when I said taking a piece of out of a Bach piece is like taking a piece out of the Bible is an actual Bible verse that you would know had you read.
which is why I made the comparison to begin with, don't insult me out of ignorance.
SqueezeMyLemonBabe 1 month ago
why not you realize you're doing? This is an insult for Bach and all music.
Loosers with no brain and no ears.....
YouTubaEnDo 1 month ago
@YouTubaEnDo Why dont you stop COMPLAING and tell us one REASON why this is bad? I hate these guys who think they know everything --'
i listen both classical and metal, what's the fucking probleme?
GaidonxP 1 month ago
oooo pesteeeeeeeeeee kkkkk (breno)
MisterGera00 1 month ago
Sorry, though there are some classical songs that do really well when converted into a metal format (Night on a bald mountain springs to mind) I think Toccata and Fugue is one of those that just don't work. There's a contrast in the original, between the harshness of the main line, the harps and so many other varients that just putting in metal guitars and drums looses, and the song suffers for it.
savagevcb 2 months ago
Question:
Why do people that like Metal also like Classical?
It's just something I noticed, there's a lot of Metal Remixes of Classical pieces.
Oh, I noticed how Batch and Beethoven posed for their Paintings, they looked fucking epic.
commodore256 2 months ago 6
@commodore256 if you combine a Classical masterpiece with the power of metal, you will get THE EPICNESS in one song
PlusAxl1 2 months ago
@commodore256 cause they are REAL music unlike pop and rap :)
bumbulika1 2 months ago 3
@bumbulika1 Hey, don't Dis' the the Rap!
I've actually heard good Rap, most main-stream Music made before 1995 (including rap) was good.
Tupac actually quoted Shakespeare!
If you wanna hear good Rap, check out independent Rap.
I've found some good stuff on jamendo and if you go there with an open mind, you'll find a few rap songs that will tickle your fancy.
I believe rap started at word of mouth, but was shoved down our throats for 20 years with no other variety from the record companies.
commodore256 2 months ago
@commodore256 rap is not REAL music its not played by human but is made by computer. rock is played by real people with guitars and drums and rap? now u understand what i mean?
bumbulika1 2 months ago 6
@bumbulika1 So, this isn't real music? watch?v=0AZ5XZHIDh0
But if you play it with a Violin, it's suddenly real? watch?v=phlrgUGpt38 (Castlevaina is very Boroque inspired)
I kinda get what you're saying, I wish more rap sounded like this watch?v=Z0tgheca5HM
If a real big Symphony is important to you, you might like Instrumental Rap watch?v=mkkRkVTAfuM
lol, 50 Cent called Beethoven a "Real OG", I agree with him, he was so hardcore, he continued to make music after he went deaf.
commodore256 2 months ago
@bumbulika1 The computer is the instrument of the producer, just as the guitar is the instrument of a guitar player. The only difference is that the computer controls the live playing of the sound, which has been built from the ground up by the producer.
It's all music in its own right, but some just prefer some types over others.
rawssremix 1 month ago
@commodore256 cause metal looks A LOT with classic... not at style, but at melody
GaidonxP 2 months ago 2
@commodore256
Yep, I'm loving it. But I love mixes from Arch Enemy, Rage and Stratovarius only. Others - imo SUCK.
VladGuardian 1 month ago
@commodore256 because metal and classical are epic. beethoven made music while deaf. that's just badass.
blooboy4747 1 month ago
@blooboy4747 Yeah, that's why 50 Cent called him a "Real OG"
commodore256 1 month ago
@commodore256 because if you transpose metal into classical instrument you realize metal roots come from classical music not the pop and rap crap these days... and of course vice versa
timosha21 6 days ago
@timosha21 Rap isn't always crap, I've found good rap.
The good rap sounds orchestral.
commodore256 6 days ago
@commodore256 There are some excellent rap artist out there. Some are just more difficult to find than others. Army of Pharaohs, Immortal Technique, Jedi Mind Tricks, GZA the Genius, and Canibus being a few.
FantasticMrHell 2 days ago
Metal already existed at Bach's times :)
HomihachiMetal333 2 months ago
all those classical composers wrote perfect sound for metal music!
flasticruth 2 months ago
The audio quality is really poor and that makes it tough to listen to what would otherwise be a rockin piece of work.
ashleylynnjoan 2 months ago
what program do you use for the soundtrack? :o
vikinga2011 2 months ago
Baroque and roll?
FunkyHorror1 3 months ago 122
You are ProRock of BaRock \m/
TheYoichi777 3 months ago
3:22 - 3:51 Best part.
Laindal 3 months ago
SOOOOOO many missing notes. Seems the guitarist isn't familiar enough with BWV 565 to perform a full transciption. Also, he's cut out about HALF(!) the piece, since it runs eight minutes. For a quality [acoustic] recording search for Philip Hii or the California Guitar Trio.
Keithustus 3 months ago
@Keithustus make a better one then...
kdani88 2 months ago
Bach: the original metalhead.
kossmikham 3 months ago 112
@kossmikham
Yes,he uses the harmonic minor scale...most metal uses that scale as well, its a very powerfull emotional scale, evoking darkness, evil and doom.
metafis 3 months ago
@kossmikham
Some say not Bach, but Vagner ;-)
VladGuardian 1 month ago
@VladGuardian Wagner
scab182 1 month ago
@kossmikham ahhhhhhhhhhh
jjmommy100 2 weeks ago
where did you get the music xD
vikinga2011 3 months ago
This is what Bach was trying to convey
LittleZelda18 3 months ago 2
great!!!
arturyt011 3 months ago
BaRock!
Angryification 3 months ago
Ahhhhh Yngwie Malmsteen.................Incredible guitarist. Still holds the Guiness world record for the most notes played in a single second.
TheDethd3aler 5 months ago
Comment removed
shiznoes 4 months ago
Respond to this video... This isn't Yngwie Malmsteen
shiznoes 4 months ago
@shiznoes Yes it is :)
ThatGuyCalledPhillip 4 months ago
@ThatGuyCalledPhillip It is not :)
shiznoes 4 months ago
@shiznoes Yeah, if it were Malmsteen there'd be a useless and tedious run every five fucking seconds lol
LibertyCityMayhem95 3 months ago 7
@LibertyCityMayhem95 Hahaha true that brother
shiznoes 3 months ago
por dios que grossos!!!
omg you rock!!!
greetings from argentina!
westrockerjorex 5 months ago
Frickin sweet!
Mcawesomo1229 6 months ago