I loved both Sarah and Alicia as Kendall but I think they should've had a who's the real Kendall Hart S/L because when the show brought SMG back before the show ended , she
was a paitent saying " I'm Erica Kane's daughter " this idea came to me because when SMG
left in 1995 , Erica & Kendall made peace then AM took over the role in 2002 and all hell broke loose with Erica & Kendall , this should've been a who's who S/L instead of the
Sarah Michelle Gellar. completely. no questions. dont give a rip what anyone has to protest. Alicia was a bit too stiff. When SMG came back for her guest spot during the final week, i bet they would've handed Kendall back over to her in half a heartbeat. She will always be Kendall to me.
Alicia's Kendall was just too sweet IMO...SMG's Kendall was a raging bizotch! I loved her because I hated her. Not trying to knock Alicia Minshew, and she is a good Kendall, but she is 'nice' Kendall...'mom' Kendall.
I think this is something of an unfair comparison... a 15yr old vs a grown woman. Now SMG as an actress certainly has the chops to pull of any role. I've never really love Alisha b/c while she's good, she comes across a weak person pretending to be strong. Whereas SMG has the chops to easily blend vulnerabitilty & strength w/o ever appearing weak. Although that's not necessarily apparent hear considering the vast difference between the s/l presented. JMO
Alicia Minshew is the best for Kendall... Point blank and SMG will never come back not that the show wants her anyway. Alicia has made Kendall into her own character, that right their says alot about her acting. She has tons of fans and is part of a super couple that is/was the driving force for AMC!
some of u guys are CRAZY! just because she originated the role doesnt mean she is the best one!!! Alicia Minshew came and made Kendall HER role! no one is a better Kendall, which is why the show is so centered around her constantly. and she's not GONE, she's coming back! she's on maternity leave, that's all! HI HATERS!!
SMG was AMAZING!!!!!!! in this role. That's why Susan Lucci hated her in real life, because Sarah could act circles and circles around her. SMG will always be # 1!!! AM is great also but she can't out shine Susan who I do love BTW. SMG is 50 times better then susan and Alicia put together. SMG wins hands down. AMC get her back!!!!! Don't hate me SL & AM you 2 are great and we are greatful to have you but SMG is and always will be the HBIC!!!!
Alicia is the best Kendall, in my opinion. She brings more humor and personality to the role. Besides, I am sure that if she had auditioned for the role back in 1993, she might have beaten SMG out of her role.
@lovesmovies477 FUCK OFF, DORK!!! I am entitled to my opinion, now learn how to use proper punctuation and grammar before you go around insulting people that you don't even know. You are such a piece of shit. Your parents must be so ashamed of you!!! Crawl into a hole and die!!!!!!
@alstonpmaroon = a filthy pig. she emailed me this gross and disgusting email with nasty, nasty words. either she is on some serious drugs or is mentally not well
@lovesmovies477 You stupid whore!!! Look who's crying foul now!!! You started this whole verbal argument in the first place, and now you wanna call me "gross" and "disgusting"??? You really are a pathetic piece of shit. Next time, don't try to trash talk people who you don't even know or call people names that you wouldn't call them to your face!!!!
I do think Alicia did a great job taking over the part, but I love Sarah Michelle Gellar and all of her work, and I think she's the best. She's an amazing actress. Also, the way SMG's Kendall acted at the time was exactly according to the script. That's how they wanted the character to be portrayed. Yes, during Alicia's time the character has become more grown up, but that's also in the script. I think that if SMG would return as Kendall today, she would do the part even better than Alicia!
ALICIA WINS! SMG was great as a younger Kendall, but AM made the role her own and I couldnt imagine anyone else playing the part! She's the bitch we love to hate that eventually stole our hearts and became a favorite character!
I have to admit that when AM first showed up as Kendall I never thought she would be able to be as bitchy as SMG. AM proved me wrong, because she can be just as much of a bitch as SMG if not worse. I do think SMG looks more like Erica. When AM came I felt she was too pretty to be Erica's daughter. I like them both.
Alicia Minshew too pretty to be Susan Lucci's daughter? Are you kidding me? I think Susan is MUCH more attractive than Alicia, and she's almost 30 years older.
yeah i have to agree with you there, i think Susan is prettier though Alicia is not ugly by any means.
for me SMG is a better actress but AM has made Kendall her own. the only thing is for me i loved Kendall when SMG played her and now with AM's portrayal of the character sometimes i really like her but other times i HATE her. hat could just be the writing though.
I was one of those poeple that would never except another Kendall but my love for the character made me love Alicia just as much or even more than SMG.
I didn't watch the show back when Sarah Michelle Gellar played Kendall, but I really like Alicia Minshew as Kendall. I think she does a great job. The clips of Sarah Michelle Gellar were great too though, but I'm probably just not used to them. I feel like Gellar wouldn't be able to take on someone like Greenlee (Rebecca Budig - sorry if that's spelled wrong). But I bet she was fantastic as well!
And the award goes to SMG!!!!! I mean I don't think AM has won and emmy 4 Kendall and SMG did so that should end all debate. And Sarah only played Kendall for a short time too, where as Alicia has been on there 4ever! It would be cool if SMG came back to be Kendall now that Buffy is over an what not.
You really cant compare one was in her teenage years and the other one has a baby, both are great actress but I have to side with Alicia because she STAYED on the show longer then Sarah!
Well first, the Sarah Michelle Gellar scene is not even remotely at her best pure evil. But no one, no one will ever play Kendall like SMG. There is no question! She can play a bitch like nobody's business!! Alicia is good but Sarah is by far better!
Sarah won the emmy, and AM can't even get nominated after almost SEVEN years (I swear it's been forever) and tons of storylines handed to her and making others the sacrificial lambs for her stupid character. I loved SMG's Kendall, and I HATE AM's entitled, phony baloney Kendall. So, yea, SMG wins by a landslide.
different times. different storylines. different acting, same character. is it ever really consistent? i think SMG was great for her storylines and maybe she would have been been a better Kendall than AM when Kendall first came back to Pine Valley, but today, the character has changed somewhat. SMG wouldn't be good with this personality. AM plays a better grown-up Kendall. Thinking of SMG now as Kendall, would be like thinking about Buffy with kids. Nuh uh!
i loved SMG as Kendall, she was my favorite character on AMC when she played her. after a while i came to like Alicia in the role but Kendall's not my favorite character anymore. i do think SMG would do great playing opposite of RB and CM but i don't think she and TK would have that same spark or incredible chemistry that he and AM do so i say it's tie, depending on who they were paired with would depend on who would carry the role better. SMG is my favorite though for who i like better.
I hope some of you guys actually watch AMC because really Kendall is not the same person and I couldn't see Gellar go up against some of the other actors on the show the way Minshew does.
Wow! A reasonable point. However, what makes Gellar and Minishew great is that it's not all about them. It about their scene partners as well, now Gellar and Rebecca would be interesting. After the rumors, Gellar and Lucci. That's why I will disagree on the exception that I don't think Gellar could spark that chemistry with Kaye(Zach).
Sarah won a daytime emmy for her acting as Kendall. I'd say that she's a great actress. It was her acting that really opened up for other acting opportunities. I thought she was a match for Susan Lucci.
I absolutely adore Sarah Michelle Gellar, she remains my favorite actress ever since her AMC days, but as far as Kendall, the role solely belongs to Alicia now. She's played Kendall the longest and both the character and the actress have evolved so much that SMG's Kendall and Alicia's Kendall are two separate characters. Equally good, but Alicia owns the role completely now.
Sarah Is Soooooooooo Much better..... Why Would You Even Wanna COnsider That The Other One Is Better... Sarah Won A Emmy For The Role Of Kendal..... Love Sarah 4-Ever She's The Best!!!!!
I loved both Sarah and Alicia as Kendall but I think they should've had a who's the real Kendall Hart S/L because when the show brought SMG back before the show ended , she
was a paitent saying " I'm Erica Kane's daughter " this idea came to me because when SMG
left in 1995 , Erica & Kendall made peace then AM took over the role in 2002 and all hell broke loose with Erica & Kendall , this should've been a who's who S/L instead of the
Erica & Jane S/L
monson108 2 weeks ago
Comment removed
monson108 2 weeks ago
Comment removed
monson108 2 weeks ago
Sarah Michelle Gellar. completely. no questions. dont give a rip what anyone has to protest. Alicia was a bit too stiff. When SMG came back for her guest spot during the final week, i bet they would've handed Kendall back over to her in half a heartbeat. She will always be Kendall to me.
JerryO89 4 months ago
Alicia is by far the more talented actress, and she even looks like the Kane women.
GenXorcist1976 6 months ago
alicia is the better kendall who cares that she didnt qet a emmy she a way better kendall
ladyybuq16 6 months ago
Let's put it this way... who won the Emmy? Case closed!!!
lfnfemme 6 months ago 2
Sarah Michelle Gellar. Alicia Minshew isn't even HALF the actress Sarah is.
DegrassiInstantStar 7 months ago 2
@DegrassiInstantStar Totally agree!!!
lfnfemme 6 months ago
alicia minishew hands down!
lady534021 8 months ago
Alicia's Kendall was just too sweet IMO...SMG's Kendall was a raging bizotch! I loved her because I hated her. Not trying to knock Alicia Minshew, and she is a good Kendall, but she is 'nice' Kendall...'mom' Kendall.
tymcbee 9 months ago
i dont think comparing a 15 yr old girl to a 30yr old women is fair...but i think smg was a great teenage kendall and alicia is a good older kendall
gookinboots 10 months ago 5
Sarah is homely.
KellyGreen5555 10 months ago
Careful Sarah, Myrtle could kick Buffy's ass...
brinpol 10 months ago
I think this is something of an unfair comparison... a 15yr old vs a grown woman. Now SMG as an actress certainly has the chops to pull of any role. I've never really love Alisha b/c while she's good, she comes across a weak person pretending to be strong. Whereas SMG has the chops to easily blend vulnerabitilty & strength w/o ever appearing weak. Although that's not necessarily apparent hear considering the vast difference between the s/l presented. JMO
TheOnly1tonid 1 year ago
Alicia Minshew has been my favorite actress since she started. I think Gellar sucks
kayla2111 1 year ago
Sarah was. The new kendalls suck
miajenann12345 1 year ago
Alicia Minshew is the best for Kendall... Point blank and SMG will never come back not that the show wants her anyway. Alicia has made Kendall into her own character, that right their says alot about her acting. She has tons of fans and is part of a super couple that is/was the driving force for AMC!
sexylibra01 1 year ago
It's proven, AMC needs to fight for SMG to come back as Kendall.
DegrassiInstantStar 1 year ago
some of u guys are CRAZY! just because she originated the role doesnt mean she is the best one!!! Alicia Minshew came and made Kendall HER role! no one is a better Kendall, which is why the show is so centered around her constantly. and she's not GONE, she's coming back! she's on maternity leave, that's all! HI HATERS!!
MrKnowles11 1 year ago
sarah michelle gellar. thats it
britt1397 1 year ago
sarah michelle gellar is the best
Horsiedudette 2 years ago
SMG was the perfect young Kendall, but Alicia has made grown up Kendall her own. So my vote is for both :D
jrchandlerfan 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
SMG was AMAZING!!!!!!! in this role. That's why Susan Lucci hated her in real life, because Sarah could act circles and circles around her. SMG will always be # 1!!! AM is great also but she can't out shine Susan who I do love BTW. SMG is 50 times better then susan and Alicia put together. SMG wins hands down. AMC get her back!!!!! Don't hate me SL & AM you 2 are great and we are greatful to have you but SMG is and always will be the HBIC!!!!
fusiongreenlee 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Alicia byy miles!
lobogirl 2 years ago
Comment removed
lobogirl 2 years ago
Alicia is the best Kendall, in my opinion. She brings more humor and personality to the role. Besides, I am sure that if she had auditioned for the role back in 1993, she might have beaten SMG out of her role.
alstonpmaroon 2 years ago
Comment removed
lovesmovies477 1 year ago
@lovesmovies477 FUCK OFF, DORK!!! I am entitled to my opinion, now learn how to use proper punctuation and grammar before you go around insulting people that you don't even know. You are such a piece of shit. Your parents must be so ashamed of you!!! Crawl into a hole and die!!!!!!
alstonpmaroon 1 year ago
Comment removed
lovesmovies477 1 year ago
Comment removed
alstonpmaroon 1 year ago
@alstonpmaroon = a filthy pig. she emailed me this gross and disgusting email with nasty, nasty words. either she is on some serious drugs or is mentally not well
lovesmovies477 1 year ago
@lovesmovies477 You stupid whore!!! Look who's crying foul now!!! You started this whole verbal argument in the first place, and now you wanna call me "gross" and "disgusting"??? You really are a pathetic piece of shit. Next time, don't try to trash talk people who you don't even know or call people names that you wouldn't call them to your face!!!!
alstonpmaroon 1 year ago
yes, lets end this. im done talking to fruitcakes that watch soaps. does your husband know what a filthy mouth you have? trash.
lovesmovies477 1 year ago
@lovesmovies477 I ALREADY ended it, jackass!! Why do you keep sending me messages?? Go jump off a fucking cliff already!!! I'm done with you!!!!
alstonpmaroon 1 year ago
@alstonpmaroon is trash
lovesmovies477 1 year ago
smg
wkgnmama 2 years ago 3
I do think Alicia did a great job taking over the part, but I love Sarah Michelle Gellar and all of her work, and I think she's the best. She's an amazing actress. Also, the way SMG's Kendall acted at the time was exactly according to the script. That's how they wanted the character to be portrayed. Yes, during Alicia's time the character has become more grown up, but that's also in the script. I think that if SMG would return as Kendall today, she would do the part even better than Alicia!
PurpleStar91 2 years ago 4
ALICIA WINS! SMG was great as a younger Kendall, but AM made the role her own and I couldnt imagine anyone else playing the part! She's the bitch we love to hate that eventually stole our hearts and became a favorite character!
MrKnowles11 2 years ago
Comment removed
lovesmovies477 1 year ago
Sarah Michelle Gellar is better as Kendall Hart than Alicia Minshew!!!!
ryanbradyjohnblack19 2 years ago 2
i love alica she was able to kendall in to a woman a wife a mother and business woman and sara was kinda bratty
Pinkranger87 2 years ago
I love alicia minishew
Billielover0011 2 years ago
Me too!
MzTJones80 2 years ago
I have to admit that when AM first showed up as Kendall I never thought she would be able to be as bitchy as SMG. AM proved me wrong, because she can be just as much of a bitch as SMG if not worse. I do think SMG looks more like Erica. When AM came I felt she was too pretty to be Erica's daughter. I like them both.
casta266 2 years ago
Alicia Minshew too pretty to be Susan Lucci's daughter? Are you kidding me? I think Susan is MUCH more attractive than Alicia, and she's almost 30 years older.
pawclaws57 2 years ago
yeah i have to agree with you there, i think Susan is prettier though Alicia is not ugly by any means.
for me SMG is a better actress but AM has made Kendall her own. the only thing is for me i loved Kendall when SMG played her and now with AM's portrayal of the character sometimes i really like her but other times i HATE her. hat could just be the writing though.
gigga143 2 years ago
SMG was AMAZING!!!!!!! in this role. That's why Susan Lucci hated her in real life, because Sarah could act circles around her.
hfxmusicman 2 years ago 5
they both did a great job it was like the same person i love them the same
lexiea2000 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Alicia is the clear winner. The only reason why SMG won an emmy was cuz she was a cute 15 year old.
IsaLopez 2 years ago
alicia minishew is better
AMCandOLTLfan81 2 years ago
smg is way better
disneyrocks77 2 years ago 3
SMG was way better!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
dddewar 2 years ago 3
I never saw SMG on the show, but I think she's a bit better than AM
L0Litsaweasel 2 years ago 3
smg
Ryonizdabest1993 2 years ago
I was one of those poeple that would never except another Kendall but my love for the character made me love Alicia just as much or even more than SMG.
Smielyb2000 2 years ago
SMG RULES!!!!
muthasausage 2 years ago 17
sarah michelle gellar was the best kendall imho
zellcurrie 2 years ago 3
I didn't watch the show back when Sarah Michelle Gellar played Kendall, but I really like Alicia Minshew as Kendall. I think she does a great job. The clips of Sarah Michelle Gellar were great too though, but I'm probably just not used to them. I feel like Gellar wouldn't be able to take on someone like Greenlee (Rebecca Budig - sorry if that's spelled wrong). But I bet she was fantastic as well!
xMegLovesYoux 2 years ago
And the award goes to SMG!!!!! I mean I don't think AM has won and emmy 4 Kendall and SMG did so that should end all debate. And Sarah only played Kendall for a short time too, where as Alicia has been on there 4ever! It would be cool if SMG came back to be Kendall now that Buffy is over an what not.
foxxy23 3 years ago 4
U know for awhile I thought Kendall was Erica's sister, not her daughter which I thought Bianca soley was.
hulkmeister23 3 years ago
I really loved SMG, but AM is good, too.
Wish we could get Sibine back, her Greens really grew on me.
nixdreamer75 3 years ago
You really cant compare one was in her teenage years and the other one has a baby, both are great actress but I have to side with Alicia because she STAYED on the show longer then Sarah!
pamula1985 3 years ago
Sarah!!!!!
HMAN030 3 years ago 4
SMG is was and always will be kendall to me. When she left the show I stopped watching.
hfxmusicman 3 years ago 4
Well first, the Sarah Michelle Gellar scene is not even remotely at her best pure evil. But no one, no one will ever play Kendall like SMG. There is no question! She can play a bitch like nobody's business!! Alicia is good but Sarah is by far better!
MEE051677 3 years ago 22
Sarah won the emmy, and AM can't even get nominated after almost SEVEN years (I swear it's been forever) and tons of storylines handed to her and making others the sacrificial lambs for her stupid character. I loved SMG's Kendall, and I HATE AM's entitled, phony baloney Kendall. So, yea, SMG wins by a landslide.
angelofmusic27 3 years ago 5
Sarah by a mile
BecauseFlintSaidSo 3 years ago 3
different times. different storylines. different acting, same character. is it ever really consistent? i think SMG was great for her storylines and maybe she would have been been a better Kendall than AM when Kendall first came back to Pine Valley, but today, the character has changed somewhat. SMG wouldn't be good with this personality. AM plays a better grown-up Kendall. Thinking of SMG now as Kendall, would be like thinking about Buffy with kids. Nuh uh!
awhisperintime 3 years ago
Well, I'm sure that Gellar could portray Kendall how she currently is pretty well, actually, but you made good points on the rest.
Foergang 3 years ago
nah. alicia. only she could go toe to toe with RB like she does.
literalmetaphor 3 years ago
Sarah!!
beyjacpau 3 years ago
Oh wow, definitely Sarah. She was the reason I watched and this new one CANNOT hold a candle. The character of Kendall died when Sarah left.
Lnert 3 years ago
Alicia as Kendall is hardly new, but I know you were just getting your point across.
Foergang 3 years ago
Sarah!!!!!!!!
marieleea 3 years ago
i loved SMG as Kendall, she was my favorite character on AMC when she played her. after a while i came to like Alicia in the role but Kendall's not my favorite character anymore. i do think SMG would do great playing opposite of RB and CM but i don't think she and TK would have that same spark or incredible chemistry that he and AM do so i say it's tie, depending on who they were paired with would depend on who would carry the role better. SMG is my favorite though for who i like better.
gigga143 3 years ago 2
saraaaaaaaaaaah
Californiagirl89 3 years ago 2
I hope some of you guys actually watch AMC because really Kendall is not the same person and I couldn't see Gellar go up against some of the other actors on the show the way Minshew does.
Kimiko1387 3 years ago
Wow! A reasonable point. However, what makes Gellar and Minishew great is that it's not all about them. It about their scene partners as well, now Gellar and Rebecca would be interesting. After the rumors, Gellar and Lucci. That's why I will disagree on the exception that I don't think Gellar could spark that chemistry with Kaye(Zach).
Diannasman 3 years ago
@Kimiko1387
Sarah won a daytime emmy for her acting as Kendall. I'd say that she's a great actress. It was her acting that really opened up for other acting opportunities. I thought she was a match for Susan Lucci.
fomalhauto 1 year ago
@Kimiko1387 Minshew can't hold a CANDLE to Gellar! I can't stand her... she's an awful actress!
lfnfemme 6 months ago
if sarah was to ever to comeback alicia could kiss her job goodbye
XxSANDRAxX310 3 years ago
I absolutely adore Sarah Michelle Gellar, she remains my favorite actress ever since her AMC days, but as far as Kendall, the role solely belongs to Alicia now. She's played Kendall the longest and both the character and the actress have evolved so much that SMG's Kendall and Alicia's Kendall are two separate characters. Equally good, but Alicia owns the role completely now.
OnyxfireDavin 3 years ago
I love both, but I really like Alicia as a grown up Kendall. She rocks!
talks2angels 3 years ago
Alicia's done a great job with the role of Kendall... but Sarah was incredible! SMG all the way!
Manda4Jolie 3 years ago
sarah rocks !
jainadawn 4 years ago
sarah rocks !
jainadawn 4 years ago
Sarah Rocks! She was the Best!!
AngelWhisper 4 years ago
SARAH WINS
XxSANDRAxX310 4 years ago
sarah michelle gellar is a great actress
!!!
BUFFY159 4 years ago 2
Sarah Is Soooooooooo Much better..... Why Would You Even Wanna COnsider That The Other One Is Better... Sarah Won A Emmy For The Role Of Kendal..... Love Sarah 4-Ever She's The Best!!!!!
LuvSmg4ever 4 years ago 3
Sarah is sooooo much better. Sequels are always bad. I <3 Sarah!!!
AccessToTheUniverse 4 years ago
I love Sarah and all but the acting is laughable!!
DaydreamerAnonymous 4 years ago 2
Of COURSE Sarah is better! She even won an Emmy!!!
BTGibson 4 years ago 3