@thomastmwc Callas, Deutekom, and Sutherland all had a much more powerful E flat by far. Lily Pons had a much more reliable high E flat and F for that matter. Pons sang this same scene transposed upward, ending it on an F. But I do hear what you're hearing that her high notes have a nice balance between power and stability.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
She bores me to death! There's no magic. She is a great technician yes. But it's hardly enough. The timbre itself is ordinary and the charisma and drama is just completely absent-NOT A HINT!
fantastic reading... her incredibly solid technique in her high register is magnificently exhibited in the unbelievably difficult phrase at 2 56 (her version of the slow trill instead of Sutherland's fast one, before gliding to the final high note is exquisite)
Técnica irrepetible, hermosa versión....Bravaaaa
MadameBorgi 8 months ago
her high E (or Eb, whichever) is the most stable and powerful amongst ALL, literally ALL, sopranos'
thomastmwc 1 year ago
@thomastmwc Callas, Deutekom, and Sutherland all had a much more powerful E flat by far. Lily Pons had a much more reliable high E flat and F for that matter. Pons sang this same scene transposed upward, ending it on an F. But I do hear what you're hearing that her high notes have a nice balance between power and stability.
dougbalt 9 months ago
esatto non è una delle migliori ma la migliore.... la più grande in questo ruolo!!!!!..
TheMusetta 1 year ago
bravissima indeed.
mediterrus 2 years ago 2
Non è una delle migliori, è la milgliore!!
elisirdamore 2 years ago 11
This comment has received too many negative votes show
She bores me to death! There's no magic. She is a great technician yes. But it's hardly enough. The timbre itself is ordinary and the charisma and drama is just completely absent-NOT A HINT!
BetuliaLiberata 2 years ago
Hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha! There is no magic! You bore us to death as well, with your uneducated and simple comments.
viafilodrammatici 2 years ago 6
What else do you want? Do you think if we ask her for a real suicide on stage you'd be able to feel the drama?
adballet 2 years ago 3
I love the end!
rOKr24 2 years ago 2
same here!!!!!!
thomastmwc 2 years ago
waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaauuuuuuuuu!!!!!!
garrapata89 2 years ago 2
Brava... non mi piacciono i trilli e vi sono troppe difficoltà con i gruppetti.
Penso la miglior Lucia la canti la Gruberova... seguita la secondo posto dalla Devia.
DiegoMartinazzoli 3 years ago
bravissima!!!!!!!!!!!
mademusik 3 years ago 4
non divina..di più! Devia per sempre!
84adlig 3 years ago 3
Decisamente una delle migliori. Brava!
Acacallide 3 years ago
fantastic reading... her incredibly solid technique in her high register is magnificently exhibited in the unbelievably difficult phrase at 2 56 (her version of the slow trill instead of Sutherland's fast one, before gliding to the final high note is exquisite)
Lohengrin 3 years ago 4
cant agree...more, haha
thomastmwc 2 years ago
this was my very first video of Lucia. i think i've watched it at least a dozen of times. she's the best!!
mekarts2 3 years ago 2