I knew the whol Nelson Mandela thing was too good to be true. Seems to the WASP financial and mining institutions still run the place like a slave-camp.
This man hasn't got a cooking clue. "The minority holds the land, industries, and economy", so you mean South Africa is like the UK, the USA, etc.? In almost any country a small handful of people own the majority of resources... don't hate on South Africa, hate on capitalism.
While there may still be a remnant of a rich white establishment backed by Washington and London, the main victims that now suffer under apartheid are in fact white Afrikaners.
The regular Afrikaners are just farmers, not part of the Anglo establishment that ran the government, and now they suffer from rampant discrimination and hate crimes. South Africa has become a Black Supremascist apartheid State with a few token white elites.
@esc1127 "a few token white elites"?? Bwoaaah haaaa haaaa haaaaa haaaaa!! You make nice jokes, dude. Are you talking about the average 6 families that "own" SA?? The same ones who became stinking rich by taking a piggyback ride on Apartheid??
Dude... there absolutely NOTHING "token" about them. Black SA'ns may have political power but these folk you're refering to still have the economical power... and will for a looooong time. Nuff said...
The whites there should have just declared an independent republic in their majority areas and see how long the Blacks could maintain South Africa on their own.
Besides liking the film and Pilger's work I like the opening song a lot. Does anyone know what it's called, who perform it and where I might access it?
@TaleOfValors - You have to go back to the Berlin Conference of 1884 to understand this. Most of Africa was used as a private piggy bank by the colonizers (learn about Leopold in the Congo and rubber (good book, King Leopold's Ghost)). It was a place to take from with no intentions of giving back. South Africa (also Namibia) were the only places were the colonizers really settled in large numbers, so it was important to keep some of the wealth there.
@kynismos - The wealth was kept in South Africa. It wasn't shipped abroad. Almost all trains in other parts of Africa were designed to go to the coasts...to leave the continent with nothing returned to it.
South Africa ended legalized racial Apartheid but failed to end that greatest of Apartheids - capitalism. Now all we see are a class of black millionaires standing alongside their white counter-parts while the vast majority of people live in poverty.
@rutagengwa Have you realised how racist this comment is? Probably not, because you are most probably a professional at assuming racism from others bud ignorant to your own racism. I vote that a law should be passed that punishes racism with the death penalty. We will never come out from under the cloud of apartheid with you racists around.
@wlsjoh013 There wasn't ANYthing remotely racist about @rutagengwa 's comment. The statement was factual and the question a justified and legitimate one.
Maybe we know now who the "closet racist" is and who is in denial of the facts. I love it when people expose themselves... Haha haha haaaaa! ;-)
@LevonaDiedrich "do you think honestly that the wealth acquired by whites was legitimate", if you cant see that this is racist, well then you are retarded.
@wlsjoh013 Haha haaa! And there you expose your own retardedness. You obviously neither understood the speaker's point, nor my response. So lemme spell it out.. NO, I DON'T THINK THE BULK OF WEALTH ACQUIRED BY WHITES WERE LEGITIMATE. Comprendér?
And NO, IT'S NOT A RACIST STATEMENT, IT'S A FACT. The proof is all around in SA, not just in this video. I understand you also want to say s.th but please do yourself a favour & stop exposing your own ignorance, idiocy and closet racism.
@LevonaDiedrich LMFAO...your channel says you are 35, but you are probably 12. The last time I had a debate with someone where they took the stance that "I'm rubber, you are glue", I was about 12. You cannot see your own racist tendencies...this is what saddens me about some people. Saying that the wealth acquired by whites in South Africa was not legitimate is a broad statement which labels all white wealth as illegitimate. How can you not see such a statement as racist?
@LevonaDiedrich The truth is that you do not want to admit that you are racist. Saying that such a statement is fact indicates that you are a hardened racist. Are you telling me that the wealth Christiaan Barnard generated was illegitimate? if so, please explain how? Please also note that I am not offended by your childish antics, so call me a racist, or a retard, it doesn't bother me, because I know full well that I am neither of those.
@wlsjoh013 If you don't know/understand that Apartheid Laws & also imperialism before that catered 4 the social, economical & political advancement of Whites only (whether directly or indirectly) that's YOUR PROBLEM. No amount of name-calling or faked amnesia will change those hardcore facts. DID YOU EVEN WATCH THIS VIDEO? Or d'you conveniently wish 2 ignore the facts presented 2 you by this seasoned journalist, amongst others? What you're doing is what one calls "closet racism".
@LevonaDiedrich What about Mark Shuttleworth? And don't even think of saying "read my last comment, I said THE BULK OF WEALTH ACQUIRED BY WHITES", because you started this debate by saying a comment which did not discern between all and most was not racist. I agree, a large amount of white wealth has some very dodgy origins, but you cannot group an entire race together in one statement. That is racist.
@wlsjoh013 Oooooh, so NOW we CAN read and now we do know that I said "the bulk" and now we even admit DODGY ORIGINS?? Oh flippen wow... hehe heeee! Nitpicking won't getcha outta this one, dear. You've proved your worth...
@LevonaDiedrich OMFG, you are annoying me! Just admit that you were wrong and we can both walk away from this. YOU said that a blanket statement about ALL white wealth being illegitimate was NOT RACIST AT ALL!! Then you proceeded to change your statement to "THE BULK" of white wealth. This does not change my original point that rutagengwa's comment was racist. I never once stated that I believed that ALL white wealth was legitimate...
@LevonaDiedrich in fact, I often see rich white people (old wealth, not new wealth) and wonder how that money was obtained. To say that ALL white wealth in South Africa is illegitimate remains a racist comment. I think you agree with me that one cannot make such blanket statements about any race without being racist and therefore I believe that we are of the same understanding on this matter. I think you reacted to my comment thinking that I thought all white wealth was legitimately acquired.
I knew the whol Nelson Mandela thing was too good to be true. Seems to the WASP financial and mining institutions still run the place like a slave-camp.
GnosticHumanist 1 day ago
This has been flagged as spam show
This man hasn't got a cooking clue. "The minority holds the land, industries, and economy", so you mean South Africa is like the UK, the USA, etc.? In almost any country a small handful of people own the majority of resources... don't hate on South Africa, hate on capitalism.
wlsjoh013 1 month ago
Comment removed
wlsjoh013 1 month ago
While there may still be a remnant of a rich white establishment backed by Washington and London, the main victims that now suffer under apartheid are in fact white Afrikaners.
The regular Afrikaners are just farmers, not part of the Anglo establishment that ran the government, and now they suffer from rampant discrimination and hate crimes. South Africa has become a Black Supremascist apartheid State with a few token white elites.
esc1127 6 months ago
@esc1127 "a few token white elites"?? Bwoaaah haaaa haaaa haaaaa haaaaa!! You make nice jokes, dude. Are you talking about the average 6 families that "own" SA?? The same ones who became stinking rich by taking a piggyback ride on Apartheid??
Dude... there absolutely NOTHING "token" about them. Black SA'ns may have political power but these folk you're refering to still have the economical power... and will for a looooong time. Nuff said...
LevonaDiedrich 2 weeks ago
The whites there should have just declared an independent republic in their majority areas and see how long the Blacks could maintain South Africa on their own.
esc1127 6 months ago
@esc1127 Well said. I hope one day they start a new trek and begin from scratch.
andy7666 3 months ago
Besides liking the film and Pilger's work I like the opening song a lot. Does anyone know what it's called, who perform it and where I might access it?
rumputuski 9 months ago
Good vid - thanks!
asas2jh 1 year ago
Why is South Africa so much richer than all the other African states? Who created this wealth?
kynismos 1 year ago
@kynismos Good question you raise there. There has or had to be a certain difference between South Africa and all the other African states...
TaleOfValors 11 months ago
@TaleOfValors - The wealth was kept there and not shipped abroad.
lovingit1000 2 weeks ago
@lovingit1000 And why wasn't it shipped abroad?
TaleOfValors 2 weeks ago
@TaleOfValors - You have to go back to the Berlin Conference of 1884 to understand this. Most of Africa was used as a private piggy bank by the colonizers (learn about Leopold in the Congo and rubber (good book, King Leopold's Ghost)). It was a place to take from with no intentions of giving back. South Africa (also Namibia) were the only places were the colonizers really settled in large numbers, so it was important to keep some of the wealth there.
lovingit1000 2 weeks ago
@kynismos - The wealth was kept in South Africa. It wasn't shipped abroad. Almost all trains in other parts of Africa were designed to go to the coasts...to leave the continent with nothing returned to it.
lovingit1000 2 weeks ago
South Africa ended legalized racial Apartheid but failed to end that greatest of Apartheids - capitalism. Now all we see are a class of black millionaires standing alongside their white counter-parts while the vast majority of people live in poverty.
blackiron60 1 year ago 2
@blackiron60 Are Black people suppose to be poor just to make everyone feel better.
makkool 9 months ago in playlist Documentaries
Comment removed
BomBomBunny 1 year ago
Crazy & PrdTB
try some intellectual honesty pilger is speaking about the long standing consequences of oppression.
do you think honestly that the wealth acquired by whites was legitimate ?
rutagengwa 2 years ago 3
@rutagengwa Have you realised how racist this comment is? Probably not, because you are most probably a professional at assuming racism from others bud ignorant to your own racism. I vote that a law should be passed that punishes racism with the death penalty. We will never come out from under the cloud of apartheid with you racists around.
wlsjoh013 1 month ago
@wlsjoh013 There wasn't ANYthing remotely racist about @rutagengwa 's comment. The statement was factual and the question a justified and legitimate one.
Maybe we know now who the "closet racist" is and who is in denial of the facts. I love it when people expose themselves... Haha haha haaaaa! ;-)
LevonaDiedrich 2 weeks ago
@LevonaDiedrich "do you think honestly that the wealth acquired by whites was legitimate", if you cant see that this is racist, well then you are retarded.
wlsjoh013 2 weeks ago
@wlsjoh013 Haha haaa! And there you expose your own retardedness. You obviously neither understood the speaker's point, nor my response. So lemme spell it out.. NO, I DON'T THINK THE BULK OF WEALTH ACQUIRED BY WHITES WERE LEGITIMATE. Comprendér?
And NO, IT'S NOT A RACIST STATEMENT, IT'S A FACT. The proof is all around in SA, not just in this video. I understand you also want to say s.th but please do yourself a favour & stop exposing your own ignorance, idiocy and closet racism.
LevonaDiedrich 2 weeks ago
@LevonaDiedrich LMFAO...your channel says you are 35, but you are probably 12. The last time I had a debate with someone where they took the stance that "I'm rubber, you are glue", I was about 12. You cannot see your own racist tendencies...this is what saddens me about some people. Saying that the wealth acquired by whites in South Africa was not legitimate is a broad statement which labels all white wealth as illegitimate. How can you not see such a statement as racist?
wlsjoh013 2 weeks ago
@LevonaDiedrich The truth is that you do not want to admit that you are racist. Saying that such a statement is fact indicates that you are a hardened racist. Are you telling me that the wealth Christiaan Barnard generated was illegitimate? if so, please explain how? Please also note that I am not offended by your childish antics, so call me a racist, or a retard, it doesn't bother me, because I know full well that I am neither of those.
wlsjoh013 2 weeks ago
@wlsjoh013 If you don't know/understand that Apartheid Laws & also imperialism before that catered 4 the social, economical & political advancement of Whites only (whether directly or indirectly) that's YOUR PROBLEM. No amount of name-calling or faked amnesia will change those hardcore facts. DID YOU EVEN WATCH THIS VIDEO? Or d'you conveniently wish 2 ignore the facts presented 2 you by this seasoned journalist, amongst others? What you're doing is what one calls "closet racism".
LevonaDiedrich 2 weeks ago
@LevonaDiedrich What about Mark Shuttleworth? And don't even think of saying "read my last comment, I said THE BULK OF WEALTH ACQUIRED BY WHITES", because you started this debate by saying a comment which did not discern between all and most was not racist. I agree, a large amount of white wealth has some very dodgy origins, but you cannot group an entire race together in one statement. That is racist.
wlsjoh013 2 weeks ago
@wlsjoh013 Oooooh, so NOW we CAN read and now we do know that I said "the bulk" and now we even admit DODGY ORIGINS?? Oh flippen wow... hehe heeee! Nitpicking won't getcha outta this one, dear. You've proved your worth...
LevonaDiedrich 2 weeks ago
@LevonaDiedrich OMFG, you are annoying me! Just admit that you were wrong and we can both walk away from this. YOU said that a blanket statement about ALL white wealth being illegitimate was NOT RACIST AT ALL!! Then you proceeded to change your statement to "THE BULK" of white wealth. This does not change my original point that rutagengwa's comment was racist. I never once stated that I believed that ALL white wealth was legitimate...
wlsjoh013 2 weeks ago
@LevonaDiedrich in fact, I often see rich white people (old wealth, not new wealth) and wonder how that money was obtained. To say that ALL white wealth in South Africa is illegitimate remains a racist comment. I think you agree with me that one cannot make such blanket statements about any race without being racist and therefore I believe that we are of the same understanding on this matter. I think you reacted to my comment thinking that I thought all white wealth was legitimately acquired.
wlsjoh013 2 weeks ago
@LevonaDiedrich and I reacted to rutagengwa's comment because it was racist (as it grouped all white wealth as illegitimate).
wlsjoh013 2 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Apartheid didn't die, it reversed.
John Pilger's nothing more than socialist scum.
crazychrisva 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I agree, apartheid just reversed.
PrdTB 2 years ago
You're an englishman from england you have just as much racisim in your country as in South Africa you hypocrite!
Sunclief 2 years ago
thank you for posting such important videos
moosa86 4 years ago 5