Added: 3 years ago
From: cgarris
Views: 33,906
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (279)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • STEVE PERRY ALWAYS.

  • so powerfull voice arnel

  • Arnel is amazing, but no one can top Perry. He's such an amazing, beautiful talent. It's too bad he wouldn't perform anymore.

  • Perry techmically is a better singer than Arnel, and a better performer. But I won't put down Arnel. He turned out pretty good.

  • some of u people dont like arnel,if he quit the band there will no journey,oh and steve perry is not coming back he''s voice different now,but even he come back he will just embarass himself and the band

  • @NoSteveNoJourney JEALOUS IS LOUSY, GET A LIFE YOU IDIOT.. YOU NEED A HEARING AIDE THAT SIZE OF YOU BRAIN..

  • WOW! Great job! I listened thru about 2:30 carefully. And the transitions between Steve and Arnel were stunning! Great editing job.

    By the way, I enjoy listening to Steve, and Steve, and Arnel. All of the three are enjoyable to listen to, and I think that we all would be at a loss if any of the three were not available for us to listen to. All extremely talented.

  • Arnel is really humble about all these - He always have said Steve Perry is his hero. Of course he has to sing those songs - it belongs to the band. Arnel does a great job in fact his voice is stronger. I can tell the more feminine tenor from the brassier tenor of Arnel cause it gets thinner when it is SP.

  • does anyone know how much cash a original JOURNEY concert reunion would bring?

  • Perry>Pineda

  • STOP COMPARING. omg.

  • what a beautiful voice arnel has!

  • To NoSteveNoJourney, what is with the Pinoy=Mongoloid crap? In case it has somehow escaped your notice, Steve is pretty ethnic-looking himself--hardly white bread. Is there a skin-head Nazi singer out there whose fan you could be?

  • its not the same with out steve this new guy sucks journey is not the same

  • I LOVE Pineda! His voice is amazing! Nobody could have replaced Steve as well as he did! Not even close!

    And yet......

    Steve Perry will always live on as the true Journey. Pineda was the best replacement ever possible, but he still can't truly replace Steve.

    Nobody ever could.

  • They are both amazing singers but Steve was Journey. Journey could never reinvent themselves and do anything original so they went and got a sound alike

  • @frankalves3 Actually, they have written all new music for Arnel. Will be touring next year!

  • Arnel has an incredible voice and an undeniable charisma. I always liked Journey and Don't Stop Believin but with Arnel as lead singer, I just can't stop playing it. He has brought an amazing, energy to this classic hit. Guys look out because the women are all lovin Arnel.

  • char talaga..badingles..^^

  • @NoSteveNoJourney -go back to the pussy of your mom

  • @NoSteveNoJourney -Then you are the best dumb !!!PinoyStevePinoyJourneyPinoy­Arnel

  • @NoSteveNoJourney -PiNoyStevePiNoyJourney

  • @NoSteveNoJourney -why do you look down people who are mongoloid?is it because they are abnormal and you are normal?with the kind of attitude you have you deserve to go back to the pussy of your mom.

  • i'm such a loser!! i eat shit for breakfast!ohhh! i keep on blaming pinoys for my own stupidity!!. sorry guys that's how losers rule!! and suckass dude like me !. I COULD BE THE

    GREATEST IDIOT

    EVER BORN!! WOW!! FEELS GOOD HUH!!guys!!.I'M BORED, I'M GAY AND WANNA SUCK COCK!! AND I WANT

    YOURS!!- ARNEL PINEDA IS SO ADDICTIVE TO WATCH. GREAT VOICE!! HE'S SO IRRESISTABLE!FUCKIN

    AWESOME!!CHECK ME OUT ON ALL ARNEL'S VIDEOS ! I WAS ONCE A STEVE PERRY FAN!~UNTIL ARNEL PINEDA

    CAME !!GO JOURNEY!

  • all the hate mail here arise from two things: band loyalty and racism. Sad and childish.

  • arnel anyday of the week and twice on sundays!!!

  • what a ruckus arnel is raising! as the saying goes in our language:(translated), "the mango that bears much fruit is so much coveted.they throw stone to get it".tsk tsk tsk!!!steve augieri and coto never got stoned like this.i wonder why!!!

  • poor poor neal reaching and trying to replace that voice, what a foolish lad. neal stop you cant do it. what? you making a buck fifty anight in stead of the thousands that perry brought to the table.

    JUST STOP NEAL. jonathn are you egging him on? waite is waiting for your return. ya the babies go there and stop!!!! lmao

  • thewoodtwo5:what????a buck fifty a night??? flanked math 101 didn't you?LOLS!

  • wallmart urged journey to RE-RECORD bec their old cd's r no longer selling much.when arnel came in; walmart can't produce them fast enough!!!what does that tell you?"a buck fifty a night"?it's 1 + 1 man!!!

  • Steve Perry was and will always be Journey, sorry copy cat no one will follow should had got Perry back

  • NoSteveNoJourney died already hahahahahah spread the word

  • NoSteveNoJourney died already hahahahahah spread the word

  • NoSteveNoJourney died already hahahahahah spread the word

  • Perry has the magic and the soul in his voice. Not as much the other guy. blah.

  • No steve=COPY DOGS NO LIFER LOSER

  • NoSteveNoJourney died already hahahahahah spread the word

  • Hey Dude, relax. Perry is yesterday, Arnel is today. There's nothing u can do about it. Just enjoy Journey's music today, if you don't like, go out and get life.

  • Arnel is just trying to copy steve in like every way and its so fake , steve was the one that made journey what it is

  • some cruel pples are the ones that sux themselves, NOT ap at all! look yourselves in the mirror before you even called ap sux, dudes! it's like words will all go back to your own mouths and bite you painfully regret when you speak rudes.

  • Rude? No not Rude! The Truth! Your just like those idiots from the arnel land who can't stand the truth! He blows just admit it!

  • I'll admit it for them...he sucks! lol

  • Yes!

  • NoSteveNoJourney died already hahahahahah spread the word

  • oh, yeah, both becoming international legends in the wikipedia already. duh! use your brain and think harder! there's no need a say Karaoke becuz every singers do the same as karaoke, too...not just AP! :-P

  • both are awesome in their own unique ways.

    some pples got no brain and kept comparing the two greatest singers.

    3 words:

    DONT BE JEALOUS...that's all I can say!!

  • so what thisdude sounds great .steve culdnt do this no more

  • NoSteveNoJourney = TRAILER TRASH MORON!

  • @nostevenojourney

    dont you think what said is kinda offending and dont give racist comment if you dont like pinedda just shut your effin mouth!

  • arnel suxs no steve no journey arnel shouldnt be in the great legendary legacy

  • NoSteveNoJourney = MONGOLOID MORON APE

  • You know i prefer Perry BY FAR Over Pineda

    and yea

    Pinedda might not have gotten where he is

    if it werent because he sounds like Steve Perry

    But

    I think hes just as good a singer as anybody

    Perry just Had this Passion in his Voice

    that made it so iconic

  • No steve is NO LIFER 24/7 days a week!!!

  • i DONT LIKE ENGLISH GAY DONKEY

  • sori ser aym not ferpect,nat lyk u....God bless you always..

  • Comment removed

  • do you care about perry or you care about journey? sorry but i love journey as the band and i am glad for their come back and pineda made it happen.

  • Yooo!!!!! hear ye, you all mother fucka, I dont care if Arnel came from the mountains of tra-la-la wearin g-string or from the deepest portion of the Pacific Ocean as a human fish, All I know he capture the voice with a little shot of steroid & trust, steve is gone admit it...I want this trademark sound called JOURNEY my favorite band I dont want it to die ok?!!!

  • good comment. past will be past. let enjoy want we have. Arnel is talented

  • idk they both have their own style i guess idk, they're both unique

  • ok .....its arnel's turns now....steve doesn;t want the job anymore....so let's not cry for the the spilled milk....we don't have to compare cuz they are both good ...im very happy that journey is back'...

  • Welch falsch mit Asiaten? Mehr meinungen bitte...

  • great mix....can you imagine these two together on stage at the same time?!! I would pay to see that. Arnel has an amazing voice and yes, there is only one Steve Perry....but both are simply amazing.

  • i think steve perry is better than arnel pineda

  • titi mo

  • traveling perry puppet show

  • lmao I sure do ...

  • alwayssshere he act a lady idiot  don't listen to this moron. bla bla bla duhhhhhhhhhhhhhh

    puppet by SP

  • i preffer Steve Perry

  • its a puppet show thats all...no matter where he came from...

  • The difficulty of fans accepting Arnel Pineda was described by Paul Liberatore AS "an undercurrent of racism." Keyboardist Jonathan Cain responded to such sentiments: "We've become a world band. We're international now. We're not about one color.

  • Sorry... I don't get it. Steve Perry is Journey. And Journey is nothing without Steve Perry. Period.

  • oh really??? haven't you heard journey is back??? where were you??? am big fan of steve perry but he left man, period... now arnel rekindled the flame and good for journey... that's period.

  • its a puppet show now.. with the karaoke king...

  • Alwayinfear has no clue. Showing stupidity with each post. alwaysinfear, you should realize whats really in your posts. If Perry agreed with your views of the band, then he has no integrity for taking money from a band he doesn't approve of OR He is taking the money because he believes in the band (especially considering he doen't need it), OR your just using him as an excuse to be a jerk,..........well? Which is it?

  • yawn as usual with you jean...jean he helped write this shit ...he gets his cut...but he'd never step on stage with what neals made of this crap

  • He won't step on stage but he'll take money from tours in which Arnel sings hu? If Perry had issues with the Neal or the bands performance of the songs he HELPED write, and viewed it as crap as you stated he does, then integrity should dictate that he not accept moneys from touring and only from original songs. So your saying Perry had no integrity, OR he in fact doesn't view the band has you do. Which is it?

  • jeangrey65 alwayssshere he act like a lady idiot. if you listen to heshe she become shemale.

  • you no know...lmao

  • alwayssshere i know and you more than imao

  • lol escariolahug! Idiot being the key word. Doesn't matter what sex you are, and idiot is an idiot!

  • Arnel Pineda i think cannot bring the magic that Steve Perry brought to the band

  • of course he can't thats why his solo career was crap and so is the zoos they still have to copy people for a living!

  • Comment removed

  • alwayssshere SP solo big flop crap out thats why he don't sing anymore. ZOO BAND booming in the Philippines. alwayssshere still bullshittin nobody listen to you ha tang ina mo walang hiya pweeee bweshit. talk to me in tagalog see how idiot you are.

  • if they were booming they wouldnt be playing in bars...lmao see how idiot you are ??what a moron you really are

  • alwayssshere in your bars moron not me ha what the f''''ck don't tell me only moron like you will tell.

  • alwayssshere im not moron and idiot you are idiot and moron more LIMAO im not stupid and you are.

  • its a puppet show now...

  • isnt this in bedtime stroys

  • Honestly, AP voice is clearer than SP.

  • Arnel Pineda is the HD version of Steve Perry. No doubt!!!

  • pineda is so clear and HD version of AP.

    Agreed!

  • alwaysshere i know i would see you here , tell your mom to wash her pussy coz i would fuck her tonight and also your dad coz i would fuck his ass too while u watch....hahahahah fagot

  • one day arnel would be on commercials ouch! lol

  • Both of them are great as their bestest. But AP already been replaced. Accept or not, as long as he's now with Journey to carry on the Legacy without letting it DIE. Try to understand the world and not putting one down. Just enjoy the music of all times, pples. Life is short, live its to the fullest and be optimistic without being pessimism. Peace!!

  • ...sigh, they will never be the same without steve.

  • The band, Journey is great and the body of it existance, but Steve Perry is the heart. The song just simple felt better with Steve Perry because the heart is there. With Pineda its dead. No live and feeling at all. Pineda replacement just like Pinnochio. His stage performance is ok but the singing finished..... So, GOOD BYE Journey. I rather bury you. Where are you man, Steve? Go SOLO if Journey don't want you.

  • no wonder journey are selling out venues..must be that bad singer..lmfao!!

  • its not like the did it by themsleves they did have heart and cheaptrick with a big following of fans for themselves ...they couldn't do it alone...

  • Steve Perry is to me what Frank Sanatra was to my parents. the greatest vocalist of my generation in my opinion. But it wasn't "The Steve Perry Band". it was and is JOURNEY! SP may have been the face or Journey,but the band was the body. And to find someone like Arnel, who does justice to the Journey classics, is amazing. Dont Stop Believin is the most downloaded song in ITUNES history. why would the band want to deprive the old and new fans from hearing that or any other journey classics!

  • Now, I'm a Steve fan. I'm not a fan of Arnel, but I have no problem with him and I think that who is better is completely a matter of opinion. But the Journey we know should have been layed to rest years ago. I realize there was MORE to the band than just Steve, but he was a huge chunk of it. He made the band what it is, and without him it just isn't Journey. If they would just abandon the classics and continue on with new material as they've been doing, I'd feel so much more respect for them.

  • i agree with your take- journey should leave former songs behind- or at least, those not written with Perry- journey is only journey with each member doing what they do best-

  • Comment removed

  • Steve perry is great but Arnel pineda's voice gives more power to the songs.Steve perry's voice is high but it is weak and soft unlike arnel's rockstar like voice.Anyway i love both of them GO JOURNEY!

  • i can definitely tell which voice matches which singer... perry uses a lot of his head voice and arnel's more of a belter... both good falsetto. wish i was either one of them

  • vidwatcher20072006: GOD will decide whos better'! not by any man, these VOICE are nothing without the permission of the ULTIMATE ROCKER! ...remember me when your already in Paradise.

  • Don't try to make a statement about who is better. It is completely subjective. What is entertaining or good sounding in music varies from person to person.

  • In this video, you can tell the difference between Arnel and Perry. Perry's voice is high pitched, and thinner, not as strong as Arnel's superior voice. Pineda's voice is strong. He has a volume behind his power vocals that Perry cannot match. Perry's high notes are high pitched, but thin, weak. This is why Pineda is winning over even the most die hard Perry fans. Arnel Pineda is the BEST ROCK VOICE TODAY.

  • not true... the studio version of this song makes perrys voice weak.. his voice is actually super strong

  • If Perry can't sound strong in a studio in which you can multi-layer the voice and add lots of effects, then he is not strong. This video is using LIVE audio, and you can tell that Perry's voice is thin. Yes, Perry has a slightly greater range, but his high notes are thin in comparison to Pineda's vocals. Pineda's high notes are very solid, has great volume, and depth. Any vocalist will tell you that Pineda's voice is gigantic. Steve perry is known for his incredible freakish range.

  • Steve Perry is known for his incredible freakish range. But don't mistake a high range for vocal strength. Perry sounds at times like a woman, a soprano. Arnel Pineda can sing incredibly high also, but his timbre is masculine, and he sings it with power. If you compare just their voices, Pineda vs Perry, Pineda wins. However, Steve Perry is a legend, and so fans of Perry include all his achievements in their comparison to Pineda, who is just starting out. On vocals alone, Pineda wins.

  • couldnt have said it any better...as far as a total artiest perry wins hands down but voice wise pineda definitely has the edge...the problem is that journey rerecorded the classics with pineda's great voice and that irk a lot of perry fans because the comparisons shows the difference between pineda's great timbre and perrys high falsettos...

  • the funny thing is yes he recorded them but when you hear journey on tv commercials ...it's perry you hear not arnels classic remakes ...go figure neal knows who people want hear!

  • steve's voice sound here sounds like just been to the dentist

  • and yet arnel still needs to copy it for a living hahahahaha

  • queer, blah blah blah. no make sense

  • and arnel would still copy that sound hahahah thats all he knows how to do

  • No need for comparison.

    Steve Perry was fantastic.

    Arnel Pineda is fantastic.

    They are both great singers in their time.

  • stupid stupid people. . . of course no body can copy anybodies voice especially in singing. . . try copying who ever is with you. . . and besides perry is one in a million voice. . .

    arnel is just doin his job in keepin journey alive again. . . can't take it? then stop beliving. haha LOL

  • Arnel says she funny. I still love Steve Perry better!

  • is arnel a female? why did u say, she is funny?

  • I didn't say she is funny.

  • all are nonsense..!!

  • maybe ur just senseless person...

  • That's the best comment yet.

  • hahahahaha... your right man... they are both fantastic, awesome...

  • Steve Perry is and FOREVER WILL BE JOURNEY. Try as they might they will NEVER replace him. Arnel has talent but he is no Steve Perry. Also Perry is an incredible song writer.

  • Arnel has replaced Perry, Perry is nothing without Journey. That's why he is so irrelevant without them.

  • no one human can emulate another a 100%. be it singing, dancing, walking, talking...up to farting.

    so to those ppl who can't live past the past, carry on living there and stop whining and stay put there.

  • perry kicks ass

  • Arnel is incredible!

  • let's give credit where credit is due. Steve helped Journey to achieve this status, it was his choice to leave the band, he didn't pulled them down. Arnel on the other hand is picking up where they left of. They are both great singers in their own rights. Let's respect the past and accept the present.

  • Couldn't be said any better than that!

  • TinyManoy's remarks say it all without question. Arnel picked-up where Steve left-off: "They are both great singers in their own rights. Let's respect the past and accept the present." The "controversy" couldn't have been best articulated than in TinyManoy's comments. I think, it is either you are a Journey supporter or not. AP or SP is not the question. AP and SP, and who knows if an "XP" might come later, complement each other for great Journey music. Peace and Enjoy.

  • arnel is a thousand times better as a frontman for this venerable rock band. steve perry was a cancer that ruined journey's chance of having a great comback when he pulled up lame for the 'trial by fire' tour. steve could sing back in the mid 80's, his voice is destroyed now. arnel is the man, he sounds identical when he needs to, has a better range on his own songs and has way more chemistry with the band.

    good riddance to the rat faced one, here is to arnel's wondeful new presence!

  • Here here!!! Can't agree with you more brother. Pinoy pride forever!

  • a cancer eh? wow youve got a way with words.You do Arnel proud.

    The only "cancer" on YT I see here is you. You obviously have no respect for history and the past of (in this case) a band) so you are not worthy to comment. try to talk so tough when youre in front of me.F*ckin' waste of YT space.

  • Anyone who thinks Arnel has more range than Steve Perry is CRAZY. His voice is much more muffled on the high notes. Steve perry has an incredible voice that CAN NOT be duplicated

  • Damn, this new lead sounds better than Perry. More bass to his voice and still make the song sound so good. Perry sounds like a little girl.

  • Anybody who has any ounce of musical wit, knows full well that Steve Perry is the better singer and is the memorable voice of Journey. No contest.

  • Arnel has helped the band tour the classics

    live. And sounding like Perry . But thats about it. The album they did with him doesnt come close to Infinity , Escape or Frontiers.

    Thats why Perry was the best frontman . He could help write hits !

  • fuck journey steve is journey:D

  • Pineda is a good impersonator, but that's all he'll ever be. Augeri totally killed his voice trying to sing like Perry, as I'm sure Pineda will also. there is only one Steve Perry,he's not coming back, and as much as I hate to say it, Journey needs to just call it a career.

  • Arnel try's to hard to say the whole word and sounds as if English is his second language (i think it is) vs Steve who just sings the damn song and has a more natural sound to it. But other than that they are basically vocal copyies of one another

  • Steve "The Voice" Perry should ask for Arnel Pineda's autograph!!!!

  • lol sometimes its hard to distinguish steve between arnel

  • Ruben Nepales, Phil. Daily Inquirer

    "The LA crowd was constantly on its feet, cheered & whistled its appreciation for Arnel & Journey.

    Due to huge demand, a 2nd show was added & both were quick SOLD OUTS!

    Blessed w/a powerful voice, a higher pitch than SP & able to sustain difficult notes, Arnel instantly proved he deserved the lead vocalist spot & turning out to be the most effective & successful.

    The crazed fans smiled appreciatively at Arnel as his solid voice reverberated."

  • RNepales, PDI con't:

    "The largely middle-aged crowd embraced their spouses, dates and partners.

    They danced, exchanged high fives with seat mates, raised and swayed their arms, sang along and screamed their approval of Arnel and his band mates while standing throughout most of the remaining set.

    The band announced onstage at the Sunday show that "Revelation" is Journey's best-selling new album since 1986's "Raised on Radio."

    Arnel is singing tall & proud in the global rock scene"

  • perrys voice is girlish and nasal! pinedas voice is masculine and more stronger!

  • Legendary music producer Kevin Shirley, Oct. 1 cavemanproductionsDOTcom:

    "Journey's new album, Revelation, IS OFFICIALLY PLATINUM!!

    "Took Wife & year old Talon to see Journey at the Greek Theater in L.A. last night. T'was great to see them doing so well on the road & Talon had his first AAA All Access laminate w/ photo ID!

    The band sounded GREAT!!

    Arnel was singing so well & it seemed like the L.A. crowd was unusually enthusiastic. They're a notoriously staid audience normally."

  • J. Blevins, Denver Post at SOLD OUT concert:

    "God freaking Bless America. Arnel's the real Rock Star.. by show end, most of the 18k fans forgot Perry.

    "With perfect pitch, power & amazing resonance, Arnel floored the crowd. He's an American rock star w/a swooning crowd hanging on his perfectly tenored voice. He can carry an even higher pitch than Perrys trademark wail. He merges a F. Mercury smoothness with a D. Roth rocker style. Arnel had eclipsed Perry in both talent & enthusiasm"

  • J. Blevins, Denver Post at SOLD OUT concert:

    "God freaking Bless America. Arnel's the real Rock Star.. by show end, most of the 18k fans forgot Perry.

    "With perfect pitch, power & amazing resonance, Arnel floored the crowd. He's an American rock star w/a swooning crowd hanging on his perfectly tenored voice. He can carry an even higher pitch than Perrys trademark wail. He merges a F. Mercury smoothness with a D. Roth rocker style. Arnel had eclipsed Perry in both talent & enthusiasm"

  • arnel didn't help write one of the new songs ...and when you hear journey on the radio arnel is NEVER the one singing.. it's always perry and what remakes did they do?The perry classics of course... arnels just a hired puppet!

  • PWired review con't:

    "For two hours, Arnel's awesome tenor voice was in perfect pitch, hitting all the high notes & delivered powerful renditions of the classics & their new songs.

    Couple that with his fist pumps, high kicks, spinning, twirling & running from stage left to stage right & back, Arnel never let up to the end, completely at ease.

    He is more confident than ever before.

    Journey played solidly and were totally in sync throughout the concert."

  • Racist ass-licker, loser jimbo tit' son "thenicchan" told him:

    "Daddy jimbo tit bastard's always out to suck a dick.....

    "He's at the street corner now stalking the neighborhood kids.."

    Jimbo Dude, it's our Arnel/Journey celebration. We don't thrash your Bestiality Sex with Animal's celebration..;)

    We Journey jammin'

    ..the racists hatin'

    While dey misbehavin'

    ...We J-chillin'..;)

  • Hey SCAB CARPENTER, Mo fo jimbo bro..;)

    "now Ass-licker RACIST JIMMYtit Chan's crying, mumblin, bumblin about how tough it is on his Sex-with-Animals road show!!!

    "and geezer RACIST JIMMYtit didn't realize it would be so tough with his badly gored all-used ASS...what a sissy..no wonder he's aka AlwaysSherrie!'...;)

    Here ol'geezer jimmytt again, having diarrhea of the brains, comes out of the ass, Then to his mouth.

    Keep yappin smack & the message will bounce back at U.;)

  • ...............!!!!!!!!!!!!... ...

    =======!!!!!!!!!!=====

    ┏┫ | | ┣┓ ┏┓

    ┗┫━━ ┃ ━━┣┛ ┣┃Jimbotit's son ┃ ━━━━━ ┃ ┏┳┫┣┳┓ ┗━━┳━┳━━┛ ┃thenicchan tells him F.U...;)

    ━━━━┃ ┃ ┗━┳┳━┛

    ━━━━┃ ┗━━━━━━jimbo's feeling's hurt..;)

    "Jimbo tit would rather love his llama hoochie hooves in his ass"....;)

  • wow eliali and his animal orgys is pretty fucking gross....sick old groupie fuck!