Awesome! I'm no pianist so I can't really say anything other than that, lol. The only thing that I think would have made it better is if you stretched the tempo a bit in some places. It sounds kinda dry-ish if you play it all at about the same tempo. But still, I think it was awesome. :) It was easy to sing to since you took a steady tempo.
You really play just by ear?? Woooow that's awesome.. I really enjoy listening to this paino version =P It's just so relaxing but at the same time kind of sad.. hehehe
im learning this song right now..whats that little bit at the start..its not in the acual evanescence song? or the tabs i got? i love playing a really fast song..like the solo bit it sounds so cool and looks really hard but it is soooooo simple!! shhhh..i didnt say anything!! cant wait till i know it all...love it...
THat was amazing. Give Unto Me is one of my favourite songs, if not my favourite, and I couldn't help but sing along as you played. Congratulations on such a wonderful effort.
You're playing too fast, there's no passion when you play...and i think you don't have the good sheets, or i don't know because a lot of part of the song are missing..
Omg! that is amazing. Do you mind if I use this track to do a Karaoke version of this song? I will more the happily give you credit of course for the piano part. :) please let me know! :D
before this was one of the demos that i kind of overlooked but now i can't believe to understand why i never really listened to it before! it is so beautiful! And i absolutly loved the way you played it from 3:08 and up! So what happened to that cover of precious things I've been waiting to hear? Have you been workin on it? Let me know, kay?
dude i know it says on your profile that you don't have sheet music because you learn by ear but is it possible for you to write down the notes and stuff? That would be so amazing...especially for all the crazy evanescence fans,
really really good, but can u PLEASE make a video of the entire song? without skipping any parts? i'd really like that because the parts u skipped are my favorite parts of the song.:)
Amy is no damned progidy, she just expresses her feelings!(Which just happen to be bad -.-) either way it's great che can compse a great song at such an early age.
OMG!!! Congratulations!!! you're awesome!!! i love that song!!! thank you so much for sharing!! and congratulationsx100000000000000!!! you rock!! really!!
hi! just to say that youre really talented and that if youre ok, I'd love to use your instrus to sing alog with them, just go to see, I posted lithium online and a french song. just let me know if you're ok!!
You sang brilliant...very dark, mysterious even if you made a few mistakes that i didn't hear too much. Please tell me where you got the music sheet from, i've been dying to get it!! If you have it please kindly post a comment on my account...if you don't mind.
PS: 3:14 gave me goose bumps
JuliH1050 1 month ago
I love playing this song, but mostly I love listening to you play this (:
JuliH1050 1 month ago
"Oh no! A mistake at 3:00 - 3:02! Fix it NOW!!!!" is something my grandma would scowl.
You're awesome though!!!!
PTShaye 3 months ago in playlist Evanescence Piano
perfect its very good
jaaklee 5 months ago
love the intro! nice job! :)
EleanorRigby212 5 months ago
Очень умело, красиво, плавно...
YaHooYeu 6 months ago
love it! you are very talented!!!
MsAddeline 7 months ago in playlist evaa sob
This is very nice you are quite talented it is a beautiful sound and is kind of sad but very pure keep up the good work please :)
nikkita2142 7 months ago
You are so talented! I could listen to you all day! Much respect!!
zejb8 8 months ago 2
Can you make the tutorial? Answer please
Svinnet92 1 year ago
You playing very good piano.
UnwantedNamex6 1 year ago
really good love the tune :)
rockangeldanni 1 year ago
<3 love this. i remember watchin this specific video a few years back over and over and it's how i learned the song(:
&i posted my cover too =]
thanks soo much :D lovely :]
katieduong52694 1 year ago
Youu should make a tutorial, cause I HATE sheet music so yeahhh aha.
:)
moonfire138 1 year ago
I can play this too :) I'd record but i dont have a decent camera and even if i did there's no where for it to rest .. help? :(
MissEvanescenceFan 1 year ago
omg like wow.. your really good.. love this tune =]
MegaKitten93 1 year ago
in my opinion it is WAY too fast.
srry :( other than that it is excelent great job :)
TiffanyMuhlbeier 1 year ago
xD good playing..but it's also very differente than the normal way to play give unto me xD
eacz12 2 years ago
please, can u make the tutorial, i cant read those sheet
shigaara 2 years ago 7
this song is beautiful¡¡ ^^
aldys92 2 years ago
3:10-3:30 juste beautiful =) ! I love this song... Thank you for this moment ^^ !
Lilye03 2 years ago
I love you
A7XRULES60000 2 years ago
i made this cover but some mistake i've made
lololol
arifdarsani 2 years ago
super! I hope you'll teach us how to play this someday soon:)
EvAmyBocuk 2 years ago
congratulations...you made a great job, i have watched it a thousand times and love to watch again...it's really beautiful
gingernorther 2 years ago
Very goooood!! You are very good!! this song is too hard to play, I need 3 hands do play it xD
silentspring2 2 years ago 2
Awesome! I'm no pianist so I can't really say anything other than that, lol. The only thing that I think would have made it better is if you stretched the tempo a bit in some places. It sounds kinda dry-ish if you play it all at about the same tempo. But still, I think it was awesome. :) It was easy to sing to since you took a steady tempo.
lakesidemourning 2 years ago
very good job but a little too fast :/
MoOn6Evan88 2 years ago
Excellent and Good Memory...
stylemilo123 2 years ago
do you have the sheet music to this and if so can i have it?!?!
AWESOME JOB BTW!!!
HondaLeyva 2 years ago
That was so beautiful. I wish I had your talent.
TheDivineVessel 2 years ago 2
I love this! are you going to do a tutorial?
Besos360 2 years ago
amazing... no sheet music?
balletgirlvv 2 years ago
wow.....it's so pretty^^ you did a great job. I love evanescence, they're awesome
tokidokiatsuLMC 2 years ago
damn!!! tearsoflithium1 u freaky as hell!!!!! talk about shivers.... by the way nice job great interpretation
avcone 2 years ago
jeez you are a genious..i got shivers down my spine!!
tearsoflithium1 2 years ago
you did an incredible job
dulecita09 2 years ago
I really like how sing this song!5*
Thanks for posting!
satothequeen 3 years ago 8
Thanks for sharing!
You're a great pianist! 100*
Magic and extraordinar music!
Congratulations!
Regards
oceanofmusic 3 years ago 2
hahyousuck- Seriously, have some respect for yourself.
Luv this! =) your amazingg
Cheyannewhore 3 years ago
it isn't complete
Sally88yllaS 3 years ago
oh well if evanescene doesn't sing it amy lee does...so yeah idk...
Goodenough12 3 years ago
oooh you've missed my favourite part of the song
you're a great pianist
nerdddalert 3 years ago
Where can I get the notes? I`ve been searching anywhere...!
Fizefazehundekatze 3 years ago
you may know this by no, but if not, you can find em on the Evanescence Reference.
EvFan15 3 years ago
awsome!!
VikingGirl178 3 years ago
what key is this in?
johnski350 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
hey can u MSG me on MSN. ID is in my profile. 9
bogoesthere 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
naughty fun. visit my profile. a
hahayousuck 3 years ago
hermoso sonidoo i like friend
kadio184 3 years ago
WOW, YOU'RE GREAT!
KARINYLEE123 3 years ago
you are my fav pianist
you are amazing:)
EvPianoGirl 3 years ago
beautiful, you're very talented and real unlike some people.
evanescenceishot 3 years ago
amazing. its just beautiful work. how long have you been playing?
xlovleylovex 3 years ago
I just need to say it. I've favorited almost all your covers. You are really amazing. I've never seen someone play these songs so beautifully.
mysticmelody 3 years ago
i love your playing it's flawless try to learn "ANGEL OF MINE"it's an awesome song..if you can..
Goodenough12 3 years ago
Angel of mine isint Evanescence, and if you already knew that im sorry i corrected u.
evanescenceishot 3 years ago 2
the music of this song is amazing|
mamioca 3 years ago
awesome!
DreamAwayWithMe 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
not good, but thanx
okkervill 3 years ago
Can somebody sent me the sheet music...??
PLS!!!!!
THANKS!!!!!!!
I will be very happy!
PS: Sorry for my mistakes, I normally speak German...
PUNKVEREIN 3 years ago
love this song
XmusicmeisterX 3 years ago
you left out the good part though, in the solo
katiewhitley174 4 years ago
you have a musical ear.
your playing is amazing
ive never heard of this song before.
but you play very beautifully
Gresaaa 4 years ago
You really play just by ear?? Woooow that's awesome.. I really enjoy listening to this paino version =P It's just so relaxing but at the same time kind of sad.. hehehe
I like it!
untitledghost 4 years ago
A little fast but good overall
theinfamouslizzard 4 years ago
tht was beautiful!! i'm going to try to learn it!!
sugarbaby892007 4 years ago
thats the best version Ive seen in youtube.
bbasakbangel 4 years ago
you are amazing and i am speechless. excellent job.
that1spazticchik 4 years ago
Awesome!
negrakat8 4 years ago
o____o tht was great,i cnt belive u did it by ear..its not too slow or fast. gr8 :)
Hazenfay66 4 years ago
where did u get the music? i have been looking 4 it everywhere. pleaz comment back!
evanescencexXxgirl07 4 years ago
Very good! :)
monny2008 4 years ago
That was gorgeous! Your're an amazing player. I didn't even know there were mistakes until I read the "About This Video" section.
musicfest41907 4 years ago
ooo, u r soo freakin good. that is the best song by evanescence! I can only play the left hand part.
evanescencexXxgirl07 4 years ago
that song's pretty hard as well.
andiwillbehere 4 years ago
You are just amazing! Brilliant job, you're inspiring me to continue learning this song again! (Thank you for the great playing!)
DodoDream 4 years ago
are you gothic? thats the question i get! all the time and anyways very good 5/5
JaderGater2 4 years ago
im learning this song right now..whats that little bit at the start..its not in the acual evanescence song? or the tabs i got? i love playing a really fast song..like the solo bit it sounds so cool and looks really hard but it is soooooo simple!! shhhh..i didnt say anything!! cant wait till i know it all...love it...
evilfairyxxxx 4 years ago 2
He does all Ev songs by ear if you look at his profile.
HollyTheFireNinja 4 years ago
THat was amazing. Give Unto Me is one of my favourite songs, if not my favourite, and I couldn't help but sing along as you played. Congratulations on such a wonderful effort.
Woopitywoo 4 years ago 2
yuup my jealousy should kick in right about now ^_^ that was awesome i want your brain so i can learn it yea GREAT WORK taaaa
thexnamelessxface 4 years ago
very good :)
cerenkaya 4 years ago 2
wow!! great job-love it sooo much :-*
iluvyaemo 4 years ago 2
that was amazing!!! you sex
ctowngirl11 4 years ago
You are absolutely amazing! Brilliant! Bravo ^^
Nezamani 4 years ago 2
It is very amazing!!!
DarkSideOfDeath 4 years ago
That was amazing!!! You are AWESOME!!!
xxsuperboixx9 4 years ago
Evanescence Reference is a wikipedia style site that tells you everything about Ev!!!
BlackOrchid66 4 years ago
##~~ Jaw Drops ~~##
MaddzaMegMeg1001 4 years ago
You're playing too fast, there's no passion when you play...and i think you don't have the good sheets, or i don't know because a lot of part of the song are missing..
Elaolith 4 years ago
WTF???? bitch pleeez shes AMAZING
klrbrwneyes 4 years ago
omg i fucking love you!!!!
evann1621 4 years ago
Utterly beautiful. You have a talent and a heart to capture the essence of the true sadness and honest essence of this amazing song.
CAFEBIZZARO 4 years ago
wow nice playin and nice piano
husnijoke 4 years ago
whats evanescence refrence??
4rj4y 4 years ago
you can find all evanescence sheet music at evanescence reference
Airheads6pack 4 years ago
very nice
misspascal 4 years ago
IT'S INCOMPLETE! DID U CUT SOME PARTS?
gothiclean 4 years ago 2
holy shit!! Ur AMAZING!!! I WAS SINGING ALONG TO IT! lol. hey can u send me the sheet music?
4rj4y 4 years ago
thts awesome playing, and i wish i could play as good, but i'm only on lvl 3b. where can u get sheet music for evanescense?
cexinina 4 years ago
wooooooow zalig goe!
BezTebay 4 years ago
w 3:08 minucie zgubiłeś kawałek piosenki;)
maggieeee92 4 years ago
i really didnt mean that....
its just my way of expressing that
YOURE AN AWESOME PLAYER AND I LOVE THE WAY U PLAY EVANESCENCE SONGS!!
intellectualrockfan 4 years ago
omfg! i am OFFICIALLY IN LOVE WITH YOU!!!!
r u single?
intellectualrockfan 4 years ago
I love that song so much, and i love piano, I want to play like that :( thanx for that vid!, i was looking for something like this looooong agoo...
XxAltereg0xX 4 years ago
wauw... for some reason i get all depressed when i watch you play.. you are so amazing, i love it.
EvilVampireGirl 4 years ago
amazing. I love watching you play.
amysagoddess 4 years ago
WOW! ur amazing, i wish i had the sheet music to it =)
briand003 4 years ago
i lAv you james, i swear i'll find u someday, and talk 2 u, i'm ur biggest youtube fan!!!!!!!
lithium1987 4 years ago
OMG!!!
Perfect!
Really good!
Uh, I love it*-*
aninhakapranos 4 years ago
upss great!
LuuLu393 4 years ago
get the sheet music on evanescence reference
emoflashbob 4 years ago
why do u guys start playing the song with that bridge part?
Ocagna 4 years ago
compliments, really...!!
xXKailleanXx 4 years ago
I love watching you play! You play so smooth and what not. Great job!
PoisonIV 4 years ago
This is one of my favorite songs and I love the way you play it!!!!
starvingforinsanaty 4 years ago
someone please tell me where to get this sheet music
psychoshrink22 4 years ago
You're very good. Where'd you get the sheet music??
xx
ToxicVampireKiss 4 years ago
This might be random but I looove your hands lol ~><~
buttercupcheer7 4 years ago
incredible
xxrasputinaxx 4 years ago
Omg! that is amazing. Do you mind if I use this track to do a Karaoke version of this song? I will more the happily give you credit of course for the piano part. :) please let me know! :D
nananess 4 years ago
pretty good id say.your mistakes dont ruin the song itself so not a big deal.
KingTonberry 4 years ago
wow u´re awesome
darkis1201 4 years ago
wow, very good piano skills! =)
chibilightfoot 4 years ago
awesome james!! btw, anyone who wants the sheet music for this song or another ev song, let me know. i have it.
MMCS618 4 years ago
hey I'd really like the sheet music to this song. DO you have my immortal also?
Thanks
TEC412 4 years ago
so much freakin talent
SKevanescenceFan 4 years ago
wow. you are amazing. great job.
that1spazticchik 4 years ago
Excellent! I play piano also. You have a very nice one, too. Do you have sheet music for this or do you play by ear?
DemonicAngels 4 years ago
amazing do you have the sheet music?
Catastr0phicM1nd 4 years ago
I'm speachless. Love it.
Cylnse 4 years ago
before this was one of the demos that i kind of overlooked but now i can't believe to understand why i never really listened to it before! it is so beautiful! And i absolutly loved the way you played it from 3:08 and up! So what happened to that cover of precious things I've been waiting to hear? Have you been workin on it? Let me know, kay?
CelestialDeathGaze 5 years ago
PERFECT,THANKS A LOT!
midangel2007 5 years ago
You're amazing.
I love you. *-*
siekuhl 5 years ago
dude i know it says on your profile that you don't have sheet music because you learn by ear but is it possible for you to write down the notes and stuff? That would be so amazing...especially for all the crazy evanescence fans,
Gethsemane22 5 years ago
Holy crap, do you have the sheet music for this?
Drusilla36 5 years ago
omg you missed out the bit where you modulate! ahhh best bit of the piece very well done though. =]
x
strephon666 5 years ago
just awesome!
TheHolyOli 5 years ago
really really good, but can u PLEASE make a video of the entire song? without skipping any parts? i'd really like that because the parts u skipped are my favorite parts of the song.:)
littleblackangel666 5 years ago
COOOL bracelets.. XD
i mean.. reallly cool bracelets (Y)
XxNo1WayxX 5 years ago
PERFECT only that word can describe your excellenet work mate
manos666 5 years ago
Only one thing: 3:02. Besides that, flawless. Yet again, we could do a kickass duet.
gilpinyor 5 years ago
You play it well, but slow down !
argheuro 5 years ago
gonna cry..
xander001 5 years ago
agree :(
andie8O4 5 years ago
agree down ;) ->
andie8O4 5 years ago
Amy is no damned progidy, she just expresses her feelings!(Which just happen to be bad -.-) either way it's great che can compse a great song at such an early age.
mypupster101 5 years ago
wow, Amy must have been a damned prodogy to seroiusly compose that song at such an early age....
grungegurl1690 5 years ago
OMG!!! Congratulations!!! you're awesome!!! i love that song!!! thank you so much for sharing!! and congratulationsx100000000000000!!! you rock!! really!!
tdavidt 5 years ago
that is amazing! great job. exellent. lol i sang to it.i love it! lol im adding to to my fav!
everybodysfoolamyfan 5 years ago
he made some mistakes in here? also can someone give me good notes or piano tab to this song
especially frm u James354
SaskiHatami 5 years ago
... sounds good dude.. seriously.. pityful for the mistakes, but we all make them =)
SanePsycho 5 years ago
aaah ur gooood. yeah, well, despite the mistakes, hehe.
kewayzey 5 years ago
Oh my god. That was...amazing. <7358235783
Kudos.
siekuhl 5 years ago
hi! just to say that youre really talented and that if youre ok, I'd love to use your instrus to sing alog with them, just go to see, I posted lithium online and a french song. just let me know if you're ok!!
sweetsacrificefr 5 years ago
Nice one James.
I don't know this one, since its from thier EP.
Cool Playing :)
=D*
\M/
*Wilfred*
SDMFWilfred 5 years ago
ohhh man what a amzing can u send me this song in midi format??
necrosplinter 5 years ago
i want your piano xD
you play awesome!!!
darksweetpain 5 years ago
You sang brilliant...very dark, mysterious even if you made a few mistakes that i didn't hear too much. Please tell me where you got the music sheet from, i've been dying to get it!! If you have it please kindly post a comment on my account...if you don't mind.
iulika08 5 years ago
sang?! was a bit confused - listen hard as i may, i dont hear any!
punkchik69 5 years ago
I love you lol
crazyspuffyfreak 5 years ago
that's awesome!! You play as well as Amy!
evanescence666 5 years ago
perfect!
you're fucking man!
thinaaaa 5 years ago
just a word: PERFECT!
franxXxcaulfield 5 years ago
ur pretty good... your choice of fingering looks so weird because it's different than mine... =|
xpapergirlx 5 years ago
<33
Deviliish 5 years ago
thats really good... hehe saw u on bebo
Shonahscott 5 years ago
Give unto me is so dark, so amazing...you play beautiful!
Violectra88 5 years ago
this is very nice... bravo... way to go... nice singing on piano... ;)
DarkBladeMk 5 years ago
That's amazing, boy, you're very good ;)
LastSatyr 5 years ago
WOW!!!
I never heard a better piano play!!!
evanescencelady 5 years ago
You're gifted. That was just awesome!
Frozenangel222 5 years ago
That was absolutely amazing...phenomenal. i'm speechless. wow
Cirafly24 5 years ago
*howls*^_^ :3...erm..dunno if I made a comment on this..whew..that whack in the head surely got me confused..
kakurine786 5 years ago
wow. that is amazing. this song is amazing. and i can sing almost perfectly along with this.you rock.
wolfloves81 5 years ago
amazing
i have sheet music for breathe no more and my immortal for anyone who wants it
Amberholic 5 years ago