Not Waving But Drowning

[ChiaroscuroPL]

1:31 - were is this from? Please answer, I'm dying to know. I don't remember this from show...how could I miss it?

[TheHorizon26]

@ChiaroscuroPL It's from 4x02 :)

[xxVampireLovexXx]

Wow. That was so intense. Leave me to die now

[soupshop]

this is utterly gripping. can't take my eyes off the screen.

[johnnydeppaddict12]

Holy Cow!! This is stunning! :O not much more I can say. *Goes to weep in corner*.

[gothdaisy]

Holy crap! This is friggin epic! You've done an absolutely amazing job on this vid! I'm at a loss for words here! What a heartwrenching tale you've told! It was beautiful and terrible at the same time.Poor Cas! This one definitely needs to be watched over & over! If you're interested, my friend created a new vid recently for Dean which I think you might enjoy. She'd love it if you watched & commented. It's called "Oh Death - Dean" by Morgoth2001

[lk737]

so amazing, so heartbreaking, so emotional. you twisted my heart for these characters in further ways i didn't think possible. bless you! <3

[az5714]

POWERFFFULLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL

[kissmrule]

i so lvoe thsi vidoe ito coo land sweet

[Winchassterwho]

you had me teared up after 10 seconds... and crying at 0:55 T_T ... this is wonderful :3

worth all the awards ;)

[khamarupa]

Excellent!!

[az5714]

Questo è il motivo per cui vado su Youtube. bravo

[KariKyrie]

Again, this is the most beautiful thing I've seen in a while

[eveninrose]

And finally, your coloring is, as usual, flawless (love the brightened white, it looks amazing and is a good reminder of what Castiel is), and aesthetically rounds out a well conceived video. Idk whether to cry or appreciate your choice to leave out the healing face-lesions moment (at 2:26), but either way, the SPN fans should submit a yearly tribute to you for such a beautiful Castiel tribute, because it's really what he deserved! I could go on forever about how much I love this video!!

[eveninrose]

It layers emotions onto already charged and heartfelt quotes yet avoids being heavy-handed at all. And 2:05 on is godlike, and I always wibble at it, perfect wrap up of Castiel's moments (ugh, Balthazar D:)!!! I love the way you get juxtaposing the newer Castiel with the older Castiel clips (especially w/Dean at 1:44-2:05). And the silent lyrics and quotes throughout lend such support and backstory to the clips, I just can't! I wish I saw the show how you saw it!

[eveninrose]

Ahhh, I haven't been on in forever and haven't been commenting as usual, but the amount of times I've watched this when not signed in means it merits a long overdue comment by now, lol.

I absolutely LOVE the song choice, and the clips you choose and the transition is so unbelievably perfect. And Death's quote is so amazingly right where it is, and the heartbeats? I adore how you timed Castiel's and Dean's exchange, when the music picks up and with the singing. -c-

[KariKyrie]

Gorgeous.

[Utawanare]

omg this made me cry so much :(

[alsotho]

WHY WOULD YOU DO THIS

[Camillelang]

Love the multiple layers and the blurs! the colors are stunning and now my heart hurts ;A;

[randomise42]

I HATE YOU! I HATE YOU SO MUCH!!! I... I just can't, this is too fucking beautiful. :o I can't deal with it, why on earth am I whatching this!!! Tears I tell you, TEARS!!! Why does this have to be So PERFECT??? Are you trying to torture us? Is that it...

[solaris266]

beyond amazing, excellent choice of music and talk ... you are so fudging brilliant doing these videos! thanks so much

[Lsdivoiletgreen]

I cant...asdakdhaa

the end killed me!

Perfect hun!

[jeffhardyabcd]

wow..

[ichiniiify]

amazing <3

[LadyMagiccc]

omg .. this is too amazing .. wow ..

[maverick494]

Wow, just wow. The editing, the music, the little nuggets of dialogue, everything was just perfect! Many users create beautiful videos, but not many users create moving videos. You do.

[Tinchy2010]

why why why is your editing so perfect?

you are killing me.

seriously,the way you choose those little moments,those perfect scenes,the way you overlay the clips,the music you choose,EVERYTHING,JUST EVERYTHING.

*please give me a peek in your brain:)*

love it bb

<33

[sparksfly221]

wooow breathtaking *___* awesome AWESOME job!! <33333

[Seekess]

O.O holy shit...wow. The rhythm in this is amazing and how you worked in the voiceovers "destined to swat you, I think" I got chills but, also, omg Cas *sobs* Stunning work. It's like actually getting to "see" a poem play out.

[LightNeverFades]

This is breath-taking! ;w; <33333

[Deanchester16]

i like it but i think i'd love it more without the text

[ShatteredDemon]

I know everyone already said it, but it's true, this video is beautiful. I miss him so much. Your editing skills are awesome, and you made me feel all the feelings.

[fuegostar007]

Beautiful video! So full of emotion...how it makes me miss Castiel :(

[k9lover27]

So beautiful and absolutely heartbreaking. Guh. I love the scenes you chose to highlight throughout the video. Very emotionally powerful.

[belongtobill]

i always love watching your video. the editing is just perfvect :)

[alittletouchoffaith]

so beautiful, i love your videos :)